So I would like to update my post... I had an issue with one of my orders.. And the one thing that…read moreI can't tell you that I always look for in restaurants is when the owners actually take the time to connect with the unsatisfied customer.. And try to fix.... And that's what this owner did and I so much appreciate it.. I reordered a pizza and it was made correctly. I do have special request. I have to admit.. But I am very grateful that it was done correctly and I will continue to enjoy my favorite Lockport pizza.,.. Thank you, Manny

This place was okay, but I just went in for a slice of pizza and it was tiny! Like an appetizer…read morereally. It was too much for the slice size. Don't recommend it.

Our go to pizzeria failed us recently so we decided to try Carson's. "Hole in the wall" is best way…read moreto put it. A couple seats inside but got takeout anyway. I hope I get the same quality pizza each time because this was great. Not super saucey which helps pizza hold itself and got a great crisp. Will order next time fore-sure. Reminds me of what Chicagoland pizza used to be!

Great staff, put in an order and was surprised that pick up would only be 35 mins which was great…read more The pizza was good only criticism was it was oily, know some people like that but I soaked it up with paper towels. Would give another go!

Absolutely Incredible! Forno is incredible -- everything…read moretastes so fresh, and the service is top-notch! The pizza dough is hand-tossed and fire-baked to perfection -- you can taste the craftsmanship in every bite. The burrata, prosciutto, and fig jam combo was to die for -- creamy, sweet, and savory all at once. We also tried the sausage and peppers and meatball appetizers, and both were unbelievably flavorful and comforting. If you're looking for authentic, high-quality Italian dishes with amazing flavor and presentation, Forno is a must-visit!

Pizzas are very good. There are two types of wood fired crust, one is more crispy and the other is…read moremore New York style. The restaurant is kind of small not for large parties and the chairs & tables are high back so it may present an issue if you have mobility problems but overall I'm looking forward to trying them again. Also, the waitress was very good and the pizzas come out fast.

Pizza was good at restaurant even better the next day. Thin sausage & cheese. Also had mozzarella…read morestick good but were not piping hot, maybe sat for 5-10 minutes before reaching our table. Service was good and drink refills were prompt. The one thing that really bothered me was the cherry scented bathroom smell, please switch to an unscented version. Very over powering smell and took over the whole restaurant. If it smell like that all the time we won't be back. Yuck!

Traveling through the area on the way home and stopped here for dinner. Servers were attentive to…read moreone of our party's allergy concerns. We ordered salads and the deep dish pizza. Both were tasty and we are enjoying leftovers right now. The decor was playful and creative, leaving one with the impression that this is an old and established pizza place (hint: it is).

The best pizza in the area. Price point is "high" but you are paying for quality ingredients,…read moreconsistency, and the best pizza in this town. There are other spots to hit but no one does this style like the Big Pauly's team.

Probably have walked out of one or two places ever but this was one. Walked in on a Friday…read moreevening...only 6 tables full. Promptly seated but then just ignored for 20 minutes. Waitress just said...well I am the only one here. Never seen a staff so specialized. One person only seats people... only 6 tables had customers. One person only cleans tables and cleaned one table during the entire time we were there. Manager or owners behind the bar just entertaining those customers and couldn't care less about the rest of the operation. To the point that our waitress...the only one there- even had to serve their food at the bar while the manager is standing in front of them entire 20.minutes joking and laughing. Wanted to give this place a try but clearly they didn't care if we did. Writing this as we are well serviced sitting on a patio at Craft'd. Not surprised to see this place packed and the other empty. No apology. Just well I am the only one here.

Food is super classic, and the *extra* thin crust pizza has a REALLY nice texture. The sauce ON the…read morepie is a little under seasoned, but pro tip: the marinara that comes with appetizers is a little heavier handed with salt and is perfect to dip a slice in. Order the super thin crust! Eat it at the restaurant with the friendly staff! Grab a beer from the next door brewery! Enjoy your life! Have fun!

The roasted chicken was very good pressurized but tasted like fried. The ravioli was loaded with…read morecheese. We ordered two pizzas, but one of them came with ham and pineapple and we actually ordered it with sausage and pepperoni so we dropped it one star

We catered through Cemeno's for brunch options for a Baby Shower last weekend and it was flawless!…read moreSome of our items are from the new Cemeno's at the Park on Jefferson St, but there isn't a Yelp page set up yet for that restaurant. We also got some pasta from Cemeno's as well! Everything was amazing and guests really enjoyed the food! There were so many bagel options and cream cheeses to choose from. (An interesting one was Carrot Jalapeño) By the end of the party, everything was eaten or packed up in our guests to-go boxes. Everything was delicious, packaged nicely, and ready to go for pick up early in the morning! We will continue to cater through Cemenos as always. :)

The cheddar nuggets were crispy and delicious. Also got the Italian Deli specialty pizza which was…read morevery good. Perfect thin crust pizza and loaded with toppings.

Staff is super friendly, treat their customers as if we were all family! Super accommodating with…read moreservice. I highly recommend the beef roll! Super yummy, even my kids like it and that's saying a lot!!!!

To be honest, this is one of the worst pizzas I've ever had. I've had better frozen and gas station…read morepizza than this. The crust was so tough I couldn't even bite through it, it had to be ripped because the crust was seriously like a leather boot. The cheese was overcooked and hard and the sauce was minimal. I can't believe a pizza place that turns out non edible pizza has always been like this, it's probably safe to assume I just got bad pizza from a dude in the kitchen that doesn't care. We ordered 3 and all 3 were garbage. I will probably never go back.

Superb Pizza with Superb customer service that makes things right! Food always feels satisfyingread more

Delicious! This place came highly recommended and we see why. We ordered a deep dish, a thin…read morecrust and the see dish was the star. Not being from Chicago we were traveling and gave this a shot. It's amazing and honestly cannot be compared to NY pizza. They are just completely different styles of pizza you cannot really put them in the same category. Apples and oranges. The deep dish crust is what makes this stellar. Crispy and decadent. It's pleasurable cutting the pizza and the cheese so thick and how it melts, almost like cutting the yolk of an over easy egg. The sauce in the pie was so fresh I could have just ate a Pint of it like soup. It was fresh, herby, and simple. Absolutely wonderful!

Ordered pick up at open (4pm). Pizza was ready within 20 minutes. Solid crispy thin crust for a…read morereasonable price, definitely beats every other local spot. Can't wait to come back and try the deep dish!

Ordered a medium, thin crust, cheese and sausage pizza. It was pretty good. Sauce had a little…read moresweetness, which I like. Sausage was tasty. The crust was think and crispy. Haven't been here in years, but overall it was good. I would recommend. BTW No done in.