This place is great! There was only one employee when we went, but still our food came out quick and delicious. The price was great and we were able to get a good large meal for very cheap. All in all, the food is delicious, the employee was clean, helpful and friendly. 10/10 would recommend. read more

I'm not sure what I was expecting by going to a hot dog place, but since Coney Island is supposedly a staple on the strip I figured maybe I'd be pleasantly surprised. Big mistake. The hot dogs came out barely warm and embarrassingly small. The chili was thin and watery, like it had been strained through a mop bucket, and the cheese tasted like it should have been thrown out days ago. For over ten bucks, I got two sad little hot dogs and a pile of mystery meat slop. You'd honestly get a better, more filling meal for a fraction of the price by grabbing whatever's been sitting on the rollers at a gas station. At least those have some substance. Service wasn't any better, just one guy watching videos on his phone until someone walked in, then tossing the order on the counter like he was doing me a favor. No effort, no care, no reason to ever come back. The only way Coney Island is worth it is if you're so drunk you can't taste a thing and your vision and judgment are so blurred you don't realize what you're spending. Ohhhh... now it makes sense why it's on the strip. read more

Bring back the hot dogs, buns & cheese that made this business famous. The stuff you use now is horrible. Back in the 70s to 90's it was awesome & was a mandatory stop every we came to Stillwater. read more

Bad service, worker saw us coming in and said he was headed to break and didnt say anything else, felt disrespected and I'm hungry

THE WORST SERVICE IN STILLWATER. My friends and I were at coney bar and they announced last call for drinks, we got some and less than five minutes later an employee approached us and started yelling at us to "get the f*** out!". They still had 30 mins till they closed according to the hours on the website. I wish I was exaggerating but this place is a joke. Do not go to coney bar unless you want to be berated by the staff. Absolutely horrible experience. read more

Great experience! Place was dead upon arrival but I was surprised to be treated with great service and great food

Dang. This was bad. I was looking forward to a true dog but woof!! This was not good. Runny chili, questionable dog, plain cheese. The only thing good was the bun. My wife got a grilled cheese and it was flat, slightly burnt with little cheese left. I found myself craving a Sonic chili dog instead and that's not good. read more

awful management got yelled at at 1:30 to get out and got attacked. do not go! they said we should go to a "real bar " if we wanted to be treated good read more

Been awhile since I came in and was really looking forward to it. Very disappointed and shocked at the prices. Burger, couple dogs, couple fries and a drink was over $33! Food wasn't even that good. read more

Once again terrible service. I just wanted a simple snack for my girlfriend and i and they left me sitting there for 45 minutes. They stacked our food so the cheese from the bottom stuck to the boats of the top and they refused me sauce when I asked for anything other than cheese! read more

What happened to you, oh beloved Coney Island? Cheese fries used to be da bomb but not anymore. They were just flat out gross. The Reuben dog was even different than it used to be. Sad to say, considering I'm moving, that was the last time to eat there and it would have been nice to leave with good memories instead of an upset stomach. read more

Haven't been here sober not gonna lie. Great drunk food. I could bathe in their ranch. Awesome prices. They decent remodeled and it's way more equipped for the bar crowds. Super yummy and great student budget friendly prices. Everyone knows it's between this and curty after a night on the strip read more

Visited on: August 3 2012, July 3 2013 Like most places on The Strip, this place feels old, run-down, and dirty inside. I've had the Fries, Chili Fries, and the Chili Coney (no cheese, no mustard). The fries are good, but the chili is pretty weak, and the coney was whatever. read more

Coney Island - Chili Coney and Fries - Hot Dogs Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

See all

had to wait 40+ mins to eat and still waiting, had to go to a performance and needed to eat, they walked out too to go eat. and waited so they could watch a basketball game. not good read more

Me and my buddies has an event to get to. We go to Coney Island it takes them 40 minutes to get the order done. By then we are late and have to leave with no food. Do not go here unless you are willing to wait 40 minutes for some french fries. read more

Honestly love the food but after 4 years here went to the bar and got a tequila shot well for 10$ will literally never come back here after that and the not so great service. If you want to come here to get a drink I would recommend everything else on the strip before this. Might as well walk 10 yards down the street and get 5 shots for the same price and one of these overpriced drinks. Will not come back and cannot recommend enough to not come here, literally every other place is better here in Stillwater than this rip off of a bar and food. STAY AWAY. read more

Great food! I absolutely love the atmosphere! Most times I hop from bar to bar but once I started coming here I stay all night! The staff is super friendly and welcome. They remember me every time I came back. The bar tenders are super fast even when it's really busy. Def recommend this place!! read more

Closing before your advertised time? That is confusing. Rude staff when we went for dinner and went for an after drinks snack. Please realize how confusing it is when you are at the door at 1:45, and it says on the door at 2. Also get rid of your game day menu. If you can't handle the menu your normally have, don't open on a game day. No burgers?? read more

