I had an absolutely outstanding experience here--this place sets the bar for what great pizza should be. From the moment you walk in, you can tell they take pride in every detail, and that carries straight through to the food. The pizza itself is phenomenal. The crust strikes that perfect balance--crispy on the outside with just the right amount of chew inside. The sauce is rich, flavorful, and clearly made with quality ingredients, while the cheese is perfectly melted and generously layered without overpowering the rest of the pie. Every bite tastes fresh, balanced, and crafted with care. What really stood out was the consistency and attention to detail. Whether you're going classic or trying one of their specialty pies, the flavors are always spot on. You can tell this isn't just pizza--it's a passion. On top of that, the service is friendly, fast, and welcoming, making the whole experience even better. This is the kind of place you keep coming back to--and recommend to everyone you know. Easily one of the best pizza spots around. Highly recommend. read more

Taglio Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

See all

Love the pizza even if it isn't my preferred style. You can tell the ingredients are fresh. Only reason I took off a star is the music was too loud for me to talk to anyone. Also might have been just the day since it was busy but the young guy taking my order seemed rushed and annoyed I was taking some time to decide on my order. read more

Pizza is good. Some things to gripe about: 1. AI picks up your delivery order.... And you can't order by the slice. And AI messed up when I was giving my credit card. So I had to order online. 2. I made my oder at 12:04pm. It's now 1pm and I'm still waiting for my order, which was apparently held up because of some grilled chicken that's still cooking. So I removed the chicken from the order. And I'm still waiting over 10 minutes after that. Totally unacceptable. read more

Pizza made from quality ingredients from Italy. The Roma rectangular pizzas are sooo good. Tight space and long waits plus hard to find parking makes this place more for pickup while another waits in car. A definite recommend. read more

See all

Love their pizza and would probably say it is one of the best in the area. My main issue is the menu. First off, you can't order by the slice online which is a big deal IMO. Also, they need to make some of the items on the catering menu available on the regular dinner menu. The fact that I can't order a side of penne alla vodka with a chicken parm plate is a bit ridiculous. If they had a larger menu, we would order from here with much greater frequency. But because the menu is so limited, we have no choice to order from the other place up the block on Mineola Blvd most of the time. read more

Solid pizza. My third time coming here, but honestly the first two times I didn't get such great experiences with the pizza, maybe because I tried the really special slices. I didn't particularly enjoy one of the slices the staff recommended to me. I asked for something with more protein. He responded they all have protein and recommends me something that had so much onions and so little meat. Decided to stick to the basics this time and it was decent. The vodka sauce was creamy. Top it off with some cola and we have a solid meal. read more

Taglio Pizza - Vodka Pepperoni and Regular Vodka Slice - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

The quality is out of this world. Im so excited that Dario from Dario's pizza is now teaming up too because the dedication to quality and taste will consistently be amazing. For what you're getting the prices are really fair in my opinion. It can seem steep to alot but you're not going to find this value is most basic pizzerias. And trust me...it is worth every penny. The heros are stuff and full of flavor. The pizza slices are huge packed with toppings. I highly recommend ordering on the app bc this place gets crazy and can get backed up. read more

See all

Saw that this pizzeria in Mineola has been top ranked, not just in the city or state but nation so I decided to swing by to try it out myself! This place is known for their Roman style pizza which is similar to Sicilian. Therefore, I did not order the basic triangular shaped pizzas to try nor did I base my rating on their plain cheese slice. Upon walking in, I was greeted by one of the employees asking what I want. I asked which slice is the most popular and he told me the buffalo chicken Roman slice, barbecue Roman slice, and the burrata regular slice. Unfortunately, I only had room for one slice and I definitely wanted to try one of the Roman slices they had. There were so many choices I almost couldn't decide but the potato Roman slice called to me especially when it was topped with rosemary (my favorite!) At the cashier, I saw the frozen drinks and asked the lady what they were - one was piña colada and the other one was margarita. I ordered a piña colada, but after I paid they informed me that the piña colada was not ready and gave me a sample of the margarita to try to see if I was ok with it. I tried it and it wasn't like any other margarita I've tried. It tasted very refreshing since it was frozen and it was more lemony than margarita-y. I sat down at one of the 7-8 tables and began to enjoy my slice. It was very good and I've never seen potatoes on pizza before. I will definitely be back to try more Roman slices and the burrata regular slice since it looked very good behind the glass too. There is a restroom at this pizzeria and some diagonal parking in front which is also shared with the Mineola LIRR station. read more

