Pie Guys Pizzeria - Meredith, NH 71 NH-104, Meredith, NH 03253 Local pride and fresh ingredients shine bright at Pie Guys Pizzeria, owned by the passionate and talented Matthew Nichols! Growing up in Meredith, Matthew pours his heart into every pizza, using Italian-imported tomatoes, non-GMO dough, and homemade sauces that bring authentic Italian flavors to town. We tried two pies on our visit: Steak and Cheese -- Alfredo sauce, Philly shaved steak, caramelized onions, green peppers, and fresh mozzarella. Creamy and savory with every bite! Pepperoni, Ricotta & Hot Honey -- Cup & char pepperoni, ricotta, hot honey, fresh mozzarella, and homemade sauce. This one was our favorite! The sweet drizzle of hot honey paired with the crispy pepperoni and creamy ricotta was chef's kiss ‍. Absolutely delicious and super flavorful! The sauce itself is on the sweeter side -- personally, I love a crispier base, but that's just my preference! Matthew is even working on a sourdough recipe , and I'm excited to come back and try it once it's ready! Overall: 7/10 Great quality ingredients, hometown heart, and a cozy local vibe. If you love a doughier, sweeter pizza crust, you'll be in heaven! Can't wait to see how the sourdough evolves and to try more flavors in the future! read more

See all

We have ordered pizza and wings from here many times and were always satisfied. This past weekend however we ordered just wings. We paid $30 for 20 wings and when we got back to the house, we were extremely disappointed. Previously, the wings had been meaty but these were the tiniest wings we have ever seen and had barely any meat on them. We basically paid over a dollar per wing and got absolutely nothing but bones with a whole bunch of buffalo sauce on it. We go there because we've had good service and the food has been good, but they aren't the least expensive option. Hoping that this was just a fluke and not a new standard because it is not up to their previous quality. read more

We got two smalls. One cheese and one Hawaiian. Price for both was very reasonable. Flavor on the plain cheese was better than average. The Hawaiian was good but could have used just a tad bit more meat. When you have to stare at the pier to see the meat....you need a bit more. Ordering experience was average. Nothing bad nothing great. Overall we were very happy with our pies. Definitely a choice spot to try. read more

Don't usually get pizza anymore, but we were traveling and very hungry. Most toppings upset partner's tummy, so ordered a large cheese pizza. And entered a time machine. This pizza tasted just like my favorite place from circa 1975. Crust was thin but not an awful cracker. Thin layer of sauce, an even layer of cheese. All cooked to light-brown perfection. They have lots of toppings to pick from, but good to know that the base pizza itself is delicious! read more

I didn't have huge expectations when stopping here but the kids were all hungry and we had hoped to find a spot to feed them that wouldn't totally break the bank. Two Pies and Two soda's later and we spent over $50 so that didn't exactly go as planned. The pizza was pretty solid all things considered. Nothing you'd put up against NY or NJ or anything, but I was expecting it to not be very good and we were all pleasantly surprised. The rating would be higher if the cost wasn't what it was. The woman who took our order was friendly but she seemed frazzled. Only two people working, they weren't able to take delivery calls that were coming in because that would leave one person to handle register and making the food. They definitely need to bring in some staff. Pie Guys Didn't Suck, but I wouldn't rush to go back. read more

Pie Guys Pizzeria - Plain Pie - Food Delivery Services Near Me

See all

Got the pepperoni and buffalo chicken pizza along with some garlic bread. Really delicious spot! read more

Pie Guys Pizzeria - Pizza - Food Delivery Services Near Me

Excellent!!!! My friend and I were looking for a quick dinner after a day of hiking and found this great pizza place. Dough is so fresh, crust thin but generous at the edges. Great sauce and fresh toppings. Pepperoni was perfectly cupped with crispy edges, mushrooms were nice and fresh. I highly recommend this place, they're serving some terrific pizza here, go check them out! read more

Stopped in last night on my way home from Ossipee, great pizza! The gentleman at the counter was pleasant to talk with while I waited for my pizza. The young kid in the back actually saw that I was waiting, stopped what he was doing to make sure I was all set. I'll defiantly be stopping there again when I'm in the area read more

I love their gluten free pizza. Probably the best pizza I've had in the area. I like to get ground beef with ricotta or goat cheese and some kind of vegetable. I always get a Greek salad too. It's super fresh and delicious. read more

Ordered my pizza online as I have many times in the past. Got a message when I tried to check out that there was an error processing my card. Tried using another card and got the same message. Closed my browser and tried the card again, and that time it took. Went to pick up my pizza and she hands me two pizzas. I explained that I only ordered one pizza and explained my experience with their webpage. The girls response was, "Well we got two orders, do you want plates and napkins with that?" She had no interest in addressing the problem. So I left with two large pepperoni pizzas that cost me about $45 that I am supposed to consume by myself for lunch. It's okay, you got me for the extra pie.... I'll NEVER be back read more

Love it here! Best pizza in the area! We get the chicken bacon ranch and it is excellent

