My wife and I sent Arlene a picture of a Wonder Woman cake for our daughters birthday, and we were NOT disappointed. Arlene created this cake exactly how we wanted it from the picture. The cake was amazing, and everyone kept telling us how great it turned out. We appreciate your hard work on our daughters cake! It turned out amazing! read more

Polkadot Cake Shop - Desserts Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

See all

We recently ordered a Wedding Cake for our Daughters wedding . It was decorated as we had asked. When it came time to serve the cake, we were very dissapointed to find how dry it was. It just turned into crumbs everything you put your fork into it. For the $500 we spent we were not happy with the texture. Its as if the cake was made Days before the event then frozen. I will never reccomend them to anyone. read more

I've said this before and I will say it again, TAKE THEIR CAKE DECORATING CLASSES! Or actually, don't because they fill up fast. I've now taken 4 classes this year. Do I have anything to do with them after the class? Nope, but I love taking the classes that to the most recent one, I brought 3 friends and was yelled at by another for them not being invited, whoops. I usually end up donating the cake to a local firehouse. The class is such a fun time and Christina is awesome at facilitating. She lets you have full creative freedom when decorating. And the cakes are always delicious. This most recent one was a strawberry lemonade flavor and another was Neapolitan which I got compliments on both, even though I've only done the decorating. I'm excited to see what they have next! read more

See all

I ordered a pull a part cupcake cake, number 9, Fortnite themed for my son's birthday. The entire experience was so easy from start to finish. From the convenient user-friendly website ordering system, payment system, and seamless correspondence with Polkadot Cake Shop, I knew I was working with a true pro. I sent a picture of what I envisioned and got exactly that and even better. I've never had any service where I have provided a picture and gotten the EXACT results! Just blown away. The ingredients of the cupcakes were top notch as well, tasted so good, my guests were commenting how it was the best cupcake frosting they have ever tasted. And the 'icing on the cake' was that we received a premium custom-made cake at a reasonable price! I will definitely be using Polkadot Cake Shop for future events, thanks for making my son's birthday a memorable one! read more

Polkadot Cake Shop - Desserts Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

Arlene made my cake for my son's first birthday. She was so easy to work with and did an awesome job bringing my vision to life. Everyone kept commenting on how awesome the cake looked and where I got it from. Not only that it tasted even better than it looked !! Would recommend her and will definitely use her again. read more

Polkadot Cake Shop - Desserts Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

Yesterday was the first time I ordered a cake from the Polkadot Cupcake Shop. Not only was the cake BEAUTIFUL, and delicious the owner and baker Arlene is a pleasure to work with. I highly recommend this shop to everyone!!! I actually can't wait until my next cake order, which won't be for over six months. Arlene made me a guns n roses cake for my husband's birthday. I sent her a picture, and explained to her what I was looking for. The cake was used to give my husband his birthday gift which was tickets to their upcoming show. Not only was the cake better then I imagined, it also was delicious. I ordered yellow cake with cannoli cream filling. My husband who is not a big sweet eater, even ate two slices! This experience was simply beyond wonderful!!! I can't wait to order more sweets!!! read more

See all

Ordered the Under the Sea cake for my sons first birthday... The cake was amazing.. when they delivered the cake my wife and I looked at it and were speechless.. The details on the cake were awesome.. with all the sea creatures on it and the whale on top.. could not of asked for a better cake.. The inside was marble cake with cannoli filling which was delish... we also got decorated sea creature sugar cookies as favors.. they were also delish... Definitely recommend using them.. read more

Polkadot Cake Shop - Under the Sea cake.. - Desserts Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

See all

I contacted Arlene (owner) regarding a graduation cake for my god daughter. Sampled a few flavors and we discussed my cake designs. Cake was executed perfectly. It was also delivered on time. Very pleased with the customer service and cake. The cake was beautiful and tastes DELICIOUS! Everyone kept asking the name of the bakery for future business! I Highly recommend Polkadot Cake Shop! Marjorie read more