See all

There's some hype about this place being one of the best pizzerias on Long Island. I'm not an expert, but it was okay. Wasn't bad, wasn't great - middle of the road. read more

Taglio Pizza - Regular slice - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

My family loves pizza! I saw a list of top pizzas and Taglio was on it! I am thinking, right in my backyard! They opened another branch in another town but we wanted to try the original one. And it didn't disappoint! We had the BBQ Chicken, Eggplant Parm, Vodka Roni Pesto and Truffle Mushroom all Roman style. They were delicious and great flavor! If you are a mushroom lover, you would enjoy the truffle mushroom. It was loaded with mushrooms! The chewy dough and crunch on the crust was so good! Service is friendly and efficient. There are several meter parking spots in front of the pizzeria. There are several tables available for seating. And a bar table against the window. We'll definitely be back! read more

Your friendly neighborhood Uber driver Barry has just referred yet another passenger to the greatest pizza place in the history of the world. These two brothers are visiting someone in the hospital nearby and after that they're going to be making their first ever trip to Taglio. What can I say? I can't come here without going and getting a few slices and I refer everybody. I know to this great place. Just giving thanks on Thanksgiving. read more

Taglio Pizza - I want to give thanks, on this Thanksgiving. Hahaha. I love Taglio! - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

Oh how I am so happy we finally tried the pizza here. I couldn't help myself. I had to try 3 slices. The potato slice was out of this world. Oh the satisfaction. I could eat this forever. The texture and flavor were incredible. The eggplant slice was a 4/5. And the veggie no cheese was also superb. The crust is the best I've ever had. This place hands down was the best pizza I've had. Service was great. Store was small but clean. read more

See all

WOW! This place absolutely lives up to the hype. Every slice was fresh, flavorful, and seriously delicious. The staff was incredibly kind and welcoming, which made the experience even better. The atmosphere is spot on - they balance a modern feel with TVs and great artwork, while still keeping that classic, casual "stop in for a slice and a Coke" pizza shop vibe. Clean space, great energy, and definitely worth going out of your way for. I'll be back for more!!! read more

Taglio Pizza - Pepperoni Spinach Artichoke The Serra Prosciutto Arugula - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

Pizza was delicious! Great selection of different pizzas - reasonably priced, space is small so getting a table might be a bit difficult during peak meal times. Service was pretty fast. You know it's good when you see local NYPD going in and out consistently getting their orders... read more

Taglio Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

Best Roman style pizza in Long Island hands down. Great selection of toppings so you're able to try different variations each visit. They offer all by the slice which is the best aspect. The dough is perfect with a light crunch. Service is friendly yet quick just how a pizzeria should be. Far as ambiance, it's just like all other pizzerias, but very clean. Situated next to a hospital and the Mineola train station so be prepared during peak times such as lunch and dinner hours to expect a line. Meter parking all around and it's a hit or miss. The few times I went, I was able to find a spot within three minutes. read more

See all

WOW. I've been dying to try this pizza for awhile. I happen to be in Manola today so I figured I have to go. It lives up to all the hype. I tried the Margherita , regular slice, pesto/vodka/margarita slice, and the grandma with pepperoni. All of it is insanely good. I wanna go back and try every single slice they have. lol. read more

Taglio Pizza - top left regular slice, top right margarita slice bottom left grandma with pepperoni, bottom, right pesto, vodka, marinara slice. - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

Tried to give it another chance. Walked in and thought I walked into a nightclub. The music was ridiculously loud, so loud that I couldn't hear myself speak. I felt bad for the older couple that was there. They looked very agitated while eating their slices because of it. Got a BBQ chicken slice which oddly looks exactly like another slice from another pizzeria but I won't name names because apparently it triggers cocky people. The sauce on the chicken is tasty but there was barely any mozzarella cheese and the chicken was inedible. It was burnt and overcooked because the chicken bits are so small. And AGAIN the bottom was charred, not even burnt this time. read more

