Everything went well. I love the shrimps, the wings and the a veggie pizza. The ambiance is amazing. I just love the people serving, I was with my daughter and son in law they were in Fajardo for a visit. They both as well as me enjoyed the place. Marta D read more

We came in when it was not very busy, the pizza was ok not bad, but the wait time is kind of long about 50mins to an hour, if you are in a rush then this isnt the place for you read more

Rustica - Pizza Near Me - Fajardo, Puerto Rico

Food was great The service was great The waitress was super nice and friendly This is a hidden gem place read more

Rustica - I have traveled around the world and I must say this is one of the best places I've been - Pizza Near Me - Fajardo, Puerto Rico

We visited Rustica on the recommendation of a couple we met at dinner one night during our stay in Puerto Rico. They didn't steer us wrong. The pizza was excellent! Crust had the perfect chew and was perfectly cooked. The toppings on the veggie pizza were just right. Our server was friendly and efficient. Go here if you need a pizza fix while in Puerto Rico! read more

Great food, great value, great service. The pizza and wings are fire !! Will be going back for a second time this weekend. read more

See all

We went this evening for the first time and loved the pizza! We had the "Grandma " which had all frsh ingredients and the thin crust was wonderful. We also had the lemonade which tasted fresh squeezed. Great pizza place for sure! read more

3.5 stars. The pizza's here solid. I came early on a weekday, before they opened and didn't have a problem getting a seat, but you should make a reservation just in case. Their bread is pretty good but they don't sell the loaves. I got some of their homemade butter and finished the leftover crusts with it. Wasn't bad. read more

Rustica - Grandma's pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fajardo, Puerto Rico

See all

Our first visit to PR and ordered delivery from Rustica. We ordered two medium pizzas with sausage, pepperoni, onion, green peppers (mushrooms on one) and the order showed up in about 20 minutes, piping hot and absolutely delicious. I would put their pizza up against any I've had, anywhere. Great job Rustica! read more

Delicious NY style pizza, great cocktails, and friendly staff. Glad we went out of the way to Rustica!

Awesome pizza! I'm not talking about out by PR, I've had NY Pizza in the big apple and this compares. Fresh crust and toppings. Waiter was hopping also so service excellent. read more

Great dinner last night. The service was fantastic. The meatballs were the best I've ever had. Not an overly "tourist" place which was nice. Felt like lots of locals just having a pizza and a beer. Salads large enough to share. I would defiantly go back again! read more

The best everything! The pizza is amazing, the drinks are unique and delicious, and the wings are the best I've ever had. We make a point to visit Rustica every time we are in Fajardo. read more

If you're in the area and you like pizza, this is the place to go. I'm from the area and yesterday was my first time visiting the place. I love the rustic feel and the decoration, the customer service was great. I had the wings and an appetizer, they were good and not greasy. This is one of the best pizzas I've had, it wasn't greasy, not to much sauce and the bread was amazing. THE BREAD, will compete with any NY or Chicago pizza. They've been there for 9 years and I can't believe I've waited so long to try them. Do yourself a favor and make sure before you leave, you have the pizza. Note, they are very specific about the payment they receive. I recommend that you bring cash. They do not accept cards. (Cash and ATH móvil) read more

See all

Hands down the best pizza we've ever had. Our group of 7 had 3 different kinds of pizza and they were all incredible. Great service, great atmosphere and even better food! 10/10! read more

Amazing! I never liked NY style pizza but this was incredible. Ordered the Veggie and was a little hesitant the veggies weren't cooked more, but wow it had amazing flavor. SO ordered the meatball and said it was the most amazing meatballs he ever had! read more

Rustica - Veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fajardo, Puerto Rico

A great pizza place in Fajardo! Definitely try the Pear Salad with a delicious dressing. We always have a mushroom and sausage pizza that we always finish and unfortunately never have left overs to take home. We always finish with Zeppolies with homemade ice cream of the day. Order it early it goes quickly. I understand the Wings are fantastic, but have yet to try them. Unfortunately Cash Only is a bummer but there is an ATM next door. Another bummer is no liquor sold on premises so bring your own drinks read more

Rustica - Zeppolies for dessert! - Pizza Near Me - Fajardo, Puerto Rico

Food. Service and ambiance was amazing.?Authentic NY style pizza and breeds. It's a real taste of Brooklyn

