Our favorite place when in PR This cozy place has the best food. It is always a hit, never a miss. Service is always friendly and attentive. It's is both a family place and also romantic. Don't miss out on this experience. read more

See all

Amazing pizza!! Unassuming spot on the island attached to a gas station. Ambiance was very intimate. We had to wait about 20 minutes because it is a small resteruant but we'll worth the wait. Once seated we were taken care of quickly, beer was great from Canada. We tried the Biana and hot honey pepperoni both were delicious!! Definitely recommend and would go back!! read more

See all

This is a prime example of not judging a book by its cover. Located in a gas station, Pimentón offers fantastic pizza. I didn't know what to expect, but the last thing I expected to find in Puerto Rico was the best garlic bread I've ever had, and at Pimentón, I found it. They have a great selection of beers and wine. The local is small but charming, and you can see the pizzas being made and placed in oven. The service was so lovely and attentive. read more

See all

Don't forget to make a reservation before heading out here. This restaurant is very popular, for a reason. The food is great. I really like the bruschetta and the tuna tartare appetizers. The La Fico pizza is excellent. It has prosciutto, arugula, and figs. Those figs really make it stand out. It is also a white pizza. The Infusione and La Pimentón are also very good. The mushroom mac & cheese with truffle oil is a great choice if you don't want pizza. I loved it. I love the addition of the outdoor patio. It provides more space and is kid friendly. More importantly, it's stroller friendly. When it was indoors, it wasn't. The private rooms are also a nice touch. They have a TV with Netflix, which was perfect because our group had three children. It kept them occupied for most of the time. Service was also excellent. read more

See all

Excellent food selection with great variety of wines and beer, cozy and service is great.

Some of the best pizza I have ever had. As other reviews have noted, this place can be difficult to find. Yes, it's connected to a gas station. See pictures for a better understanding. read more

Very good brick oven pizza and appetizers. Lots of bottles of wine to choose from. Now I can say I at one of the best pizzas in Puerto Rico inside a gas station lol. Highly recommended read more

See all

Great service! Quaint environment! The food was soooo delicious! Hot Honey pizza was so yummy

I believe Pimentón is easily one of the top 3 pizzerias in PR. I've been here twice and everything is top notch, from the food to the service to the vibe. This second time the only thing that change was the vibe. It was better. The first time I came here was before the pandemic and it was all indoors, in a small room inside the Shell gas station. It was small but fun. That was part of its charm. But it was always too crowded because there was not enough room. This time around the indoor area is used as a wine cellar, it seemed to me. On the side of the gas station they set up an outdoor patio surrounded by small trailers. The trailers are private rooms for larger parties. I went with my wife, son, parents, and one of my brothers and his family. We were mince total so we got a private room. It was awesome. The room had air conditioning, a TV. It was tight because the trailers are small and narrow but very nicely decorated. My wife even saw a microphone, possibly for karaoke. I think this addition makes the place even better. If you want beer you can buy it at the gas station. They have a really good selection of craft beers. Our server was great, friendly and attentive. On point all afternoon. We started out with bruschetta, mini calzone, and tuna tartare. For the main course we ordered two large pizzas, one was La Pimentón and the other was Infusione. We also got two small pizzas, La Fico and a cheese pizza for the kids. Small pizzas are circular 6 slices. Large are squared 8 slices. Aside from pizza they have pasta, mac & cheese, steak and salmon. My wife ordered the mac & cheese with mushrooms and truffle oil. The portion size is for sharing. Everyone got a spoonful or two and she still had more than enough for her. Easily for two people. Everything was delicious. I would recommend everything we ate. For dessert we had key lime pie and either a chocolate cheesecake or salted caramel bread pudding. I was wasn't around when they ordered it and didn't try it (too full). Overall, an excellent experience. I highly recommend checking this place out. Next time I'm trying the meatball appetizers (polpette and polpette sliders). I saw another party eating them and they looked good. Reservations are highly recommended, especially for larger groups. You can park at the gas station or across the street. read more

Awesome service Daniel gave us an excellent service. Food was really good. The overall environment was good, casual and friendly.

This place is unbelievable, I almost got lost trying to find this GEM! Everything we ordered was outstanding, I'm not kidding from the appetizers all the way to the coconut cheesecake. It's located on the gas station property, save yourself from getting lost . The service was impeccable. Went back for takeout days later and it was just as great as my first time. read more

I always come here when i visit P.R. I love the food and our servers and everyone there are always very pleasant and accommodating. The last visit all the food was great, meatballs, garlic bread, pear ravioli. I do have to tell them next time LESS salt. All had too much salt. read more

Although small in size, it packs a HUGE punch. The pizzas were delicious. The pizza with honey is a must. Incredible selection of wines and the service was great. Can't wait for my next visit. Thank you. read more

The most unlikely place for a wonderful pizza with an even selection of beer and wine. It is a must-stop if you want a break from the wonderful Puertorrican food. read more

Great food with great service. The best pizza with the best selections of wine in town. Reservations are a must because seating is limited.

