We actually went to Aversano's by mistake ... But am so glad we made a mistake! We had multiple friends in town and after touring our museum in Patterson and studio at Mt Ebo, we frequently go to another Italian restaurant 5 minutes down the street. Thought that's where we were going when I searched on Yelp but Aversano's came up #1. We had an amazing dinner. The baked oysters, calamari and pepperoni trey was delicious that we all shared. The short rib was one of the best I have ever had. Everyone at the table bragged about their meal. They even had port wine from the best winery in Porto, Portugal that we personally visited. The staff was knowledgeable, friendly and checked on us consistently. Many tour this area: this is a great place to bring guests for dinner. Parking is super easy being in a shopping center. Will absolutely be back again. read more

Went to Aversonos on an early Saturday evening for dinner with my wife. Started off with the Asian calamari and parm garlic bread which were both outstanding. Wife had the veal cutlet parm and spaghetti. She loved the veal but was a little sketchy with the spaghetti, said it tasted a little off. I had the rigatoni Bolognese with a side of meatballs. I am usually not a big fan of Italian meatballs but there meatballs are actually pretty good. (My wife does make better) Their rigatoni are short, fat little things that are outstanding. Good gravy. Service was excellent and knowledgeable. Atmosphere was a little noisy (bridal shower in the back room) but other than that, I would not hesitate to go back. read more

See all

Valerie is a waitress and she is excellent all the specials what they're about. OK, so let's talk about appetizers Nonna meatballs are unbelievable, then we move onto the Cajun calamari oh my god what a twist it is absolutely a new taste. That's unbelievable. Then he had a special was kinda like an egg roll with sausage and broccoli Rob and something else I wasn't paying attention but when they tasted it, oh my goodness so good. My meal was Catelli and sausage with ricotta. So between the appetizers and the main meal, there was so much food. I'm definitely haven't leftovers. Now we move onto the chocolate martini I've never seen anybody put this whipped cream with some chocolate syrup on the top of it and it is excellent and then we move onto the rainbow cookie dessert cake it tasted like a rainbow cookie unbelievable. read more

See all

Amazing food, great service and beautiful ambiance. Consistently good food. Best penne vodka pasta and shrimp!

From a cocktail at the bar to our waitstaff through dessert! Aversanos is top notch! We had several appetizers- all delicious! And the entrées, wonderful! We ended with a few shared deserts and our party of 4 raved about everything! If you are looking for a lovely place to have a great meal I highly recommend this spot!! Can't wait to go back again. read more

You can tell by the entrance that the inside is on the fancier side. It definitely matches the interior. The interior is dim, calming, and inviting. There are two entrances, one that is closer to resembling a fancy pizza parlor. The staff is attentive, they listen to your preferences and respect them. I got dessert before my entree and it came out stat just as I'd like. I got my entree after my dessert was finished and cleared, just as I'd like. The staff is friendly as well and try their best with their attitudes and overall service which I love. I got their popular sachetti which lives up to its popularity-- it's delicious . The blend of cheeses are just right, smooth, and not overpoweringly rich. I would def come back here . Their cosmo was delicious, not just thrown together. There is an art to making drinks, they shouldn't just taste like a bunch of booze. Happy with all that I've tried from their bread to their entree. Everything was reasonably priced too. read more

Aversano's - White Truffle Sacchetti - Pizza Near Me - Brewster, New York

See all

When it comes to a proper Italian celebration--food, laughter, wine, and the kind of full-bellied happiness that makes you loosen your belt mid-meal--Aversano's in Brewster delivers like your favorite nonna on a Sunday afternoon. Recently, I had the pleasure of dining there to celebrate a friend's birthday. From the moment we walked in, the staff made us feel like family. The service was warm, attentive, and genuine. There was no robotic "Hi, my name is..." spiel here--just good people who know great food and love sharing it. Let's talk about that food. The seafood fra diavolo had that spicy kick but not 'burn your mouth' spicy. Portions? Generous. Flavors? Authentic. Vibes? Straight-up old-school Italian done right. There were MANY specials on the menu, and our server was able to explain each and every one without any notes. IMPRESSIVE!! Aversano's has that rare balance of classy and cozy--perfect for birthdays, date nights, or just treating yourself to a damn good meal. It's a place where conversation flows, glasses clink, and you leave planning your next visit before you even hit the parking lot. My only gripe was that my wife and I ordered Tanqueray and tonics before we were seated. The tonic water was flat, and there was very little gin. Our other cocktails were perfect. Aversano's has now become one of our go-to Italian restaurants! EXCELLENT!! read more