The atmosphere and location updates are great. A good rooftop is always appreciated. The food though? Average. So average it might be below average. Drunk college kid food. The young bearded fellow who cooked our food made it with such apathy that it came through in the flavor (or lack thereof). Try harder Coney Island. The city of Stillwater needs you to. read more

Great burgers. Quite possibly the best in town. My kids love it too!! I'd give them 5 stars, but the Only thing holding me back is I wish they kept their mayo cold rather than letting it sit out on the counter all day. read more

This is a must have when in Stillwater. They have delicious coneys. Try happy hour Monday through Thursday from 2-4pm. They have Coneys, friend onion cheeseburgers, and beers for $1.50 each. read more

Coney Island - Hot Dogs Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

See all

Only two people working. Came in with group of 4. Waited 40 minutes for food. My coney was cold. Each of our orders were incomplete. Did not see anyone sanitizing tables. Hand sanitizer not available through restaurant. All around poor experience. read more

One of the best places to eat in Stillwater. Good prices, quality ingredients and great taste. New remodeled building gives an entirely new atmosphere. Also a great place to have a drink and watch a game. Employees are very friendly and helpful when deciding what to order. read more

Coney Island is a guilty pleasure! The coney basket along with tots is the absolute best!! The remodel is wonderful with a lot more room!

What a fun place to meet a friend for burger or Coney. Feels so much cleaner since the remodel. The rooftop option is a unique option for dining! I'm there for the food so I don't go during evening "bar" hours. Our son says "best burger in Stilly." read more

This bar is fantastic and has excellent service. The staff works very fast and offers a great service for customers. The management is great with Anthea but not only the bar but the food is great as well. Greatest hot dogs I've had but the cheese tots are even better. No one competes with this place and I recommend making the drive here. read more

I don't know what happened, new ownership maybe, but it's not the place it once was. The skinny fries are now thick ones. The coneys are quite different, in a bad way. And they are offering the same foods you see offered in gas stations like Hunt Bros pizza and those do-it-yourself shakes (only they do it). It's a real shame as this used to be a great spot for coneys. Sticker shock too when they total you up. read more

We were very excited to grab and onion burger, fried pickles, and a coney. The burger came plain with no onions. We asked for onions. Then asked again after 5 minutes when we didnt see any opinions on the grill and received cold onions. When we asked if they could be heated in the grill, she brought back 3 grilled onion slivers and said she hoped is was enough for my burger. We would have been totally fine if she had offered an explanation, but she was not interested in providing any kind of service. read more

Simple concept and a staple in Stillwater. My neighbor told me to try this place out and it wasn't anything fancy. A hot dog is a hot dog. But here, it is done well. Kinda wish the wieners were a little bigger but, it is what it is. I had a coney which had a sweet tangy slaw and chili on it, and a kraut dog .chops and nice cold beer to wash it all down. read more

Coney Island - Little doggies - Hot Dogs Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

One of the icons of the Strip. The food here is great (not great for you). There is also plenty of entertainment after midnight on the weekends. Slaw dogs, nuke dogs, and crawdaddys are classics. You need to try them, but don't sleep on the grilled onion cheeseburger either. It is a forgotten gem. Every student who passed through Stillwater probably has a few stories of fun nights that ended here. read more

I LOVE Coney Island! Their frito chili pie is amazing! They now offer pizza and milkshakes and my husband and I go so often they usually know us by name. They are usually pretty fast at getting your order out and the staff are always very friendly. read more

Smells amazing every night abd the food is quick but pretty much what you would expect from a "college town" late night munchies, straight from the bar kind of place. Pretty cheap too which definitely helps read more

Been here twice after a night at Outlaws and Murphy's. It hasn't disappointed yet. Highly recommend the Heaters!

Nothing Special. Not your Coney I-Lander of Tulsa, known for their chili "made for coneys." These coneys seem like something you would make in your kitchen with Hormel chili from a can. They weren't awful if you just needed something to eat. It would be like going to a sandwich shop just to be handed a generic sandwich with plain, cheap ingredients from the grocery store. read more

Went to my old favorite this past weekend after the OSU Super Regionals. The coneys were great and the place was packed! What a great OSU tradition!! read more

This place is fantastic and well placed. They have amazing hot dogs and chili dogs. I haven't found a place that can beat this. Two guys with weiners on the strip still isn't as good. read more

Tried Coney Island for the first time. Had the regular chili coney. The bun was cold needs to be warmed. Needed a little more chili on the dog. The taste was good over all. Tater tots were good but can't really go wrong there. The place was clean. Friendly staff. read more

I have always remembered this place as the absolute best coneys anywhere. Whenever I return to Stillwater, I always get my fix of 2 coneys, fries and a cold beer. read more

There is nothing I enjoy more than having a greasy, fried cheeseburger after a long night out on the strip. The CI is where it's at when it comes to drunk food. My boy and I love this place. read more

This place is great for a coney place! Is it a 5 star restaurant? No, but it's a pretty great place to grab a cheese coney! So if you're craving a coney, then come chow down! read more

Coney Island - Coney with chili, cheese, onions, and jalepeno! - Hot Dogs Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma