Love their pizza! Their delivery is prompt and courteous. Sicilian or thin crust. Really good sauce. Our go to pie for many years!

I know take out on Halloween was probably busy but we placed an order at 1:30 for a pick time of 4:00 for an order of 20 boneless wings. Some of the wings were extremely small the size of a quarter but half of the wings were chicken strips cut into small pieces. If they ran out of wings they should have called us with a substitution. read more

Manhattan Pizza and Wings - Chicken strips cut up to look like Bone In Wings - 20 Pieces - Pizza Near Me - Manhattan, Illinois

See all

Great pizza! A good find for a small town. We ordered sausage, mushroom, and pepperoni pizza with wings. The wings were okay but the pizza was really good!! Easy ordering. read more

Pizza is great and so is the customer service!! If you're looking for pizza, this is the place!

We use to order from Manhattan Pizza & Wings once a week for a few years. Recently the quality of food and customer service has decreased significantly. Today I ordered for the first time in months and needless to say I will not be ordering again anytime soon. Was also not provided a receipt. read more

Manhattan Pizza and Wings - Pizza Near Me - Manhattan, Illinois

Photo: small Italian beef pocket. I think I do prefer the way they used to make the beef pocket as now it is more like a calzone and leaves about an inch of twisted crust on one side that doesn't seem to get eaten. In my opinion the food here is better than pizza4u. The staff is very personable. read more

Manhattan Pizza and Wings - Small Italian beef pocket - Pizza Near Me - Manhattan, Illinois

See all

We love ordering from Manhattan Pizza and Wings. Our favorite is the Sicilian pizza; feeds our whole family and doesn't break the bank

Worst customer service ever. Instead of correcting their errors they would rather double down and blame the customer. Delivered wrong order and failed to notify order was delivered. Owner is an awful person. read more

Always been loyal to Malnati's, Giordanos and Beggars but thought to finally try local. Glad we did. Everything was delicious especially the antipasto salad and sicilian pizza. Found a new fave! read more

I have been ordering from this place for years. It had gone down hill over the past few months. The business owner has very poor customer service, poor management skills, and blames the customer for their constant screw ups on orders. There was no attempt at a resolution for me (the customer). All he kept saying over the phone and text listed below is that "he personally made the pizza." Congrats dude.. it was completely wrong and was still not even close to what I had ordered in the first place. I had ordered a full 16" pizza " DOUBLE DOUGH" with pepperoni, garlic, gardinare, and pineapple. I also paid for ranch, garlic butter sauce, and extra marinara sauce cup on the side. What I received was 2 salad dressing ranch packets with no marinara sauce or garlic butter sauce. The pizza as shown below with my order specifically shows what I requested. On the pizza, I received was half a pizza with cheese with a garlic butter crust & the other half with the toppings that I originally ordered. Also, shown in the picture is their cardboard thin crust that the owner swears is the double dough because he personally made it, once again himself. There was obviously no double dough because a jacks frozen pizza had more crust than this. The pizza was ice cold upon delivery and I was charged for all topping for a full pizza. This pizza and 10 piece boneless chicken wings ran almost $60 dollars and wasn't worth $10. I mean at least they didn't screw up the chicken wings. Instead of trying to make the order right and possibly keep a valued customer happy, this owner had to point the finger and blame me for their screw up. I'm all for supporting a small town business but this place doesn't deserve any more of mine. I will not be ordering from here ever again and highly do not recommend this place to the residents of Manhattan. Learn how to treat your customers. Pathetic. read more

See all

Best sandwiches, always fresh made. Wings and pizza also good. Salad are just ok. Service is good, fast. read more

Good portions of toppings and quick delivery. They are always offering specials which are actually useful

Great food. They always deliver earlier than the time they quote when you order. Don't let the appearance scare you.