See all

Absolutely brilliant designers and DELICIOUS bakers! We hired this amazing team to create a cake, cookies, cupcakes and chocolate covered Oreos and pretzel sticks for our daughter's Pete the Cat themed 3rd birthday party. (Pics below) WOW!!! Thank you so much to the entire team!!!! read more

Polkadot Cake Shop - The dessert table!!!! Cookies, cupcakes and cakes! - Desserts Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

See all

I am so over the moon happy with a cake that was ordered for my best friend's bridal shower this past weekend! Arlene was so incredible to work with and made sure every detail was perfect. Not only did the cake look beautiful, but it tasted even better! I would recommend this shop to anyone, and can't wait to order for the next big event (and try all of the other amazing flavors)! read more

Polkadot Cake Shop - A cake fit for a bride to be! Filling: marble cake with mocha meringue! - Desserts Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

Polkadot cupcake shop hands down has the best desserts I've ever had. Arlene is so easy to work with and makes your cake dreams come true. I love her cookies (no cookie will ever compare) but my absolute favorite thing is her vanilla with lemon cream cheese and raspberry preserves filling! I had it once at a food truck event and I ended up ordering it as my birthday cake this year! The lemon cream cheese is just the right amount of tart and cheesy to break up the sweetness of the preserves! As if delicious flavors weren't enough, working with Arlene is a dream. I have ideas in my head and she meshes them perfectly together and then takes them to the next level. We love getting our logo on cookies as a special treat to our customers! I can't say enough about Arlene and Polkadot Cupcake Shop. Once you give them a try nothing else will compare! read more

Polkadot Cake Shop - Desserts Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

See all

I have ordered 3 cakes from Polkadot and absolutely love love love love LOVE THEMMMM!! We got a cake for my sister's birthday, my husband's groom's cake and our birthday cake. They are very kind and their cakes are so good and their cookies too! Simply amazing. Will hire them again, recently inquired for my "dessert table" for my college graduation party so super excited to see how this new event will go! read more

See all

Love this bakery and will absolutely be back for all my party needs! We had a 80s themed surprise birthday party for my husband and Arlene and the team here made an AMAZING cake! It was exactly what I envisioned and hoped for!! It was beautiful and it was DELICIOUS!! Honestly the best chocolate cake I've ever had!! Can't wait for my next party and next cake! Thank you for making something spectacular! read more

Polkadot Cake Shop - Desserts Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

This cupcakes are amazing! Plus they have a make your own option. The toppings are rich and fluffy and the cake portion itself is moist and delicious. Cannot also say enough nice things about the owner. Always a pleasant attitude and always on social media displaying her work. Way to go. read more

Arlene of Polkadot Cupcake Shop was at a corporate event and served her cupcakes. Excellent cupcakes! Texture and taste was very good. The cupcake texture is a cross between a cake and a poundcake. It was moist...always a plus... Much success to Arlene and her cupcake business! She was also very nice...always a bonus... Carmen read more

See all

This review is long overdue... but read me!! I ordered my daughter's 1st birthday cake from Polkadot. Let's start with customer service and responsiveness: Arlene was wonderful to work with! I couldn't have asked for better communication. Now... appearance and taste: beautiful and DELICIOUS. The cake was Snow White themed and came out just as I hoped for. I ordered a banana cake with vanilla icing. The cake was moist with a realistic banana taste and the icing was perfect. I will be ordering from Polkadot again!! read more

Polkadot Cake Shop - Desserts Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

Arlene knows her cupcakes! As an event planner in NY, I use Polkadot for any event that needs her treats! She did a fabulous job with the St. John's School of Law, graduation last year...that was A LOT of cupcakes!!!! I have not made it to Jersey to see the food truck..but I have only heard great things on Facebook! My favorite... Irish Car Bomb, made with Bailey's! read more

Polkadot Cake Shop - St. John's ~ St. Patty's Day Dinner - Desserts Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

