Absolute best Key Lime Pie I have ever had. A friend brought it over and now I will drive from Scottsdale to get a pie from here. It really is that good!!! read more

I am so very disappointed that they did not take preorders this year. We have ordered our pies from here every year since they opened. I was NOT able to get No Sugar added pies! We have several family members with diet restrictions due to medical conditions that can't have sugar. I guess I will be finding a new place for Christmas and Thanksgiving and Easter pies. It was fun while it lasted! So very sad. read more

My family and I have tried three pie varieties since Piefection opened at the beginning of September. The blueberry, coconut cream, and banana cream. All three have been wonderfully delicious. I cant wait for the next time I have an excuse to go pick up another pie. Looking forward to trying the peach next time! read more

See all

Dropped in on Christmas Eve Day - I got there at 9am and they really do have their act together for the holiday rush. Three people at the counter, two helping in the lobby, stacks and stacks of pies waiting for happy homes. I was glad to get exactly what I wanted (no, I didn't think ahead enough to pre-order...) - can't wait to try the AZ Orange pie and various savory pies (today's special was Green Chile Beef, yum!). I have to give Piefection five stars for what I expect will be a killer pie and terrific service on a holiday! read more

Got a great perfect pie for a thanksgiving dessert - we ordered last minute the staff was super helpful and most importantly the pie was delicious! Thank you!! read more

Oct. 26, 2020 about 12pm.Came in to get a pie to do different than a ordinary birthday cake. Was super excited because my other half loves pies. Thinking it would be amazing compared to a store bought pie, boy was I wrong and super upset once we took the first bite. The crust has absolutely zero flavoring, dry and when we opened the box it was completely cracked. I almost think they mistaken it for a sugar free pie. We paid 16.00 plus tax for a pie that was uneditable I didn't realize at first the lady was a little rude until my we got into our vehicle and my son said he felt weird by her behavior. Vary VARY UPSET. A birthday celebration was completely ruined, wish we would have just got a cake. We literally threw out the pie. Waste of money! Totally not fair if I hadn't cut everyone a piece I would have took it back for sure! Instead it went to the garbage along with our money and a birthday fail! read more

Piefection - Country Apple pie - Desserts Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

See all

It was Christmas Eve at Noon. I was rushing to get all of my last minute things done. When I realized I hadn't picked up my pies. I went to another store and they were CLOSED! I raced to Piefection. I told the nice Lady in the front I had no pie! This is hard for me as I have celiac and can't eat just any pie. Cheryl the owner came out and asked me to come back right before closing. If she had a gluten free pie she would sell it to me. I came back right before closing, I was presented with a beautiful gluten free pie!!! They had made one just for me!! I was so happy, Cheryl and her team saved my Christmas with their gorgeous pie. Some companies go above and beyond, but this was far more. I appreciate they care about their customers and their special dietary needs. Thanks to everyone at Piefection!! My chocolate gluten free cream pie was more than I could've imagined. It tasted amazing! read more

My mom loves lemon meringue pie and no one else in our family does. I needed to find a good pie for her birthday so I posted on Facebook asking if anyone knew where I could find one. Many people recommended this place and I certainly understand why! Great service, pie was ready when they said it would be (when I needed it by) and the pie was a beauty! My mom LOVED it. Very, very pleased and can't wait to go back and try other pies!! read more

Piefection - Lemon meringue pie! (Holes in the top are from the birthday candles.) Very pleased. - Desserts Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

My family has always enjoyed the wonderful things made at Piefection. Their pies are to die for. During the pre-Thanksgiving pick up when there were people lined up out the door, I was impressed with the cashier, Savannah, who was pleasant, helpful and friendly during such a hectic time. read more

Had the chicken family pie tonight. It was good but way to salty! For older people this is way to high in salt!

