30 mins before closing, we called & ordered the burrito family meal. Such delightful service & delicious, fresh burritos were prepared very quickly. The family meal also came with a half pint fresh sour cream & amazingly creamy guacamole. If taco sauce was offered, it would have added a nice flavor; we used our own. I'll have to inquire if there is any available next time we order. Thanks for preparing such a delicious, fresh meal for my family! read more

Good mexican meal with mexican interior design and music! Pleasant dining experience. Clean restroom. High chair seen. Accepts debit/credit card. Limited parking space since it is shared with other buildings tenants. See images for reference. read more

See all

A friend was raving about Plaza so we decided to try it one Friday night in January. There is seating and space is casual and colorful. We were able to grab a table and placed our appy orders. Unfortunately it took about 30 min. Looked like a small staff and everyone was hustling to do their best. Dinners came out and they checked up on us a few times. Was taking a while though to get check so I went to the counter myself. Aside from the wait, the staff was great and food was tasty. It's a great spot for Mexican. There's some street parking. We parked next door at the post office. read more

See all

Delicious food, catered for 24 people. Julio was so great to work with! Lots of food, on-time, piping hot! Everyone really loved it! Wonderful job Plaza Tikal - Thank-you! read more

Plaza Tikal - Burritos, Fajitas, Guacamole, Rice/Beans, Churros! - Salad Near Me - Bernardsville, New Jersey

See all

Fresh, tasty and excellent Mexican food. They consistently cook well executed Mexican dishes. Love their tacos birria. read more

Hidden gem. I'm so picky about my Mexican food I literally eat it everyday. This place is prime time legit. And quick

When I was craving a burrito, this restaurant was the best choice. They have good quality dishes and a fun atmosphere.

Update: I ordered carnitas online for delivery and got a call from the restaurant asking what sauce I wanted on my enchiladas. I corrected the person and said I ordered carnitas. He said, "Oh, right!" Still, he asked what kind of sauce I wanted. I told him I didn't know carnitas had a sauce on them and asked him if I could have it on the side. He said it comes on the meal, not on the side. I chose salsa verde, thinking that might be interesting. The order was delivered promptly, but I got enchiladas verde with raw red onions and lettuce on top. That phone conversation apparently meant nothing. I did call to tell them what happened, and they said sorry. That was it. read more

We really liked Plaza Tikal for authentic Mexican food. We shared Birria Tacos and 3 Pastor ( Pork w pineapple tacos) ( forgot to take a pic of those)and a been and cheese Pupusa. The consume for the Birria tacos was very flavorful with pieces of beef. The pico served with the tortilla chips (brought to table right away) was yummy. We asked for more with our Tacos. BYOB. We had On the Rocks Pre mixed Margarita in a glass over ice bought at Adelphia Wine store nearby. read more

Plaza Tikal - Birria Tacos - Salad Near Me - Bernardsville, New Jersey

See all

Small place in town with very good Mexican food. I would give 4 stars for food but service was not good. We needed to ask a few times for extra chips, water etc. There was only one other table in the restaurant so not sure why. Maybe take out is busy? But they should be a little more attentive to patrons in the restaurant. Otherwise food was delicious and large portions. The guacamole was delicious and very fresh. We will have to try again. read more

See all

We picked up take out the other day and received guacamole. Wow! It was fantastic, so fresh. We eat a lot of guacamole at home and it doesn't even come close to the taste of Julio's. I don't know how they do it but it is awesome! Before I could snap a pic to share it was gone. Thank you and Thanks for aways being so nice too! Our favorate Mexican restaurant. read more

I LOVE LOVE LOVE Plaza Tikal! I never dined in but I always take out since it is located close to my job. They have a small lot next to Plaza where you can park to either dine in or to just run in and pick up your food. The restaurant is super fast with the food it is usually done before I get there in 15 minutes to pick it up! Now let me tell you, the vegetable burrito is generously portioned with sour cream and guacamole on the side. The outside is crisp and the cheese on the inside is melted to perfection. My burrito only runs me about $11 and it gets me satisfyingly full every time. Definitely recommend Plaza Tikal for some authentic Mexican food! read more

Plaza Tikal - Veggie burrito to go! - Salad Near Me - Bernardsville, New Jersey

The service was amazing, and the ambiance great. The food could've used more seasoning and the cook overcooked my shrimp and forget a few ingredients in my burrito. I compared it to my partners burrito and he had all the ingredients so maybe just a mistake? Won't be going again though read more

This is my go-to Mexican spot. Authentic, delicious, great decor and atmosphere. The staff is so lovely and the food is fresh. What a hidden gem in Bernardsville! I love that it's BYOB. It's a great spot to come with friends and family- I love showing people this place! I'm a vegetarian and they have plenty of options for me. They even serve pupusas which are hard to find in NJ. The food is consistent when I order out from here and when I sit down to eat here. My food was still steaming hot when it was delivered to my house the other day. I've eaten lots of Mexican food in Mexico and Southern California and can confidently say this may be the best Mexican food I've ever had. The options are limitless- I'm still excited to try so many more things on the menu! read more