My Wife and I recently had our daughter's 4th Birthday Party here. The owner has extra space, so on occasion she rents it out for parties. The space can hold between 10/15 kids plus a parent which is typically a mom. Although their were a few dads there of course including me. The owner is very nice and accommodating. She has an assistant who is also very helpful. All the kids sit down with a blank canvas aka cake and get to decorate it. The cake was vanilla with a cream filling. They supplied a variation of fondant pieces ranging from hearts, stars, little castles, cars, and crowns. There are 100 different pieces to choose from we chose those. Halfway through decorating they supply pizza and water for the kids and adults. We provided soda if anyone wanted that instead of water. Their minds ran free and went to work and made some great and interesting cakes. Of course the parents assisted, I think they had as much fun as their child did. At the end each child's cake is boxed up so as they can take it home. We had a special cake made for our daughter of Funfetti with chocolate and strawberry. It was beautiful! We have gotten dessert table cake pops, custom cookies, chocolate covered Oreo's, Cannoli's, even a gender reveal cake for our family, for our second child. For my birthday a few years back my wife got me a custom Gun N Roses cake, cause she had gotten me tickets to their show at MetLife Stadium! Was absolutely amazing! If your having an event at a Restuarant or another venue they will come and setup everything you ordered. It was a very nice afternoon, in the end it all came down to the kids having fun which they did. Would we we do it again absolutely! Will we use tagain absolutely, highly recommend in my book! read more

See all

My mom hired Polkadot Cake Shop to make a cake for my baby shower in September. The cake was so amazing, that I rehired Polkadot to make a cake and favors (chocolate covered Oreos) for my daughters baptism this weekend. Guests were so impressed by the cake that I don't thInk one person walked out without asking for the bakery information! I can't wait to work with Polkadot for our next party!! read more

I recently ordered a cake for my son and daughter in law's rehearsal dinner and it came out beautiful!!! The cake was exactly what I wanted for the design and it was delicious! The staff was pleasant and so accommodating, reaching out to me to ensure I was happy! I would post a picture but in the hustle and bustle of the day I forgot to charge my phone and it died before the cake came out. I will definitely use this bakery in the future!!! read more

Back for second party cake, my husbands 40th birthday! Another beautiful creation and a pleasure to work with! read more

Polkadot Cake Shop - Hubby's 40th! - Desserts Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

See all

I went to Polkadot Cake Shop for my law school graduation party and Arlene did not disappoint. Not only did she make me a beautiful and delicious cake, she also made and set up two dessert tables for my party. Arlene was very easy to communicate with and answered emails very quickly. I showed her pictures of what I wanted for my cake and she made the cake exactly like the pictures I showed her. The cake and the desserts tasted great and fresh. Planning a party is stressful but I did not have to stress when it came to the desserts and my cake because I knew I was in good hands. I was originally going to go to a bigger named bakery and I am so glad that I didn't. Everything was perfect! read more

Polkadot Cake Shop - Desserts Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

See all

I worked with Polkadot Cake Shop for 100 decorated sugar cookies individually wrapped as favors for my baby shower and I was very happy with the results. It was extremely easy to communicate with Arlene by email (I live in NYC), manage the contract and payments online and have the cookies delivered to my event in Bloomfield by the agreed time without a hitch. I had sent Arlene a screenshot of an Instagram post of super cute Christmas-baby themed cookies and PCS's execution of the 9/10 designs was gorgeous and professional. I appreciate how I didn't have to worry about a thing. Thank you so much for your help, wishing you great things for 2020! read more

I'm a fat guy... i've had a lot of delicious ooey-gooey scrumptiously amazing desserts over my 30 some odd years on this planet. So trust me when I tell you that I have a good frame of reference to adequately review sweets. This afternoon, The Polkadot truck came to Hoboken for a party that our building threw for its tenants. I brought home a pumpkin spice cupcake, and a cannoli cone for my wife and daughter since I am watching my weight. (Like I said, I'm a fat guy, just not a stupid one) After seeing the eye-popping reaction of my wife and daughter, I had to take a bite. I had one bite of each, and I have to say... It was absolutely heaven. Without a doubt, I would buy ANYTHING that these guys made. Consistency, flavor, and presentation are out of this world with them. The only words I can use to begin to explain are: Wow!!!! And the emphatic pronunciation of mmmmmmmmmmmmmmm. read more