Taglio Pizza - BBQ Chicken, chicken was rubber and bottom was charred. - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

Wow! The barrata slice was incredible. Artichoke and spinach amazing. Margarita was delicious. Can't wait to go back. The guys behind the counter were awesome too. Wish I lived closer. read more

Great pizza experience! The atmosphere and customer service is excellent! The pizza is outstanding. I highly recommend the Margarita sesame seed crust and the Roman style Sicilian pie with fresh basil! read more

Taglio Pizza - Roman style Sicilian pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

Amazing find near the mineola train station! It appears to be a pizzeria in the middle of nowhere where. But it is a gem! When you walk in you see cartoon characters art work on one side, flour and tomato on the other, and a counter displaying many of the different pies they make in front. There is a line to order pies and a line to order slices. Was you approach the back you see the menu flashing across the screens. What to choose, what to choose. There are over 20 types of pies you can create. You can have it "Roman" style or round. Be a little healthy and order one of their salads! Don't forget to get a cold beer or one of the fun Frozen sangria or margaritas. Everything was delicious! You can't go wrong with whatever you order. Looking forward to coming back to try the parm plates or heros. Looks amazing!!! read more

See all

7-30-25. My 2nd time here. Definitely a notch above your average Long Island pizza joint. You can certainly taste the quality of the ingredients they use to prepare their pies. Today I tasted a white slice, a mortadella and pistachio slice, a broccoli rabe with sausage and peppers slice, a New York pepperoni slice and a burrata slice. I have to say they were all really good but the pepperoni slice and the burrata slice were fantastic. The doough is excellent and it has just the right amount of char which provides a blend of crunchy and chewy that will have your taste buds wanting more. Most of the slices are $6.25, which I feel is a little steep even for today's prices, but as I mentioned, the quality of ingredients provides a noticeable difference. It's a pretty busy pizza place and they do a lot of take out. If you want to dine in, there are probably about 9 or 10 tables inside......so if you walk in, grab a table because they get gobbled up quickly. My only issue with this establishment is ordering is a bit of a sh!t show. There's plenty of people behind the counter but they aren't all helping customers. They shift back and forth preparing pizzas, taking orders and checking on what's in the ovens. If you don't speak up and are a little pushy, you might get overlooked or others "in line" may just jump ahead of you if they make eye contact with one of the employees before you do. read more

Taglio Pizza - 7-30-25. Pepperoni N.Y. slice, ricotta cheese white slice, mortadella slice, sausage & peppers with broccoli rabe and a margarita slice. - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

See all

5 stars! SO worth the hype. The texture is unreal and unlike any other slice i've had before--so airy! If you're placing a to-go order you have to order online as they don't take orders via phone. When I got to the restaurant, I got to watch them put fresh basic and cheese which was so cool! Even though this place is quite the hike for us, I would definitely go out of my way to get it again!! read more

See all

Taglio has a reputation for being one of the best pizzas in NY. Boy are they right! Let's start with the service. Very good, staff was great. The place is tucked away but it's a nice spot. Now on to the food. Pizza is as advertised, the Roman style is delicious and not greasy. It's a bit pricey but worth it. Go eat here!! read more

Taglio Pizza - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

See all

Pizza is below average. The owner is a reason not to go in itself. Go elsewhere. So many better options.

We came to Tagglios after hearing it called "the best on Long Island" and even seeing claims that it ranks #3 in the country (a bold statement that sets the bar high.) The regular slice was excellent: crisp yet chewy crust, and just the right amount of cheese and sauce. Classic, well executed, and satisfying. We tried a few of their specialty slices the mushroom truffle and burrata were both solid, but the real standout was the potato, mushroom, and rosemary. Surprisingly my favorite earthy, savory, and beautifully balanced. That said, claiming to be the third best in the nation is a big responsibility and one they don't quite live up to. For Long Island, it's definitely a top contender. But compared to NYC pizza standards, it falls just short. Still, I'd give it a solid 8/10, which is pretty impressive. Worth a visit if you're in the area and craving a quality slice. read more

