Pickleman&#x27;s - Stillwater

I travel for work and I'm frequently looking for a place to stop for lunch. I am so glad that I…read morechose this little spot to stop at! Not only was the food delicious, but everyone was so warm and inviting. It's not something you'd expect in a college town, but was so well received! I had the BLT and chips, and all those simple it was so yummy! I will definitely be back to visit red rock next time I'm in Stillwater!

Everything...food, people, atmosphere...mediocre. McAlesters is way better. Although I did not try…read moreany of their desserts which all looked fabulous.

Avocado toast sans bacon

Wet donuts on bottom

See all

The other half of my delicious sandwich.

Persimmon Hill Farm And Bakery

4.4(10 reviews)

0.5 mi

While I can't eat anything here due to allergies, my family loves their baked goods. (We've not…read moretried the "non-desserts.") My son thinks they make the "best brownies ever", and judging from their smell and appearance, he's likely right. Meanwhile, my daughter's favorite dessert is macarons, and Persimmon Hill can compete with the best she's had. My husband recently tried a strawberry puff something (looked like a picture) and said it was amazing. We've always had good experiences with the staff as well; they're kind and helpful each visit.

The food and staff were incredible! They bake everything in-house, which is a huge plus. Greeted by…read morefriendly staff and so many delicious looking desserts - I ordered their macaroons and Mexican wedding cookies. They were absolutely scrumptious! This place is definitely worth checking out!

Pumpkin Season!

See all

Jersey Mike's Subs

3.8(15 reviews)

1.8 mi

I had a Mikes Famous Philly at the Team Costello Store in Stillwater last week the service and…read moresandwich were great! New owner and management in the last 10 days. Highly Recommended.

Food was good and the other employees were really nice, but one of the girl employees was really…read morerude.

See all

The Original Hideaway

3.9(255 reviews)

0.2 mi

Locally owned & operated

Family-owned & operated

Pickup order. Phones were always busy, but once i reached them, process was great…read morePickup was on time, quick and easy Pizza was not up to usual high standards. Crust was much thicker than normal. Ingredients were tasty and fresh. Quality control needs to improve. Perhaps the summer staff is just not as skilled.

This is a must visit place when you're in Stillwater! This…read moreHideaway is amazing! The inside has a great ambiance to it. It's neatly decorated and very clean. The bathrooms are very clean too! They also had some fun music playing the in the bathroom. The service here was great! All of the employees here were very kind and helpful. It was super funny to watch them yell "Corner!" every time they turned a corner. The food here was amazing! I really enjoyed their pizza and my friend enjoyed his pasta. The sausage pizza is especially amazing here! Also, their garlic bread was pretty good. Overall, great restaurant and I highly recommend trying It!

Homemade Cookie Cheesecake

See all

McAlister's Deli

3.3(46 reviews)

0.9 mi

This place is outstanding in customer service. The food was fresh. The restaurant was clean and the…read moremusic was a great choice as well. Harley our waitress did a fabulous job. We will definitely becoming back. I forgot to mention I accidentally selected drive thru and we went in and they switched it to dine and it is just excellent service.

Really enjoyed the meal it was quick and a good value and the staff was really nice…read more It was really clean and smelled good

See all

Nikki's Greek

4.3(67 reviews)

1.4 mi

I wanted a light and simple lunch and I saw this place and had to try it. This was a really small…read morefamily run business. They had a great authentic menu. The service was fast and friendly. The gyro was nothing special but good it was a normal gyro. And I also had the dolma which was really good too. I would go back.

Solid little place. The pita points and hummus was amazing. Loved the atmosphere and service. It's…read morebeen a long time since I was able to get a great Greek Keftedes. Worth a visit.

Hummus and pita bread.

See all

Schlotzsky's

2.9(20 reviews)

1.1 mi

This chain has been around for I don't know how long and I finally tried one of their locations! I…read moremean, it's a sandwich shop. There are sandwiches and chips and cookies. It was delicious. Some people might think the price is a bit high, but I think it's decent relative to inflation. The customer service was fantastic. The art inside is really cool.