Not many options around here for Mexican food so tried this place out. Everything could have been salted more and just have more flavor. Portion sizes are good but the taste is lackluster. The chicken in burrito was dry and no salsa on the side. Don't think I'll come here again and drive further next time when craving Mexican food. read more

Very fresh food, good flavor not over powering like some other places that go crazy with spice. They have Coca Cola from Mexico in the glass bottles which was so cool!! Server was friendly and service was quick! read more

See all

I love plaza Tikal and it's sooo yummy in my tummy! Aight gang gang cuzzo, but it's LIT!!! I really be feinin for more after this grub

Loved this place. Excellent service. Everything was fresh and cooked perfectly. I can't wait to go back. Large portions and delicious. Parking may be tough as the shared lot is small. Can't wait to go back! read more

See all

This review is ONLY based on service. The food looks like it could be pretty decent based on the pictures but unfortunately we never got to try it. Went on a Tuesday night. We were the the only ones in the restaurant. 2 other couples came in after we did. We placed our order quickly but that's where it went down hill. It took 25 minutes to bring us our waters. After that we waited another 50 minutes and still no food and no server in sight. So after an hour and 15 minutes since we placed our order we just walked out. The couple sitting next to us walked out a few minutes before we did and the 3rd group went to the front counter to complain a few minutes before that, so no one was happy and no one was served any food. I am not sure if they were short staffed due to Covid which I can certainly understand. My problem is there were only 3 tables in the whole restaurant occupied and the server didn't come check on any of the tables at all for almost an hour. For an almost empty restaurant there is no excuse for not at least taking 10 seconds to check on your only customers. I really hate to leave a 1 star review but this was a pretty terrible experience. I just hope the owners see this and make some changes so they don't loose anymore business. read more

To start, when we were ordering, the server forgot to ask a member of our party what they wanted to eat. Their menu also had more American food items than Mexican. Once we got our food, one of our tacos had avocados and the member of the party was deathly allergic to them. They then said that they would make us another taco but would have to charge us for the tacos that no one wanted. The food was ok and my food tasted like something I've bought in the freezer section of the grocery store. The waiter also did not speak enough English to get our orders right. The atmosphere was like I was eating in my grandma's house(in a bad way). The restaurant was tucked away in an alley with barely any parking and I think it is a good reason. We were the only people in there and the service was still long. If you want mexican food please go to casa maya. SO MUCH BETTER! read more

They never disappoint. We were celebrating a birthday and they went beyond making it a special day. read more

The employees are so nice that we I had no chance and so does the employees they went to the nearest store to get change and they were so nice and the food it good read more

Great little spot, easy ordering and pickup. The food is really good, and the family platters are a terrific bargain. Friendly and fast service. The al pastor is some of the best around! read more

Plaza Tikal - Vegetable fajitas - Salad Near Me - Bernardsville, New Jersey

See all

Little place, clean and comfortable, tacos are delicious and the horchata is perfect. You can't mess up tacos but these guys definitely added some great flavor with the pineapple touch. read more

Plaza Tikal - Shrimp tacos and horchata - Salad Near Me - Bernardsville, New Jersey

This place was SO good! I got the Chicken Mole and my son got a SUPER stuffed burrito! We also went to TOWN on their house-made guac and chips!!! We'll totally be going back! read more

Plaza Tikal - Chicken Mole - Salad Near Me - Bernardsville, New Jersey

See all

Went here with a couple of my friends for a dinner together and was thoroughly impressed. The waiters were rather attentive and kind. The atmosphere was lovely, the dining area was sprinkled with paintings while the lighting was moody and the music fit very well. As the for the food, the appetizers were delicious and likewise, my dish, the Bistec Mexicana, was fantastic. I highly recommend this destination if you're looking for some great Mexican food. read more

Plaza Tikal - La Bistec Mexicana - Salad Near Me - Bernardsville, New Jersey

Delicious friendly atmosphere large portions just wonderful! The salsa sauce was incredible - diced and fresh. I had the fajitas with shrimp and chicken read more

Fantastic Mexican food at reasonable prices. The guac is delicious. So are the burritos and quesadillas. I've only eaten inside the restaurant once and it's very casual but has upbeat fun music on. This is a go-to takeout staple in my household but I should try to eat there more often because my toddler loved dancing around while eating his food (note- we only did this at 4pm when the restaurant was empty but the staff didn't mind it :)) read more

Can't remember the last time I was so disappointed in a Mexican place. Everything from the food to the service was subpar. The three tacos are all very plain tasting and dry. The beef that is in the burrito is plain and the burrito itself was dry as well. No extra seasoning to make it seem unique, and beef was was basically cut up pieces of meat that seemed like pieces of rubber. The flour tasted very plain as well. The nachos faced a similar disappointing fate, cheese and meat and only on the top layer. The service was also very disappointing, we waited ten minutes for our check as we watched our waitress (who was also a hostess) walk passed us multiple times to go clean up a table. Only reason it's not 1 star is because you get chips and salsa while waiting for food read more

