I finally tried this place after venturing into their shopping center numerous times. The staff are friendly and attentive. We were greeted and helped immediately. They have a nice variety of pizzas on display but I was in the mood for old faithful cheese. GF snagged a slice of their salad pizza. We took everything to go and ate it at home after a few min in our oven. My slice was one of the thinest crusts I've ever seen. It was barely a crust. If you told me it didn't have a crust I would believe you. It was incredible. The sauce was tasty and the cheese ratio was on point. My slice was DELICIOUS. GF stole my word, delicious, when referring to her slice. "Perfect crust" she adds. I might have to wander in again in the future. read more

I love that they have so many different soups there's at least five different ones that pepperoni pinwheel awesome so those are the two things I had today. You order your food they bring it right over to you at the table and then pay later. read more

Gaetano Pizza - Italian Wedding Soup - Pizza Near Me - Brewster, New York

See all

The food here is good, however the customer service is terrible, cashier was very unprofessional and rude.

Nice place if you are in the area and want something good and quick to eat. I also got some wings for later. But I definitely would be back when I'm in the area read more

Gaetano Pizza - Vegetable pizza was very good. Not too much just the right amount of veggies - Pizza Near Me - Brewster, New York

The food was great. We all had a slice of pizza, with lots of variety to choose from. The service was fast and friendly. All round a nice dining area, and squeaky clean bathrooms. read more

Crust on the Marsala slice at 1pm on a Mon was so hard it literally snapped and crumbled. Mushrooms were slimy, chicken was dry. Took two bites and chucked in the garbage. No way that wasn't sitting around from the day before. read more

Pizza is good,especially the Sicilian pizza But no one makes a better soup . Give it a try it will warm up your insides. read more

Best by far the best Sicilian Pizza around in Putnam County. Perfect! crunchy bottom, soft and tasty middle, great sauce and lots of melted mozzarella. Best salad in town, not just salad, their Asian salad. cold crisp romaine lettuce, crunchy Asian noodles, sliced almonds, mandarin oranges and the best Asian dressing ice ever had, served with Italian bread (yummy) and butter. Enjoy. read more

Loved the pizza! , Eggplant Parmesan dinner! with warm bread, beautiful salad, and choice of pasta side, Pasta Fagioli soup!, Steak, pepper and onion hero. Basic large space with plenty of room and tables/booths. Nice service and price for such large portions. read more

Pizza was good and wedges. The bad thing is they use grub hub to deliver. Which took almost two hours to get to my house (2 miles away) I would have picked up but I was drinking so definitely not going to drive! Where are all the places that actually do their own delivery! Oh and the delivery guy left garbage in my driveway when he pulled the bag out of his car. read more

The best pizza in the Carmel area. Great sauce and cooked as you prefer. Add your own fresh Basil from your garden and it's MAGICAL. read more

Really, really good pizza spot. Their sauce is flavorful, crust is the perfect thickness, the toppings are generous, and everything is super delicious. I recently tried their stromboli and it was fantastic - everything I desire from a stromboli and priced fairly. Great place to come for a quick slice or a larger meal. read more

This is my favorite pizza spot around town. The food is perfect, the service is great. Nothing bad I can say

Food was ok. Service was good and atmosphere was very comfortable. Had a Sicilian pizza , dough was a little plain , not much taste . Sauce and toppings were good . read more

Grabbed a chicken Italian wrap, was good . Several pizza's by slice to choose from looked good. Very nice staff read more

Their pizza is amazing. We have alot of pizzerias here, really good; Gaetanos is amazing.

I'm hear now, ordered a mushroom pie to stay and its so well over done. Next time I have to say Not Well done! So disappointed

Gaetano's is the best. First off, their pizza is sooo good. But after I went vegan, I learned that they'll make pizza with soy cheese. They even let me bring my own vegan cheese and made the pizza with that for me! Also, try their incredible broccoli rabe and the broccoli sautéed in garlic. I wish I could make it as good as they do. Everything I've ever ordered from this restaurant has been fresh and topnotch. Highly recommend. read more

Good local pizza place. I like the balance of their sauce and the texture of their dough. Prices are reasonable and it's close to the train station. The pies are ready when they say they will be done. We use their app to order. read more