First time I went to this place and would of given a higher rating but see vice was horrible! We waited because two employees were with two customers. One employee went to the back. No greeting coming in. We were next so the girl looked at me but said hello to the guy behind me! I said we are next. She apologized but it was super rude! We tried one of the three slices of pies and was good. Not sure to return due to the customer service! I love to promote local businesses but this one for sure I shared the service was horrible ! I'm sure I won't go back there again. I love to promote business I love. They messed up. I shared with friends the horrible service. read more

If you want the best pie in the world than go to Piefection! The coconut cream is my favorite pie. Savannah had a great welcoming smile when I came in and got my pie. read more

My go to for all pie! Homemade crust (not that Costco stuff) and delicious! Our fav is Michigan Cherry Crumble. To die for!

BANANA CREAM PIE. These pies outway any home made one I have ever tried! This thing was loaded with bananas and the filling inside was spot on. The girl Laney that helped me me was super friendly. Same with everyone else working in that store! read more

Pies are perfect! We took home a mixed berry pie and it was out of this world, my entire family enjoyed it. Will definitely go back and recommend to others. read more

Great homemade pies! Just a little pricey (4.5 stars for the price). I purchased 3 pies for $45. Love all their pies that I have had so far. They use quality ingredients. Only place that I have found that has quality pies. The strawberry rhubarb was the perfect amount of sweet and tangy. The presentation was really cute. Love the heart in the middle. We also had the banana cream pie. I love banana cream pies, so this was really amazing. This was the one I was craving for and it hit the spot. Presentation made me want to eat it more. It was like eating clouds! The last one we had was the black and white pie. DOUBLE LAYER CHOCOLATE with RUM cream. How could that not be amazing?! Definitely will go back again when I'm craving pies. read more

Tried my first pies at this pop up shop and was very disappointed. The selection was great and I was excited to have somewhere new close by, but unfortunately, they missed the mark. I ordered the chicken pot pie, a strawberry rhubarb pie and a blueberry pie. The chicken pot pie was awful. It was heavy on one flavor, that I couldn't even make out, and there was barely any chicken in it and a few canned vegetables. I didn't like their crust on any of the pies. And after all, what's a pie without a good crust. Tastes like they use lard, instead of shortening or butter, and it was just mushy and underbaked. I actually only ate the filling and threw away the crusts. Filling wasn't bad on the fruit pies, but definitely not a buttery, flaky crust. Sorry, I really wanted to like it. I wish them good luck. read more

We just happened on this place driving home from up north one day! The pies are so good. Try to catch them on pie slice day and you can try different kinds. This weekend we had the privilege of FREE PIE at the Improv club JesterZ on 3.14201592653 and we had another great experience. Thank you PieFection for always coming into our lives at the best times!!!! I would rate as a 5 but they have wacky hours so you can't just pop in whenever you have to pay attention to when they're open. read more

I wish i could give this place a decent review. They do have nice boxes and I felt the service was kind...it's just when you open that box...you realize really quick that's really all they've got going. The pies aren't that good and some were just plain bad. We've tried a few options. The French Silk consistency is like brownie batter, not firm at all, and the taste is just was too sweet and not good, even the chocolate shavings on top weren't that good. Of the 4 of us who ate this, none of us like it. The Strawberry Dream had very little strawberry on top (NOTHING like the picture). It was a about 50/50 pie filling to pie topping ratio - I could see the white of the cream cheese and it appeared a few strawberries were used as a light sprinkle on top. The taste of the cream cheese wasn't awful, but also a bit runny in comparison to similar Strawberry Dream type pies. The Arizona Orange may have been okay if the graham crust was substituted for a traditional crust, but again, not that good and hard to say if that would even help. I will say the Banana Cream was probably our favorite of the four. It was just alright. For all of the pies, the crust is very flaky and thin in spots. I expect more from a shop thats main focus is actually pies. Overall overpriced. A pie from Albertsons would be better received and less embarrassing to present to a friend if taking to as a gift. read more