Delicious pizza, both full pies and by the slice. It was great to be able to stop in fo a slice for lunch. There is a great selection of specialty pizzas, such as Meat Lovers, Buffalo Chicken, Hawaiian or Chicken, Bacon Ranch. We also tried the Gluten Free Cauliflower Crust, it was delicious. They also offer salad, breadsticks and desserts. It's nice to have another delivery option in Meredith too read more

Great pizza! Very quick service! Bbq pizza was so good it was cheese and stuff piled high!! read more

$23 for a large pepperoni pizza is INSANE. I get you're in a "vacation spot", but cmon man. The world is already expensive enough. Pizza has always been the classic "cheap" meal. NOT HERE! Avoid this place if that's what you're looking for. That being said.... Arguably one of the best pepperoni pizzas I've had in NH. Perfectly cupped slices. Ample cheese. Delicious crust. On the greasier side but to be expected. 4 stars because this places prices are through the roof. But food quality is superb. read more

I placed 2 orders many months apart Each time they neglected to ask what size Pizza I wanted & made the most expensive. 2nd time, I got a lecture that it was MY FAULT for not specifying what size. How obtuse can you be to take an order for something that comes in different sizes and NOT ASK if the customer forgets to specify?? This shop is run by immature kids with no business sense. The pizza is good but overpriced. I looked at their Grek salad. Lots of lettuce and feta cheese, but I couldn't see any other vegetables. Stay away. read more

We've been here 5 times in thier first month open and had consistent wonderful food and service each time. From the perfect ratio of different cheeses to the pizza sauce made with the finest ingredients and perfect dough. The pepperoni is outrageous and my mothers fave the "Greek boy" , WHOOPIE pies, cannolis and appetizers it's all fantastic! Mostly the service and customer interaction is above par, we wish these guys the very best. read more

Pie Guys Pizzeria - Greek boy pizza - Food Delivery Services Near Me

We just bought a house in Meredith and have been looking for some good take out pizza since we came here. The pizza in this town is horrible, until Pie Guys opened. We ordered a pepperoni and cheese, mushroom and cheese, and a cheese pizza and they were delicious! Tasty crust, great toppings and good sauce. We will 100% be ordering from here again when we need takeout. read more

Pizza is ok, staff are nice. A large cheese and large half pepperoni and veggie was $53. Charged me $2.50 for each veggie they put on. Won't be back. I'd recommend heading to Rossi in New Hampton. Much better pie. read more

We have to be realistic in what we buy as food consumers. This is a pizzeria and everyone likes good pizza. I bought the 'lunch special' consisting of two cheese slices, bag of chips and a bottle of water. 12:30 PM so pretty straight forward. I was presented with two rather small slices that had obviously been sitting around for a while. There was no offer to warm them up and I didn't bother asking. I should have waited for a fresh pie but didn't have the time. My bad. Crust was a bit on the tough side. Thin. Not enough sauce (buy what was there was good quality) and not quite enough cheese. Pizza Guys, you can do better work. Quality over quantity wins the race but you 'Guy's' have to work on both. Raise your prices if need be so you don't compromise your values. I'll come back to try again and update my review and I hope that it's favorable. I'm not one of these people that consistently leaves negative reviews. read more

Pie Guys is delicious! I've stopped in quite a few times for lunch and have tried a few of their different specialty pizzas. I've been impressed with every slice I've tried! read more

Great new pizza place in town! Had lunch there yesterday and the pepperoni pizza was terrific. Lots of 'roni and cooked to perfection. Immaculate space. Friendly help. Recommended. read more

Great pizza, best in town in my opinion. Cute little shop and pizza was ready fast! Absolutely our new spot.

We were lucky enough to stumble on this place during their opening week. The pepperoni pizza was AWESOME! My daughter, who does not like pepperoni usually, devoured 2 slices. I hope we get back to the area soon. I would love to try some of the other amazing toppings. read more

Not a fan of pan pizza , but the sausage pepper and onion tasted nice. Not enough sauce. Price is a concern, pretty high for my liking. Was nice to see a new place in town that i tried. Back to guiseppis' since sub crazy as of last year only had pizza maybe on the weekend. To bad they made the best pizza in the area read more

I was happy to discover this jewel. My cheese pizza was perfect. The crust was crispy topped by a flavorful sauce and gooey cheese.

Decided to try this fairly new place when a blackout occurred in Center Harbor stopping me from ordering at Piccolo"s. VERY high prices for so so pizza. The crust was chewy. Since it's cooked on a conveyor belt, you aren't going to get a crispy crust. Topping were OK. Sauce was meh. Staff was friendly. Won't be back. read more

nice people good pizza. but prices through the roof! sorry pie guys we won't be back.

Great to have a new pizza place in Meredith New Hampshire. At the time of this writing, the on-line menu does not have pricing. I ordered a 16in Pie Guys. This is there pie with everything on it. Good Pie. Too bad the price of the pie was $40.00. I did not know the price till I got there to pick up the pie. When I realized the pie was $40 dollars, I still paid for it. I'm a good guy, did not want to be an ass, I ordered it. I live around the corner to this place and purchased from the pizza place they replaced many times over the years. To bad about pricing. I will purchase from Giuseppe's again. One last thing, the pickup up time was 1 1/2 hrs after I placed the order read more