See all

Best pizza on Long Island. Wonderful employees named Luis and Santiago gave us recommendations on what to get and we had 6 different slices between 3 people and all were delicious. I'm convinced any slice you get is as yummy as the next. Ambiance was very special, many diverse people came in and out. Parkings not the best but worth it for some of the best pizza you can find. We got the Roman, regular slice, buffalo, burrata, vodka, meat lover, and San gennaro. We've been to the other location, while both are good, definitely come to this one! read more

Minus the fact that parking was very limited.. the food was excellent. We got their pizza and we got two different types of their pizza slices and it was really delicious and super tasty. We really enjoyed it there and will be going back soon. read more

Today I decided to stop by Taglio pizza after having a procedure done at the nearby NYU Langone hospital . I was starving and when I walked in the pizza looked amazing . There was so many different kinds I really didn't know what to order nor what I was even looking at . So my first recommendation is that they put a sign by the trays of pizza so customers know what it is . I asked about two of the pizzas but didn't wanna keep asking because the worker was obviously busy . I ordered 2 margherita slices and one slice of pepperoni with sesame crust . So I was excited to try it because I was hungry of course and because of all the hype they get on social media . Well, it certainly seems like hype because the pizza looks good and it's fancy and definitely picture worthy . However it looks crispy and fresh it was neither of those . How is a pizza charred looks well done and crispy but it's floppy and chewy and so thin that it lacks basic structure. I'm glad I tried it but this was definitely a one off . I'm thinking well hoping that if someone was to order a whole fresh pie perhaps it would be much better . read more

This location os prime!!!! Near the LIRR, hospital and just a nice hustle and bustle of mineola. Indoor seating was sufficient enough for the busy time of a day we got there. I loved the custom artwork throughout the place, obviously thats why i snapped some flics. But most importantly, the pizza...... SPOT ON!!!! I seen bbq chicken slice and of course had to get that. To begin it was cooked to perfection, from the crust to the dough to the temperature the sent it out at. The best part of the slice was the pieces of bbq chicken though, that had a really great bite to them and just were the exact bbq it needed. I also had a vodka slice which again hit the mark spot on from every aspect of enjoyment you can think of. The regular slice with pepperoni was crunchy, with stringy hot cheese and just the right amount. Of pepperoni on it. The pepperoni was cooked to crispy and like little cups. It made me want to go back to try the many other style of pizzas they had but i decided to just promise myself another trip to this gem of a pizzeria read more

See all

Being Italian and raised on homemade pizza, I can tell you that what makes Taglio's pizza superb is the quality of their ingredients. All imported from Italy, it's what all pizza should taste like. The crust is super thin and crispy which I like. No coal or wood oven here, just electric so don't expect a woodsy or charcoal taste. The crust has sesame seeds on the round pizza so just know that if you can't have seeds. The only thing I wasn't crazy about is the very loud pop music playing. Not that I hated the music, but it's a small place & not everyone like loud music. It could be more neutral and serene. This place was voted the 3rd best in the country. I'm not sure about that (because NY has THE best pizza anyway!) But I will say it's the best sauce, prosciutto & mozzarella cheese I've ever had in a pizzeria! 5 stars for the sauce, minus 1 star for the Uber loud music. read more

Taglio Pizza - Prosciutto & arugula slice, Buffalo chicken & 2 margarita slices - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

Was excited to try out the #3 pizza place in the US (also #99 in the world)! Conveniently located right outside the Mineola train station - for when you're grabbing a slice on your way to or from home; we saw a lot of people in their work clothes grabbing boxes to go. They also have online ordering available, which is what we did but honestly the line seems to move pretty fast - so I'd say not necessary unless you have a large order. The price is reasonable, with most slices ~$5 and specialty slices at a higher price point and each slice is substantial with lots of dough and toppings. I got the Classic NY Slice which was everything you want in a slice - saucy without being drenched and crispy. I also tried the Palate E'Rosemario Roman Slice - the dough very much resembles focaccia, really soft yet crunchy. While I knew flavor was going to be simple (potato slices with rosemary and pecorino), it was almost too simple for my taste - whether it be punchy peppercorns or flaky salt atop or more rosemary, needed a little oomph. But that wouldn't stop me from coming again - I'd love to get a whole pie of their Vodka Roman Slice, delish! read more