For my future daughter-in-law's ("FDIL") bridal shower this past Sunday, Arlene of Polkadot Cupcakes was brought in to handle the dessert table and the results were spectacular. From the original ordering process with her truly helpful tips to her on time arrival for setup an hour before the event to the wonderfully delicious and visually stimulating desserts themselves, nothing could have been better. The guests were raving about the cupcakes, the tower cake topper, the cheesecake and those super cute bride, groom and wedding dress cookies. There is little else to say other than great products, lovely proprietor and thank you for making my FDIL's day so very special. read more

See all

My daughter asked for one thing for her birthday and it was a dinosaur cake. Arlene delivered a magnificent dinosaur cake that not only my daughter loved but every guest loved. We provided some art work and it was exactly what we asked for. In terms of customer service, top notch and very responsive. Highly recommend using Arlene and the Polkadot Cake Shop! Would have given more than 5 stars if it was an option. read more

Arlene and I had corresponded back and forth for a while in order to ensure every detail was perfect. My husband and daughter have the same birthday and I wanted to have a double sided two-layer cake for their first birthday together (his favorite book on one side and her favorite tv show on the other). It went off without a hitch. Everyone loved how it looked and it was absolutely delicious. They kept asking who made it. I will definitely order from here again! read more

Polkadot Cake Shop - Desserts Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

See all

Arlene put together a fantastic Sesame Street themed dessert table for my son's first birthday! Her designs and artwork were ADORABLE! It was a big hit at the party! read more

See all

Just had my daughter's first birthday party, and I ordered multiple treats from Polkadot Cupcake Shop. They were delivered to the restaurant before party time, and was surprised when the waiters brought them out for us. Ordered cake pops, choc covered oreos, choco covered marshmallows, rice crispies, brownies, sammies, ice cream cone canolis. I took so many photos of the treats that by the time I placed my camera down, it was all gone. My guests were like bees on honey. I was so lucky to grab a choco covered oreo before anyone could snatch it. I had so many compliments from family and friends. They had a great time. The treats added to the beautiful arrangements I had prepared. I just want to thank Polkadot Cupcake Shop for making our daughter's birthday a very memorable one! read more

See all

Update: Arlene did get back to me and we discussed the design issues I mentioned. I think that was a great touch and as were short on time, we could not send it back. However I do still the texture of the chocolate cake and sweetness of the lemon cake were not upto my expectations. Original Review: I wanted to love this place but was very disappointed. Arlene was great in scheduling and design. We went back and forth a lot and she was very adjusting. The cake arrived on time and in perfect condition. My main disappointment was in the flavor and slightly the look. I got the chocolate cake with chocolate ganache filling and vanilla cake wih lemon cream cheese + rapsberry filling with custom fondant work on top. The fondant colors were perfect however there were some crack on the top layer. The Bottom layer's work was not as delicate as I expected. One other thing was that the decorations (which were supposed to be all around) were only on the front side. I have ordered cakes before and there are some decorations which need to be all around. The flavors were a sugar overload. The chocolate cake was a little crumbly and K struggled to find the ganache. The vanilla cake was good however there was no tartness in tbe fillings to counter the sugar overload. We ordered a cake serving 38 people for a 50 people party and still had leftovers. I am not from this area and relied only on reviews and my experience was not good. I have had better cakes. It felt like a cake that a junior baker would make. read more

So happy I decided to order my mother's birthday cake from here! It was beautiful and delicious. I can't wait to order again. read more

Polkadot Cake Shop - Desserts Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

Another amazing cake from Polkadot cake shop ! We ordered a naked cake for my daughters 30th birthday. It was delicious and looked amazing. I cannot say enough about them ! Thank you for always going above and beyond! read more

Polkadot Cake Shop - Desserts Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

I ordered a cake for my boyfriend birthday.. this was a huge risk for me because 1 he is super picky on his cake & the texture of the cake/frosting has to be perfect, 2 design has to be amazing. I use to order all my cakes from Pennsylvania because most of my Jersey bakery experiences have been a total blow. I am so happy with this risk, Arlene was an absolutely delight to work with! She respond right away, the cake itself was amazing, and a lot better than what I expected it to be. I thought it was going to be a regular painting of a Ralph Lauren bear but NOPE I was wrong the details, the background, everything was perfect. she gave me a cake That I loved from the moment I saw it and I wa even more pleased with the taste! I am ordering all my cakes for upcoming events from here Arlene & the Polka Dot Bakery have a loyal customer now :) read more

