Local neighborhood spot that has been around forever. Still the same family who owns it, and it's incredible! Pizza is awesome, and hands down the best calzone I've ever had in my life! read more

So... I have been patronizing Pizza Supreme for about 50 years now... Actually longer as I started coming here as a teen when they were in Roosevelt Field. (Wow, do I feel old.) This place is awesome and their pizza is what makes this happen. They are currently located on Stewart Ave behind Roosevelt field in the Burlington Shopping Center. Very easy in and out with plenty of parking. My wife and I wanted a couple of slices of pizza and thought it would be fun to stop by here for some pizza and memories. Pizza is still delicious and tasted exactly the way I remember it. I always enjoyed watching them take it out of the oven and slicing it. Everyone always wanted the coroners for that little extra crust. Great crispy crust, tasty sauce and cheese. They now also have the more conventional slices and toppings. Glad me made it here and looking forward to some more return trips KUDOs to the friendly team at Pizza Supreme. read more

See all

OMG, I've been testing Classic Pies for over 60 years and "SUPREME PIZZA" Thru Generations It has never lost a Touch. I Love the "Classic "But others Swear By the Sicilian. There never will be or ever will be Such an establishment" to deliver Perfection' . Thank You for an Experience" few will ever enjoy Unless they Visit SUPREME" JUST AMAZING...... CHRIS WESTBURY Always read more

I enjoyed this Pizza Supreme over 60 years ago at Green Acres shopping mall in Valley Stream, Long Island. Years later, I happened to come across this one at this location. I wasn't sure if it was the same one i enjoyed so many years ag 87-6TX783-44o. (A slice at that time was .15 lol). When I tried their unique square slice, it was the same delicious flavor I had enjoyed so many years ago. I was very pleased that they delivered at no delivery charge. All their food is delicious and reasonably priced. The portions are generous, and they don't cut corners in their preparation. NOTE: I found that if you try to order online, you may receive a message saying your address is outside their delivery area. BUT IF YOU CALL THE STORE DIRECTLY, THEY WILL PROBABLY DELIVER (as I found out) . read more

I drive 30 miles to get their square pizza. Crust is light, cheese is stringy....outstanding!

Square pizza is the best around. Been coming here for almost 20 years, when my parents used to bring me. I'm sure the rest of the pizza matches the quality of the square slices, but I just can't bring myself to order anything but. read more

Love their square pizza. Moved to Florida miss them so much Going to ny in august. Planning on having pizza every day!!! Bruce read more

Best pizza in Nassau County! Service is great. Classic square pie, thin slice, sweet sauce.

Ordered from here for a party at a local gymnastics facility for a birthday party. Pizza was good. Very reasonable. However the delivery guy did not speak a word of English and we were expecting to pay with a credit card. Luckily we had cash on us but it was very unprofessional to have a delivery driver not being able yo communicate with us. read more

I'm a Pizza enthusiast and accustomed to the good Pizza available in the boroughs of NYC. So, take that into account when considering my opinion. I was disappointed with the round pie. Crust was "doughy," undercooked really. It didn't have that snap when folded. Sauce was good, cheese was good, but the crust was so disappointing. Mediocre Pizza in my opinion. The shop itself had a nice/good feel, like an old Pizzeria from Brooklyn. The owner was present, which shows a level of care, and it was clean with plenty of parking. I'll try their square pie next. read more

I used to like this place and we used to go all the time.Recently I ordered a pizza pie and it tasted pretty bad. The cheese wasn't gooey enough and the sauce tasted weird. Never will be coming back :( read more

Careful when ordering to stay and they say go sit down they may just forget about you and when you get up because you know your food's been in the oven too long they'll still sit there and just help new people ordering and tell you to wait and take your chicken roll out of the oven the bottom is permanently stuck to the oven and your slice is so hard. It's like biting into a piece of Styrofoam, but don't worry that Minnesota will cost you $17. read more

I've been visiting Pizza Supreme since I was probably about 8 years old. My dad used to visit the record shop that was next door and we would grab slices afterwards. A Saturday tradition. This place is home of the " Square Slice ". A slice that looks much like a Grandma slice but is a little thicker but thinner than a Sicilian slice. This slice is very moist. Very cheeses and perfect amount of tomato sauce. Very good quality for the price. The counter guys are nice and the owner is always on staff working hard. I love the garlic knots here. Full of garlic and very fresh. The also have great rolls ! Try the veggie roll with broccoli rabe and spinach. Very good. This is a classic pizza shop clearly here to stay in the mini mall. read more

Ordered pizza here tonight when I was at my moms. Came out really good! Meatball parm hero was realllly good. I would come back!

