The slices were OK. They were both overdone and not warm enough, and the crust at the end hadn't really fully risen before it was baked. I also wasn't crazy about how they gave it to me, i.e. in a box with one slice dropped on top of the other one. What really irked me, though, was that I ordered the slices and asked for a cup of tap water, and the kid behind the counter literally said to me, "we don't have tap water." Really? A restaurant where people have to wash their hands doesn't have... tap water? I think if I'm paying six bucks apiece for slices, I could get a cup of water. If they didn't have cups, they could've said that. The nonsensical lie plus the subpar slices make this a place I won't want to come back to. read more

Pie in the Sky - The crisp pepperoni was nice, but overall the slices were overdone and the thick part of the crust was dense and chewy. - Pizza Near Me - Cayucos, California

Pizza was on point! Great beer selection for a warm coastal day. Ordered a pepperoni pizza and couldn't have been happier, sourdough crust adds a unique twist, and those crispy pepperoni hit just right! Will be back next time we are in Cayucos! read more

Pie in the Sky - Salivating for sure!! - Pizza Near Me - Cayucos, California

NORTH COUNTY SAN LUIS OBISPO FINALLY HAS PIZZA! Located on Ocean Front Ave, down the street from the pier, is Pie in the Sky. This place has an order window and two tables. That's it! You, pizza and nature, how God attended it. I ordered the 16" Cheese and "16 Cayucos Margherita. First bite, felt weak in the knees, immediately thought "North County has PIZZA!" Both had great bottoms and dough. Crunch slight char on bottom, little grit and great fluff, airy, chew! The sauce was bright and fresh, you can taste the sweet Roma's! Wonderful fresh cheese. The pesto drizzle was vibrant and packed a sour, herbal punch to cut through the fat of the cheese and the dough. They were both absolutely wonderful! *Please, my fellow central coasters, pretend you're Italian when you order here, eat it at one of the tables/beach and enjoy nature and the beautiful work of art this guy is making! Fresh is the full experience!* read more

See all

Yummy pizza in front of the beach just perfect you order you wait with a view or like us we went next door to get a drink and got our pizza and enjoyed our dinner. read more

Pie in the Sky - Yummy drink - Pizza Near Me - Cayucos, California

See all

The pizza is tasty but the ingredients are sparse. It would have been a better 16 inch pizza if all of the ingredients were on a 10 inch pizza. Taste is pretty amazing but ingredients are skimpy. read more

Delicious, fresh, sourdough crust - ocean side. Sweet space, beautiful view and yummy bites.

We're local and I've been wanting to try Pie in the Sky for a while...We finally did on a recent evening, and, while we liked it, it didn't blow us away so we'll continue our quest to find the best pizza in the area. Here is what we noticed: - We went to call in an order, but we discovered that there's no phone number to call. You can only order online or by stopping by the window of the shop. They also have a fairly limited menu, and only one size of a full pizza to order. - We usually like to order half-and-half pizzas, because it enables us to try two different kinds. That wasn't possible on the website, and when I asked about it while picking up the pizza, they said they don't do that unless it would be cheese and pepperoni (in any event, their website doesn't even give you the ability to order half-half pizzas and there's no phone number to call). - I was a little surprised to find the pizza sitting in the warming bin when I arrived at the shop, even though I arrived five minutes before the time that it was projected to be ready based on the online ordering notice (since I generally like to pick up a pizza when it's just comes out of the oven). - The pizza wasn't bad, but I missed some of the gooey cheesiness that you normally get with a pizza...not sure if it's the type of cheese they used or the oil coming from the pepperoni, but it was definitely a bit different. And, I don't think it's because of the time it took to get home since we live very close by. The sourdough crust was good but a little tougher to chew than with some pizzas. Having lived in New York in the past, this is definitely NOT New York pizza (although to be fair, few places can really replicate true New York Pizza without the NYC water, etc.). Bottom line: Not terrible pizza by any means, but not a place we're clamoring to go back to, especially given the price for what you get. It is nice to have a local Cayucos pizza shop option for sure, but it might be best suited to people at the beach who want a quick slice. read more

Pie in the Sky - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cayucos, California

Easiest five-star review ever. Outstanding SOURDOUGH crust. Got the pepperoni and added sausage and mushrooms. Other pizza was Less Haters More Taters. Both excellent. Ordered online. No problems. 100% recommended. This pizza is fantastic. read more

Pie in the Sky - Tater pizza up top. Pepperoni/sausage/mushrooms below. Son doesn't like mushrooms so they were only on half the pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Cayucos, California

Dude. Big fat huge slices for $5 and $6, tremendously good sourdough crust, house made ranch is thick and perfect, sitting at a little table looking out over the beach and south toward Montana de Oro. Def coming back, def bringing my kids back read more