Primera vez que voy este weekend con mi pareja y unas amistades a comer... cuando llegamos nos dejaron pasar a las mesas... nos atiende una muchacha.... pedimos la orden de pizza y bebidas.... luego llega otra mesera y nos comienza hablar en ingles.. luego una de las amistades pide una ronda de bebidas y no nos la quisieron vender, supuestamente porque pasamos un vaso vacio el cual se llenaba con las bebidas que se le pedian haciamos consumo del mismo... en ningun momento desde que llegamos nos dijeron que no se permitian otros vasos... luego la mesera nos comenzo a tratar mal... Pagamos y nos retiramos... Es una pena que con las actitudes de sus empleados pierdan clientela.... primera y ultima vez que voy.... read more

Nice place with good drinks Not expensive, pizza crust was awesome, would go again Costumer service was great too read more

We had the best spinach and pear salad ever. The roasted Asparagus with cheese and bacon was fabulous. And we enjoyed good ol pepperoni pizza. Good beer, wine, cocktails and super friendly service. It was a little loud but not a deterrent. read more

We came tonight with my family we order the drinks and the food at the same time , the first thing that came to the table was the food , the waitress barely came to the table to check if we need anything, she was occupied talking to the bartender .The pizza was good the service sucks. read more

I live in New Haven the capital of Pizza in the US. This pizza is excellent. EXcellent. The most enjoyable really handworked dough. One of my most lovely food experiences in PR. Thank you! Actually after two slices - it is the best pizza I have ever had. I would have flown in for that pizza. It is the best pizza I have ever had. Wow. Great job. I loved it. read more

OK, no idea why this is not top of the charts in Yelp for Fajardo. Simply amazing pizza and always consistent. The decor is well thought of and service on point. By far the best pizza place around. read more

Vegetarian options in Fajardo are a little tough but pizza always hits the spot. After a hike or long day at the beach, few things can compare to well made pizza. Got the cheese and one with green peppers, mushrooms and loved them. Pear salad was delicious as well. Just a reminder (I didn't know) they only take PAYPAL or CASH. read more

We retuned once again to our favorite pizza restaurant. As always the bruschetta was delicious! read more

Rustica - Inside PizzaRustics - Pizza Near Me - Fajardo, Puerto Rico

Great Pizza! I tried their pepperoni & mushroom one and it was quite good. That said, whether you're ordering to pick up or dining there, be ready to have cash, as for whatever backwards reason they only accept cash or ATH Mobil (a fact they neglected to mention when I ordered over the phone), which is seriously inconvenient and is the reason for the two stars. read more

An awesome find in Fajardo. If you're looking for true Brooklyn style slice, then this is the place to visit. Owner Marc A, former owner of Roebling Pizza, Grew up in Brooklyn and was classically trained in the art of real style pizza making. During our conversation, I learned that he also spent 3 months in Italy learning from the best chefs and used his knowledge of Italian specialties to open up Rustica. PR should be proud. I know Brooklyn definitely misses him! Ladies, hes single! read more

Rustica - The bruschetta is amazing! - Pizza Near Me - Fajardo, Puerto Rico

This place made my day! Made my travel! I am an avid pizza lover with a high taste expectancy and this location passed the test. Directly off the highway, the pizza was made with everything fresh from hand carved tomatoes in front of your own eyes! The flavor, Magnifico! The service- on point. If and when you come to PR you have to give this location a try. From the moment you walk in the aroma will have your mouth watering! The staff, sexy and professional (just keeping it real) - clean, full bar with outdoor seating. I loved the rustic feel with all this enraptured within a cement establishment with views from 3 sides of the construction! The environment in hot ass Puerto Rico was air conditioned of course set to the perfect pitch, like the music playing in the background.. It all makes ways for a great experience. read more

See all

So yummy !!!! Pizza is delicious and drinks are so good. The mojitos are to die for!!