Polkadot Cake Shop - Desserts Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

Arlene made a fantastic cake for my son's first birthday party AND a little teddy bear cupcake/smash cake for him! The cake not only looked like a work of art but was one of the best I've ever eaten. Just the right amount of sweetness and balance. Personalized service and amazing custom cakes. read more

Polkadot Cake Shop - Amazing custom cake for my son's 1st bday. Best. Cake. Ever. - Desserts Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

We at NYCupcake Guide are HUGE fans of Polkadot Cupcake Shop! We had the privilege to first try the cupcakes at a Cupcake Takes the Cake meetup, and we were impressed with many of their flavors, namely the Strawberries & Champagne, Cookies n Cream, Chocolate Peanut Butter and Cookie Dough. We've reviewed Polkadot a couple of times at our review site if you're looking for more details :) http://www.nycupcakeguide.com/?p=229 http://www.nycupcakeguide.com/?p=269 read more

Can't say enough about this place! They did an exceptional job with bringing my thoughts to life and providing AMAZING flavored cupcakes and cookies while doing it. My husband hates sweets and even he raved about how amazing they were and asked me to "save him some". Book them! You will not regret it! read more

Polkadot Cake Shop - Exceptional service! Exceptional flavors! Book book book, you will not regret it! - Desserts Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

See all

I'm writing this review under my husband's name - I wanted to throw a surprise whiskey & cigar party for his upcoming birthday! I was doing some searches on places that had whiskey flavored desserts and came across Polkadot Cupcake Shop! Arlene was absolutely wonderful to work with! I gave her an idea of what I was trying to accomplish and she brought it to life!! She was fast to respond and made things so easy! She gave suggestions on how many items to order based on how many people were coming. She delivered and set up the whole display right on time and what she created was even better than I could have imagined! I can't tell you how much everyone loved the whiskey barrel cake topper! Not only did everything look great but the taste was out of this world!!! Arlene was also kind enough to email me the following day to see how everything went! I can't thank her enough... I will be back!! -Nikki Doblin read more

See all

I couldn't be happier with the way my daughters first birthday cake came out! While looking for a bakery to create a cake for my daughters first birthday that delivered, I came across this polka dot bakery. After browsing the website and reviews I made an appointment with Arlene. The experience couldn't have been more pleasant. Arlene got back to me quickly and we were able to schedule a mutual time to meet and discuss the cake. Arlene knew exactly what I was looking for which made the process super simple. I was able to touch base with her when the event came closer with he cake flavors. The day of the party, the cake was delivered 1/2 hour ahead of schedule and came out absolutely perfect!!! Not only was it exactly what I wanted and looked amazing, it tasted delicious. I have had many cakes with fondant and this was like no other. It wasn't super sweet and the cake and filling was fresh! I got so many compliments at and after the party. Thank you Arlene for doing a fabulous job! We can't wait to work with you again! read more

Polkadot Cake Shop - Desserts Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

Had these cupcakes at the Meadowlands food truck mash up last night, and was so annoyed by them had to look up the actual shop on Yelp. These were honestly some bad cupcakes. Cakes were really oily meaning lower quality ingredients are being used. Flavor was bad too. What flavor there was tasted artificial. Strawberry tasted like soap. No idea how a business was built off of these recipes. read more

I ordered a cake for my sisters surpise 30th Birthday party from the Polka Dot cupcake shop and it was great! The process of ordering from Arlene was easy and smooth. I told her the theme and she came up with so many great ideas to choose from. She helped with decisions on things and make it stress free. The cake cake out awesome the birthday girl was so happy with it and it really made the dessert table complete. I will defiantly be ordering again for my next event. I already gave out the information for the shop to a couple of the guests who loved the cake. Thank you so much Arlene! read more

Polkadot Cake Shop - Desserts Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey