Pizza Mia is a staple in Homer Glen, so seeing a New Lenox location meant we had to try it -- and it delivered exactly the classic experience you expect. We started with the sampler appetizer, which comes loaded with chicken tenders, fried mushrooms, onion rings, and mozzarella sticks. It's a lot of fried food, sure, but that's the contract you sign when you order it. Everything hit the spot. Pro tip: get the ranch and their garlic dipping sauce -- the garlic sauce especially takes the onion rings to a new level. The thin crust pizza was exactly what it should be: the perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings. And then... The Chub. An Italian beef baked into a pizza, served with au jus. It's not for the faint of heart, and you'll end up feeling like you just finished a seven-course meal, but it's a one-of-a-kind Italian beef pizza delicacy that nobody else offers. Overall, Pizza Mia is a treat, not an everyday spot -- mainly because I can't walk in without ordering The Chub, and honestly, I think you can only legally consume The Chub twice a year. read more

See all

Pizza Mia is the best pizza anywhere. I like extra sauce on mine but the pizza has lots of ingredients. No skimping. It's a little pricey but worth it. I give it a 5 star. read more

Always perfect. Food is great , delivery is quick and reliable. Love having this neighborhood gem! read more

This is cheap, soggy pizza with zero redeeming qualities. They use cheap frozen ingredients that I wouldn't stock a food pantry with. To top it all off, their prices are outrageously expensive for the junk they serve you. read more

Decent pizza, Chicken sandwich was really good. I am a pizza snob so I can't say it was memorable. Place is clean, fast, and friendly service. read more

Their pizza is on a whole other level than ANY OTHER PLACE outside of the city. Sausage is the best I've ever had in my life. Not sure if it's made in house but it's incredible. I order my pie well done, crust is crazy full of flavor. I would've given 5 stars but once in a while my pizza just gets forgotten about by staff. Showed up cold a couple times. This place is just so busy it's got to be almost impossible to get em all out the door perfectly so I understand. read more

Great food and great service. Hailey always takes care of the customers! Give it a try you won't be disappointed

We have been getting pizza here for over twenty years.Have never had a bad experience . It is the only pizza place we go to and there are plenty to choose from. read more

This is our favorite pizza restaurant that is near our house. Thin crust never disappoints.

The younger girls at the counter have the worst Attitudes. The one was yelling at the other so disrespectfully. It made me uncomfortable. Not only that but they took down my order wrong. Instead of a large they gave me a medium. $26 for a pizza that barely fed my family is outrageous!!! The quality isn't the best. The sauce has NO flavor and the toppings were sliding off because of the excessive amount of cheese. Whole experience wasn't the best. read more

So order the Feta Fetish, hold the feta, substitute sausage and a side of pizza sauce for dipping. Tell me your not happy after that. Only complaint (only4stars) is price on the Chubs, again a very awesome pie, but $32.00 for a small is why I've only ordered it once. read more

Let me start out by saying we used to go to their location when they were on Harlem all the time then that closed and moved to New Lenox , the good news is I love broasted chicken and theirs is no exception it's very good, the bad is the prices have gone up and their chickens are half the size they used to be, the drum sticks are tiny, the wings little to very little meat, and the biggest piece is usually the breast, well that's shrunk down to the size of a thigh, so we have decided to look else where and it's even closer, every bit as good and much bigger and juicy pieces, I get chicken prices went up but I'm comparing chicken to chicken there is a new place on Rte 45 Lagrange road just North Texas Road house ....winner winner chicken dinner read more

I ordered catering for a family party. The food was absolutely amazing. The amount of food you receive for the price is Awsome. Definitely will recommend and cater again read more

Overall a good pizza with good ingredients with my only caveat being an unimpressive crust and the lack of an 18 inch size.

Went here on the spare of the moment as the family wanted to try somewhere for pizza. Person on the phone was very efficient in taking the order. Arrived five minutes early and order was just coming out. They seem to have a large delivery operation as a few drivers were taking out pizzas to deliver. Place was clean inside. Pizza was very good and will be returning. read more

Love it! Hot pizza! Not over my greasy. The staff is always busy and friendly! The store front is always clean. The buisness is a great representation of the of the owner. read more

Pizza was delicious! Ordered for pick-up! Got all modifications correct and cooked to perfection. Ingredients were also very fresh!

twice I have gone there to get a pizza before 10 PM and they will not answer the phone A third I came in to the establishment around 9 PM and was told they quit taking orders read more

We carried out and really like there pizza. The crust is not cracker thin, but not to thick. Sauce is great. I asked for it a bit more well done and it was perfect. read more

Staying at at the Sheridan four points in Newberg NY. We were too tired to go out to eat so we ordered pizza delivered from this place. It was very good! The crust was super thin and the sauce was tasty. This place has been voted best pizza in the Hudson Valley by Hudson Valley magazine year after year. read more

Pizza Mia - the menu for the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - New Lenox, Illinois

See all

The best pizza in New Lenox. Delivery is always quick, and piping hot!! Chicken is also very good.