I love Schlotzsky's! I crave their salads. We came into town to meet with family and were told to…read morepick up our lunches on the way. We tried to order online, and they had a deal for free drinks and chips with an entree, but it wasn't working at online checkout. On a Sunday for lunch, the drive-through was really busy, so we chose to order inside. Parking was plentiful. Olivia kindly took our order and answered questions well. I ordered their chicken-avocado cobb salad with honey mustard and my husband ordered their French Dip. The wait wasn't too long and their drinks were self-serve. Olivia helped us get our meal deal which saved us $4. The food was so good! The salad was fresh and very yummy. French Dip was warm and very juicy. We will always be back!

See all

Coney Island

2.9(44 reviews)

0.0 mi

This place is great! There was only one employee when we went, but still our food came out quick…read moreand delicious. The price was great and we were able to get a good large meal for very cheap. All in all, the food is delicious, the employee was clean, helpful and friendly. 10/10 would recommend.

I'm not sure what I was expecting by going to a hot dog place, but since Coney Island is supposedly…read morea staple on the strip I figured maybe I'd be pleasantly surprised. Big mistake. The hot dogs came out barely warm and embarrassingly small. The chili was thin and watery, like it had been strained through a mop bucket, and the cheese tasted like it should have been thrown out days ago. For over ten bucks, I got two sad little hot dogs and a pile of mystery meat slop. You'd honestly get a better, more filling meal for a fraction of the price by grabbing whatever's been sitting on the rollers at a gas station. At least those have some substance. Service wasn't any better, just one guy watching videos on his phone until someone walked in, then tossing the order on the counter like he was doing me a favor. No effort, no care, no reason to ever come back. The only way Coney Island is worth it is if you're so drunk you can't taste a thing and your vision and judgment are so blurred you don't realize what you're spending. Ohhhh... now it makes sense why it's on the strip.

Storm Cellar now Open Full Service Bar behind Coney over looking the Strip

Stillwater Tradition for 50 years with New and Updated Style

See all

Best Fried Onion Cheeseburger in Stillwater

Himalayan Grocery Store

4.3(26 reviews)

0.6 mi

This hole in the wall was recommended by our campus tour guide. The restaurant is located in the…read moreback of the grocery store. The teen that works the counter is nice. The adults who own/work at the restaurant do not speak English. The service is a bit lacking and when we were done, we couldn't find anyone. We also had left over food but they didn't have lids that fit their containers. It was a bit frustrating. One male worker was trying to close the lid on my container and his hand slipped a bit and his finger went into my left overs. The food, however, was delicious so I'm torn as to whether or not I'd return there. The portions were generous. We didn't order the cream cheese garlic naan (we ordered regular garlic naan) and didn't realize they had this on their menu until we tasted it. We thought it was their unique naan. When we looked at the menu again we realized the young girl had just written our order wrong. It tasted fine but not something we will likely order again.

Who knew Stillwater had authentic Himalayan/ Nepalese food?…read more Yes to their chicken momos, butter chicken, mango chicken, kormas, biryanis, and naan. A tad pricey but worth it for the cost benefit, for sure. Biryani portions are large. Everything is as flavorful as you want it to be. The spices and aromatics are *on fire*! One of my go to places when I don't feel like cooking at home but still want something warm, comforting, and delicious.

8. CHICKEN KORMA and chicken tikka masala

HIMALAYAN LAMB SPECIAL

See all

7.CHICKEN MANGO

Hatch Early Mood Food

4.3(104 reviews)

0.8 mi

They have good food here, and some unusual choices too: never had a Breakfast Cuban before! (Note…read moreto self: go more conventional next time.) Our server did a great job, even refilling our drinks after we'd paid, which is unusual. I wouldn't hesitate to go back.

Absolutely fantastic brunch! Service slightly below par (sleepy college student had to be prompted…read morea few times to remind him that we needed silverware, but as expected in a college town). Food was all around fantastic, and the atmosphere is lively. Full bar menu to accompany the home cooked food... everything you want in brunch is here.

