this spot is going to be a place that no matter how many times i end up in stillwater, i'm going to check out pickleman's. my partner & i were on the move while finishing up a graduation, we wanted something quick. we came here right on time because right after our order, it started getting busy! i went with the #12 aka the smokehouse stack, the 1 of 3 pulled pork sandwiches that are on the menu. i usually go the bbq route, i switched it up as this sandwich has (housemade) chipotle ranch, pulled pork, smoke bacon, provolone cheese & lettuce. you can make the sandwich the way it is on the menu or you can jazz it up & with that being said, i added pickles & cucumbers (no onions). i got a small, which was a pretty good size, & made it a combo. the sandwich simply got the job done. i got a good amount of everything that came with the sandwich (& of course what i added). the chips on deck were kettle chips (my favorite kind of chips) & i went with the hickory bbq (there were around 4-5 different flavors to choose from). to drink, they have a strawberry lemonade that tastes like candy, not in a bad way. i'd get it over & over again. all of the employees were super nice & friendly. they had me wanting a pizza (another thing they offer) while waiting on our orders & that's something i'd want to try next visit. you can add your phone number at the register to get rewards points. on top of that, as first visit, i had a $5 discount that went towards my order from adding my number. good experience all around. read more

See all

Horrible service, the guy who owns the place was not nice with customers. Hideaway pizza is way better for the price. Would not come here

Quick bite with great prices. The place is pretty clean for a college town sandwich shop. The kids that run it were friendly. Definitely will be back sandwiches were great. read more

Pickleman's - Stillwater - Cuban - Pizza Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

See all

I ate at the Picklemans in Edmond ok and liked it so thought I would try the one in Stillwater. It did not disappoint. The staff were great. My sandwich was really good. Nicely toasted and the cheese was melted just right. I really liked this restaurant. read more

Pickleman's - Stillwater - Outside - Pizza Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

Perfect place for a hungry group after stopping by several bars. Not too crowded, plenty of seating and reasonably priced, delicious sandwiches. Quick service. And yes, the pickles are quite good as well. read more

Pickleman's - Stillwater - Are the sandwich as soon as we got it. . But here's the pickle! - Pizza Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

See all

I had a really disappointing visit to Pickle Men's. I wanted to order from their kids menu because I was looking for a smaller portion, but the staff immediately judged me and scoffed, saying the kids menu is only for 12 and under. I tried to be polite and just went along with it. Then, when I went to get a water cup, I was followed and harassed by a woman who looked very unprofessional and even told me it would cost three dollars for the water. The whole experience was uncomfortable and rude. Definitely not a place I'd recommend if you want respectful service or a relaxed atmosphere. read more

Pickleman's - Stillwater - Pizza Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

Amazing experience, staff was awesome and very friendly will be going again. The only thing better than the pickle with a staff.

This a good sandwich place. Customer service was a little less than desirable because we didn't understand the process. But overall, it was good. read more

The food here is great and full of variety. Service was very quick and efficient. Place was very clean. Has good sweet tea.

Love this place! Great options and when we want soup and sandwich it is our go to spot!

I love their sandwiches and have never been failed by them. I tried a side of Mac and cheese and it turned out to be tasting almost sour. it was one of the worst Mac and cheese bowls I've ever had from somewhere. Do not get the Mac and cheese bowls unless you want tangy and sour mac. read more

Great food and great service. Ashley was outstanding we came in with full team and she was working a catering order too. Super

This place was delicious, super friendly, and felt like we were in a high-end Deli! The bread was fabulous. Their house made pickled relish was amazing. read more

Always super helpful and delicious. Good prices for what you get and fast service. Nothing more to say, I never complain here.

New place. First time tasting pickle mans sandwiches Decent sandwich's. Small size for one, otherwise it was nice try something new. read more

See all

Two words...don't go. I got the tuna. It was bland at best. Nothing against the staff. They're doing their job. Back to the tuna. The bread is ciabatta lettuce and tomato. But it's neither sweet nor tangy. This is a student hangout. I'd prolly go if I was a student. However it's been a while since I was in college. Nothing personal against this place. Maybe the other sandwiches are great. But it's hard to screw up tuna. I'll try again if I'm in Stilly... read more

Pickleman's is so f-ing good and I definitely think the staff / food need more grace and credit but that's extremely hard to do when you say you close at 3 AM but lock your doors at 2, with no line. Then kick out people who are more than willing to probably pay double the price for a sandwich in that moment. Kinda shady and super annoying. Maybe change your hours online if you don't feel like following those practices in person. Not to mention, damn near harassing customers saying your overworked, not my issue sorry, speak to your manager. It's a job. 2 stars from me picklemans. Xoxoxoxo read more

The food was good and people were friendly. I had a pizza and the cauliflower crust wasn't bad My boyfriend had a bbq chicken sandwich and that was "pretty good" as he recalls. Was empty when we got there so all the service was fast but I'm sure it's the same way when it's busy. read more

Food is usually good but I really wanted a chicken chipotle and sandwich and they gave me chicken salad ... after I already nicely corrected them once. read more

The employee Libby was super awesome! She was super friendly and was great in helping me decide my sandwich for the night. Will be back again for the great service. read more

Such a good addition to the strip! Love getting new restaurants in Stillwater. I had pepperoni pizza and I love the thin crust! Make sure you get ranch for your pizza too! You won't regret it read more

