Tried some again. Very bland, dry toastlike pizza. Not really understanding the popularity. read more

That's chopped! I'm thankful to have this mention of a cheesesteak as a reference to quality. Oh! My mistake, the "Shaved Rib Eye" is the reference I'm making. The bread on this sandwich tastes great. The Cooper cheese is also present to assist the main ingredient. The rib eye was cooked and sliced as if it was art. They have these buffalo chicken rolls that I wish came to a PO Box. Through all this place is serving some good cheese steaks; Didn't really like the chopped cheese read more

We stopped here halfway through a long drive for a quick dinner and were very happy with that decision! Both types of pizza were very good! The chicken Cesar wrap was also delicious. There was a good amount of chicken and the salad dressing was great! It tasted homemade. The garlic knots were just ok. The dough was good but they didn't taste like they had all that much real garlic on them. The only other downside was that parking around there was hard to find on a Friday night. Otherwise, a great experience! read more

See all

Amazing !! The gut friendly sourdough pizza is great and always cooked perfectly ! 10/10

Visited Pizza Lyfe for the first time, specifically the Milford location. It is right in Downtown Milford; the interior is well designed and has plenty of seating and also they sell pizza by the slice. Their menu is vast including main entrees, sandwiches, apps, dessert, and pizza of course; they also sell beer inside. You order at the counter and they bring to the table. We loved the pizza; the dough is delicious and the sauce is top tier. Cant wait to try more of their food items. We will be back! read more

See all

Pizza was ready as promised. It was easy to order it online and pickup in store. We had a large truffled mushroom and a small cheese pizza. Both pizzas were okay at best. If they were somewhere out in the Midwest we might have viewed them more highly. However, compared to the competition this pizza is average at best. The pizza was very doughy and did not have enough toppings. Also, presentation was not best especially for the cheese pizza. See photos. Price was a bit steep for quality and completion around them. read more

Pizza Lyfe - Pizza Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

See all

Welcome addition to Milford Downtown! The calabrian cheese steak packed a spicy punch, but the smooth mix of sweet and savory offered by the tri color provided the perfect balance. Plus you can't go wrong with garlic knots! The staff was friendly and welcoming and provided quick service, yet time to enjoy the warm ambiance. I'll definitely be back to pick up a quick slice! read more

See all

I really love the text promos for storm/blizzard prep- my favorite is the half tray chicken cutlet with penne- chicken is thin and lightly fried. Their salads are delightful and everything is always packed really nicely! Also- it's the most handy local thing to have giant rainbow cookie cake slices available (and wine!). Looking forward to trying their espresso and gelato soon read more

The pizza are well presented and tasteful and the venue is ideally located on the green. However, my driver to give a 5 stars today is for the crew that works here and more specifically to Jaime. I left a prized belonging to the restaurant by mistake and would have been really upset if it had disappeared. Instead, they picked it up, put it aside in a secure place, waiting for me to pick up half a day later. Kindness seems to fade these days, these guys proved me wrong. Well done, team Pizza Lyfe read more

I got a large cheese for pick up. It was ready when promised. The crust was good, it didn't have a sourdough taste. The sauce lacked flavor. The pizza didn't really taste like anything but it's acceptable. Very tricky location to pick up a pizza so you'll definitely have to park and walk as the storefront is an intersection. I'm glad I tried it, I actually was excited. But, it's not something I need again. read more

See all

Pizza Lyfe is finally open! I have the best fiancé and he brought me a slice of pepperoni and the spicy pizza lyfe. Both were great. Love they use the roni cups. A few days later we decide to do takeout. It was insane. My fiancé waited an hour for our food. He got his usual plain cheese, we got a garlic bread and I opted for the lemon chicken sandwich. The garlic bread was nothing to write home about but let me tell you about my lemon chicken sandwich. It was incredible despite not being really warm once we got it home. The flavors were on point. We will probably wait till the place settles down a bit but excited to have that lemon chicken sandwich again but this time in its full hot glory. read more

