David's Custom cakes made us another wonderful cake for our celebration. We were so happy with the bear and fireball cakes. They were absolutely perfect, and delicious. Every detail was done to exactly what we ordered and the cakes truly became the centerpiece of the celebration. Our guests couldn't stop talking about how wonderful they looked and how delicious. Thank you for your professionalism, talent, and for making our event so special. Deb & Rob K read more

See all

I can't say enough about this cake! It was for my son and daughter-in-law's baby shower... It wasn't only the cutest thing I've ever seen, but was delicious too! read more

David's Custom Cakes - A little dumpling is on the way! - Custom Cakes Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

David's Custom Cakes is the baker who works with the Tides Estate next door, which is where we had our wedding. We came in maybe about a month and a half before the wedding for our cake tasting and it was a fun little experience. You pick which cake/filling combinations you want, and they bring out little cupcake versions of it on a tiered plate. My only gripe (which was minor) was that there were options that the Tides included in our package, but we had to pay extra to sample at David's (i.e. red velvet). We did end up picking that as one of the tiers of the cake. That is something I did appreciate - the cake design we chose had four tiers and we were able to pick a different flavor for each tier. Top tier was funfetti (saved for us for our one year anniversary), second tier was a marble cake with hazelnut buttercream, third was red velvet and cream cheese frosting, and the fourth and largest tier was the same as our top tier. Guests were able to pick which flavor they wanted and the marble was a hit. If you have any cake florals, toppers, ribbon, etc. you have to bring it to David's a week before your wedding. We don't live nearby and luckily our florist was able to place our florals, and since we had a simple cake topper, she ended up doing that too. But just something to keep in mind. Overall, I'm happy with how the cake turned out. read more

David's is the best! They made the most delicious wedding cake for my special day. I had a three tiered cake with a 3 different flavors: vanilla cake with dulce de leche mousse, vanilla cake with cookies and cream mousse and red velvet with chocolate pudding. Guests raved about how delicious the cake was and my husband hasn't stopped talking about the dulce de leche mousse. It was so memorable for him that I had to order cupcakes of that flavor for his birthday. He said it tasted just as good as it did on the wedding. I highly recommend David's for the special moments in your life. read more

David's Custom Cakes - Custom Cakes Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

See all

Delicious wedding cake flavors. Beautiful design. Prompt delivery. Would recommend to any couples planning a wedding!

David's cakes was phenomenal from beginning to end. They made it very easy to order So it was painless. Everyone complimented on not only the look of the cake.But how scrumptious it tasted. I would use David's again without a second thought! read more

David's Custom Cakes - Baby shower cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

I am extremely happy with David's Custom Cakes. There customer service is second to none and there cakes are even better. They pay attention to detail and there cakes look exactly like the picture that was sent to them. There prices are excellent! If you want to order a cake this is the place to go!!!! read more

We used Davids Custom Cakes for our Wedding and we could not be happier with the outcome! The cake tasted amazing and look spectacular. The amount of detail and work that went into the cake was so evident to all of our guests. We are so appreciative of the service and care the team took with our cake and would recommend them again and again! read more

Wow, just WOW! Cake came out PERFECT, exactly what I wanted! The fact that everything from this place also tastes AMAZING is an added bonus! Can't wait to order from here again!! read more

David's Custom Cakes - Custom Cakes Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

David's Cakes is a must for your next special event! We have used them for a wedding, a baby shower and most recently a Bridal shower. each cake was beautiful and absolutely delicious. You will not be disappointed and your guest's will be thrilled! Ordering was easy and they delivered the cake too! I don't usually rwrite reviews but this is a solid business and they deserve it!! read more

I ordered a cake for my son's 7th birthday. It was cute, reasonably priced and delicious. It was also easy to order from them and they had good flavors to choose from. I was actually surprised at how good it was! Thank you David's Custom Cakes for making my son's birthday extra special! read more

David's Custom Cakes - Custom cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

Every single cake we've gotten from this place has been amazing!! They are super creative and can design most anything you wish. I'm sharing a couple of our favorites. My granddaughter's taco cake filling was funfetti! Yum!! My geode cake had cannoli filling. Everyone raved about how good they were. And the best part is you don't have to break the bank to get what you want. Love this place!! read more

David's Custom Cakes - Geode cake with cannoli filling. - Custom Cakes Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

See all

We used David's Custom Cakes for both our wedding and shower. There were so many good flavors we were able to mix it up for both. Everyone raved about the buttercream icing! And they worked with us to make our design work on a round cake. Loved them and will use them for future event cakes read more

David's Custom Cakes - Custom Cakes Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

