I live this place! They cook to order, and usually stay busy! Good food , good prices…read more I like their subs , pizza& wings

A hidden Gem in a small town in Monticello, Georgia. I come to Hunt every year in Georgia and I'm…read morealways looking for a good place to eat. I didn't expect to find a place I would normally find in California or New York in the small town of Georgia! Great pizza, with the right amount of sweetness and zest. The combo salad was fresh and crisp with lots of toppings including freshly cooked bacon. I also ordered some hot wings and they were huge pieces that taste awesome too. This is a take out only with no places to eat! Definitely worth a try. I will be back for more

Very slow! We ended up leaving with krispy krunchy chicken from Larry's because they didn't start…read moreour order. After 15 minutes of ordering they still hadn't started it. One cheese pizza and an order of bread sticks. Ridiculous...

We of course decided to order again. They again gave away our order. The time it was estimated to…read morebe done was 5:45 and I showed up at 5:50. They had gave my order away. I can not get in touch with anyone at the store. This is not how you do business!

Not my first time here, but it is my first review for them! This is really good pizza! (Is there…read morebad pizza?) very traditional, thin, Neopolitan style crust. Not huge, but two or three people could enjoy. (6 slices cut) I wanted to try something different so we got two and boxed the rest. Shelby greeted and seated us, and although she lacked a little knowledge on the beer menu, she made up for that with a trip to the bar to investigate our questions on sour beer, and came back with two excellent samples! We settled on a Dr. Robot and the Charcut-a-pie. I loved the toppings and balsamic drizzle. Goat cheese and arugula just go together. A little honey and I was in heaven! The crust on this one was a little well done, which disappointed but, the overall flavor was on point. Next, we sampled the Spicy Italian. I'm usually pretty good with spicy things, and while this was no exception, it did have both of us in a small sweat! If you are averse to spicy, stick with something else. This crust was also cooked and not over done. I'm not sure what McDonoughs' obsession is with vaults, but it seems to be a recurring theme around the square. You'll find vaults or at least doors that look like vaults all over. The rest of the decor inside and outside was well done. Exposed brick gives it immediate rustic charm, while black floors, raw wood art, and leather stools wrap the package nicely. I definitely like their lighting! Oversized bulbs hung around the pizza oven bar (which you can sit at if there's space) and giant hoop rings finish the rest of the space. It isn't that glaring light that spotlights your table, it's just a nice warm ambient light that makes you wanna pour a vintage red into a wine glass over and over. Oh! I almost forgot, they do have an outdoor patio up front, so on those less humid days and nights, I'll definitely be hanging out there!

This is my usual go to whenever at the square and grabbing a bite, the bar is top tier and the…read moreservice is good. The seating and outdoor area are sooo tea, it makes me wanna hang out all the time on a sunny day! Margherita pizza is my go 2

I'm from New York and was looking for some good Brooklyn style pizza. This place is pretty darn…read moreclose! The pizza is delicious. I usually get a personal pan size since it's just me, but the prices are good and they have specials. The service is always great and the place is clean. It has a Statue of Liberty inside which is cute!

Izzy's NY Pizza offers enough deals and "by the slice" options. We got a large because you get more…read morepizza per square inch. It's just math. I also like pizza. The crust is thin and crispy--well, until the "NY Supreme" toppings made the middle a little soggy. I don't didn't mind and it seemed to bother the wife more than me. While the sausage, peppers, and mushrooms were fresh, I was hoping the menu had something more unique about it besides your obvious options. The crust was good too. Pizza by Yandy's is delicious but their crust was almost inedible. The chef is a multitasking machine, juggling a mountain of orders. Judging by the Sunday night crowds, it's a local favorite. I understand. Would I come here again? Maybe. I was just somehow in this area but I might prefer Italian pizza more than NY style. It's a good pizza but I'm also venturing into making it at home. It's kind of a fun process and it costs like $3.

Burger was better than I expected and the service and view were great. It was freezing cold, but…read morethey had the heaters keeping us toasty. Will be back this summer.

Fire and Ice is the best restaurant on Jackson Lake and it isn't a question. The food is good but a…read morebit pricey. The staff is really nice and friendly. The atmosphere is nice and has a nice view of Jackson Lake. But the best part is that they have their own ice cream place inside. They have lots of flavors and yours is probably in the bunch. Would recommend Fire And Ice if you are on Jackson Lake.

