My family and I recently visited Pizza Thief on a Tuesday evening and the outside seating area was relatively crowded around 6:30 p.m. Between the 7 in our large party, we picked up two pizzas and an order of their cheese bread -- along with a side of their garlic anchovy dip. The first pizza we ordered was their special -- a sweet corn and chiles, and the other one was the "baller" from their standard menu, a meatball topped red pie. If you enjoy spicy pizza, you'll absolutely love the corn and chiles one. The seeded peppers definitely pack a punch. With the baller pizza, the beef & pork meatballs were well-seasoned and had a nice balance of lean and fatty bits. What I really liked about the pizza here was not just that the combination of flavors worked really well together, but the quality of the crust was fantastic. The crust is rolled out to be super thin, is cooked to be crispy enough that it doesn't flop over when it's folded, and the crust has a wonderful chew to it that doesn't exhaust your jaw as you're working on your second or third slice. In addition to whole pizzas, they also do pizzas by the slice, sandwiches, desserts, beers, and cocktails. This spot really has it all. I cannot recommend Pizza Thief enough -- definitely worth going out of your way to check it out. read more

See all

The best gluten free crust I have ever had! I judge all other GF crusts based off of this. It is thick and great chew. You would not suspect that it is GF. So...is this place safe for celiacs? No. They make a LOT of regular flour dough pizza here so there will be a ton of cross contamination. You have been warned. I actively avoid gluten and have not had a problem here. I always order the Meat Sweats on GF crust. You have to sub out the meatballs on this because the meatballs have gluten in it. Service is walk up to the counter and order. You either get your slice right away or they give you a number and you go sit down in anticipation. [[HIGHLIGHT]]This place isn't fine dining by any stretch, and it isn't meant to be. It is a casual place to sit, eat, and catch up with friends over a slice or two.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Open 7 days a week. Walking distance from adidas store. Perfect when I don't want to shop while family takes forever. Pizza by slice and whole pizza. Lots of desserts. Got cookie looking thing with pine nuts. Yum. Can't say the name even if I want to read more

Pizza Thief - Pizza Near Me - Portland, Oregon

See all

Margarita pizza had great flavor- was a little on the saucy side which made it a tiny bit soggy. Kale. Caesar and Greek salad were excellent read more

Pizza Thief - 18" MARGHERITA - Pizza Near Me - Portland, Oregon

FIRST TIME - BEST PDX PIZZA! I saw a guy loading up huge tubs of fresh organic lettuce from Sunrise Farms at the Wednesday farmers market in Shemanski Park, South Park Blocks, near Arlene Schnitzer theatre. I guessed he must be a chef buying for his restaurant. Yup - Darby is one of two chef/owners of Pizza Thief on NW 26th ST and NW Vaughn ST, Alphabet District. We chatted briefly. I was delighted to hear he buys mostly "ALL" organic and local NW for his pizza place. Gotta go! Two days later my wife and I showed up for lunch. We ordered the market salad loaded with farm fresh organic veggies and the Sunrise oak leaf lettuce. The salad presentation was so colorful (carrots, radishes, green beans, snap peas, pickled asparagus, chives, sheep mile feta) looking like a Claude Monet painting. Big hearty salad tossed in a big bowl. Ya, edible art! So delish with scratch made green goddess dressing. Order a whole pizza or by the slice - which we did. Wife went for a "Vegan Special" slice with tomato sauce, roasted mushrooms, piquillo peppers, kale, mustard greens, Calabrian chili-garlic oil, and Sicilian oregano. I had "Hot Tony" with tomato sauce, pepperoni, schiacciata salami,  calabrian-chili, piquillo peppers, jalapeño mozz-provolone, fior di latte, grana, and sicilian oregano. The pizza looked like abstract art too and was delish. Perfect dough, cooked completely through and not soggy, crispy crunchy crust and slice loaded up with farm fresh ingredients. Sourdough fermented pie is also local and organic NW Camas Mill (what the top pizza places in Portland use) with whole grains. We've been to James Beard award winning or nominated PDX pizza places like Ken's, Lovely Fifty Fifty, Nostrana and Mozza (LA) - throw in other good PDX pizza like Oven & Shaker, Mount Hood brewing and APizza Scholls too - Pizza Thief is in this best pizza in Portland conversation but - but - but - the local NW farm fresh ingredient moved my pizza needle - Pizza Thief to the top of my "OH MY" list. Oh my - I love this pizza! I love supporting local farms, especially organic or pesticide free farmers, who are growing product good for my health - good for the soil - good for the environment. Then, I love those restaurants like Pizza Thief that buy from Oregon NW farmers! Winner! Winner! Winner! Farmer! Pizza shop! Yelpin Foodie! All winners! Pizza Thief serves it up for a Yelpin foodie. I will be back for with my Yelpin bib on for more salads, sandwiches and pizza with a cold brew. Chow out! Chow down! read more

See all

Pizza Thief lives up to the hype. We got the Valley girl, which was absolutely delicious. It's one of their vegetarian pizzas with a basil pesto cream instead of the regular house, and the toppings went very well with it. It was savory and filling You can also order by the slice if you want to try this one first or another one. This was our first time so we decided to go for it since I love pesto, and it did not disappoint. If you like your spice I definitely suggest getting the Calabrian chili dip on the side. Has a nice kick! It was easy to order online and pickup, but they do have plenty of tables to walk in as well read more

Pizza Thief - 18" VALLEY GIRL - Pizza Near Me - Portland, Oregon

pizza thief is very good pizza. new haven style i think? anyway, it's a go-to for our family despite being on the other side of town for us. and it's saying something to stand out as a pizza joint in this town known for its good pizza. they sell by the slice, which is rarer and convenient and all the pizza slices i've tried are quite rich in flavor and crusty and delicious. but my favorite is the hot tony (jalapeno and pepperoni) or the meatball one. their specials are good too. and their ice cream is a must have as well. lastly, i must mention their ranch dipping sauce - it is next level greatness, especially if you like dill. extra special. and it's nice that pizza thief shares a wall/door with the bar next door which provides nicely made stiff cocktails. read more

See all

Delicious thin crust pizza. My friends and I split a whole pie, we each ate two slices and took home 2 slices which was a better deal. We tried to get a whole pie of the seasonal one but understandable they were limited on ingredients so we got the Woodland - which is their mushroom pizza, not red sauce based. We were recommended the Calabrian chili garlic sauce. It was two extra dollars, but did not disappoint as a pairing for the mushroom pizza. Too full for the ice cream, but it appeared to be made in the store and had some fun flavors. [[HIGHLIGHT]]They have a fair amount of seating inside.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]And they also have a patio, which is unheated but is covered and you were able to bring the dog.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Pizza Thief - Pizza Near Me - Portland, Oregon

A soft crust pizza that's cooked perfectly! They have a bunch of different pizzas but only serve what you see in the display. I got a classic cheese pizza and it was yummy! The slices are decent sized. My friend and I shared their Caesar salad which was made with kale. We honestly weren't too sure about it at first but it worked so well. The dressing was perfectly sour. Only street parking here. I came on a Wednesday afternoon and didn't have trouble finding parking at all. read more

Pizza Thief - Caesar salad - Pizza Near Me - Portland, Oregon

Been here twice now, I live in the neighborhood. First time I had the vegan slice, which wasn't too bad... the crispy kale chips on top were fun and pretty good. Hub had a pepperoni slice and thought it was good but too salty. Went again yesterday for another round, same orders and added foccacia. Blech... the vegan slice had way too much kale, and the kale underneath the crispy kale chips was soggy and bitter. I removed most of it. Hub thought again that the pepperoni slice was way too salty and got a rare case of heartbburn afterward. We didn't finish our slices. Foccacia was ok... a small portion at over $5, and cold... why? It would have been much better heated and maybe served with a tiny bit of marinara. I don't know. We decided two times was enough times. read more

Pizza Thief was the best spot I had in Portland, OR. It's so hard to find a good pizza in my opinion, especially thin crust, but Pizza Thief proved that it can be done right. The restaurant is really comfortable and cozy. Despite the menu offered, they only offer slices that's in the box. I had the Pepperoni, the crust was so thin and crispy. The cheese and pepperoni complimented the side of Calabrian chili sauce wonderfully. I also had another slice that came with hot honey--I don't remember the name, but also delicious. The bites with honey complimented the chili sauce perfectly! They also had sandwiches on the menu and dessert which unfortunately, I didn't get a chance to try. The gentlemen who took my order was also very kind! read more

Pizza Thief - Pizza Near Me - Portland, Oregon

I have been here twice. I wasn't impressed the first time but wanted to give it another shot. The pizza is ok not great but ok. The dough is pretty good. My issue is I ordered a cannoli and the price says $6.75 but rang up $7. I know it's only 25 cents but change the sign price to reflect the price being charged. I'm pretty sure I was charged more for each slice also but don't remember what the board price was. read more

Great pizza, friendly staff, [[HIGHLIGHT]]nice indoor and outdoor seating options[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. They sell large full pizzas, slices, and individual gluten free pizza...all good! read more

My favorite pizza in Portland at the moment! Can't go wrong with the pepperoni and got the current special. Sandwich is pretty stuffed and got messy. Not pictured is the cookies, chocolate chip and jam thumbprint, get the cookies. Service is excellent. There was a miscommunication when ordering and a slice was missing but they comped it for us! Outdoor seating with patio heaters read more

See all

I was briefly in Portland and went to a pizza spot that I knew had some delicious slices. The seasonal pesto slcies were our favorite, but their cheese is pretty great too. This time for some reason the wildeood pizza wasn't quite as great as I remembered it and I didn't really like the cannoli much, but the cookie was delicious and their ranch dressing here is superb as well! It's always nice to stop by one of my favorite pizza spots in Portland. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The service is always friendly and the ambiance is pretty nice as well :)[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

See all

The pizza is pretty mid. Standard NY style pizza. Greasy. Sold by the slice as well as whole pies. Tried both a mushroom and hot tony. Mushroom was less flavorful than expected and hot tony was just hot and also lacking flavor. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The vibe is cool and the beer list/bar next door are great.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] At 0200 after drinking a lot- this pizza would be satisfying for sure, but for a sober lunch it's a 3. read more

Amazing pie! Per slice available, I tried The Tony. Crispy pepperoni and the right amount of heat. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Patio is an amazing vibe.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Definitely give it a try! read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Order at counter, grab a drink from the bar, and hang whilst listening to 99's jams.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Very friendly and fast service. Kale salad and Pizza were on point. read more

See all

Oh my goodness the pizza is sooo tasty and crunchy!!! You must accompany it with the Kale Caesar Salad. Gosh, the entire experience was phenomenal. [[HIGHLIGHT]]From the service, to the flavors, to the ambiance it was such a great visit.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We'll definitely come back again! read more

Pizza Thief - Pizza Near Me - Portland, Oregon

See all

Always a good meal here. 3 slices and salad was 25 bucks not bad. Food is always good as well as the music and vibe. Easy parking on the street read more

Pizza Thief - Pizza Near Me - Portland, Oregon

See all

Wow. Between great pricing and really delicious flavor profiles, this spot nails it! Don't blame them for parking challenges ...

We got delivery, big pizza came and it was tasty. Our caesar salad was packed well and everything was in the right place. Would love to visit one day! read more

Pizza Thief - Half Marinara, half pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Portland, Oregon

During a work trip to the NW Montgomery Park area, found a great pizza spot. Pizza Thief, as you walk into the building you are greeted by a very friend staff. The interior is very causal and inviting, there is an attached walk way to an attached bar. To place your order, you line up and then queue to the main counter, to your left they have a large display case of the various pizza types, you can order them by slice or a whole pie. The menu board is easy to read, you really need to try the various dipping sauces, they have a small charge for them, my favorite the Ranch is amazing, enjoy the others. I ordered the Kevin Pepperoni slice, I really love the small Pepperoni, its a nice large slice of pizza, it takes a few min to heat up your pizza, they will call your name once its ready. They offer a variety of drinks both alcoholic and regular drinks. The pizza was amazing, very flavorful, cheesy and a nice crust, again the dipping sauces are a must. If you enjoy the outdoors, they have a nice covered area with bench style seating. It was very clean, bright and inviting business. I cannot wait to visit again. read more