Consistent ambiance and food is what we like most about this restaurant. The food is delicious and the service is outstanding when people like Sue is the server! She is polite and professional and her recommendation of the Chicken Adlina was spot on! read more

Had a quiet Sunday lunch here. Was not too busy on the restaurant side. Lots of yummy specials on top of their usual menu. Pasta was delicious and prices were very reasonable. Service was very friendly too. They offer great catering options as well! read more

Aversano's - Rigatoni Bolognese - Pizza Near Me - Brewster, New York

See all

Take out | Dinner | $10-20 There was a time I felt this place was 5 stars, but now I would consider it "hit or miss". Sometimes when dining in, the meals and drinks were excellent, but yesterday we were disappointed in our pizza. We ordered a half cheese/half pepperoni, and it was obviously reheated slices instead of a fresh pie. I just feel that sometimes they cut corners and sacrifice quality. read more

Food is just ok and overpriced. $40 for a large pie with the basics, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms and garlic. Soggy pizza and OVERPRICED! First time and last time! read more

Dinner with two other couples. Service was very good. That was about it. Drinks were meager. We had to ask for a second shot to add to the first for two drinks. Don't remember the appetizer we had. Three of us ordered the veal chop medium rare. All three came back well done, firm, and dry. They were served on a bed of thin sliced potatoes that were also overcooked and unappetizing. One of us had the branzino, which was fine. Another ordered halibut which came on a bed of sauteed spinach that was poorly seasoned. All of us were disappointed and will likely not return. read more

We had our 40th wedding anniversary dinner here yesterday and it was amazing!! The atmosphere, staff, food were all great! The owner came out and was so welcoming and friendly made you feel like family We highly recommend Aversano's restaurant. Thank you again for a great experience. read more

Aversano's - Anniversary dinner - Pizza Near Me - Brewster, New York

See all

Moving away from ny I always visit for good pizza. Not happy with this at all! Usually good but this time salty and eggplant pizza was not the usual squared pizza. Salad pizza had no dressing and it took over an hour to be delivered when the place is 10 minutes away on a Monday night. Overall not satisfied! read more

Solid pizza, solid service, good prices, good people, easy parking. I would go back. read more

Aversano's - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brewster, New York

We had a wedding lunch there and everything was made so special for us! John and his staff were attentive, food was great, as was the ambience! Highly recommend!!! read more

Aversano's - Pizza Near Me - Brewster, New York

Management: We came to Aversano's on Tuesday April 1st at 4:00 PM. There was only one other customer in the entire place. By 5:00 PM I look around and three other tables are eating their main course, and we are still sitting here waiting. Are you kidding me???? My food is not warm. My wife's food is not warm. That's because the food was sitting on a counter somewhere! The restaurant was not crowded it was empty. I don't want to hear, "thanks for being patient" OUR FOOD WAS NOT WARM... $120.00 for what!!! I kept my cool with the other guests, but I am beyond upset! read more

Puzzling evening here. Have been here several times, each time convincing myself it will be better. Beautiful dining area with all the sensory things; terrific music, candlelight, bustling friendly staff, charming hostess. The waiter did a lovely job of reciting all the numerous and detailed specials, though it was way too much work to memorize them and to compare with the wine list; I asked for a printed version (I'd be happy with a chalkboard) but there was none, so I ignored it and stuck to the menu. We enjoyed our mozzarella and tomato appetizer very much; seasoned perfectly and the dressing was absolutely phenomenal. The bread and oil was delicious and my husband loved his meatballs and "gravy". The salmon and asparagus was fine, though the sauce was a little chunky and more copious than necessary. A solid meal. Sadly, our server disappeared half way through. I would have enjoyed a glass of wine with dinner, and our water glasses went dry. The third busser my husband asked for bread for his delicious sauce finally brought some. We never were offered a dessert or coffee suggestion, and after each of used the facilities and waiting around some more, the second busser we asked brought us a container for the scraped off salmon and found our waitress to give us a check. I'm an ok cook myself, and I enjoy cooking a lot. So, about 75% of the motivation to go out is to feel the luxury of being "waited on". As my career is in the helping professions, it feels so nice to relax and feel nurtured while dining out. Sadly this didn't check the box. read more

I came her last week on a rainy night to meet a friend. The restaurant was warm and cozy, the staff super friendly, and the food was fabulous. I also loved our waitress. I really appreciate when we ask if we ordered well and they make a suggestion! Our waitress steered us towards the best fried mozzarella app and also helped us pivot a pasta order to something that was simply delish. SACCHETTI - Purse shaped, cheese filled, shallots, prosciutto, peas, white truffle cream WAS OUTSTANDING. Will definitely be back! read more

If you want an old reheated pizza - this is the place for you! Happened to us once again...we're done with this place