Pizza Lyfe - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

See all

Pizza Lyfe is right in the heart of Milford, easy to find and where all the fun is. They has the most amazing staff who are polite and provide some amazing recommendations. Special shoutout to Jamie who helped us with recommending some absolute gems from the menu. We decided to get the mozzarella sticks which were not at all like any other place or the frozen ones being served. That was so true. I am so glad we got the mozzarella sticks. They were cheesy, fresh, thick and crunchy on the outside. Just the best when dunked in the marinara sauce. The garlic bread was also pleasantly different from the usual ones and was prepared on a sesame seed bread. That did make a huge difference the quality of the bread was awesome! I definitely recommend you guys to try the kale and quinoa salad which had chick peas for the protein, feta cheese to give a little savoury flavour and their special in - house Italian dressing. Absolutely amazing. We moved on the to entree section of our night with their special veggie pizza. This pizza is a dream come true for a vegetarian like me. It was loaded with some absolutely delicious vegetables like onions, peppers, mushroom, broccoli and more. The perfect charred edgesand evenly charred bottom. Everything about this pizza screams delicious. The pasta was a customeized preparation where we chose rigatoni, alfredo sauce with broccoli and mushrooms. It turned out to be an absolutely amazing choice. Totally recommend. My husband enjoyed the spicy chicken vodka sauce sandwich which was also prepared on a sesame seed bread. He said it was delicious. The cannoli was our dessert and it was crunchy and creamy and yummy. Foodieveggie recomends 10/10 read more

I didn't think we needed another pizza place in Milford but all the best spots don't deliver. I'm not big on uber eats but in a crunch we ordered pizza lyfe which exceeded expectations. I've heard similar positive reviews from friends. Still haven't gone inside but it's looks like a good place to stop anytime of day. Service was through the app but that worked as we hoped. All in all a solid delivery addition to Milford. read more

Tried the grandma slice, truffle slice and now tried the hot honey slice and meatball calzone, unfortunately 2 times tried and eatable at best. My last visit, very disappointing, was expecting great food and just didn't do it for us. I'm truly sorry, I love to support local businesses but I just have to be honest. read more

So many ways to customize your perfect pizza. Great quality, easily a favorite pizza place. Highly recommend!

Excellent and tasty pizza. Just a terrible location to pick up. Parking is not easy and not close. Both the Truffled Mushrooms Pizza and Calabrian Cheesesteak Pizza were very good. Both could have used some more flavor as the truffles and Calabrian chiles were somewhat muted but still very good. read more

Pizza Lyfe - Calabrian Cheesesteak Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

See all

We placed a significant order which consisted of pizza, stromboli, parmesan sandwich and french fries. This food was for eight people and none of us were pleased with the food. Even the fires were off. read more

Chef Aiden is the best chef at pizza lyfe he makes it best pizzas in the world. He has so many talents and all the workers are so kind and sweet. I highly recommend this place to everyone! read more

Solid NY style pizza...Online ordering is simple and service has been great. The only drawback to the Milford location is lack of parking at a busy intersection read more

3.5. Like someone else said very ok pizza. I would consider ordering again (different toppings). Flavor was lacking in the pizza but the garlic bread with cheese was great. I will be ordering a sandwich next time for sure. read more

They sent us coupons in the mail and when we called to order they said we needed to order in person in order to apply the coupon. It did not say this on the coupon so false advertising. We went previously and there are much better pizza places in Milford. read more

This is the BEST pizza I have had in a long time. I had the truffle mushroom and spicy lyfe pie. They were both delicious! Will deff be back. read more

We stopped here recently, when we were in town for a funeral. After a three hour drive, we were starving and the wife wanted pizza. So, we check out the slice pies and they looked good. We ordered slices and sodas. Out to our table coming some piping hot slices with a crispy not-burnt crust that far exceeded expectations. I personally enjoyed the sausage and pepper pizza very much. The wife loved the regular cheese pizza. Service was quick and gracious. It had the usual pizza shop ambiance, but pleasantly, had some great music playing (Coldplay from 2002). We highly recommend Pizza Lyfe to visitors and to the Milford locals. Wish we had one up here in Boston. read more