See all

The slices are pretty good but not as good as many people make it out to be. Prices are quite high as well. $6+ for a thin crust slice is on the steep side. read more

Pizza Thief - Cheese Slice - Pizza Near Me - Portland, Oregon

Pizza Thief lived up to the hype! Their service is efficient, the atmosphere is lively and the food is doggone delicious. It is here where you can order pizza by the whole or by the slice. They have gluten free options and alcoholic beverage choices if either are your thing. But the best thing is that, yes, they do serve Coca-Cola products! My food recs are below: * Caesar: This is made with kale and is sprinkled with garlic focaccia crumbs. I highly recommend it because it pairs perfectly with a slice of your choice. * Wildwood: I love mushrooms and this is an excellent mushroom pizza! I'm definitely getting this again! * Highway 99: I didn't try this one personally but my friends were raving about it so figured I'd include it on my food recs. They said the braised pork shoulder is so delicious. It's a seasonal item so I'll definitely come back again (before it's gone) to try it for myself! Parking was a little scarce but not a huge problem. We went on a Sunday at 2pm. There was ample seating (and we were a party of 6). It's worth noting that after we ordered and took our seats, a big rush came through. However, the line moved rather quickly so don't feel discouraged. I highly recommend this place because it's really good pizza! Definitely give it a try! read more

This place connects to a bar and has plenty of seating. They have slices and an interesting menu. I saw a few sandwiches and desserts I would go back for. If you stop in around dinner time, expect a wait - even for one slice, which was all I wanted. It's "short order service" with one line to order at one register, so if a family of 6 has a big order ahead of you - it adds some time. Many options for slices, even vegan. I got the "hot tony" which lives up to its name. The toppings felt scarce for $6.50, especially for such a small slice. While tasty, it left more to be desired. I paid $4.50 for a small, glass coke - which might be the most I've paid anywhere in town for that size. I'll say the staff seemed nice, and they had a lot of people. The food seemed quality, but this is not your spot for a cheap slice. read more

See all

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Casual pizza place, with indoor and outdoor seating.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The kale/caesar salad is incredible and I pick one up every couple of weeks to bring home for dinner. Their chocolate chip / hazelnut cookies are also a real treat! read more

I'm going a 3.5 to 4 for Pizza Thief. Service: Great service! Very friendly and personable staff. Environment and ambiance was great for a pizza joint. I love that they do pie by the slice! Pizza: TBH, I feel that the Pizza Thief robbed me a bit on overall flavor. I got a plain cheese and pepperoni, as one should for judging. The plain cheese left me underwhelmed. The sauce has a nice herbaceous tone, but I really wish it had more tang and brightness. The flavor on the cheese was mid as well. The pep slice added nice flavor. The stracciatella sandwich was great and was recommend. Same with the delicious jalapeno cheese bread made fresh to order! Kale Caesar was pretty good as well. Overall, a good pizza spot, maybe not one of my top in the Portland area. I wouldn't discourage anyone from going, but I'm not screaming mug that you need to go either. If I'm in the area and need a good bite, I'd be coming back. read more

Pizza Thief - Stracciatella Sandwich = absolutely yes - Pizza Near Me - Portland, Oregon

See all

Finally checked out this "best pizza in Portland" spot... and honestly? Kinda average. The pizza wasn't bad, but it definitely didn't live up to the hype. Tried the focaccia too, and that was a miss for me. That said, [[HIGHLIGHT]]the atmosphere was really nice--cozy, lively without being too loud[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]--and the service was excellent. So while the food didn't blow me away, the overall vibe of the place was great. read more