Chicken Franchase sauce was awful, they obviously don't know how to make it. No taste, and oily, no flavor of butter and lemon at all. The chicken was tender and cooked great but had no flavor. The eggplant Parmesan was extremely oily, would not order from here again. read more

Horrible service.,.. used door dash and after waiting over an hour had finally call Aversano's and such poor customer service and rude as hell. Lied told us we were too far away when we only 5 miles down road. I've always had problems...no apologies no delivery. They are the worst when ordering delivery. Even when I walked in to pick up-Order not there. Horrible service the owners should be ashamed. Their food is not as good as their prices claim- def overrated. SINAPIS all the way!!!! Better food and personable family-like service. Never again Aversanos- sorry!!!! We just received our replacement Sinapi's order in 40 minutes and home style as usual!! read more

Excellent Italian food! We came with friends that had only ever been in the takeout/pizza side, but we dined in and it was fantastic. The service is excellent, the food was amazing and the ambiance is warm and inviting although the tables were a little tighter together than I like. That's frankly a minor detail compared to how awesome the food was. Our group of 4 each had something different. I had their chicken parm, which was outstanding, my wife had their seafood pasta and loved it. One friend had their sausage and broccoli rab over orichette, which he said was awesome and finally, our other friend had their short ribs (which was a special) and it was amazing! They do it right and hit the trifecta of great food, great service, and a warm and inviting vibe. If you're in the area it's a must try if you're into Italian. read more

I definitely recommend this restaurant. My family has been with them since their first restaurant in North Brewster Rd. Last night we ordered a large half sausage half mushroom and it was not what we expected. The sauce was very salty. I was very disappointed. Their Sicilian and Grandma are superb. Their hot entres are excellent . read more

Live in the area and ordered a pizza to go on our drive home. A convenient location and we hoped equal to the quality of other area pizza. With the added topping pepperoni .onion, and green pepper the cost was $43 , roughly 2x the price for the same pizza at our normal place. Quality was weak with a cardboard crust. A specialty slice at Bruno's is $5 in New Fairfield would have cheaper to by a slice at a time. Frankly , no pizza in the area has been more than $25 piled high so sticker shock . Had the quality been equal no review to be less than and a rip one of very rare reviews read more

Very glad that we decided to come here. The service was excellent! The hostess and servers were all extremely nice and attentive. I'm not sure if they were the owners or the chefs, but there were two men in chefs attire checking on us, and everyone else, in the dining room and they were very friendly and welcoming. We had the chicken parm, chicken alla vodka, apple sangria, and espresso martini, and everything was delicious!! We were too full for dessert, but took a cannoli to go. I had to try one since everything else was so good, and it did not disappoint! We will definitely be coming back! read more

Great food Good people And the pizza is very good Prices are not bad but food is off the hook read more

Delicious meal. Terrific service. Attentive but not intrusive. Chicken Francese, chicken scarpariello, truffle pizza were delicious. Calamari appetizer was a little chewy-our only negative. Ricotta cheesecake and tartufo for dessert were great. Warm and comfortable atmosphere. read more

Delicious Pizza Try the Calebese Pizza - spicy New York style pizza Excellent option read more

Excellent food and a community minded business...great owners!!! Eat in as well...all the dishes I've tried are delicious!

The food was amazing and the waitress Terry was very polite and made sure we received our meals on time (we had another engagement after and were pressed for time). She was a great waitress (unfortunately sometimes waitstaff is rude or indifferent). We loved the food and are grateful that Terry helped us in a timely manner. It was our Anniversary so it meant a lot. Thank you Terry and the staff at Aversano's for making our Anniversary extra special. read more

Website says open till 10pm on Fridays and Saturdays. I drove all the way there walked in at 9:28pm and was told the owner decided to close at 9pm. You can't do that to your customers, that's terrible customer service. You should be embarrassed that's how you run your establishment. Shame on you for your false advertising and for wasting my time. I've lost all respect for you as a business owner. You promise something on your website you need to abide by it!!! read more

Aversano's - False advertising of hours - Pizza Near Me - Brewster, New York

had lunch here last week with some friends .The restaurant was clean and we were like the only ones there at 1pm. I ordered the personal margarita pizza and my wife ordered the tortellini soup . We were a party of 7 ..The wait was over an hour to eat .our waitress was nice but i feel she was overwhelmed or very new. My pizza was actually good and my wife said her soup was ok.She also ordered a appetizer of mac and cheese balls.She said they were good but were greasy..The prices were high for lunch and she didn't give us the option of ordering calzones which i would prefer.. read more