Probably biased because I had my first date here with my girlfriend but I really enjoyed Pimenton. The pizza has a great sauce/cheese/topping ratio and it's delicious. I was a bit bummed to see they got rid of the larger pizza sizes (can't remember the dimensions) but still a place I plan on coming back to. It's in a gas station and can be hard to seat on weekend nights. read more

Excellent pizza! But what is pizza without a good cold BEER! They only have artisanal beer but that's not what goes with pizza. Darn! Bought a beer in gas station but not cold . I'm willing to pay more as long as it's cold read more

I ordered takeout, the food tasted amazing I ordered a Bianca pizza. It has pesto sauce bacon and ham I choose to leave out the onions. I also pick a soup of the day, it was tomatoes soap and Mac and cheese with skirt steak which was very good. The place to sit inside the restaurant is very small, but pretty. It has limited space, but I believe the have some sort of containers or gazebos outside so you can eat with a bigger group. read more

Everything about this place is 5 star! Took a while to find it. It's located inside a Shell gas station. Once inside you forget you are in a gas station. The ambiance is of a bar type pizza-Italian joint that is rare to Puerto Rico. We ordered the stuffed tomatoes for appetizer and the Infusione and Riserva pizza. Pizza is really really good here! One of the best I've ever had. The crust was super flavorful and ingredients fresh and delicious. They also have a variety of beers bottled and on tap. A lot are local brews. They also have a beer tasting sampler available, which I regret not trying. It was my son's b-day and to top off the night they brought out this chocolate cake and ice cream concoction that tasted delicious and looked amazing. Highly recommend this place. The people there are super friendly and helpful. Wonderful experience from start to finish. read more

See all

This place is one of me and my husband's favorites in San Juan (well, actually is located in Carolina). The pizzas are delicious, there is a wide selection of artisanal and local beers, and the services is great. Lost recent time went there with my parents, and we all had a great time. Only downside is the parking situation, because the restaurant is located in a gas station, and it tends to be difficult to find parking space, but that is greatly compensated by the delicious food. Highly recommended!!! read more

So far the best Pizza I have had in PR. It's part of a gas station but don't let that fool you. Excellent staff. Outside patio is very nice and the have private rooms for small get together. Will make this one of our regular stops. read more

Owner and waiters were so attentive. The Hot Honey pizza is to die for. Excellent wine selection and not overpriced.

Excellent service and delicious pizza, wine and food. Highly recommend this hidden gem.

Best pizzas you'll indulge! Only Con is the slight wait time of approximately 30 minutes on busy hours. Everything else is a Pro on this establishment. From Service-menu selection-alcohol beverage, this place has got it pat down. Plus when you arrive, the least you'd expect at the gas station is to feel as if you were in the TRIBECA area at Manhattan. One of the best 2 hour fuel fill up you'll experience, literally! read more

Excellent place!!! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED! Food outstanding, service exceptional! At the right price! This place is always packed! Never had the chance to try it since is always full! Today we went thought and ask how long was the wait? It was 15 minutes.... but in 15 minutes we had already our drinks and were ordering our entree!(By the way, the churrasqueria pizza is highly recommended!) The craft beer selection is great! They have plenty to choose from! Will definitely back! read more

See all

I can not recommend this place enough! The food is amazing and the staff is incredible! A must visit for the pizza and burrata - although you will not go wrong with anything on the menu! read more

Before being there I read some reviews here and I almost change my opinion to try this place. Well, I'm happy to finally hit the place with some friends. This restaurant is pretty limited in space, and yes people need to wait most of the time. After seen some couples waiting we wait and spend some time in the coffee shop at the gas station. A group of 5 and we wait for 40 minutes. The food it's really really affordable and awesome. From the variety of draft beers, to the appetizers and the pizza. Cheese bread and pomodoro sauce lovely! We order 4 different pizzas. Very thin and crunchy crust, savory and no over flavor sauce and fresh ingredients. Waiter service outstanding!!!! The chef come in person to every single table yesterday. read more

See all

This place is a comedy show .. I placed an order for cauliflower margarita pizza after waiting for almost an hour the girl handed to me margarita pizza and said ,, didn't have cauliflower dough this is regular pizza ,, . Second time I placed the same order and I got cauliflower pizza . I felt the bottom of the box was cold so they gave me a pizza to take home to bake it .. Whatta retards . read more

