I liked the original Pizza Thief in NW because the pizza slices were alway so fresh with quality ingredients. But it was far so I was excited to check out their new Southeast location closer to my neighborhood. I went on a Friday night, and it's a nice big space but it got packed pretty fast. It was my first time there so I was disoriented by the menu and whether to order by the slice or a whole pizza. The counter guy wasn't helpful at all, he had this aloof attitude and didn't say much so we were just left to figure it out on our own. My friend started ordering the slices he saw in the counter case so I followed along. We both had a slice of the wildwood or mushroom pizza, and then the "double spicy pepperoni," which wasn't the typical NY-style pizza but squares like Detroit style. The double pepperoni was really good, warm and comforting, with crispy pepperoni that was rounded out by the drizzle of honey. The wildwood was actually overly cheesy, so much that you could barely find any mushrooms. Plus, the slice was warmed up but it still felt like it was sitting there all day, not really fresh like. I also tried the Caesar salad, which is made with curly kale and mustard greens. It was a huge salad and tasted good, which crunchy elements, but it didn't remind me of a Caesar as much as a spot on kale salad. I also got a "Darby Was Here" (I think that's what it was called) mezcal cocktail and it was done well. Besides the one person at the counter, there was only one guy serving, which is basically running the food to the tables. So when it's packed, it could feel a bit confusing as he tries to figure out how much stuff you're waiting for with your number or if he brought all your food. I feel overall the pizza was good but there's other decent places in the neighborhood as well. With the tiny parking space for the lot, not sure it's that convenient. read more