Plaza Tikal - Burrito is just beans, meat, and cheese, very bland - Salad Near Me - Bernardsville, New Jersey

See all

Very quiet night. We were their last to dine with them but they were taking carry-out up to the minute we left so we didn't feel rushed. Wonderful people! One of the cooks ensured we were satisfied when he was passing. I assume family owned and operated since a very young quiet girl was our server. She was doing her closing duties, and didn't check in with us much, but we didn't need it. But we aren't going there for the service. Or the ambiance. Btw everything looked very clean and current... I wouldn't be surprised if they renovated recently. All the food tasted fresh and authentic. No wilted or soggy cilantro or browned avocados/guacamole. The black bean soup was on the salty side for me but good nevertheless. Shrimp ceviche was excellent! read more

Good simple Mexican food, friendly people, shiny new restaurant, same short menu at lunch and dinner, but unbearably slow kitchen. On a quiet Friday at noon our simple orders took 30 min to appear, that's just too long. Free chips arrive first in the Mexican flag colors green, red and (almost) white. The Plaza Tikal salsa was generous but forgettable, very mild. A pupusa for $3 makes a yummy appetizer, basically a savory pancake stuffed with cheese, comes with a nice side of cabbage and red dipping sauce. I tried al pastor tacos, three for $10, good balance of meat and sliced radish, great cilantro sauce on the side, double corn tortilla supporting the whole pile of goodness, yummy. My buddies got the burrito and the quesadilla. Burrito was a huge portion of rice, beans and animal protein for $12, generous with the guacamole also. Quesadilla had been nicely browned, also lots of guac. Vegetarian rating: 2 stars, The pupusas are a good choice and you can get a vegetable burrito, but most of the dishes are chicken and beef. It's worth finding this brightly colored new place in its niche on Quimby Street, but BYO and leave yourself plenty of time. read more

See all

I had the chicken fajita here and chips with guacamole. Their salsa was very good, and so was the fajita. The guac was a little small , and the taste was mediocre. I would def recommend the fajita though!! read more

Gave this place a second try after having prior to Covid and nothing has changed. Both times the food had no seasoning at all. No flavor

Just tried this new Mexican restaurant in town. I am so glad they opened. Bernardsville has a lot of high-end restaurants, but we REALLY needed another casual place to eat. Our food was very good. I had a chicken burrito, which was delicious and (thankfully) not one of those massive ones they serve at Chipotle. My wife had a chicken fajita, which was also delicious. The wait staff was very friendly, but it was a bit chaotic as they just opened and are working out the kinks. The only complaint was that their chips are not the best quality. I think they are out of a bag, whereas other Mexican restaurant make them fresh. read more

See all

Excellent food! Been there several times with many friends and everything we've ordered has been excellent, very fresh, and quickly served. Ana has provided excellent and attentive service, too. read more

I've had take out and been in restaurant a couple of times and it's a good place. The interior is casual, colorful, cozy, and welcoming. read more

Plaza Tikal - Mix Molcajete: this thing is huge and wonderfully tasty. - Salad Near Me - Bernardsville, New Jersey

This place is awesome! Food was delicious and fresh. Staff was friendly and accommodating. The Shrimp Enchiladas were delicious. We will definitely be back! read more

Excellent authentic tasty delicious food. Very fast friendly delivery too. Try it you'll like it!

I was pleasantly surprised with how delicious my meal was here. It was not filled early Saturday evening but it started filling up as the evening progressed. And I noticed take out orders leaving consistently. We parked on the main Street nearby but there might be lot parking to the side of this place, I couldn't tell if it belonged to the restaurant. They provide chips and salsa at the table. The chips are fine. The salsa isn't special, but the diced onion in it is great. Definitely try the nachos! We all loved the beef nachos. Perfect amount of chips, cheese, and the meat was in diced chunks and flavorful. The jalapeños weren't spicy. It was great. I'm picky about burritos, and while this wasn't the best burrito I've ever had, I would definitely order the carne asada again! The rice, refried beans, and cheese were gooey and soft. The steak had a lot of flavor with spice and char. And they sear the outside of the burrito and serve it with lettuce, guac, and sour cream. I was so stuffed. The kids burrito was the same size as the adult burrito and equally delicious. My spouse's beef chili relleno was gooey and tasty. He raved about it. Prices are what I expect for this area -- burritos are $12, the main entrees start about $12/$14 and go up. Quality food and lovely atmosphere. Great staff. You can't go wrong here. read more

Great Mexican and South American food without having to drive to Somerville or Casa Maya. We were so excited to see this place open and have been really happy with the food quality so far: High Points: -Great vegetarian options with a great burrito and awesome to stones. -High quality, fresh tasting food that is a great value and shows obvious care in its creation. I wish there were some vegetarian or vegan taco choices and desserts, as well as breakfast options on the weekend because I would love to be spending more money on their yummy food. read more