I find it a bit funny when I finally get around to trying a business that has been around for years, 60 in this case, then wonder what took me so long to try it. Pizza Supreme, just as the name suggests, is all about really good pizza, especially their square pie. The square pie from here is all about the texture, but of course the tangy tomato sauce and creamy mozzarella cheese brings it all together. I love the crispy bottom and crust while the rest of the dough is light and airy. I could probably polish off a half a pie of these slices without blinking an eye, but I usually pair a slice with another type of slice they have in their case. Of the ones I tried, the Chicken and broccoli is generously topped and well made. I really liked the spinach and broccoli combo because all that green makes me feel healthy. I have yet to try a slice I haven't liked. The service is very good, there are plenty of tables so I usually hit this spot for a quick bite on my way to shopping in stores in the area, but I would order delivery from here next time I am looking for some pretty damn good pizza! read more

Not my go to pizza joint in the Garden city area. The texture of the bread and crust is too chewy for my liking. It feels like you're biting into an "Auntie Annes bagel" instead of a nice crunch heard from a slice of pizza. The Sicilian slice is not your typical slice that I'm use to having. It is much smaller and like I said before, the crust is just too soggy for me. The place is OK for a quick fix, but if you want to drive around, there are other better pizzerias in the area you could try. read more

Pizza Supreme - Chef - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York

See all

This place has been around a long time, I remember when it was in Roosevelt field Mall. I am glad they are still in business though sometimes I am at a loss to know why because my beloved is so in love with this pizza we always order their square pizza (he loves it) really its just ok the sauce is ok not smashing stunning but just ok the cheese looks like it was sliced from a block of pollyo which is ok if you like pollyo but I don't its a bland simple pizza they have a fridge full of the usual canned and bottle beverages the place looks like it was new in 1985 its clean enough but nothing fancy service is with a smile read more

Pizza Supreme - I love grape soda with pizza I don't know why - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York

If you consider yourself a foodie you must try their square slice. Made with Vermont mozzarella, it's out of this world. That's not to take away from their plain slice which is very good too. Barstool needs to come review the square slice. I give it a 9.2 read more

Pizza Supreme - Square pie w/ pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York

square is the bomb! just always perfect and consistent and i'd recommend the regular garden salad also to compliment

Might be the worst pizza I've ever had. The sauce was bitter and watery. The guys who work there were nice, but I will not be returning, unfortunately. read more

I was in Garden City any way so I had too stop at my favorite pizza place in the whole world. Pizza Supreme has the best square pizza in the entire world. Would not of been a complete day in garden city if i did not stop and have a few slices. Just writing this review is making me want more. Very friendly and helpful staff always a smile on there faces. read more

Pizza Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York

Was passing by and decided to stop in, as per the reviews. Tale of the tape: Garlic Knots The reviews got me in here to check these out. Upon first glance they looked good. They have a light to medium texture, with an ok garlic flavor. I'd say they were ok to good. Spinach and Broccoli Vegetable slice Spinach and broccoli sauteed up proper, but not oily at all. Great flavor in and of itself, which includes the just enough tomato sauce supplying the right amount of tangy savoryness. The crust, in addition, is amazing - thin, crispy, having a flavor all its own yet strong enough to support the vegetables on top. This slice is a winner from beginning to end! Square slice This is what Pizza Supreme is known for, as they proudly tout it on all of their take out menus. Unfortunately, it's been so long since I went to Pizza Supreme, that I totally forgot whether I liked it or not! I will go back and give it another shot - that'll teach me! read more

Love love love their pizza here! Not from the area but whenever I'm near by I'm always stopping in! The workers are nice and clean! Will definitely be back read more

I stopped here for a pizza slice. I ordered the square slice. It was OK. You order at the counter. I would go there again for a slice.

I have been going here for so many years. I go back to the days it was in Roosevelt field. There square pie is one of a kind

Their choice of pizzas are very good. The quality and taste are excellent when they're freshly made. I went to their website and looked at their menu. I then called in an order and had it delivered. It shows on their menu $12.95 per dozen chicken wings. I ordered a dozen Buffalo wings. When it arrived it was $19.25 per dozen. With tax $20.80. No carrot sticks, no celery sticks , no blue cheese, no ranch dip. Only 12 wings. read more

Very good pizza just the way I like it. Salads are also good if you want to go that route

YUP i finally have found them. The motherlode of meatballs. Yes the square pizza is great too always has been since they were over in the Field. But i asked for meatballs to go today and they were spectacular. So impressed. Friendly place, seating inside. Score read more

Hahaha.. People who left bad reviews because there is too much cheese.... Go back to Olive Garden. They have been in business over 60 years... They must be doing something right. Just get the square pizza and some garlic knots, you can thank me later read more

Pizza Supreme - the inside of a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York