Pickleman's - Stillwater - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

Ordered a pepperoni pizza from Pickleman's tonight and it was delicious. The delivery driver was very courteous and it arrived ahead of schedule. I will definitely order from them again. read more

Great addition to the strip in Stillwater! I was very impressed by the thin crust pizza. Very fresh and shareable with others. The Italian sandwich was also very good. The atmosphere is very fun with the ability to open the garage door windows depending on the weather. Will definitely be back! read more

Pickleman's - Stillwater - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

Solid sandwiches, but often overdressed (too much mayo etc). Staff is very friendly. Last three times I've been in, they have raw cookie dough out right by the cash register and are scooping onto a tray--super exposed to every unmasked client who came up to the register to pay. read more

Their sandwiches are absolutely bussin. But my only concern is how clean the place is along with their soda machine, other than that the place would be 5 stars. read more

Ordered the southwest salad to go. Got home and opened it and the lettuce and spinach was rotten. The entire salad was slimy and stunk. I can deal with a few pieces and pick it out, but this wasn't even safe for consumption. On top of that, the avocado was not ripe and the skin to the pit was included in my salad. I drove back to ask if I could be refunded. After showing the worker my salad he was very rude and didn't see a problem with it. After receiving a refund he told me to take it with me when I left, after I asked if he could throw it away for me. read more

Pickleman's - Stillwater - Southwest Salad - Pizza Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

I used to love going to pickleman's because they're open late and their sandwiches generally taste good. I don't think I'm going to go back anymore. It's happened 2 times now where I've ordered a sandwich online and had custom add ons like adding pickles, spinach, etc. and they've forgotten to put on not only the add ons but also what comes originally on the sandwich. So, instead of getting a full sandwich like I ordered I got a sandwich with half of what originally comes on it and half of the add ons I chose. Usually I would give the workers a pass as I worked countless fast food jobs, but like I said it's happened twice and both times the restaurant was dead with nearly no one in there. read more

I love picklemans! Their sandwiches are always good and customizable. They have a good choice of soup/salad and pizza as well. I usually get mine delivered and I've never been disappointed in quality. I don't have a picture because I ate my sandwich to fast. read more

Agreed w Yelper Michael F. Decent sandwiches but overpriced. Their whole sandwich is a regular 6-inch sandwich at an average of $10 while their half - u do the math - 3 inch sandwich at an average of $7, depending on what kind u get. After paying almost $30 for 2 half sandwiches & a whole sandwich, we came home racking thru the pantry for more food. read more

In all reality, the food is good but overpriced especially considering the size of the sandwiches and of the pizzas. I will say, their chocolate chip cookies are among some of the best I've had from fast food/restaurants. Definitely better than Insomnia down the street, believe it or not. read more

Got the Italian sub. It was probably the best sub in town, but small especially for the price.

I was very excited to try this new addition to Stillwater, and so far, the food has not disappointed me. The pepperoni pizza is my favorite so far. But, never go on game day. The restaurant with 10+ employees behind and around the counter was not welcoming at all, and with less customers than there were employees there was a lot of standing around and mouthing off. The cashier mumbled my total and broke change for a larger bill than necessary after I tried to correct the amount given to her. I'm extremely disappointed. To top it off, they charged automatic gratuity (which they did not earn with that service) just for it being game day. read more

From Oct 25- They still seem to be in training. There had to be 10 people standing in the prep line. The ones who knew what they were doing were surly. No one smiled or acted glad to have customers or to be there. Those in training looked afraid and uncertain. The smell of burning food lingered in our clothing. Salad was great. Had half an Italian. It had lots of meat and veggies. And the price was right at $5.79. My husband had the Italian sub. He thought the sandwich was tasty, but pretty small- not a good deal for $7.29. They just about refused to put any veggies on it. He told them no tomato and asked for extra onion and the woman put one single round on it. It was very drippy but not soggy. I don't recommend the 'pick 2 combo'. The price is figured by upcharging the price of the 2 items you select. A half salad and half a meatball sub (no more than 3 inches long) was $10.40. If you want a combo go to McAlisters. They'll give you more food, better quality for a couple dollars less. Finally, hard to believe but a restaurant with the word pickles in the name charges almost $2 for a whole pickle. read more

Their staff was amazing and very friendly. The food was really good! Also, my friend forgot to mention she was lactose intolerant, so they were kind enough to remake the sandwich. I highly recommend trying this place. read more

Great food. Fast delivery. They really know how to make a meatball sub! I would highly recommend them!

Not open hours they claim they Are open. Hours they claim they are open is Wednesday-Saturday from 11am-3am. But last night, Wednesday, around 1 am they were closed. My friends and I were extremely looking forward to slamming some pizza extremely intoxicated but we had to settle for curty across the street. Sad! read more

Using the website for ordering was so easy. I was able to place the order within 5 minutes and then they had it ready when I arrived. Will definitely do this again read more

Large selection and good food. Wait was a little long but all new staff and improved on our second visit.

Yummy grilled cheese!! Like really cheesy goodness and tomato soup combo hit the spot. Cookies are the closest to homemade taste no weird after taste. read more

I love this place! It is great on the strip as it's just casual, easy and delicious. They deliver so late at night. They have a variety of food so there is always something read more