The service was great. I had gone in to order the banana cream pie and they did not have any ready at that time. The gal at the front said they can make it for me in 10 minutes. I of course had 10 minutes to spare and probably waited for to be made. The flavor of the pie was good, but the pie itself did not hold up very well. It was a bit of a mushy mess even though it sat in the fridge for 4 hrs. It is a little pricey so I would not come here on a regular basis, but I would come here again for special occasions and try another pie. The pie deposit was a little surprising but I don't mind. It's a good way to recycle and support a small business. read more

Piefection - Desserts Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

See all

Went there at 8am to get a pie for the office and went in and the lady was very unhelpful and rude. Exclaimed wet not open and went out. First time in and last time in. Sad for the ownership of the company. Employees can make or break ya. read more

Best pies! Wide selection of sweet, savory, and seasonal pies. They have a wide variety online and in-store, some by the slice or whole pies. They also offer delivery and holiday pre-order pickup. save the tins, you can get discount off your next pie! read more

I have gotten many pies Cherry Peach banana cream key lime everyone has been delicious never had any complaints if I wasn't trying to lose weight I would be going there every week for new pie just like I used to do read more

The Chicken pot pies was terrible, and the Raspberry pie not good....Very disappointing......

I heard nothing but great things about this place. My husband loves pecan pie so we picked one up. The pie tasted burned, very hard to cut through it. The texture in some spots were so sticky and very hard consistency, hard to chew. It was possibly over baked. We also picked up a slice of lemon meringue and by the time I got it home it was melted in to runny mush. We had high hopes for this place. Not sure we will be back. read more

Went by for pie fix. Store is closed and construction crew at work. Still has this address on website. Closed for good? Moved?

Updated Review: I received a comment promptly back from the owner of the business apologizing for the experience. I will return to this place for many more pies in the future. In hindsight, many of the problems experienced during my visit can be contributed to it being the holiday season and the large number of people in a small area all wanting the same thing. I am willing to admit when I was wrong and will say that having drove three hours to pick up pie for the upcoming holiday and being overwhelmed by everyone's behavior in the store at the time led to a harsher review than what was deserved. Initial Review: It was my first and last visit to this establishment. Staff was rude. There is no order to this place. Just mass chaos with people cutting in front of others. I opened the case to get an Arizona Orange and a young girl came up in front of me and grabbed it. Staff said more were coming out from the truck. I was paying and asked if there was more. Told they were sold out and asked for a bag for my pies because everyone else was getting one. Lady rolled her eyes and then gave me one. Horrible experience. read more

This place is so amazing. The pie is on point. Fresh tasting, great ingredients. The store front is super clean.Great service with a smile. The girls are inviting and friendly. If you're in the area and craving something sweet and delicious; Definitely, make this a stop. read more

Piefection - What's left, soooooooo yummy! - Desserts Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

Just amazing. Best pies I've ever tasted. Period. The staff was very knowledgable of all the pies too!

Have been going to this place for the longest time, in fact I had to bring several pie tins at a time since I get that much..But just recently, I had to drive fast knowing it closes at 6:30pm ( which is early coz a lot of people working would just be coming out by then & I'm sure, they'll get more business if they close at a later time. I get there before closing to get pies for my friend's b-day that day & they tell me THEY WILL ONLY TAKE CASH coz their register is closed...with technology nowadays, who carries cash?..even food trucks have the square now for their sales...I was so Disappointed coz I've been sharing your info to a lot of people...there was another customer who was there too & wasnt able to buy pies...smh read more

Horrible service. When I got to the store there was no organization. I tried to order two slices of pie but they served 4 people, that came in after me, before me. At one point they had my two slices cut but then someone came in behind me and said she would take those two slices and they sold them to her! I felt very disrespected. Eventually they rang me out but tried to over charge me for the slices. read more

I bought two pies to try. They were the white chocolate raspberry and the strawberry rhubarb. They were too pricey in my opinion. If I'm paying 20 bucks for a pie then it needs to have mind blowing flavors and be really full of filling. The flavors were fine but not anything better then what I could make. The filling is only an inch thick in each pie. I like one that is deep and really filled up especially at that price point. The crust was soggy too. The shop itself was really cute and clean. I liked the pie boxes. They were a nice touch. I was hoping that this would be better then another pie place I tried in Mesa, but it is not. I will not come back because it's too pricey for what it is. read more