See all

We ordered two pies from here and they were both drowning in cheese. For some of you cheese lovers out there, you would think that this would be good. However, the crust couldn't support all the cheese so you literally couldn't eat the slice unless you ate off your plate. Would not order again. read more

What's with this pizza place?? There is nothing I love more than eating a cold slice during lunchtime........... Normally, A pizza place should be rockin' during lunchtime. Hot pizzas coming out of the oven, not here. I walk in about 1pm and there is no line. Hey, do you have a Grandma slice? Nope, just this regular pizza. The guy takes a slice and slings it in the oven. I give him a five and he gives me back two bucks? I'm like, dude. What the eff?? Oh, I ran out of quarters and he gives me .75 back. $2.25 per slice? I sit down, oh snap. I need oregano and red pepper flakes. There is a big sign: don't bring the shakers to the tables! Kinda in your face don't you think? How about, I have a short time for lunch so how about a hot slice of pizza? read more

Consistent good food and great delivery service . Owner and his staff are very nice and accommodating.

I don't know what it is, but lately I've been on a pizza bender. That beautiful cheesy triangle with all the fixings is what my body has been craving as of late. So it's no surprise that when I saw "Pizza Supreme" my steering wheel made a unexpected u-turn. The building isn't special, it's your standard pizzeria layout. So I knew it had to be about the food. I walked over to the counter and saw a team of guys working to make the very best pizza. I spoke to one of the guys who was very friendly. He asked what I wanted and that was the problem. What to choose! I knew it was definitely going to be a speciality slice, but which one? They all looked so good and covered in cheese (Did I mention I love CHEESE!!). I wanted to try my goto but decided against it this one time. I spotted the white slice and said "It's you on the menu today." I made my selection and when to the bathroom to freshen up. By the time I got out my slice was hot and ready. It also was covered in a mountain of cheese and handed to me with care. I sat down and admired the work before I went to work destroying it. When I got the formalities out the way I took my first bite. It was a match made in heaven. The white slice was incredibly tasty and fresh. I couldn't believe they got away with using so much rogatta cheese. I was in awe of their work. Trust me when I say I will definitely return. It's not to much trouble or out of my way being from Suffolk County either. I recommend if you're on a bender like me the obvious choice is to go Supreme. read more

See all

Stopped by for a quick bite. Service fast, food fresh. Would have liked a little smile or something with my meal but, maybe they're just not into the Christmas spirit this year. IMHO, I love service with a smile.... Goes a long way! read more

Pizza Supreme - My slice with extra cheese, yum! - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York

See all

I visited Pizza Supreme at lunch time on a Friday. The service was prompt (I waited no more than a few minutes). My order was straightforward: one square and one round slice. The round slice must have recently come out of the oven, as it was hot and needed to reheating. The square slice, however, was put in the oven. I tried the square slice first. It was mediocre. The sauce was dried up and there was a sparse amount of cheese. Overall, it was relatively flavorless (so I put a small amount of salt on it). After, I moved on to the round slice, which was large. It was the better of the two slices. Two comments however - it was VERY greasy. Ordinarily, I don't use napkins to soak up oil, but it was necessary with this slice. Secondly, it was a very "soupy" slice, and a fork and knife was needed. I'll probably give it a second try, but this pizza spot did not "wow" me. read more

Absolutely WONDERFUL pizza. The white pizza is AMAZING!!! I have tried pizza all over the map and they are definitely one of the best places I've had! Keep being amazing y'all! read more

Pizza Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York

This business has had three owners. The first two really knew how to make pizza. The new owner says he worked for the old owners for 20 years. Obviously he learned nothing. We rented a car and drove out from Manhattan as we always remembered this being fabulous pizza. A waste of time and money. It was Awful! The dough taste it as though it were toasted bread! There was not very much sauce and what they're was was sour and pasty. The cheese was a very poor quality, not "Melty" As you would expect. No reason to go back here. read more

Great pizza ! I remember going here with my grandpa when I was a kid and I still go back 30 years later. Excellent service as always and everything I've ordered is delicious especially the square pie ! read more

Pretty sure I ordered pizza, not oil with a side of cheese, bread and tomato sauce. Such a hit or miss with this place but how you mess something so simple up to this extent doesn't show it as a honest mistake but straight up carelessness. Never again. Other places are more expensive but at least they can put together a plain pie read more

Honestly... I've been there before to pick up and eat there and the pizza was good. Today I ordered for delivery, sorry but never again. Cold pizza, I mean not frozen, but def not hot nor warm. So disappointed. I even called up, and the guy on the phone was like ehh... whatever. I'll take my business elsewhere, to many pizzerias around to be served cold terrible pizza. I posted a picture, you can see the harden cheese and sauce. read more

Pizza Supreme - Terrible cold pizza for delivery - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York