Pie Oh My specializes in 10' personal wood burnt pies. We ordered a pepperoni pie and a margarita pie with mushrooms. Their pizza is a hybrid cross between Neapolitan and traditional styles. The crust is relatively thin, soft and a bit chewy. I think our pizza may have been just a little undercooked as it didn't have any of the classic charring that you typically get from wood burning ovens. The sauce is fresh and flavorful and the toppings are top shelf. The place is take out only however there are a few tables outside that they share with the Sip n' Swirl ice cream shop next door. The staff were efficient and courteous. I almost forgot. We also ordered Jalapeno poppers which were ok, but forgettable. All in all Pie Oh My was pretty decent and a good value as well. Give it a try. read more

Leaving this review for their frozen pizzas you can buy at the West Caldwell ShopRite. They have Margarita and Mushroom pies in the frozen pizzas section. They are just as delicious oues I got hot from the Fairfield location. We probably eat 4 a week, crazy delicious!!! read more

Excellent pies, particularly the crust; small, personal size (10"); toppings very generous; cost very reasonable;storefront hours ( days) are a bit restricted; primarily uses food truck for events. read more

Rented the pizza truck for my husband's birthday and it was so easy to coordinate and work with Jed. My big wish was to park the truck on our driveway, and he made every effort while dodging our trees which I very much appreciate. Jed and his staff pumped our fresh delicious pizza from their wood burning stove. Our friends raved about every flavor topping! Super fresh and flavorful ingredients!! While we had a small group, he wasn't stingy with making the pizzas so we had several pies to keep at the end. I highly recommend for anyone looking to host a pizza truck at their event! read more

PIE OH MY - Pizza menu - Food Trucks Near Me - Fairfield, New Jersey

See all

Was attending a birthday party today with this food truck there and it was so cute! The pizza was also delicious. Some staff members were wearing masks inside the truck making the pizzas and the one serving us was wearing gloves. It was pretty amazing to see their setup though to make wood-fired pizza in a truck! The dough was deliciously chewy, which I like. My favorite was definitely the Vodka pie which was very flavorful and everything was evenly balanced. The Artichoke was basically artichoke on top of the Vodka pie. I thought the artichoke was a bit too salty. The margherita and gabagool were pretty good as well. For food truck pizza I was pretty impressed! read more

See all

I hired their pizza truck for a party and the pizza was amazing!! All my guests were raving about them all day. I chose them based on their positive reviews and I'm happy I did. I would highly recommend them for an event. read more

PIE OH MY - Pizza truck - Food Trucks Near Me - Fairfield, New Jersey

See all

We hosted a family reunion with fifty people in our yard yesterday. Pie oh my provided the food. Everyone loved everything about them and this is a predominately Italian family who all love to cook and eat good Italian, so that is a huge compliment! The staff, especially Brett, was super sweet and kept the pizza coming there was never a lull where anyone was waiting for food. The meatball sliders were apparently so good, I missed them lol but I loved the pulled pork sliders, pretzels, roasted pepper and artichoke salad, pesto pizza, vodka pizza, pepperoni pizza and margarita - yes I tried them all! Just hire them for your event you will be happy you did, as you can just relax and enjoy your party. it was easy booking, they seamlessly added on items the day before for us, although I was disappointed because I thought I added wings to my order as we wanted to try them, but that was my fault I forgot to add them we will certainly try them next time. read more

I recently was at a military sponsored party where this truck was present and we were allowed to have endless pizza. Every other truck was limited to just 1 order, but not this one !!! There were four choices of slices and they were all great !!! The people running the truck told a joke to each kid who came up to grab a slice. It was well done !! And the pizza was super good too !! read more

We hired Pie Oh My for our baby shower and they did a great job!! Great pizza and crust and kept pizza coming out really fast for our guests! Love the vintage truck! read more