Specifically wanted to go here for my birthday as I have heard great things about it. Previously had someone get me one of the take and bake green chili pot pies which was delicious - hence, why I wanted to go. If you go here, plan for pick up and take home as it is NOT dine in friendly at all. Also, my daughter specifically asked and they do NOT offer any type of birthday special. Not the experience I had hoped for. First, there is very little seating if you want to eat there - just a couple of patio style wrought iron small tables with chairs - and one of the tables was being utilized for the BOGO free over-baked pie slices. Second, limited availability of their hot and ready savory pies - I had really hoped to try the Italian beef pot pie - but none were available. My daughter and I had the green chili pork (still great), my son-in-law the pizza pot pie (I think he was disappointed with it as he is not an olive fan and there was no description of the contents. Also I tried a bite and personally would not order it as I felt it was too "sweet" versus pizza tasting), and my husband ordered the turkey pot pie which he said was good. We then ordered a couple of pie slices - the turtle cheesecake and the Almond Joy. I was disappointed with both of these. The Almond Joy had a very strong amaretto flavor, which the posted description did not indicate. I am NOT an amaretto fan and had I known would have gone with another choice. The turtle cheesecake was disappointing in that the "homemade caramel" tasted more like butterscotch. Not sure if that was the recipe or if the caramel had been scorched, but was disappointing. At $4.50 a slice, was DEFINITELY not worth the money and a disappointment to the point I feel like I should return the money to my daughter who kindly bought them in celebration of my birthday. I suspect I will enjoy in the green chili pot pies occasionally in the future. Based on the disappointment with the pizza pot pie, not sure if I will spend the money to try the Italian beef. I may perhaps will try various slices of the fruit pies, however, I believe I am done wasting my money on the "specialty pies" as both slices we tried were disappointing, and I do not feel the descriptions were accurate. All in all I had a very enjoyable evening because of the people I was with, not necessarily because of the food we partook in. In the future, I would look elsewhere. read more

Not impressed with the quality of the pies for Thanksgiving! I bought 4 pies which cost me about $70 for our family dinner. And 3 of the pies crust looked like kids made it! What a rip off! I understand they are busy this time of year but don't sacrifice quality! It was embarrassing to serve this to guests. read more

Piefection - Not worth what we paid for and to have the pie look like this!!! Looks like a bunch of kids made it. - Desserts Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

Pies are decently good, but the service is not- they are rude for no reason. They should hire better people to be in the front that won't be rude. read more

Delicious! Drove all the way from Scottsdale and was not disappointed. Excellent pies and friendly employees.

Huge selection of pies, but I was not impressed with the caramel apple pie I bought. The filling tasted like something they might use in a high school cafeteria, what little fruit it had was very mushy and tasteless. A bake-at-home Sara Lee or Marie Callender pie would be half the price and much better. read more

We highly recommend Piefection for your holiday pies, other celebrations or just because. The Southern Pecan pie is a outstanding treat. Thanks for making these delicious pies. read more

I haven't taken a bite but I know I won't be back. BEWARE: if you order online, they will give you an order number but it doesn't necessarily mean their system accepted it or it went through. The older, blonde lady that seemed to be in charge was obviously busy but had little customer service and was snarky and asked me to pull up my bank statement immediately as her first response. She also assured me more pie was inside but it was not and she was condescending when I said I didn't see what I needed and blew me off. Bummer, wish the service could meet reputation. First and last timer at Piefection. read more

If you are looking to splurge on a really tasty treat, Piefection is a delicious choice. Our family always picks up a pie on various holidays. They have a great selection, but I have yet to try their savory pies. We have had a time or two when the apples in their pies were a little sour, but most of the time their fruit is perfect. read more