I've been coming here for countless years -- mostly for family functions -- and we've also used…read moretheir catering for parties. This place has always been reliable, and our most recent visit reinforced why we keep coming back. We were here on a Friday night to celebrate a retirement with a group of around 30 people, and it was such a lovely evening. We were seated in the side room (I believe it's called the Arthur Avenue space), which felt like a cozy wine cellar -- intimate, warm, and perfect for a larger celebration. The food was served family-style, which I personally love, and everything was delicious. Some standout dishes were the Chicken Capricciosa -- an absolute crowd favorite and something I'd come back for alone -- as well as the penne vodka, shrimp Francese, and pizza. All were excellent. Service was very good and attentive throughout the night -- drinks were always full, and they brought out plenty of food whenever we needed more. Overall, this is a fantastic spot for group dinners and celebrations, offering great food, warm service, and a very reasonable price point. Always a great experience.

On Tuesday night we arrived starving! First they bring a nice loaf of bread to the table. Nice…read moreand warm and we inhaled it! Ha Next we ordered our dinners which we were all happy with and came out so fast!!!! I was happy about that. I ordered the Spicy Scampi with chicken and rigatoni on the side. They served it with lots of chicken (3 slices) and the hot cherry peppers (not so hot) with a light sauce with mushrooms, garlic and other things. It was delicious with plenty of leftovers for dinner tomorrow. If I had anything to comment on, I wish the sauce was thicker so it would coat the pasta. The Chicken scarpariello and the Penne alla Vodka were enjoyed by our other guests and they reported that it was delicious too. The dining room has a homey feel and our waitress was fantastic! I would definitely come back.

I love the food here, but I ordered a delivery via slice at 6:09 pm on a Friday night. Initial…read moreestimate for delivery was 6:59 pm - 7:14 pm. Update that it was busier than usual, now 7:06-7:21 pm. I called at 8 pm saying it was 40 minutes late (past the "out for delivery" estimate of 7:21 pm, which it had been saying for a LONG time) and was told rather rudely and abruptly that they were very busy and I shouldn't trust the slice delivery time, that they didn't see my order and two delivery guys recently left. It came at 8:02 pm. 40 min past the delivery time isn't acceptable. I also asked for my side to be "vegetable of the day" and it was pasta with sauce. I really do love the food, but was very unhappy with the delivery service. I am very hesitant to order from them again.

I have been a long time Customer of Oscars even before it was Oscars. It was Three boys pizza. I…read moreknow Oscar took over from the prior owners and I've been loyal custom, for 20 years. However, every single time I call for a takeout order there's something wrong with the order. Many times I just give them the benefit of the doubt. Sometimes I call so they can rectify the issue. Tonight I just asked for extra sauce for a meatball and eggplant Parmesan subs, cause although the subs are good they're a little dry sometimes and they need extra sauce. They did not come with extra sauce, same old dry sandwich. I called. They said the kitchen put it on there. That's not what I would've expected. This is my last time ordering from Oscar's cause I'm fed up with them getting my order wrong. I'm really not a complainer or a Karen, but I guess the jokes just on me and they don't care. Sorry Oscar. Your staff is really not that good.

Very good pizza. Personal sized chicken, meatball, fresh garlic with hot cherry peppers was…read moredelicious. I wish the crust was touch thinner, but overall very good. Mozzarella sticks are on point too.

After 36 years, it's the best pizza in town! This pizza place has truly won me over during their…read moreshort time here. El Macho Buffalo Pizza amazing!!

My Cousins -- Sunday night, belly full, world makes sense again…read more You know it's good when everybody's quiet at the table. No arguing, no complaints--just chewing. Food comes out hot, portions are serious, and nobody leaves hungry or emotionally unsettled, which after a long week is a miracle. This is real comfort food. The kind where you lean back, loosen the belt, and say, "Alright... that hit." Service is solid, no rush, no attitude. They let you eat like a human being. Five stars. If this place didn't exist, Sundays would be a problem.