Window seats

Steak and Eggs Benedict with lightly dressed arugula and hashbrown tumblers

See all

Baby Kale Cobb (no egg)

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Steve R.

0

7

0

3 years ago

Great sandwiches. Very friendly and prompt service. My go to is the BLTC with onions!

Lauren W.

0

5

0

1 year ago

Great options for all types of sandwiches and wonderful service is always appreciated.

Marche A.

0

1

0

5 years ago

Service was amazing. knocked my pickle right off!

Pickleman's - Stillwater - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Stillwater, Oklahoma Desserts near Pickleman's - Stillwater

BEST of Stillwater, Oklahoma Restaurants near Pickleman's - Stillwater

BEST of Stillwater, Oklahoma Things to Do near Pickleman's - Stillwater

BEST of Stillwater, Oklahoma Coffee near Pickleman's - Stillwater

BEST of Stillwater, Oklahoma Parking near Pickleman's - Stillwater

BEST of Stillwater, Oklahoma Breakfast near Pickleman's - Stillwater

BEST of Stillwater, Oklahoma Shopping near Pickleman's - Stillwater

BEST of Stillwater, Oklahoma Dinner near Pickleman's - Stillwater

BEST of Stillwater, Oklahoma Movie Theatre near Pickleman's - Stillwater

BEST of Stillwater, Oklahoma Burgers near Pickleman's - Stillwater

People found Pickleman's - Stillwater by searching for…

Best of Stillwater

Things to do in Stillwater

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Pickleman's - Stillwater also viewed

The Original Hideaway

3.9

(255 reviews)

Pickup order. Phones were always busy, but once i reached them, process was great…read morePickup was on time, quick and easy Pizza was not up to usual high standards. Crust was much thicker than normal. Ingredients were tasty and fresh. Quality control needs to improve. Perhaps the summer staff is just not as skilled.

This is a must visit place when you're in Stillwater! This…read moreHideaway is amazing! The inside has a great ambiance to it. It's neatly decorated and very clean. The bathrooms are very clean too! They also had some fun music playing the in the bathroom. The service here was great! All of the employees here were very kind and helpful. It was super funny to watch them yell "Corner!" every time they turned a corner. The food here was amazing! I really enjoyed their pizza and my friend enjoyed his pasta. The sausage pizza is especially amazing here! Also, their garlic bread was pretty good. Overall, great restaurant and I highly recommend trying It!

Empire Slice House

4.2

(30 reviews)

Took order to go and the young lady that served us first time visitors was professional as she…read moreexplained that when you order pizza by the slice you cannot customize it (whatever toppings are on menu is what you will receive; however, it does not stop you from ordering toppings on the side. The pizza is just the way I like it prepared, soft, just enough crunch crust, liberal toppings just enough sauce and cheese. Additional 2 pepperoni pizza slices not pictured. They have plenty of seating indoor, covered patio and outside at tables on the lawn. You can also order from the silver food truck outside. What a nice touch! Would definitely come back!

I love this place! Great pizza, clean and diverse facility and staff. The only thing that was…read moredisappointing was they only serve a select few toppings depending on what day of the week you go.

Shortcakes Diner

3.6

(80 reviews)

I decided to wade through the, what I know now to be BS one star reviews, and see for myself…read moreShortcakes. What I found at 6:30 this morning was a smiling greeting to a wonderfully smelling classic worn tables diner. Food (chicken fried steak breakfast) was great. Service was great. Company was great (a couple of regulars included me in their conversation about beautiful sunrises). I'm not sure how it could have been better. 5 stars feels thin.

As I write this, I an sitting in the parking lot of Shortcakes Diner. Is it good? No idea. You see,…read moreI just walked in and sat at tbe counter. Before I could even take a look at the menu, this is what I saw... One of the ladies behind the counter was lifting a waffle off of the waffle iron. Apparently its far too much trouble to use a utensil, or even put a glove on her hand. She just lifted the waffle and put it on tbe plate, bare handed. If she does that in full view of the customers, can you imagine what happens in the kitchen? I'm not someone who is germaphobic, but come on! I just got up and walked out. Save yourself the trouble...don't go in.