In Portland for a visit and a local friend brought me here for dinner. It was amazing! The Hot Tony and Wildwood pizzas are solid, always on rotation to order pizzas. A solid dinner. NOW the Hwy 99 was INSANE, on of the best pizzas I have ever had! I loved it. Ordering, service, timing - everything was friendly, professional, and great. If you live in the Portland area or are just visiting you have to stop here!! ABSOLUTELY worth it! read more

Great if you want something to eat after visiting the Adidas employee store. It's a few blocks away. My wife and I walked there while our kids were shopping at Adidas. Good solid pizza. Thin crispy crust. Only had one slice that was reheated so not sure if a fresh whole pizza would be better. Nice that you can get it by the slice. There are so many good pizza places in Portland... I would say top third, but not top 3. read more

Friendly staff and amazing pizza! Love thin crust and all the different types of pizza, beers on draft and desserts! It's a delicious stop after shopping at adidas:) read more

Pizza Thief - GF SEASONAL - SUNGOLD SUMMER - Pizza Near Me - Portland, Oregon

See all

Had a great Italian sandwich and pizza inside Great Notion Brewery NW. You sit inside the brewery, place your order and pay on the computer, and grab a number for them to deliver your food to your table. It was a bit busy for lunch but we got our food pretty quickly. I wish the pizza was a little less browned, but I would definitely like to try it again. The Italian sandwich was large and was great split with two people. I will definitely get it again. read more

See all

Great pizza at $6/slice with lots of different options! Cool bar attached and a nice by the glass wine list. Chocolate Hazelnut cookie and the Kale Caesar salad are a must! read more

How totally Portland! good thing it is up by Montgomery Park and out of the bad zone of downtown Portland. We loved being outside on a nice day. The pizza is wonderful, very tasty without the heartburn after effect. The staff is wonderfully helpful. You have an option of eating inside, or going outside. They were set up for a birthday party inside which takes up most of the seating. you can go into the bar next to it as well. read more

See all

I've heard great things about Pizza Thief and wanted to check it out. It was a Saturday night so we expected it to be busy. Once we got to the counter we were told we could get slices right away but whole pies would be a 45 minute wait. They only had one of the two kinds I wanted to try by the slice so we ordered a couple "appetizer" slices of the Wildwood to hold us over until the whole "entree" pizza (The Baller) would be ready. We walked into the adjoining Bandit Bar, grabbed a table and a couple drinks to wait. Pizza was good, service was friendly, drinks were ok. read more

Pizza Thief - The Baller: tomato sauce, fresh basil, ricotta, meatballs (pork-beef), mozz-provolone, grana, Sicilian oregano, & chili flake. - Pizza Near Me - Portland, Oregon

See all

Stopped here for a slice before going out and was not disappointed. Good price for a large slice, and exactly the kind of decadent greasy pizza you want. Was hard to choose a flavor they had so many good ones. Service was quick too. We sat outside, which was great for people watching, and it is dog friendly. read more

Pizza Thief - Pizza Near Me - Portland, Oregon

First time having getting lunch to go. I ordered a slice of seasonal, vegan and a pepperoni pizza. The service was amazing and very helpful. The vegan slice was my favorite and the seasonal. I got the pepperoni slice for my coworker. Highly recommend this pizza spot!!! read more

Pizza Thief - To go box - Pizza Near Me - Portland, Oregon

See all

Best pizza I've had in Portland. NY style pizza that actually reminds me of NYC. Great, speedy service. Restaurant has great vibes including great music and two classic arcades (being quarters). The attached bar makes lots of great cocktails as well. Plenty of sodas as well both craft and classic. Today I got the Hot Tony (Pepperoni w/ peppers) and my kids got Kevins (Pepperoni). Their classic pepperoni is always a home run. My second slice was their seasonal w/ squash and goat cheese. The sweet and savory combo was incredible. Pizza Thief is my kid's favourite pizza in Portland (and it's mine as well). Sorry, no pics cuz we basically inhaled it. read more

Wow. First time here and even though it took a bit to get a slice to go it was 100% worth the wait. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The vibe is really nice.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The staff were super nice too. However! This slice of pepperoni is out of this world. It's so good!!! I'm so happy my new apartment is around the corner! HIGHLY recommend!!! read more