The very first thing we noticed on entering, and even making a reservation, was how friendly and…read moreaccommodating the staff was. Our service throughout the meal was excellent with both our server and the manager (or owner?) checking in consistently. I really liked the decor and music as well. The decor is minimalistic, but I really liked how clean everything felt. I asked about the music -- it was 80s and 90s rock like Journey and Elton John and it matched our tastes perfectly for the particular moment in time we were there. They said they use pandora and the music varies from night to night, but we were fans. The food is where things weren't quite up to 5 stars, which is why the rating. We started with an autumn (squash) soup and wedge salad. The soup was good or maybe even a little better than good, but not great. For me, the salad was the same way. It comes with candied bacon and that just doesn't fit the profile of bleu cheese and iceberg. I ended up eating the salad without the bacon and then having the bacon at the end as an "opening dessert." The salad was super fresh and the dressing was well done. And the bacon alone was delicious--just not great together for my palate. We went with a couple handmade pasta dishes as our mains and they were both good. Again, not quite great. I liked mine better than my wife's. That is sis's new favorite was well named to my mind. It was spicy, but not overly so and the tomato and broccoli added depth to the dish that was missing from my wife's pasta. I would 100% come back. If we do, I think we'd split a pasta and a main. Some of the fish dishes we saw go by looked fantastic. The one negative to me was an occasional whiff of marijuana. I'm totally fine with someone taking a break to calm themselves if that's what they need. I just don't want to smell that while I'm eating, especially in a restaurant that is otherwise very very nice.

From the moment you walk in, it feels like a real neighborhood Italian spot--not pretentious, not…read morerushed, just warm and welcoming. The food is the star here: fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. Everything we ordered was spot-on, from the perfectly cooked pasta to the rich, balanced sauces that actually taste homemade (because they are). Service was attentive without hovering--exactly how it should be. You can tell the staff genuinely cares about the experience, not just turning tables. Portions are generous, prices are fair, and the quality punches way above what you'd expect for a local spot. If you're in Mahopac and want legit Italian food done right--this is the place. Trattoria Sei just gets it. We'll be back.

I've been here a few times with my in-laws and every time it's been great. It's a quaint little…read morerestaurant, but a great ambience and great service. Easily the best Italian food I've had in Mahopac and always my go to when visiting. I would recommend the chicken vodka parm. Just look out the portions are huge! Great spot!

Hands down my favorite pizza place of all time. For the two decades I lived in NY, this was my go…read moreto pizza spot. I moved out of state, and no New England spit can touch the pizza, salads, wedges, calzones and dinners found here at YPP. The business is family run, and I had the provide of working there for 10 years and always feeling like I was part of the family. Everything made here is made with love and dedication to being high quality. If you love good Italian, you can bet you'll get it here. The vibe of this place is typical NY pizza place. Red booths, glass display with all of the day's slices on displace, big soda fridge, and counters where you are greeted with smiling faces. They added on a second room for more formal dining and larger parties. Joe and family do so much for the community; they feed them, they care for them and they give back. It's a small business unlike the rest!

Pizza +++ not many pizza places like this. Pizza good with real mozzella (if not real better than…read morethe rest) quality food with nice portions (I hope you are the real deal)

Chop salad with chicken was wonderful at Oscars. We also had fresh rolls…read more Service was great.

I love their salads and appetizers. Due to my special dietary requirements I order mainly grilled…read moresalmon. I must stop ordering from Oscar II due to the fact that whenever I order grilled salmon (medium) the inside is mush. There is absolutely no consistency to it. This is a rather expensive dish. I always order a dinner salad and dessert with it. I am a long time customer but I give up. The WORST thing was when I called to talk to the manager about the salmon (food), they text me telling me to text Grubhub (delivery service). Too many places serve grilled salmon and other wonderful dishes. If you can't cook grilled salmon correctly then I will not recommend you further nor will you get my patronage.

I'm looking into restaurants where I can host my daughter's graduation party. We recently heard…read moreabout this place so I wanted to try it before considering it as an option. We went last night for dinner. Made a reservation for 6:30 and were seated immediately upon arrival. We tried the Eggplant Stack as an appetizer and were blown away! It was delicious!! Our entrees were just as good. All of the staff were very friendly and the ambiance is beautiful. We will definitely be back soon.

Service was not good. Can't blame the staff. It seemed like the owner (son Michael, not Lisa)just…read moregot them off the street. No experience. We were rushed through the entire dinner. Not good. Very disappointed. We come here a lot Lisa the owner was not there. That explains it Although her son Michael was there. Not up to par Lisa you need to oversee everything. Michael was not checking on tables like you do.

We dine here often. The food, pizza, drinks, and never disappoint. Great staff. A++++read more

I came here with a few family members on a Wednesday night. We made a reservation, but since we…read morewent on a weekday, it wasn't that busy. I ordered the salmon and spinach salad. I really liked the salmon, but I thought the salad was a bit overdressed. The service was great and everyone in our party liked our food.