My wedding cake this week was perfect! So many people at the wedding commented on how beautiful and delicious it was! The entire process was very easy to design the perfect hallowedding cake with the designer. This was the second cake they did for us in the last couple years. The first was for my husband's 50th birthday. That was a replica of his classic car. Both were gorgeous and the tastiest cakes we have ever eaten. At both parties, the guests were raving about the cake. Thank you for making both events so special! read more

David's Custom Cakes - Replica car cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

See all

Beautiful Cakes had 2 done for communion and baptism..,Can make anything you like...Had many done here read more

See all

These cakes were so gorgeous, made exactly as described, and the taste was phenomenal! The Cakes were moist (funfetti, chocolate and vanilla.) The Fudge filling and chocolate mousse was creamy and chocolatey. The raspberry filling was tart and sweet. The Buttercream frosting- I think I ate a pound of it. Everyone at the party was raving about the cakes. The entire ordering process was the easiest part of planning this entire party. They were quick to reply and eager to help. I highly recommend! read more

David's Custom Cakes - Custom Cakes Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

I have never written a negative review about a particular business. However, this is an important issue that needs to be addressed. I ordered a cake at Dave's Custom Cake Shop and specifically told the woman who took care of me at the front counter that under no circumstance to include strawberries. I repeated this several times since I am allergic to strawberries. She failed to write it down on the order and unfortunately, strawberries were included. She denied that I told her and I then suggested that she review the store video cameras which are displayed in the front of the store. Her attitude was very none concerning to an oversight that could have lead to a very serious medical emergency. I strongly believe that customer service is crucially important in all businesses and I recommend that they be more responsive and careful to their customers needs. read more

David's Custom Cakes did an excellent job! I recommend for any special occasion you are planning. read more

David's Custom Cakes - a birthday cake with the name of the band - Custom Cakes Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

My wedding cake was amazing. Not only was it beautiful but it tasted so good. We did vanilla cake with cookies and cream filling. Every one raved about it! read more

David's Custom Cakes - Naked cake- vanilla cake/cookies& cream filling - Custom Cakes Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

Got my 30th custom cake from here and it looked amazing! We dropped off macarons fresh flowers to be add to the cake and they did a good job incorporating that into the cake. However I was disappointed with how the cake tasted. Majority of the cake was frosting & and a small layer towards the bottom was actual cake. The frosting didn't taste good. Almost felt stale. I wish there was less frosting and more cake, that way we would have definitely enjoyed it more. Not sure if I would order from here again. read more

We have bought cakes from David's on multiple occasions. We ordered a cake for my sister in laws shower(obviously I wanted it to look like her daughter). I sent a picture that I wanted on the cake. They didn't have the exact picture but found one of a baby of different ethnicity. They then apparently downloaded the picture so I could choose which baby would be on the cake. I went back and forth with her multiple times and choose/screen shotted the correct picture. When i went to pick it up the day of the shower it was the wrong ethnicity. The girl working there was young and clearly had nothing to do with it. I emailed the owner that I went back and forth about it with the whole time and she never answered me. She made the young high school girl call back and deal with it and never even reached back out to me herself. I understand things happen but we went over this for weeks specifically and then the owner didn't even have the decency to speak with us herself or even care enough to double check the picture I chose as I went over it in detail multiple times. Their cakes are pretty good but over priced and now after this experience of the owner not even being about to take accountability for her mistake and push it on her worker has put a bad taste in my mouth. It was a $400 cake and she couldn't even call me herself to apologize or even answer an email. That's not how you run a business read more

See all

Jen was very accommodating and flexible with me. She helped me design the perfect cake for my husbands 40th bday and was very patient with me. The cake looked amazing but it was also very tasty! I chose the vanilla cake with pineapple filling. read more

David's Custom Cakes - a black and gold birthday cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

First time I used David's Custom Cakes and I was very satisfied. They did an excellent job with the design of the cake and they are very reasonable. I got two different flavors and they were very good! Not a single piece was left! read more

David's Custom Cakes - Sprinkle cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

We held our wedding at Indian Trail Club (10/11/19) who partners with David's Cakes - and we're so glad they do! We easily scheduled our tasting which was very basic itself. David's Cakes offered a bunch of options, combinations, and recommendations without being overwhelming. They were responsive and patient via email. We had three different combinations for our cake (chocolate cake/PB buttercream, vanilla cake/dulce de leche mousse, red velvet cake/crea cheese buttercream) and they were delicious! We're so happy with how our cake came out! This, in combination with following them on social media and seeing their outstanding designs makes us want to have another event with a David's cake ASAP! read more

David's Custom Cakes - a wedding cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

