3.5 stars rounded up…read more The pizza was fantastic, loved the sauce and the crust. It almost made up for the mediocre service and the terrible parking.

I got meal of stuffed shells delivered , food cold, sauce was watery and tastless. I have had…read moremostly good expeirenecs with them now compleetely displeased.

Really good food and a great group of guys, we worked out a menu for my workplace, fantastic!…read more It's simple, do yourself a favor, just order some food or stop in and see why it's not your average pizzeria, ciao.

Catered my party. Chicken Francese and eggplant parmigiana…read morewere absolutely delicious. A cut above!!

The 10th time was as good as the first! This is my go to restaurant when I'm in this area. You…read moreare greeted before you are even completely in the door and the staff is attentive to your needs. What keeps me coming back is the friendly ambience and the delicious food. I don't have a favorite meal (maybe the osso Buco!). This last visit there was a new addition on the dessert menu of cheesecake and it reminded me of a well loved bakery in Germany. The cheesecake was extra fluffy and I can't say enough good things about it. The restaurant is family friendly, and my niece loves the pizza here (I do too!) Luigi and family, thank you for many delicious meals and we will see you soon

Let me tell you a something!! We looked at several pizza restaurant reviews, yes they matter to…read moreme. I am so glad we paid attention to them because we would have missed out on the ABSOLUTE BEST PIZZA we have had. We are a group of 7 friends visiting from Ky and Ohio and we ordered the Americano (my personal favorite) the pepperoni was so delicious, the crust was such a compliment to the flavors on top! Also the Margherita was appreciated by our vegans. Then there was the 'make your own' pizza that had the most delicious pepperoni,mushrooms and onions. I can't say enough...then there was the salad.....what a salad. Luigi you gave us a wonderful memory of New York pizza!! We did a carry out but once I stepped inside, I wished we had chosen to eat inside...nice atmosphere. If you don't put forth the effort to eat HERE....YOUR LOSS :( Luigi....Thank you...Thank you...Thank you! Kentucky

Awesome NY-style pizza! Perfect balance of cheese, sauce, and dough -- reheats very well. Chicken…read moreparm hero was great too. Super clean place with easy parking. This is our new favorite spot--can't wait to try more!

Broadway slice is bomb. I'd call it a grandma slice. Sauce on top. Love that. Also tried the…read morechicken Florentine slice. Thumbs up. Flavor is right. Dough is right. Bunch of pies on the counter. Cool spot in Brewster. Great vibes. Get a slice!!! yeeeeee

The food here is good, however the customer service is terrible, cashier was very unprofessional…read moreand rude.

I love that they have so many different soups there's at least five different ones that pepperoni…read morepinwheel awesome so those are the two things I had today. You order your food they bring it right over to you at the table and then pay later.

Valerie is a waitress and she is excellent all the specials what they're about…read more OK, so let's talk about appetizers Nonna meatballs are unbelievable, then we move onto the Cajun calamari oh my god what a twist it is absolutely a new taste. That's unbelievable. Then he had a special was kinda like an egg roll with sausage and broccoli Rob and something else I wasn't paying attention but when they tasted it, oh my goodness so good. My meal was Catelli and sausage with ricotta. So between the appetizers and the main meal, there was so much food. I'm definitely haven't leftovers. Now we move onto the chocolate martini I've never seen anybody put this whipped cream with some chocolate syrup on the top of it and it is excellent and then we move onto the rainbow cookie dessert cake it tasted like a rainbow cookie unbelievable.

Amazing food, great service and beautiful ambiance. Consistently good food. Best penne vodka pasta…read moreand shrimp!

Avoid this place at all costs. I got completely scammed. I normally don't leave negative reviews,…read morebut this experience was ridiculous. My wife and I placed a prepaid online order and scheduled a pickup--only to arrive and find the restaurant completely shut down. No sign explaining the situation, no notice, no answered telephone, no nothing. Their website is still live and actively taking orders and money, even though the place isn't even operating. This is a total scam. They continue to be live on third-party apps like TooGoodToGo.

Quick stop - GIANT slice of sausage and peppers. $4.75 (ouch) but it was so big it was like 2…read moreslices. Dude behind the counter reminded me of when I was a kid. Not friendly not mean - "Whatcha need?" Love it. Slice was delicious. Will be back when Im in the area....

Boring menu and atmosphere . Prices were high for portions…read moreserved . In a word , one and done .

Food quality / price (value) rating 7. The atmosphere is simple tavern style. Totally local…read morecrowd. I had the Chicken Scarpariello. Two very small half breast filets, some stuffed sausage slices with hot peppers and sliced potatoes over linguine. It was just okay. The pasta was doughy. I got the salad to go, amd when we got home and looked at it, it was the smallest salad I've ever seen. The wife had the Cappelini Prima Vera, which didn't have very much flavor. We sat in the bar area, where the bartender was serving the whole room, and not really paying attention to those not seated at the bar. We've been here four or five times andit hasn't been impressive.

Great pizza Stopping by for a slice…read more Or calling in for pies Also a large variety of salad options Friendly, local!!

Heading up 684 from LaGuardia and needed NY slice right away! Yelp reviews were positive so we gave…read moreit a try. Not disappointed in any way. First, they were open at night and served by the slice. Just a short drive off the highway, their pizza was exactly what we needed, kept it simple, just a slice of cheese and they did it right. Crust was perfect, everything else was correctly portioned. There are a few tables and a counter for dine in. Service was friendly, nice variety of pizzas to choose from including Sicilian.