10/10 food, service and atmosphere. I had blackened chicken alfredo and my mouth is watering…read morethinking about it. It came with a salad and garlic knots!

Biba's WAS our go to place for take out pizza. Especially during COVID…read more Last three times the pizza was far from good. Tonight's order was the worst yet. Very little sauce and cheese....crust was inedible.

Food was good. Service was great. Would definitely go back!! The mozzarella bites were the best!…read moreCatfish was good! Friendly place.

For some reason, it takes 25 minutes to run a credit card at this place. This has happened all…read morethree times I visited. Owner seems more interested in making small talk than waiting on customers. Wings were barely warm by the time I got home. Will not be back. Disappointed.

I love Godfathers! One of my favorite pizza chains! I was excited to pick up a pizza from here to…read moretake home from our recent RV trip up to North Georgia. Traveling is tiring! I go in to order and and informed I have to order at the main pay counter because they aren't allowed to have a till and can't take orders. So I go to the counter to order and pay (we are dumping here also so I had to pay for that anyway). I tell the girl at the register what I want- a deluxe half no mushroom. She looks and can't find a deluxe and reads all the different pizzas off to me which don't sound right. So I go back over to the pizza counter and look at the menu again and come back and tell her it's a Classic combo. Half no mushroom. She can't figure out how to put in 1/2 No Mushroom. So I tell her just to put it in and I'll tell the cook when I go back over there. Having solved the first part of the pizza puzzle I go back over to the counter to hand the man my order ticket. I explain I only want mushroom on half. He says"so you want two different pizzas on one pizza?" Ummmm NO. I want the same pizza but don't add mushrooms to half of it. I am not joking I had to explain this six times to this man. Finally he understands (I think) but I follow him to the pizza making station, on the customer side of course :) He starts making our pizza and following the toppings chart and wowza am I getting the toppings!! When he got to the mushrooms he looked up to me and says, "just this side, right?" Lmao yes, just that side. Anyway he made us an awesome pizza with lots of toppings and tons of cheese and it came out really delicious! We had to reheat it of course when we go home and it was still one of the best pizzas Ive eaten in a while! 3 stars because the above ^ and because of an unclean, visible work area (btw I asked him just to put our pizza in the box and I would cut it when we got it home because of this). Godfathers/Loves - If you want people to order somewhere besides your counter you should put a sign there saying so. I told at least 5 people how to order because your one employee couldn't do everything?! One person only working at any restaurant is never enough! BTW the Hardee's next door was dead and your people should be able to work both restaurants as needed. It's not hard to make a hamburger or a pizza. I've done both, many many times, at many many restaurants. Get some food management at this location!

Food is usually pretty good but I know for a fact, the staff will sometimes intentionally leave the…read morephone off the hook so they don't have to take orders as I've tried calling and continuously got a busy signal and would then go in and see the cordless phone with the talk button lit up. Would give the food a 4 out of 5 but as far as intentionally leaving the phone off the hook, that's a definite 1!

Wow, this is my new favorite spot. Definitely authentic NY Pizza. It was just like I remembered it…read moreas a kid growing up in NY. They have a great selection of pizza you can order by the pie or slice! What a treat to try several different slices! We have a sausage slice, drunken Grandma, Sicilian to name a few. So excited this is in our backyard and better than anything we have had in years! We can't wait to go there for dinner! Made a reservation on the way out. Try it you won't be disappointed! This restaurant is NEW! Don't be confused by the address (and OLD REVIEWS) which is the only thing left over from any prior restaurants here. (Don't bother reading any reviews prior to May 2026) NEW OWNERS, NEW DECOR, NEW FOOD Santoro's -Welcome to Lake Oconee!

Could have been a bad night - they were very busy (ambiance = loud). Our server was good, but in…read moreour table of 6, one meal had to be remade, another should have been remade, one was mediocre and a couple were adequate. For bad meals they give you poker chips for 10% off or a free cannoli (assuming you'd come back). The only good things were the garlic knots and cheesecake. Owner was too busy to care. Certainly does not warrant a second chance. So disappointing after all the hype.

I was looking forward to a nice pizza... the place looked like a nice pizzeria! But I was…read moreabsolutely amazed of the quality of the pizza I received. The dough was some form of pre-manufactured dough and the mozzarella cheese did not taste real. Not to mention what kind of pizzeria doesn't carry root beer! Will not be eating here again!

Nice clean place customer service is on point and the food is great. First time here and I will…read morereturn.on my next visit to GA.