Taglio Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

Went there today with friends for the first time . Had a great experience. Marvin was taking care of us at the counter and treated us like any customer would want to be treated. Excellent customer service . All the various slices we had were great. If I had to note one negative it would be Not enough Marvin's. lol , Serious though I could not really find any negatives and we'll definitely be back . read more

Pizza best I've had so far in Long Island. Very crispy love the taste very fresh. Service was quick and attentive. Very hip place music was good not loud. Also have TVs showing sports at the time. Definitely worth trying out. Thank you for the great piazza really enjoyed it. read more

Taglio Pizza - Taglio New York style pie - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

Got regular pie of pizza to go! Called ahead and was super crowded inside. All ingredients are from Italy; sauce, cheese and dough. read more

Taglio Pizza - Regular pizza pie! All ingredients from Italy! Crust is out of this world! - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

Came here after trying the pizza at Farmingdale and being super impressed but this location wasn't the best. I got the prosciutto arugula slice which is definitely good but it was different than the one I had at Farmingdale. My other one didn't have red pepper on it, maybe it was supposed to before but the pepper overpowers everything. The bottom was also a little tough so it was hard and I couldn't chew all of it. Still it was a delicious slice and I'd go back read more

Had the opportunity to visit Taglio pizza on a random Sunday fairly early around 5:30 PM, a small line on the inside, patrons, selecting the choice of pizza that they wanted, which gave me thankfully, a few minutes to decide on my own. The pesto vodka, I believe seem to be the most popular. I went with the mortadella pistachio, the spinach and artichoke, and the Burrata, which was a round slice. the proclamation everywhere for Taglio pizza is "Roman style pizza" so I haven't been to Rome (yet) however I am unfamiliar with what the style of Roman pizza might be? My first guess would be the shape which is a narrow rectangle pie as opposed to a square or the more common round for the American style. at the cash register the clerk noticed that I had Yelp open on my phone and said oh are you looking at the reviews and I told her that I was Yelp Elite and she did not know that what that was, and I tried to explain it briefly to her (Badly because I am socially awkward) and if I am not prepared, I become unable to compute. After my bungled explanation, she said oh! You get a free slice next time which was sweet of her. I had the mortadella slice in House, and I took the other two slices to go. The mortadella slice was piled high, and my only recommendation would be to have them heated it up a little bit longer because the middle was not warm. at home I had the spinach artichoke and I had to toast it twice because it's very top-heavy and I like my pizza crunchy. I'm not sure exactly what sets Taglio pizza apart and I'm not sure why they got voted "best of" or "number one in"yet the pizza was delicious. I am always a sucker for pizza piled up with toppings and a crunchy crust. The staff was accommodating and absolutely on point. They did not have fountain soda. I did observe Peroni, and beers? some Italian sodas and regular bottled soda in the fridge next to the register. read more

Taglio has been on my go to list since reading some of the exceptional reviews. Yesterday had the opportunity to be on the island and stopped in. All the rave reviews are worthwhile. I shared a half dozen slices of their Roman style pizza. Each one was exceptional. The rave reviews are definitely not an understatement. Noteworthy after enjoying those I did not feel sleepy tired or over stuffed probably result of their dough making skills. The pizzas were substantial and filling however, I didn't need to take a nap afterwards this really underscores technical quality of their pizza making. That said each of the variety of the Roman style pizzas were delicious. I also had a round margarita slice which was very good. However, the Roman pizzas are the standout heroes of the show. I have a real soft spot for Roman style pizza, which you just don't see well-made here in the US. Bravo Taglio, excellent,I look forward to coming back. read more

Well the pizza lived up to the hype. We only sampled the Classico Roman style but it was delicious. Definitely a nice change from our usual spots. There are a bunch of tables inside and there were about 5 folks on line when I picked up my pie- BUSY. The parking stinks because it's all meters but their pizza is really tasty. Eager to try some of the other pizzas! read more

Very tasty New York style pizza. When I came in, did not see a regular plain triangle shaped slice, but many other delicious styles and options. Crowd favorite with alot of activity and limited seating. Bathroom is there and it's drafty in the winter but good take out. read more

Taglio Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

See all

I tried many different slices and I would definitely recommend to go for the tomato based ones. The tomato sauce was very well balanced and the burrata on top was tasty. I think the mushroom and potato one is overrated since they are quite dry. read more

Taglio Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

See all