Their pizza is always spot on. if you came from the city this is as close to NYC thin crust pizza as you can get. The Chicken Marsala pizza is one of our favs. read more

Awesome pizza and great service. We stopped here on the way from the Poconos to Connecticut, and we were rewarded with exactly what we needed. read more

I really like this place. Pizza is great here. Garlic knots are delicious. I got the biggest size of pasta fagulai and i had to order more!! It was great. read more

Gaetano Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brewster, New York

Pretty much your typical stripmall pizza joint. A plentiful selection of pizzas sitting out under glass for who knows how long. My wife and I both had calzones....they were sitting out too but they looked a little better than most of the pies. While smaller than most calzones I've had, it was pretty good. Service was quick and friendly. You could probably do better at a place that makes their pizza fresh to order but if you're in the area and looking for a quick bite to eat, this place will do and you could certainly do worse. read more

Gaetano Pizza - the front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Brewster, New York

Pretty good pizza and very convenient location (right off the highway). I love their gravy/sauce that they use on the pizza and their pasta. Service is always fast. read more

The ziti slice is the best I've ever had. Whenever I am in the area, I have to pick up a slice. The staff is always friendly. read more

Gaetano Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brewster, New York

Amazing pizza. My favorite in the area of Brewster. Pizza is to die for. Very tasty and place is pretty clean.

Great pizza and fast delivery! Couldn't recommend it more for people in the area or passing by.

I love this pizza Gaetano' is fantastic stuff I just got two slices the other night and mama miaaaaaaa it was delicious they have huge slices and the crust and sauce is perfect I will be back :) read more

I come here every once in awhile when I'm in the area there food is pretty good there pizza is very thin and they have some pretty good wedges only bad part is there sauce is a little salty I've noticed but overall I'll give it a 3/5 it's a good pizza place to go too when your shopping in that area read more

Gaetano Pizza has never disappointed me. I love this local pizza spot, location is great- right near the metro north, and retail shopping. Just flew in to LaGuardia after an awesome wedding weekend, hungry and too tired to cook pizza was our only salvation and it was everything I needed! Large Pepperoni for the family of 4. The crust is not too thick, and maintains a nice crunch despite the sauce. Oh and the sauce is just spectacular! I'll be going back very soon. read more

We love Gaetano's, crispy pizza with lots of flavor, the dinner entrees are delicious.

Gaetanos Pizza is the best pizza shop you'll ever encounter, the food is always fresh and amazing. From their pizzas, to salads, soups and wedges, we are never disappointed. Service is always friendly. We travel over q half hour just for their pizza. read more

Oily funky tasting pizza. Place needs thorough cleaning! Bathroom looks like it's never been cleaned. What is kitchen like?

A large variety of Pizza. The best pizza I ever ate. I love the White pizza and my husband always has sausage on his. We order by the slice, but you can get a whole pie. This is the ONLY place we order pizza from. It is as good as it gets! read more

Had a personal pizza here awhile ago and forgot to write a review lol The pizza was really good. I ate the whole thing. They even made my crazy picky pizza which not every pizza place will do which is annoying. Anyway will definitely be coming back when I can Yummm read more

The lasagna slice is really tasty. The combination of that with a side of sauce is perfection as far as I'm concerned. Can't speak for the dinners or any other slice because that's the only one I get every time I go. read more

Came here for a quick lunch. We had pizza which was not bad but it wasn't like true ny pizza. Good parking and fast service. Most likely won't return but it satified my lunch crazving for pizza. read more

This place is convenient, and looks nice. stopped for a few slices. Pizza was blah, I've had better and for what I paid it wasn't worth it. $8.00 for two slices. The service is what really sucked, not friendly like someone else said. Won't be stopping here again. read more

Delicious, absolutely delicious and fresh. No long waits and very nice people. Absolutely loved this place

We moved to Brewster 10 months ago, and i think we have tried every pizza place in town- and surrounding towns - some we've even been to twice just to see if we ordered on a bad night the first time, because so many people kept recommending the same places over and over. I was disappointed with each and every pie i consumed. I had no idea Gaetano's was there, until a friend suggested i try it. Tonight we ordered just a simple, plain pie and took it home...and it was everything I've been looking for in a pizza...and more. I'm beyond excited to have finally found my pizza shop! read more