Great pizzeria! Right on the square in Fajardo. Tried a pepperoni pizza and the Brussels Bianca...yum yum. Great mojitos...try the mango one. Very good. Clean place, good service! Must try while in Fajardo. read more

This has to be the BEST PIZZA on the island. I come from NY and therefore I am very critical of how pizza is made, but this is by far one of the best PIZZA's I have had. The entire place is amazing, the cook makes amazing food and is also the owner of this amazing place.. great atmosphere, delicious food, and the drinks are PERFECT! If you are in PR, this should be on your Puerto Rico must go to places .. I know people must say why would I go to PR for pizza, but trust me, it's worth it. My 5 year old with such enthusiasm blurted out , FINALLY A PIZZA I LOVE.. highly recommended place read more

Holy shit. Angel, keep your shorts on. No one has anything on el pescador. Sorry no appetizers available at all. But wait...the Table next to us has appetizers and salad. So we ask for salad...well you can have one but it will take a long time. We order it anyway. Mojitos are excellent. Meatloaf Parmesan was just ok. Grandma pizza was good but nothing to write home about. Did I say we live in NYC? This is not NY pizza. Paulie Gee's blows this place away!!! Don't waste your time hauling away to Fajardo for pizza. Go home for pizza. Update: changed from 1 star to 2 because the owner had the courtesy to comment politely about my review. However we were not upset about a change to the menu, we were upset due to attitude of server, attitude of bartender and attitude of man at bar eating who glanced at our table and shrugged his shoulders as if he didn't care that we came here specifically for appetizers we read about on Yelp and then were told callously that there was nothing but pizza and two sandwiches on the menu. Also, isn't it great to watch the next table eat 3 salads and a caprese appetizer while we are told sorry none for you. It was just bizarre behavior. But the place is cute. read more

Unexpected surprise! The pizzas were delicious. The wings weren't bad either and they were on the happy hour menu for $5.00. Bartender made great pina coladas! Wouldn't hesitate to go back. read more

Best pizza in the World. Brought his Brooklyn skills to Fajardo Puerto Rico. Now Fajardo has the best pizza and pizza maker. My wife and I are extremely fussy about the pizza we eat. A NYC, especially Brooklyn style is for us the best. Mark has brought the combination of ingredients, timing, oven temperature to Fajardo. He has an artisanal consistency without it being a rubber stamped corporate pizza. The crust being about 3/8 inch thick is baked with the toppings to the most flavorful toastiness yet easy to fold in the proper NYC and Napoli traditions. There is a wide selection of toppings and the amount used per pizza provide a flavorful experience that is balanced not overwhelming. Our favorite pizza is the Grandma, to which we add sausage. This is so good it is hard not to go every night. There is no obnoxious amount of oil that runs down your arm while eating. The proportions of all ingredients are such to provide the most flavorful experience of pizza. Fajardo is our 2nd home, so we come to the island several times a year. We never miss an opportunity to come to Rústica to delight in the pizza when we come here. The bartender is creative and makes great drinks. The service staff is exceptional and all speak both English and Spanish. If you like pizza this is the place! read more

Absolutely the best pizza ive ever had. Everything tasted fresh and homemade 10/10 Will definitely be back next time I'm in PR read more

Best Pizza in PR ...from an old style NY Pizza guy from Brooklyn .We are there for our pizza fix every week, more if we have company. The classics are great for purists like me: Margarita or Grandma, but drinks from the bar: think negroni, Moscow mule, or Aperol Spritz and a short but well thought out wine list makes this a go to spot to hang out. read more

Convenient was it is located at the Caribe Hilton. You pay for the conscience as food is pricey. Food was great. Had two menus, one Italian, one Puerto Rican food. Service was mediocre. read more

Such friendly folks work here - came in for a quick drink during happy hour and some bruschetta, which was incredible! Fresh basil, tomatoes, onions, parmesan, and little surprise pockets of blue cheese sprinkled with olive oil. YUM. Liquor license is out here, so they are only serving beer at the moment (maybe call before you go if you're looking for the cocktail experience). Really friendly service, I would come back if in the area. read more

I read the reviews I was skeptical being from New York. We ordered regular slices, Caesar Salad and a grandma pie and it's just as good as true NY pizza if not better. I highly recommend it! read more

Pizza was good & tasty but took over 30 minutes for them to prepare & cook. I guess that means really fresh! read more

Rustica - Menu 6-20-17 - Pizza Near Me - Fajardo, Puerto Rico

See all