I love to support local biz., but...... 3rd time I have ordered this pizza ( delivery). First 2 times were 'ok', the pepperoni pizza always came loaded with pepperoni, but what I noticed was the very minimal sausage and peppers on the peppers and sausage pie, I kept thinking it was an oversight, but the 3rd time, no, this latest del. was so sparse I had to review it ( see image, there is like 1, 1/8 inch strip of green pepper across the top of a slice, nothing else on that slice), the sausage is barely noticeable. Plus the pie was not fully cooked..... As opposed to the pepperoni pie which was burnt, badly, I think there was 2 slices barely edible out of the whole pie. See images...that pepp. pizza should never had been sent, meanwhile the other part of my order wasn't cooked enough and minimal toppings, sorry but won't be back. read more

See all

It was nice to be able to buy just a slice of pizza instead of a whole pie. I might have purchased one that had been there a while because it was just okay. The service was excellent. read more

Very good pizza. Boy one person working so a bit of a wait but it was worth it. I would definitely recommend

OMG..... Seriously the best pizza, it's our new favorite "go to". It's delicious and our family of 4 finished both pizza's read more

Pie in the Sky - Margarita and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Cayucos, California

We picked up a pie to go enjoy on the beach. We got the special pizza - it was phenomenal. The veggies on it were super thinly sliced which added great flavor & texture. The goat cheese was subtle and everything felt really fresh. We added Cayucos sausage on it, which was delicious (although they could've added a little more). The ranch was delicious too - nice & thick. We liked the sourdough crust! read more

Surf vibe is alive and well at pie in the sky! Waited the 15 min then walked it to our room at the shoreline. Pizza was very good. It's a walk up and order deal. Two little metal bistro tables for those who want to devour on premises. read more

Pie in the Sky - The Crazy Bernie official home of great pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Cayucos, California

The pizza was so Burnt that we couldn't eat it. I just threw it away,So I don't know how it tastes! I was very disappointed .

Love supporting local. Walking up to the window and being told someone was ahead of me without money, not so much. Then doing it yet again after that guy ordered multiple pizzas? Definitely not. She could care less. Disappointing. Love supporting local business, but not at the expense of being there in person and being told twice to wait. read more

A tiny, but mighty pizza hole-in-the-wall. Only outside seating, but there's only two small cafe style tables. If you don't get a table, not to worry; they're ocean-front, so grab your pizza and go sit on the beach, or the pier, or just take it to go. The menu is also very, very small, but the few pizzas they do serve are really good. A definite cut above your average pizza joint. Certainly the best pizza in the Cambria and Cayucos area. They sell pizza by the slice, but I recommend the whole pie. Crispy crust with flavorful toppings all done to delight. read more

Pie in the Sky - Sweet and Spicy Pepperoni special-of-the-day pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cayucos, California

I've been waiting to try a slice at Pie in the Sky for a while. Here's the details: Ordered a pepperoni slice If you like thin-cracker style pizza this is your place. Reminds me of ordering pizza from the drive-in. It's definitely not my favorite, but I did try it once. $ bucks a slice. Friendly people inside. Location location....I'll check by in April to see if they made it. And we're walking...... read more

Pie in the Sky - Self explanatory. I think I'll hold off next time. - Pizza Near Me - Cayucos, California

Came by for a quick slice of pepperoni and it was marvelous as usual....but I'm sorry that they are not going to continue using these cool boxes for take out slices....oh well! Try the pizza here it's fantastic and take it to the Pacific Motel about a quarter mile south of the restaurant and enjoy your pizza with a beer....almost as good ambience as the beach. BYW....on Mondays locals get a 15% discount read more

Pie in the Sky - On Mondays there is a 15% discount for locals... - Pizza Near Me - Cayucos, California

See all

This pizza is the best food in San Luis Obispo County. I ordered the pizza and then watched the sunset, pizza took about 20 minutes and I kid you not it was terrific. Since then Ive exclusively only ordered from here. My favorite is the pepperoni and the cheese. The staff are super friendly and down to earth. I'm surprised this place doesn't have a cult following yet but I know that's sure to change. read more

Pie in the Sky - Pepperoni pizza & Cheese pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Cayucos, California

Ordered a Mushroom and white sauce pizza last evening. 1st time there. Pizza crust was very good. That said there were hardly any mushrooms on it. We added sausage and found a little bit on one section of the pizza. For $37 we were disappointed. We are local and love to support local business. Going to give them another go and are hoping that the skimpy toppings was just a thing that night and not the norm. read more

Wow! This was such a treat! We were about to pay for delivery for an icky chain pizza. This was soooo great. I typically make my own sourdough pizza. This hit the spot! Thank-you for the quality dinner! Plus one pizza fed myself, husband, 2 kids, and mil. Plus it was right on the beach! read more

THANK JAH FOR GOOD PIZZA BY THE PIER!!! Im something of a sticker when it comes to quality pie, and while euphemistically the name of this joint implies an unobtainable measure of yumminess, I can attest that a succulent slice is well within your reach. Get the hot honey, and what appears to be an especially ~thick~ homemade ranch to accompany yer slivers. What a godsend. I anticipate becoming a regular with ease. read more