Yesterday evening, I tried some new pizza in downtown Milford. After passing by it a few days prior, me and my partner became interested in visiting ourselves. We placed our order online for a large cheese pizza. This came out to be about $20 plus some change. We placed online so we could take it down to the boating docks and tables right down the hill. First off, smell was amazing. As always, we were a bit skeptical after looking at the pie but after eating it, we fell in love. I usually always pair my pizza with a side of blue cheese, I was unsure if they had the option to get in a portion cup but next time I will try and ask. The crust of the pizza was delicious. I love sourdough crust pizza but not every place knows how to work with it well. It had a herby sauce, which is good. I just feel like the only thing that's missing is more cheese! Everyone is each to their own, but I just feel like this pizza would've been 5 star if it had another layer of cheese. Something felt like it was missing and the cheese is the component. I feel like this spot is a good pizza place to have for dinner for two rather than ordering multiple pies since they are $20 each. You must also get to the pizza quick, because it cools down fast. Not disappointed, just wanting more! Service was good, the gentleman at the service counter was attentive and got us our pizza quickly. Inside the restaurant is clean, just a bit tiny. Though considering it's on the corner of the street, they are working with the space provided. Overall, enjoyed the pizza, enjoyed the time in downtown Milford. We will be back. read more

See all

Ordered a Sicilian almost $40 !!! a few vegetable toppings with no cheese still almost $40 , the dough sorry for me 3 out of 10. I will probably give it another shot. Maybe they have to iron out the kinks from opening up recently however I'm sure it's still gonna be the same dough recipe read more

Caution. This restaurant uses LATEX gloves when handling food. Too bad. We really wanted to try this new place in Milford.

Pizza Lyfe just recently opened on the beautiful green in Milford CT. I recently popped in to check the place out, because I heard it was usually packed, and being the kind of sleuth I am, and having an aversion to waiting in lines, especially when I'm hungry I wanted to see first hand what the deal was. There is seating for maybe around two dozen people. There was no one else in the restaurant when I picked up my meatball parm grinder and slice of cheese pizza on a late Sunday afternoon. The grinder was on a fresh 12" sesame seed Italian sub roll, one of my all-time favorites for a sandwich. It was very good, overstuffed with juicy meatballs, but could have definitely used more sauce. The slice was also good, although it's not fair to judge a pizza place by their slices, since they are cold and only warmed up when a customer orders one. I can't wait to go back and order a fresh pie! I do think Pizza Lyfe will do very well in the spot they're in, I can see lots of people just stopping in for a slice New York style, and the location is prime for a nice romantic stroll down to the docks afterwards. So I said I'd order a whole pizza next time, so tonight I ordered a large cheese pie, no toppings, so as to get a taste of the basic pie without other flavors complicating it's taste. I am happy to say the pie was quite good. It's not New Haven style, but more like a slice you'd get in NYC. If your o.k. with that, you will enjoy it.! read more

Pizza Lyfe - 2 slices down, six to go! - Pizza Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

Great place for slices. Milford needed that, ever since Franco's closed. They have a good selection ready to go. We've gotten slices and their probiotic sodas a few times this summer. The crust stands up well to take-out. We walked them to the harbor for a nice summer evening meal. (Picnic tables on the Green would also be a nice spot.) Excellent addition to downtown Milford! read more

This was a to-go order. Website offered curbside pickup ("bring my order to my car"). I placed the order 1 hour before the desired time of 6:45pm. Arrived near restaurant on time and called. I was told to come inside and pick up my order. There is no good parking spot next to the restaurant. Order was not ready. Finally walked out with my pizza 20 minutes later. Logistics aside, the pizza is good. read more

Great pizza from start to finish. The crust was perfectly cooked, crispy on the outside and soft inside, with just the right amount of chew. Sauce was flavorful, cheese was melted evenly, and the toppings were fresh and generous. Everything tasted hot and made with care. Ordering was easy, service was friendly, and the food was ready on time. This is a solid local spot in Milford that I'll gladly order from again and recommend to anyone craving quality pizza without hesitation every single time. read more

Perfect addition to the downtown with very good pizza, and food in general. Two minute walk to the baseball fields and train with beer to boot. read more

A wonderful spot to stop into while taking a walk through milford's green. the atmosphere and kind staff are highlights to this establishment. The fact they use sourdough crust is a huge plus and stands out cooked to perfection read more

Delicious pizza. Loved the sourdough crust. Staff were friendly and love the sell single slices

Nice place for NY pizza. I like that they sell slices. It's a great addition to downtown Milford

Loved the crust! Great service. Nice to get a different style pizza in this area. Plus so many other menu options.