Cancel

Open app

Search

Pizza Pie Cafe

3.4 (89 reviews)
InexpensivePizza, Buffets, Salad
Open • 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

Order Pizza Pie Cafe Takeout or Delivery

Pizza Pie Cafe Photos

Business Info

PIZZA PIE CAFE ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Moderate noise
Casual
Good for groups
Good for kids

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Pizza Pie Cafe

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Matthew H.

This pizza place is awesome. Not only can you get pizza, they also have a pizza bar, so you can try all kinds. They also have a pasta bar with different pastas and sauces. Make your own if you want. They have dessert pizzas also. To top it all off they have a great salad bar. We came in to try it out and Macie helped us. She was great. Very helpful and friendly. Great customer service. Thanks Macie!

Oreo Dessert Pizza
Cole P.

Pizza Pie Cafe is best described as quantity over quality, a place you go when you want to chill with family, have lunch with a friend, or hold a birthday party. It is not a place you come to get amazing pizza, but rather a place to get unlimited mediocre pizza. They also have both a salad bar and a pasta bar for those who want more than just pizza. The dessert pizza is the best thing here by far but sadly after one or two pieces you will have a stomach ache. The atmosphere here is perfect for family gatherings or lunch breaks. One of the best things I've found is that even when the place is jam-packed, it is quiet enough that you can hear your friend talk to you from across the table. One thing I wish they would improve is the pizza serving area. It is quite difficult to get a piece of pizza with the serving tool they give you, and most of the time the pizza you are looking for is not there and you have to wait 5 minutes for them to put a new one out. I would only suggest coming here if you just want to have a good night out with people and the quality of the food is not super important to you.

Renee P.

Fun place to try on our road trip to Yellowstone! I'm gluten free and was happy with the salad bar options, that they had gluten free penne pasta and that they make you your own gf pizza any way you want. You pay $2 more for gluten free. Their dessert pizzas looked great! My family's favorite was the Oreo pizza! Wish there was something GF for dessert.

See all

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Amanda D.
0
141
27

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 3 of 3

Ask the Community - Pizza Pie Cafe

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 168 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Righteous Slice - The best pepperoni pizza

Righteous Slice

4.4(239 reviews)
0.9 mi

Courteous staff, absolutely well-run and the NY and Neapolitan style pizzas are incredible. Light,…read morecrunchy, delicious crust, and pizza combos you can't find everywhere (like the Bee Sting, pepperoni, ricotta and finished with local honey). Don't miss out on the freshly squeezed lemonade--refreshing and delightful. Family-friendly, plenty of seating, and you can watch how they make your pizza. Award-winning for good reasons! Less than $40 for a huge pie that feeds 4 people.

I'm not a big pizza fan. But I love this place! My brother-in-law was the owner's mission…read morecompassion back in the day and he told us about this place and how the owner always wanted to open a pizza joint. Well, he opened a really good one! We ordered the Bee Sting/Godfather pizza. The Bee Sting has Crushed red pepper, oregano, assorted spicy Italian cured meats, ricotta, & Howells Honey, fresh mozzarella, pecorino Romano, crushed San Marzano tomato sauce, olive oil. I never thought of putting honey on my pizza. Honestly, you can barely taste it. The Godfather has Italian sausage, cup-and-char pepperoni, sliced meatballs, provolone, mushrooms, fresh mozzarella, pecorino Romano, crushed San Marzano tomato sauce, oregano. We ordered the New York crust. It was crispy and it held its shape. The sauce was not overpowering and blended well with all the spices The Dessert Katie Kay pizza was amazing. It had strawberries, blue berries, strawberry gel, fresh whipped cream and powdered sugar. What a great way to satisfy your sweet tooth.

Photos
Righteous Slice - Inside of restaurant

Inside of restaurant

Righteous Slice - Sausage pizza

Sausage pizza

Righteous Slice - The menu has something for every taste

See all

The menu has something for every taste

Da Pineapple Grill - View of Sushi Bar

Da Pineapple Grill

3.4(175 reviews)
1.1 mi
•$$

Here's the good: the sushi is very good, the Moco Loco is authentic and delicious, the hamburgers…read moreare amazing (better than most places), pretty much anything I have ordered is good. Here's the bad: You will wait and wait for your food. Then you will wait and wait for your check. They simply don't have enough staff. Bottom line: great food, decent atmosphere, friendly staff - but takes too long. We have chosen to eat elsewhere on evenings when we have to pay attention to time.

The food is GREAT! We love da mixed plate and the sushi is amazing…read more I ordered online and the guy taking my order put me on hold to "go and ask the kitchen how long my order would take" he said 15-20 mins. Okay.... Around the 15 min mark we went in and it took at lease 5 minutes before anyone even spoke to me. Someone asked why I was there I said a pick up order they said they'd go check on it and never came back. 10mins later I talked to another server who said the same thing-- Left and never came back. Finally a third person asked me if I'd already been helped and when I said yes they just walked away. I eventually just left. 15 mins later they called me to tell me my food was ready. I don't understand why they make such a big deal about going to ask the kitchen how long the food will take only for it to take double the time than the kitchen said. I originally thought it was a one off but when we went back today it was the exact same experience. It's the most odd experience and you will walk away feeling like a burden to their service. I don't think we'll be back despite how good the food is.

Photos
Da Pineapple Grill - A classic roll of spicy tuna and cucumber topped with black sesame seeds 😍👍 for only $8.95

A classic roll of spicy tuna and cucumber topped with black sesame seeds 😍👍 for only $8.95

Da Pineapple Grill - Hours

Hours

Da Pineapple Grill - Pau Hana Roll (left), Mango Moonlight (right)

See all

Pau Hana Roll (left), Mango Moonlight (right)

The Hickory - Yummy appetizer.

The Hickory

3.4(395 reviews)
0.3 mi
•$$

The only problem with this place, particularly for a tourist who may only get one opportunity at a…read moremeal, is what the heck to choose from the menu, which has too too many things from which to choose. We got a chicken bacon ranch wrap and a Brisky Burger that comes topped with that slow cooked brisket. And the cactus tails (onion strings) and cheese curds on the side. I mean doesn't that already sound like a killer selection of food...in just one meal! Postscript: the burger is to die for excellent; Not so much the wrap, although the avocado salsa makes it good. The cheese curds have never been my thing, but these are great and the onion straws are delish too. Oh and the final thing...light lemonade with no-sugar strawberry sauce...wow!

As a BYUI alumni who's been to the original location before they moved to this location and this…read morelocation when it was new as a student, I was so excited to take my husband who had never been before. I was raving about the brisket stacker, lemonades, and the cheese curds. When we arrived, it looked just the same, but definitely a bit worse for wear. A lot of the murals on the walls are dinged and need some TLC. The bathroom was honestly pretty gross too. Our service was good and attentive. The drinks were exactly what I remembered. The cheese curds were even better than when I remembered. But the brisket stacker felt wrong. The brisket was cut differently and honestly was a bit tough, and you used to be able to put on any bbq sauce since all the sauces were on the table, but this was prepared with another barbecue sauce. Did I have fun? Yes, was it hard for the memories not to match in my head? Totally. Will I be back to Rexburg? Probably not.

Photos
The Hickory - Decor inside

Decor inside

The Hickory - Prime Rib French Dip & Cheese Curds - Yum!

Prime Rib French Dip & Cheese Curds - Yum!

The Hickory - Menu

See all

Menu

Pizza Pie Cafe - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...