Food is always on point never had any problem. Everyone is always super friendly and most of all respectful.

Pizza is amazing!!! I live in a nearby suburb (15 mins away) where there are three pizza places and I always go to Pizza Mia!

Just tried placing an order at 7:59 pm on a Tuesday and they said they just took their last order for the night. They don't close until 10:00 pm according to the website. read more

Love this place! Everything is really good, our favorite is the chicken, pizza, & breaded mushrooms! Their service is amazing! NOTE: This is a take out place, no dining area. Try it, you won't be disappointed. read more

Great pizza....can't believe we waited so long to find it! It was tasty and the C/S had loads of sausage. Yum!

This is my 1st time trying this place, it is very hard trying to find a good pizza spot. I believe I found my second favorite pizza place. I will definitely be back again read more

Pizza Mia - medium sausage, onion with pepperoni on top. Soo good fresh and just right amount of pizza sauce. - Pizza Near Me - New Lenox, Illinois

Ok. The pizza is delicious. The Chub is outstanding, but be warned: cardiologist not included. Their delivery service is top notch. The new online ordering on the web site is very easy. An outstanding place for pizza. read more

Great neighborhood pizzeria with nice sandwiches, good ribs and good broasted chicken

We used to have great service here and the food was great. I don't know what happened! Maybe they started hiring ex McDonald's people cause now they can never get our orders right. Every time lately we have an issue. Well no more! This last time when they came back to bring the rest of our order I gave them their menu back and said we will not need it anymore. Done with this place!!! read more

Hands down best pizza in the area. I have tried pretty much everything on the menu as well as having food catered and it's all good. Owner Dave who's been in business for over 30 years knows what he is doing. Great food, service and staff keeps me coming back. Glad to have a place like this in the neighborhood. read more

Found this place by accident...so glad I did. The beef sandwich with baked mozzarella cheese is by far one of the best sandwiches I have had in a long time, much to the dismay of my cardiologist. TRY THIS PLACE FOR PIZZA TOO. read more

So I only ordered from them for catering for a party. The staff was helpful and friendly. The food was great and huge portions. They impressed me so much and the price was just right that I would go here so many times again. read more

This the only place I order pizza from in New Lenox. The Chub is great as well and the broasted chicken is incredible. I've never had anything bad from this place. It's simply the best! read more

Consistently great pizza considering it's in new lenox. Albeit they dont have much competition from the clowns at chicago faux and other okay chains. Would stack this up to the premier thin crusts villa nova, vito, little joes. A must go to if you live near here. read more

Delicious chopped salads! And pizza Yummy! Always fresh and pleasant staff Love this place! read more

I used Pizza Mia (as one of my friends gave them a glowing recommendation) to cater lunch for my customers. Everything has been top notch and delicious every single time, and I couldn't recommend them enough. The portions are large, they work with your budget, and the food is consistently absolutely delicious - not to mention that they are a pleasure to work with: personable, timely, very professional. My customers have loved everything I've ever catered from Pizza Mia (ask for Dave - he is awesome!), which includes meatballs, spinach artichoke pasta, bruschetta salad, homemade brownies, and so one. I look forward to dining there myself, if I'm in the area -- do yourself a favor and give them a try, I have no doubt you will have a great experience. read more

Pizza Mia is pretty good and very close to my house, so we've ended up ordering there a few times lately. I've only tried the thin crust, which is just okay. I hate that they don't have any specialty pizzas, making my favorite pizza (a selection of veggies) impossibly expensive. The last time, I ordered it with the toppings I didn't have in the house, and then sauteed my own spinach and green olives at home. I know that sounds cheap, but I really can't spend $20 on a basic, medium-sized thin crust pizza that's not much better than frozen pizza from the grocery store. The boyfriend really loves the chicken, so he's been ordering from there a lot. He gets the 8 piece without the potatoes, and sometimes they charge less for leaving the potatoes off and sometimes they don't, which bugs me. read more

Now that my wife and I have a newborn we order delivery grub more than we used to. When we lived in Saint Charles we were addicted to a certain Asian restaurant. When we moved to new lenox we had a lot of TERRIBLE experiences with local pizza joints... Aurelio's is D- Beggars is B Nancy's is a C- Pizza Mia has quality delivery food, extremely rapid delivery and a A+ menu. You won't be disappointed! read more

What happened Pizza Mia? Could the attempts to franchise get you to cut corners and manipulate your pizza recipe? Never had a bad pie here until this Christmas holiday. Something was seriously "off". The dough tasted like the cardboard box the pizza came in. The abundance of cheese that was usually a treat, seemed heavy and unappealing. Nobody even fought for the left overs the morning after. And that says a lot. read more