PIE OH MY - Food Trucks Near Me - Fairfield, New Jersey

See all

I've had Pie Oh My twice, and it's by far the best pizza truck you can rent. The first time I had it was at a kids birthday party. Both the kids and the adults LOVED the pizza. It amazed me how quickly they managed to turn out the pizzas as well. Shortly thereafter, I had my own party and I contacted Jed. He was an absolute pleasure to work with, and so was his staff. Everyone raved about the pizza, as well as the appetizers. Some things that really stood out, aside from Jed being the kindest caterer around: -Amazing crust -Fresh ingredients -Awesome flavors. I wish I could have more of the artichoke pizza, which has a vodka sauce and of course, artichokes! I also LOVE his pesto pizza. So good!!! -The wings! They are the perfect combination of sweet and spicy. Here's the coolest part....While I can't wait to have Pie Oh My cater for me again, I can actually buy their pizza now online at thepizzagift.com. I plan on ordering some of their frozen pizzas today : ) read more

We had Pie Oh My for our backyard party, and everyone raved about the pizzas. I agree whole heartedly.

Brand new next to the Sip N Swirl. Came in after some ice cream to give it a try. Good pizza that was ready very fast. It is similar to Neapolitan style pizza which is not my favorite style but still enjoyed, otherwise would give 5 stars. Friendly service! read more

I have used this company for many of my events and I can honestly say... I never want to use anyone else! Always on time, courteous, professional, and above all delicious! The pizzas are fresh, made to order, and there are a ton of varieties. They offer catering options as well... from wings, pretzels, salads, you name it! All of the employees are very nice... never had a bad experience. It's a whole different experience to watch your pizza being made in the oven. Definitely book Pie Oh My.... you won't be disappointed. I love them so much that, yes, I even had them at my wedding! They're THAT Good!!! read more

See all

If you want to find and taste the most delicious pizzas, look no further! These pies are loaded with toppings, of your choice, and the crust is as delicious as the toppings! Very light and tasty! I've tasted their scrumptious basIl pesto bread (homemade of course) and it was devoured by my family in minutes! The bread tasted as good as it looked, and we could not stop taking just another slice until it was gone!! Their homemade ice cream birthday cakes are made exactly as you ordered and their ice cream is addictive. I love the their tiny cookie cones with your choice of flavor ice cream that is dipped into multicolored sprinkles. I love both vanilla and chocolate ice creams and can't decide which I love better! The cones sprinkled cones come totally sprinkled and they look as pretty as they taste! Their ice cream is the best our family has eaten! I can't wait to make a party and call up PIE OH MY to cater it!! The owner is really a sweetheart and extremely accommodating! read more

Originally from New Jersey I moved to California in the late 90s. Since moving out West I have non-stop craved East coast pizza. During Covid Quarantine I started seeing adds pop up on my Instagram feed from this little NJ bar making these wood fired pizzas. They looked incredibly delicious. It actually made me feel a little homesick. Much to my surprise I noticed that Pie Oh My started shipping these pizzas frozen and I just received my first order in the mail today all the way from New Jersey. Naturally I couldn't wait to break it open and heat it up It was everything I had hoped it would be. I have two more in my freezer and I'm already looking to order more. Thank you for finally creating an East coast pie for the West coast! read more

If you are looking for some of the BEST Pizza ever!!!!! Look no further!!! I had their Pesto and Pepperoni pies and OMG wow. They are personal pies about 12" and perfect for one person. Very flavorful, the dough which can really make or break a pizza was super tasty!! Best part if its wood fired pizza and it comes out super quick!!! Cant wait for them to open a brick and mortar store so I can get their pizza more frequently!!! read more

This is one of the best pizzas in the area by far. It's cooked well, delicious, and leaves you very satisfied. Everything is fresh and you taste it. The owner is a good dude and very personable. I highly recommend this place and would try anything they cook. read more

Not good bad service it just trash food found mold in the pizza the the don"t use gloves to make the food just ewww