This bakery came as one of the vendors for our wedding venue, having never heard of them before we tried their cake at the tasting. My wife and I were immediately blown away with how delicious their cake was. Our cake tasting with David's was a very fun experience. We were able to bring my sister, brother-in-law, and now mother-in-law to the tasting. We honestly had a tough time choosing between all the different combinations. At the wedding the cake was just as good as at the tastings, and several guests came up to us to comment that this is the best wedding cake they've had. I would definitely recommend this for any type of cake as we saw several amazing birthday cakes in their fridge. We can't wait to eat our cake top on our one year anniversary. read more

Placed an order for my son's first birthday cake. The cake was exactly like the photo I sent and was delicious. Definitely the best cake I've had. Every single person at my son's birthday party complimented how beautiful and delicious and moist it was and asked where I got it from. Highly recommend them and will be using again in the future. read more

David's Custom Cakes - Custom Cakes Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

I'm just gunna get to the point. We ordered a cake for a specific date to be delivered. A week before that date, someone came down with covid which made us have to put the cake on hold. As I talked to one of the younger people working there she advice me that I reach out to the owner to see if the owner could help us out, because at this point we didn't know if the covid victim was gunna die or not. She had mention that they didn't even start on the cake yet so maybe I could get a full refund. And I did just that. I emailed the owner letting the owner know what was going on, on my end. To which the owner had one of the younger workers do her dirty work. I worked for so many small businesses that I know when it comes to losing money the owner HATES to stand up and take ownership of their business. You can tell the awkwardness in the younger person's voice as she says "um... so since our policy says..... so we have to keep the deposit." Ok I get it. You have a policy. I just thought the owner would at the bare minimum speak to me rather then making this person do it for her. After a long recovery, and David's custom cakes having $250 of our money, we decided to just go with them any way. BUT AS SOON AS I REACH OUT TO THE OWNER ABOUT RESCHEDULE the owner was so quick to respond. How funny. Money hungry I guess. We reschedule to a date a month later. The cake was beautiful don't get me wrong. But we had the cake scheduled to be delivered at 4. Once 5:05 came around and no way of getting in contact with David's custom cake, my mother ran out of the party to find a cake somewhere else. Causing her to cry "why isn't the cake here! I can't call them, it says on google their closed" she felt sick because the cake hasn't got to the party yet. As my mother was out shopping for a new cake, the delivery driver showed up. As the party started already! And they just put the cake down on the first table they saw and that was that. Ran out the door like nothing happen. Now. All though the cake looked amazing. The taste was SO sugary. We couldn't even eat the cake due to how sugary it was. I felt sick after taking a bite. It was like paste in our mouths. It just wasn't a good tasting cake. Now that the party is over. It's just SAD how much the owner could care less to speak to a customer about canceling the order. How the owner was right their to take our money again. And then the cake to go to waist because it was like giving my self a cavity. $500 down the drain. It's just sad because I wanted to believe that this place was good. But it's just not. The young people that work their are pretty much the only thing I can say were a better part of the experience because they were so nice. But at the end of the day, I wouldn't be surprise the owner replies to my comment with the same thing every one of my boss has said to other customers "we are sorry to hear you didn't like it but you ordered blah blah blah and we have a policy and we can't control the delivery time." I wish the owner cared more about the customers then money in their pockets. Or at least just take the blame. But you know how it is. It some how won't be their fault. Sad. Just sad. P.S. I wrote this review on google as well but it seems it got taken down. Even more sad. read more

MY CAKE WAS AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!! I got married on July 27, 2019 and we enjoyed every moment working with Davids. My mom came along with me to the cake testing, and was so hard to choose the flavors as all of them were mouth watering! We chose four different flavored tiers for our cake and picked the design with sugar flowers. I sent them an email with a picture of the exact color I wanted for the flowers, and they executed it perfectly! I cannot praise this place enough, their hospitality and perfect execution of our cake made the day so special and we are so thankful!! Not to mention delicious!! THANK YOU!! read more

I bought a 1/4 sheet cake that cost me 55.00 for my grandsons graduation from the here recently. It was a red velvet cake with cream cheese on the inside and butter cream icing. It was one of the worse cakes I ever had. The cake was dry and the icing was super sweet that you couldn't even taste the rest of the cake and the icing it fell apart when we cut it what icing does that. It seemed like the cake was old. I was so embarrassed to serve this cake to company. I would never recommend this place or buy another thing from there. I could have done a better job myself for 1/4 of the price. TERRIBLE read more

I am a repeat customer and I am never disappointed. Megan is an incredible baker and has always delivered an amazing quality cake. I will be purchasing my 7th cake from her for my nephew's baby shower and I cannot wait to see what amazing creation I get from her. read more