Cozy small restaurant, hidden inside a gas station, yes sounds crazy but the ambience is awesome!! Great selection of crafted beers (local & imported), wines and good sangria. Lets talk about pizza, the oven is huge, pizza come out fast, topping are fresh and creative pizza are delish! I recommend the Bianca, Pimenton & Fico if you like sweet & Salty! The staff is great and really friendly!! And akmost forgot the have live music!! read more

Pimentón - Pizza Near Me - Carolina, Puerto Rico

Where to even start!? Pimentón has been one of my favorite pizza places ever since I tried it years ago. I had the same reaction to most people when I first went there (as in where the heck am I?) as it is next to a Shell Gas Station. Don't let that fool you! As soon as you walk in you will think you are in a fancy restaurant in Old San Juan. The place is so nice and cozy and the smell just hits you! I usually order the Churrasqueria- it has skirt steak with chimichurri, veggies and all the cheese goodness you can think of. I also order the bistecca which is more meat lovers like but just as tasty! Don't let the size fool you- it is very filling! We also orden the guava cheesecake for desert (and usually to split as we are very full at this time!) They also have several beers and have a coffee shop right next door. So no matter your like you will find something to order (and rave about). I don't live nearby anymore but Pimentón is ALWAYS on my to eat list whenever Im an back home in Puerto Rico! read more

A true gem! Excellent service and incredibly delicious food!! Their artisan pizzas are my absolute favorite. Unlike other artisan pizzerias, Pimentón is not overpriced. (Price and quality better than Pirilo's!) As this place has gained reputation, tables are filling quickly, but let me tell you, the wait is so worth it! read more

Pimentón - Sei formaggi - Pizza Near Me - Carolina, Puerto Rico

See all

Wow! This place is great! A hidden gem forreal. Circled around for a while looking for this place. It is right inside the shell gas station! Who knew! Pizza is, for one, amazing and, two, a great price. The workers are friendly and the inside looks modern. Arrived here at 6:30 to be seated right away. Our stomachs were too full to order a pasta. Got to try it next time! Would definitely recommend this place!!! Ordered: insalata $8, riserva small $12, infusione small $12, and kids menu cheese pizza read more

Looked for a pizza place for my sons bday and Found this from TripAdvisor as one of the best pizza in Puerto Rico and I can validate that it is indeed one of the best pizzas I've ever had. We ordered Riserva and the Infusion and it was mouthwatering. So unfair because I kept wanting to eat more but carbs.... Also started out with the stuffed mozzarella tomato appetizer and it was so good. Highly recommend. Luckily we came on a Tuesday about 6:30pm and was not crowded yet. Staff are very friendly. Great ambiance but strange it's at the Shell gas station. We will be back before the end of our vacation They did a fun happy birthday song for my son with chocolate cheesecake. Was so yummy read more

Great place with great service. Amazing food with an acceptable price! I'll be come back soon! read more

This is a nice hidden location. Took a few minutes to find where it is until we realized it was at the gas station lol the pizza was great. The dough on the crust was very soft and tasty so any pizza is great. No pineapples tho. My favorite was probably the Infusione. Beer is good too! read more

Pimentón - Stuffed tomato is definitely worth trying! - Pizza Near Me - Carolina, Puerto Rico

Hands down, best food (pizza) I have had in a very long time. The service was phenomenal. Tons of crafts beers and several we're on tap too. The pizza was fresh, made to order right there. I ordered the buffalo margerita pizza and my friend ordered a pizza with ham and several cheeses on it. It was fantastic. 5 stars and I will be returning. read more

The pizza is awesome!! Omg!! Is incredible delicious! The best pizza I've ever taste! For appetizer I had brocheta, it was so delicious !!! For main course I ordered the bistecca, it was out of this world !!! The service is Good, the place is very cozy and very decorated! If you want to taste a really good pizza, this is your place ! read more

Pimentón - Bistecca - Pizza Near Me - Carolina, Puerto Rico

Awsome hidden gem in the 65th ave. Cozy restaurant offering an extensive range of beers and great cocktails. The pizza is amazing with different variations for all tastes. Not your typical greasy pizza and just delicious. While they are recognized for the pizza, they offer other amazing courses such as churrasco, pastas, risottos. Fully recommend! read more

You will notice that the most recent review dates back a long while ago. The original pizza guy (Luigi from the REAL Italy) moved on and left locals in charge. Not what it used to be and not better than your nearby pizza place. Too salty and undercooked dough with basic ingredients. Must say the hostess was deceiving with timing and uninterested. Sad! read more

I absolutely love this place, every time we go try something different and we never miss. Even though the place is small so always seems to be full they always accommodate and staff is very welcoming and insightful about their menu and drink offerings. I love this place ! It's a must! read more