Pie in the Sky - Classic pep - Pizza Near Me - Cayucos, California

Went to the beach to watch the sunset and got the amazing aroma of cheesy pizza and couldn't stop thinking about it so had to give it a try . Pizza was good just a bit dry . Service was ok as well although it was a very fast transaction with little to no conversation being made. I would definitely still recommend if ur ever in need of a quick bite while at cayucos ! read more

Pie in the Sky - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cayucos, California

I'm lowering my rating from 5 to 4 stars, because I showed up on a Monday afternoon and the place was closed during their posted business hours, with a handwritten sign on the window that said "Sold Out!" Probably best to call them before going there to make sure they're open and well stocked. read more

Finally got a chance to try your pizza and it was AMAZING! I LOVE the pepperoni cups! Perfectly crispy! (Get extra!) The Sourdough crust was delicious! The side of ranch must be homemade it was thick and creamy. Will definitely be back! read more

Pie in the Sky - Pepperoni & Ranch - Pizza Near Me - Cayucos, California

I dropped by for a slice at lunchtime and was very pleased. The slice was hot and fresh, and a generous size. Not greasy. $5 for lunch is a bargain these days. read more

My family recently bought pizzas from Pie in the Sky and they were great! It's in such a convenient location and it's perfect that you can order and then eat right along the beach. We ordered a second time and there was a bit of a technical issue with the online ordering but they gave us a full refund and even offered us pizza for free! The issue was really not entirely their fault (silly technology) so it was really sweet to give us the pizza for free. Part of the pizza was a new flavor combo they are trying out and it was SO GOOD! I will definitely be ordering from them again!! read more

Delicious in every way! Nice chewy crust, not too much sauce, tangy cheese! We ordered (online, for pick up option) the sausage and bell pepper pizza and there was enough for 3 people. Got a text from door dash when it was ready and grabbed it while it was still piping hot. First impression was the toppings were sparse, but then it was love at first bite! I wouldn't have changed a thing. Ready in 25 minutes (roughly) and fresh as it gets. We keep commenting on how good it was! read more

This place is pretty rad. Love that you can grab a pizza, walk across the street and soak up the ocean vibes. Locally sourced ingredients too. The mushroom and white sauce pizza was yummy. Excited to try every pie they have! read more

Pie in the Sky - Owners with sold out sign - Pizza Near Me - Cayucos, California

See all

Actually sell pizza. Ordered 5 slices and girl at register refused to sell more than four slices. We had 4 adults and a toddler in our group. We requested 3 cheese slices and 2 pepperoni and was told " I can't sell more than 4 slices for a group". No one was in line or anyone sitting out front. The place was dead while other restaurants were packed. Its obvious you can't have a proper business model by refusing to sell the very item you are marketing to the public. This place won't last. Might as well close now and let the crappy tourist kayak rental take over your place. No way the reviews are real on this place. Positive reviews must be from overly proud local snobs. read more

Honestly, such good pizza! & right across from the beach! However, the young boy that works there is so rude. But that has nothing to do with how the quality of the pizza is, so five stars. Just ignore the boy and taste the pizza! lol. It's worth it. read more

Delicious pizza and HOT! The way it's supposed be. So much better than the pizza before these new owners.

Great customer service i love the sweet girl at the front, went after kite festival in mb , been told it was new pizza and owners, loved it we got 2 pizzas mushrooms snd ehite sauce and classic pepperoni,,, congratulations to the new owners and huge improvement on the pizza love the sourdough crust, i needed yo dip it in some hot honey not sure if you offer that as a side but maybe in the future!? But all around great service and food thank you read more

The pizza and service were very good. The pizza was slightly soggy in the center and could be cooked just a bit more

We like to come on Mondays and are so thankful they are open! The pizza is really good & unique. You can tell it's carefully handcrafted. And beyond that they have the cutest logo & branding ever! Glad they are here! read more

Sourdough crust was amazing This is the third time we've tried it. Margarita pizza is great. My daughter doesn't eat meat, but we bought the little one one slice of pepperoni and that was great. read more

Best pizza place on the central coast!! You can't go wrong with a margarita pizza and the view. We ordered ahead and picked up. So convenient and delicious. read more

Paid $34 for a pepperoni pizza added mushrooms +$2. Couldn't tell that mushrooms were added at all. Good thing my wife picked up the pizza or if I had and looked at it I would've asked for my money back. The pizza was sub par at best. If that was their 100% then I feel bad for others. They weren't even busy when I ordered and picked up so there's really no excuse for the lack of quality. Enjoyment to dollar ratio is very low. The people were friendly, just ho hum, meh pizza. I wish there was a little Ceasars closer that would've been better. D- barely passing grade. read more