Homestead Family Restaurant

4.3

(27 reviews)

Everything was pretty good except that frickin gravy. My God what is that stuff. A cup of…read moreflavorless white paste. I ordered sausage gravy. It had a table spoon of crumpled sausage floating on top. It was too bad to be a mix. Someone purposely created this sinister concoction. I loaded it with copious amounts of salt, black pepper and Cholula. Nothing helped. The flavors were absorbed, vanishing into the white abyss. So, just don't order the cream gravy. The rest of the breakfast was decent. This is an Oklahoma oilfield town diner. A working man's café. Apparently, it has been in operation for a number of years, judging from the volume of reviews. Some good some bad. The service seemed a little slow and disorganized. Overall, I rate it as a very average 4-star diner. Pictures of the meals look very good. But it didn't make the cut for me. Before you go, call ahead and ask about the gravy........

Service was great and the food came out fast. The diner was very clean inside. The southwest…read morehashbrowns were the BEST I've ever had. Will definitely be back when I pass through again.

Nikki's Greek

4.3

(67 reviews)

I wanted a light and simple lunch and I saw this place and had to try it. This was a really small…read morefamily run business. They had a great authentic menu. The service was fast and friendly. The gyro was nothing special but good it was a normal gyro. And I also had the dolma which was really good too. I would go back.

Solid little place. The pita points and hummus was amazing. Loved the atmosphere and service. It's…read morebeen a long time since I was able to get a great Greek Keftedes. Worth a visit.

Sandwich Planet

4.8

(20 reviews)

My family and I tried this place because we were told they have some amazing Greek food. And I love…read morea good gyro. It's a tiny unassuming restaurant with 4 tables that's apart of the Cowboy Gas station on Perkins. It's near Trax and next door to the Neighborhood Walmart. The person that greeted us - which I'm assuming was the owner was very friendly and welcoming. We took a look at the menu, which offers gyros, shawarma sandwiches, burgers and other items. As well as Egyptian food. The owner brought over a complementary plate of koshari (it has lentils, macaroni, rice and onions) plus a vinegar based sauce called dakka (this is spicier than you'd think! But very good!) as well as a tomato based sauce with chickpeas. It was delicious! He said this was a special for the day. He also gave us some homemade baklava as well! My husband specifically said it was delicious, and he said he's had it before but wasn't really impressed. He said this was a cut above the rest! My husband and I both order their half order of a gyro and fries. It was still massive! And then my oldest had a crispy chicken sandwich on ciabatta. He said it was very fresh and the bread was nice and toasty warm. We're not sure what the seasoning is on the fries but they were good! And last my youngest had a Philly cheesesteak also on ciabatta with fries. He said his was also good! The owner was incredibly generous by also sending us home with a massive serving of the koshari, and the accompanying sauces. I was surprised to say the least! We would totally go back and definitely recommend! Try it all you'll be very surprised with the food. And eat in you never know what you're going to be able to try.

The food is as good as the people! Had a gyro basket and a humus plate and I will be back soon. The…read moreowners were so kind. Great addition to Stillwater!

Ranch Burger

4.2

(13 reviews)

This place was a very pleasant surprise. We all ordered cheese burgers with fries and tater tots…read more Was one of the best cheeseburgers and tater tots I've ever had. A lot of sitting inside and very clean. Service was also excellent. Will definitely be back. Loved it!

Great burgers for a good price. Burgers are an 8.7 in my book very high score. Fries and sides are…read moregood to go! Good service and friendly.

