Food service. Everything was great. Pizza is one of the best in Dane County…read moreThey have a large menu besides pizza and all are satisfying

Arrived with a party of 6 on a Thursday night at 5:30pm.... maybe half the tables in the restaurant…read morewere full. After placing our order, we started to receive our food about a hour later. It took over 10 minutes for everyone to receive their food. I was done eating before the last person was served! The food was average at best.

We love coming here! They subs are very good - I love getting them toasted. This little pizza was…read moredelish and seemed fresh. The sausage on the pizza was bomb. They also have UW Babcock ice cream in the summer which is the best ice cream! Follow me on Instagram at yelpershawn for more reviews!

Service is really good. The food has been going downhill calzone only had spoonful of pizza sauce…read morewas dry and overcooked. Also the subs I have to ask for extra lettuce because they hardly put any lettuce on a I believe that is the staple of sub. I shouldn't have to ask for extra lettuce.

Our waitress tonight was amazing! I think her name was Heidi. She had the entire place outside to…read moreherself and she was hustling. She was very kind and lovely! This is my second time here and the food is consistently good. The Brussels sprout appetizer is hands down a fried delightful surprise. The Caesar fries are also a great starter. I get the figgy piggy and fat uncle Tony's to share as a table and it is delicious! Great crust and pizza!

My wife is gluten free so when we found out they had gluten free pizzas she was excited. We started…read morewith a burrata and strawberry salad. It was great. The pizzas came and they both were great. The service was great.

Great Pizza and service is great. Great menu and apps are really good Love the "new chicken…read morenuggets Poppers are all good. If street parking is full, they have a large lot behind them.

So I was honestly back and forth between 2 and 3 stars on this one. I hadn't been here in close to…read morea decade, if not longer, and came here with a friend on a Friday night. The place was pretty steady in the bar area but not crazy packed. I get that this is a local spot, and I love supporting my local businesses, but this one was a bit uncomfortable. Everybody in there stared at us as we walked in and walked around the bar to find a table. Like long stares that followed us as we moved around. We both commented on it as we took our seats. I've been to places that obviously have a regular crowd when I'm clearly an outsider, but they've at least been nice and welcoming. This didn't feel that way. Nobody outwardly acted like they wanted us to leave or anything, but it was still really weird. We each ordered a beer and took some time to look over the menu. They have a lot of options, and we both each decided to go with the smaller 7" pizza. I love that they do have a smaller pizza option for an individual, but so often I find the "personal" pizzas might feed a small toddler, but certainly not an adult who loves pizza. This was a lovely size and I was full when done. Each pizza came out on the kind of paper plate you might buy at the grocery store. We both thought our pizzas tasted like a frozen pizza you might buy at the grocery store, but honestly I really love frozen pizza so I don't necessarily mean that in a bad way. Nothing remarkable, but it was good and I ate my whole pizza. It was a torrential downpour while we were there, so we were considering getting another drink and trying to wait it out. But then our server dropped off our bill without saying anything else or asking if there was anything else we needed. We already felt a bit outsider-ish and this was just kind of the final reminder that we weren't regulars here so we decided to pay the bill and go. While this wouldn't be my first option to come back to, I'd happily eat here again if someone else wanted to drop in.

We were searching for a good sub place that wasn't a chain, and I'm SO glad we found this! The…read moreowner was working by himself and was incredibly friendly and personable, which made the experience even better. The subs were absolutely delicious, and the bread was so soft and fresh. We also decided to grab a cheese pizza to go with our meal, and that definitely didn't disappoint either! We're not from the area, but one thing is for sure--next time we're in Madison, we WILL be back! Highly recommend checking this place out if you're looking for great food and a friendly, local spot.

We always enjoy North Shore. Everything is always good. The salads, pizza and sandwiches. Very…read moreauthentic East Coast!

This place has a really fun vibe with lots of interesting posters on the walls. We were seated…read moreright away but the food did take a little while to come out after ordering. I ordered the medium Umami Bomby pizza and it was delicious! The crust was super crispy, the cheese super melty, and topped with a generous amount of toppings. I could only eat a little over half of it, but if you have a big appetite this could be for one person. If you want some good Detroit style pizza, definitely come here!

Got takeout from here on a Friday night, which is definitely the way to go. The space is pretty…read moresmall inside and they were packed with a wait, but our order was ready ahead of when it said. Super easy pickup. We ordered the tik tik boom and the not on the first date pizzas, unsliced so that the toppings stayed on better. It's nice that they make this recommendation when ordering. It's a good Detoit style, which we likened to a focaccia with toppings and a nice crust of cheese around the sides. The tik tik boom was our favorite, as the toppings paired well together and it's a unique flavor. The not on the first date had my favorite sauce of the two as even though it didn't say it, there seemed to be a little lime in the crema. Overall, would recommend!

I was a little disappointed considering all of the hype around the environment. We sat outside and…read morehad intermittent check-ins from our server who i think was not a server? They seemed unprepared to serve us. The menu was smaller than I thought it would be and the flavors were a little lacking in some of the dishes we tried. Parking can be a bit challenging too. I am hoping I just caught them on an off night, would be willing to try again!

They have delicious pizzas and other dinner options. They have a nice seating area indoors as well…read moreas outdoors, and you can even get their pizza next-door if you're getting a drink at Gibbs's. The staff is sweet, the pizza is delicious, definitely a thin crust pizza option for everyone!

Good stuff. Thin Crust is not sweet like east coast. It's more Chicago style. Sausage and sauce…read moreboth are flavorful.

I order once or twice a week. The owner is a great guy with good food. The sausage and hot…read moregiardiniera thin crust is definitely a go to. Keep up the great job. The lunch deals are great.

We met some friends for dinner before a concert at the Monona Terrace. I hadn't been there since…read moreDec (if you haven't been to Lucille in Dec, it's a must do for their festive decor and drinks) and I was really impressed. We enjoyed the summer harvest salad, yummy umami pie and a grilled peach & tomato platter (can't recall the name) special. Everything was fresh, tasty and beautiful. We ate too much because we couldn't take leftovers to the concert and we didn't want to throw anything away. Definitely recommend!

I always enjoy checking out local favorites when I travel, and Lucille's in downtown Madison…read moreabsolutely lived up to the hype. On a beautiful day, I grabbed a table outside and enjoyed the downtown atmosphere while digging into a classic wood-fired personal pizza and a cold beer. Sometimes simple is best, and Lucille's proves exactly that. The pizza was delicious, with a perfectly cooked crust and great flavor in every bite. The service was friendly and attentive, and the staff made the experience even better. Combined with the lively ambiance and prime downtown location, it's easy to see why Lucille's has become one of the most popular pizza spots in Madison. Great pizza, great service, and great vibes. If you're visiting Madison or looking for a reliable local favorite, Lucille's is well worth the stop.

Everything was cooked fresh and our order was spot-on. The service was great, and the dining area…read moreis clean and roomy. It was pretty quiet inside--seems like most people grab their food to go. The location is a bit tucked away and easy to miss; bigger signage would definitely help. That said, the food was excellent!

Permanently CLOSED. They were only open for a few weeks in the old KFC / Taco Bell location. They…read morenever really got off the ground. It's a shame because the location will be hot in a few years when the Stoughton Trailers property is fully developed, and the roads are fixed for better access. The place never really recovered from the disastrous KFC that was horribly mismanaged and dirty.