I arranged a family gathering/party for a Sunday lunch. Everything was great! The food was delicious, the service was attentive, the room was comfortable...even the bathrooms were clean! Excellent job! Thanks for everything John! read more

The strangest worst "truffle" pizza we have ever had. This "truffle" pizza has prosciutto, capers, and truffle oil on it. It was so bad we didn't know what to do. The total shock and horror of seeing these toppings on a truffle pizza. But wait there's more. The calamari was frozen tiny rubbery round pieces. You can't even call it calamari, maybe put on the menu "round pieces of rubber" instead. It was horrendous. Then you think okay well the buffalo mozzarella has got to be good, right? Wrong! It was old cooked prosciutto wrapped in a brick of mozzarella with some after thought old tomatoes on the side. Absolutely appalling. The sacchetti was their only saving grace and probably because it wasn't even made in house. I would never ever go back there for a dinner. Maybe a quick slice of plain pizza if I was starving. I can make a meal home a million times better. This place should be ashamed of themselves. Please google TRUFFLE PIZZA " and take notes. read more

Aversano's - The most horrible truffle pizza ever - Pizza Near Me - Brewster, New York

I can't begin to tell you how much I appreciated everything they did for my son's wedding. From our first meeting, we knew it was a perfect fit. John was so attentive, professional, and kind. We honestly felt like family. He made sure that every detail was perfect, even some of the crazy ones! To speak about the food, where do I begin? Having a large group of Italians at the wedding I knew I had tough critics. A week later they're all still raving about how delicious everything was. This is our new favorite place and I will thank you always for making William and Olivia 's day perfect! read more

Aversano's - William and Olivia - Pizza Near Me - Brewster, New York

My family and I have been coming here for years, and have rarely had bad experiences. The food is great, the staff is friendly and management is visible and involved. The overall atmosphere is what we continue to come back for. Normally, our favorite waitress is Kathy. She's phenomenal and always takes care of us. We love her recommendations. Our last visit, we started at the bar then shortly moved to a table, at which both Brian was our server. He was helpful and knew his specials. We can be a difficult and indecisive group, but he seemed to stay patient with us. We enjoyed this past experience, however, one of the two problems that came up was that they ran out of mushroom ravioli, and we didn't know until we tried to order it. But that just proves how delicious it was that it sold out! The app specials we ordered were good, and luckily they came right after we all scarfed down the complimentary bread and oil, which is always a tempting starter. I got my usual, red pepper ravioli and as per normal, it was delicious and so filling I couldn't finish it! I was slightly disappointed in my left overs, the bus boy hadn't wrapped up my raviolis with any of the extra sauce or extra red peppers. It had looked as if he just forked out the two raviolis from my dish, they were quite bare. Dessert is always delicious here, I tend to gravitate towards their tiramisu options. I love their dessert cocktails as well. Drinking my dessert is just as good as eating it! Whether you sit at the bar or grab a table, the food is great and so is the service. You most likely won't be disappointed or hungry by the time you leave. read more

Aversano's - Cocktail list and glass of red blend at their small but efficient bar - Pizza Near Me - Brewster, New York

Nothing like what they show on the website! They charged me $25 for 3 shrimp and linguini. I can't remember when I had a worse meal. NEVER AGAIN. read more

This is a place to avoid! Ordered at 5:20 and at 7:05 still no food. When did finally arrived it was cold. I had to reheat the shrimp fra Diablo, the salad packed on top of the fra Diablo was warm, I threw the salad out. The food itself was not very good. Overdone shrimp and linguine soaked in thick sauce. Even the bread was yuk. Wasn't really a nice piece of crunchy Italian but what appeared to be a pizza crust, maybe focaccia not sure but very dry and crumbly. Paid a lot for this dinner, waited a long long time, was hoping the wait was worth it, but NOT. read more

My boyfriend's mom had her wedding ceremony/celebration of close to 40 people at Aversanos on Saturday night and I feel the need to rave about how fabulous the night was. My boyfriend and I arrived an hour early to setup table decorations and 3-4 staff members immediately offered to help with whatever we needed which included filling 15 vases with water & lighting 15 floating candles. We got the setup done in no time. I appreciated the detail they put into setting the table in terms of beautifully folded napkins, bread & oil plates with parm. cheese setup every few seats, etc... When the party started, the wait staff was fantastic at getting each course out quickly and clearing dirty plates in a timely manner. Drinks were flowing and the bartender was personable & helpful. One of my favorite parts of the night was when the live band started and played several love songs which got everyone up & dancing in the bar area. Such a special and fun night. If you have a celebration coming up and are thinking about having Aversanos host... do it!!! Great job, looking forward to coming back for dinner!! read more

See all