Vintage Steakhouse

4.1

(40 reviews)

Imagine owning a business where you allegedly pay all of your staff under the table so you can…read moreallegedly avoid paying federal taxes, but on top of that, you allegedly don't allow them to clock in/out and you don't allow them access to see or count or question the tips collected daily because you allegedly pool their tips and then YOU tell THEM what they made at the end of each shift. Imagine these servers being college students and single mothers. Also imagine that each one of these servers is on to your alleged theft and deception and they collectively decide they've had enough of you stealing the money THEY earned while you're allegedly putting in a beautiful, brand new pool at your home. Then imagine they allegedly start keeping their own numbers and accounting for their earnings which allegedly do not match up with your VENMO payout each day. Imagine one of them is my 21 year old daughter, who is a college senior and allegedly rallies the entire staff to stand up for themselves and finally question you. Then imagine in the meeting that allegedly every single word was recorded, YOU FIRE HER, after allegedly cussing her out, and refuse to show her, or any of them, your accounting. That's such a wild concept to me! You fired a 21 year old who questioned her earnings because you knew you were caught, Brittany Rupp. As for dining at The Vintage Steakhouse in Morrison, OK, (where the FB reviews are turned off ) I would strongly discourage you from spending your money there.

If you are not Local Do not Bother Eating Here!!!! I have eaten at 10,000 plus restaurants Extreme…read moreHigh end to Lovely lowly hole in the walls. This place does not even great you but Loves To Slam everything on the table. Hate is what you feel when the waitress is near. Place is a Chaotic Mess to watch. Reservation is required and ours was listed for our 27th Anniversary. We have had 26 better meals starting at Waffle House when I was Army Infantry and what we could afford. Arrived 10 minutes early took 20 to be seated by the Bartender no Hostess. Thank god you are forced to have reservations for Dinner. 45 minutes later after we got seated we flagged down the Bartender Hostess to take our order. Our waitress Stacy never came to our table she has 4 in a row and would skip us Everytime! Seems you need to be a Local to eat here or even get service. FOOD: Appetizer 4 star Hand Breaded Mushrooms Very well seasoned fried well slightly soggy 4 stars Wife and I had ordered identical meals 16 oz Ribeye Med-Rare House salad and Loaded baked Potatoes. SALAD Lettuce is old rotten. RIBEYE STEAKS: Wife's is the picture. Medium Burnt to Hell on the outside. She is ok with it. I hate burnt food. It should have never left the kitchen but it was more tender than my medium rare. The statement on the menu is Center cut Steaks. My wife's was a center cut mine an end chunk. Low Quality Beef. Wife's 2 star mine a 1 star Torched as Hell steak. Would have complained but with no management or waitress who do you even talk to. My Honest opinion if you give this above 3 Stars you are Just used to Crap Food and Service and You don't know any better. $200 of pure Sh@$!!! Overall 1 star. Worst of 27 Anniversary Meals.

La Carreta Mexican Bar and Grill

3.8

(6 reviews)

The service here was excellent. Everyone we interacted with was friendly, attentive, and welcoming…read morewithout hovering too much. The menu also deserves credit because there was a huge variety of options, enough that just about anyone could find something they'd enjoy, and the prices were very reasonable for the portion sizes and atmosphere. Speaking of atmosphere, the interior was stunning. Bright, colorful, and beautifully designed in a way that almost felt like dining inside a Mexican cathedral. It had warmth and personality without feeling tacky or overdone. You can tell a lot of care went into creating the space. Which makes the actual food situation even more disappointing. The food itself was not bad in terms of quality or preparation. Underneath everything, there were good flavors there. The problem was the salt. Nearly everything we ordered was so aggressively oversalted that it became difficult to enjoy after a few bites. I'm not usually sensitive to sodium, but it actually caused a mild dermatological reaction for me afterward, and my girlfriend could not even finish half of her meal because it was simply too much. It is honestly a shame because almost every other part of the experience was great. If the kitchen could rein in the salt levels, this place would be a great spot for after a movie. Unfortunately, as it stands now, we will not be returning.

Great food and such friendly service! Very thin crispy homemade chips with tasty salsa and…read moreexcellent queso! Definitely will be making this a regular stop in Stillwater! Great ambiance and super clean!

Happy Buddha

4.2

(37 reviews)