We ordered delivery to Elwood on Tuesday Jan 25. Pizza and 20 piece boneless chicken wings. What I received was 5 piece chicken tenders cut up into 20 pieces. A 20 piece wings is $18.99 and 5 piece tenders is $6.99. I called and spoke to Matt who just said "sorry about that but that's how we serve them". How the heck can you call those boneless wings?? You can't. They're tenders. Over charging for wings when they aren't wings is ridiculous!!! First and last time we will order from this company. We will stick to Pizza 4 U that has BONELESS CHICKEN CHUNKS that are way better then some over cooked tenders cut up!! So if you plan on ordering boneless chicken wings just order tenders and save yourself $12!! read more

Absolutely my favorite pizza around. Makes me think of my pizza places from my hometown. It's my go to pizza for any pizza joint around here. Love them. read more

Over priced subpar pizza. They never seem to be that busy yet always seem to mess up orders and offer no compensation for their own mistakes. Wouldn't recommend at all. read more

The hours online say they close at 10:30 on Saturdays. I called at 9:00 on a Saturday night and they told me they were already closed... either stick to your hours or change it on the website. read more

If you want pizza near Manhattan this is the place to go. Double crust loaded is our favorite. Bread sticks and chicken tenders are good too! Nice staff and good turnaround time! read more

Sincerely great pizza, it's so mice when you can support a locally owned business because it's great, not just because it's local! The pizza is always on time, it's exactly what I order and honestly the people are amazing as well! read more

Good pizza worth trying. Support local small business. Lots of options for food here too.

Wow!! This is a GREAT PIZZA!! I've been working for 15 years at a pizza restaurant chain thats consistantly voted into chicagos top 10. Manhattan Pizza is FAR better!! The storefront is small and somewhat uninviting, but don't let that put you off...the kitchen is clean (as much of it as I could see), and the staff was very friendly. The sicillian style pizza is at gourmet level, but priced at a point that any family can afford it......I'm truly blown away! read more

5 Stars for the pizza. Best in the area by far. Management and workers are fantastic. Ingredients are fresh and the sauce rivals Chicago pizza. The only gripe I could think of is their salads are uneventful and strange combination. Iceberg lettuce, black olives, green peppers and onion. If they had better salad options, we'd order from here more often. Pizza is super though! read more

Excellent food here. Service is always good. Best wings in Town!

There is so much potential here! I always order it well well done like others have suggested but it is still usually under cooked. They have really good ingredients but they really need to start cooking the pizzas longer. read more

We love Manhattan pizza, always comes out great!! We moved here a year ago, and we are very happy with their service

Phenomenal pizza! Absolutely delicious! Can't wait to try the giardinera stuffed garlic bread!!

The pizza was better than I had expected, The big win for me here is that they offer a gluten free crust. (I had been going all the way to Monee for an acceptable GF pizza.) Tips for ordering though: Ask for well done, (or perhaps "well, well done" as I saw written on another order's box) unless you happen to like your cheese just barely melted. I had to put our pizzas under the broiler for a couple of minutes to brown them up a bit. Second note: If you order an individual size pizza, request they put it in a pizza box. My friend's pizza was on a paper plate in a styrofoam container. By the time he made it to the third piece, the crust was so soggy it wasn't worth eating. I know we'll order again, though if Pizza 4U had a gluten free crust, we would probably still go there instead as their ingredients seem a little higher quality. read more

Undercooked even after asking for well done. I see this is a problem. I order from elsewhere and get pizza the way I want it as I am the paying customer. read more

Best pizza in town and as a matter of fact best pizza within the surrounding areas! Pleasant employees and delicious pizza, what more could you ask for!! A+! read more

Finally found a pizza place in the area. I moved to New Lenox 2 years ago and I haven't been able to find a pizza joint that I like. I always ended up driving 25 minutes away for a pie. Well, I found one much closer. I had the deep dish and it was outstanding. The sauce was delicious and the crust was nice and crispy. I would highly recommend. read more

Really good pizza, likely the best in the Manhattan/New Lenox surrounds. Very small pick-up area but fast friendly service.