Pickup order. Phones were always busy, but once i reached them, process was great Pickup was on time, quick and easy Pizza was not up to usual high standards. Crust was much thicker than normal. Ingredients were tasty and fresh. Quality control needs to improve. Perhaps the summer staff is just not as skilled. read more

This is a must visit place when you're in Stillwater! This Hideaway is amazing! The inside has a great ambiance to it. It's neatly decorated and very clean. The bathrooms are very clean too! They also had some fun music playing the in the bathroom. The service here was great! All of the employees here were very kind and helpful. It was super funny to watch them yell "Corner!" every time they turned a corner. The food here was amazing! I really enjoyed their pizza and my friend enjoyed his pasta. The sausage pizza is especially amazing here! Also, their garlic bread was pretty good. Overall, great restaurant and I highly recommend trying It! read more

See all

We came to Stillwater to take our grandson out to lunch. We gave him a choice of where he wanted to eat and out of all the restaurants near OSU, he chose Hideaway. This isn't just any Hideaway, but the original. They do things a little different here. The crust is different and, in my opinion, better. I am so glad we have a grandson with impeccable taste in food. He not only chose an excellent restaurant, but a very delicious pizza off the menu. We started with fried mushrooms that looked so good Dan and I both completely forgot to take pictures before they were gone. The breading was fried perfectly and the mushrooms were hot and juicy. Our grandson's favorite pizza, Paradise Pie, might have just become my favorite, too. It had a nice variety of ingredients: chicken, bacon, mushrooms, tomatoes, and spinach. I don't usually like bacon on pizzas. I did like it on this pizza. I think the difference is that Paradise Pie comes with Alfredo sauce instead of red sauce. It is a very good combination. We got friendly service. I loved looking at the decorations, which reflected the college community. We had an amazing time visiting our grandson and sharing this fantastic meal with him. read more

See all

This was the original hideaway, and I was very excited to try it. All of the employees were very nice and nothing went wrong. The mozzarella sticks were very good and we all enjoyed them. The food came out quick, and was also very delicious. The ambiance of the place was awesome, and it's safe to say I was not disappointed by this place. You should definitely come here if you are in the area! read more

The Original Hideaway - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

See all

Some of the locations outside of Stillwater are not - in my opinion - as good as the original. The original certainly maintains its high standards. Drove to Stillwater to take our OSU grandson to lunch. Started with an appetizer of fried mushrooms served with ranch and marinara dipping sauces. Yum! Caution. They come out very hot. Ordered the Paradise pie. It has Alfredo sauce and grilled chicken with bacon, mushrooms, spinach, tomatoes and mozzarella and provolone cheeses. Really good stuff. Well served by Lila N as well as some of her colleagues. Lots of leftovers for grandson to take home. read more

The Original Hideaway - One of the dining rooms - Pizza Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

See all

Very overrated establishment the food is mediocre and just not that good the service is quite nice the vibe is as well just the food lacks

I stopped in for a quick lunch before leaving town. Because I was a single, I was seated at a small table at the intersection of hallways next to the restrooms. It was not a fantastic experience. I had the salad and pizza lunch combo with the vegetarian pizza. The salad was good and the pizza was ok. The crust and cheese were tasty, but the overall flavor was meh. The team of servers were polite and attentive. read more

Ordered a double pepperoni pizza for delivery and there were maybe 2 slices of pepperoni per slice. We called and they only offerers us $3 off the whole pizza which still makes it $32. (I never got the refund) The owner was very rude on the phone and said she didn't want to send out another pizza during their peak hours. We ordered here frequently but after this treatment we we will be ordering from empire instead. I suggest if you order for delivery check the pizza is correct before you sign off because they won't compensate you on delivery orders. read more

The Original Hideaway - "Double pepperoni" - Pizza Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

We started with the mushrooms then enjoyed a pepperoni pizza. The food was great but what really made the experience special was the service staff. Abby and Owen were fantastic. Maybe it was because it was the first weekday after the students had gone home but they were super attentive. Abby met us at the door with the more pleasant smiling greeting and Owen made sure we were never in want of anything. Whoever trained these guys did a great job. read more

Whenever we are in Stillwater for a game my kids love stopping here. The staff is super friendly and the pizza is better than any of the other locations. read more

Most originals are hard to duplicate, and the original hideaway is a perfect example. I've been to several of its offspring, but there's just nothing like the iconic feeling of the Stillwater original. The campus corner ambiance can not be duplicated, some would call it a little tired but that is the best part of years of memories for so many. I love the mini pies here, in particular the little kahuna with just beginner salad and a local brew. They work any weekend wait down quickly by all the staff doing everything. I was impressed. Multiple staff jumped into wait on our table, each delivering service if it was their specific assignment. read more

Long time favorite in Stillwater OK neat the Oklahoma State University campus. Offers a wide variety of delicious foods.

With family in Stillwater, I've been going to Hideaway for as long as I can remember. There is no other restaurant that can make fried mushrooms like them!! They are best with marinara or creamy Italian. Also, they have an unbelievable lunch menu - you can get a mini pizza and salad for under $10, that's with me adding extra toppings on the pizza and salad (I love the in betweener salad style so I always add ham, turkey and cheddar to my salad which is a dollar or so extra, and the pizza comes with 1 topping but it's not much to add more - if you do it the way it comes you're looking at under $8 I think!). I can't visit Stillwater without stopping here - usually more than once haha. Their pizza is great, not too thin or thick. I'm super excited I am getting a Hideaway near where I live, I hope it is just as good as the original location! read more

The Original Hideaway - In In-Betweener Salad from lunch special, add ham, cheddar and mozzarella and Lunch Sized Fried Mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

Pizza, bruschetta, and spin dip. Great. Service not so much. We ordered our 4 mini pizzas and apps with each having a soft drink or draft beer. We receive the drinks and immediately the server drops off the check. We sit and wait while the apps come out. Then pizza. They bring out a wrong pizza and immediately take it back to make a new one. The person then brings back a check again with 50% that pizza. But yet they didn't take off the charged for additional toppings she didn't want in the first place , so that didn't even matter. We continue to sit with only people running food. All drinks are dry. The last new pizza comes out and we ask for a ranch and a refill. One refill of tea and a ranch and never again will an employee be near us. We wait and wait and finally flag down someone for boxes. The guy while we ask for boxes asks to clear our table instead. All in all, I would try again because the pizza was good. But don't be in a hurry and ask for at least 2 drinks at a time since you won't ever get a refill but will get charged for everything. read more

The Original Hideaway - Pizza Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

See all

Lack of sauce flavor. Looks pretty, but tastes just okay. Service wasn't the best, lack of communication or just service itself... asked for water two times and had to ask a third time. Not a busy time either. Not our first time here. But something seemed off about this visit. read more

See all

Greta pizza. My favorite are their lunch specials. So fun to be able to get a personal pan pizza.

Good service. Pizza tasteless. Crust just plain - no crisp. Pasta was bland. Prices are good though.

The Hideaway is an institution. It's not always at its best, but it's always the best at its consistent favorites. Pizza, mushrooms, sandwiches--a Stillwater staple, and there aren't many. read more

Always a favorite of the locals and our guests. Walking distance to McKnight Performing Arts center and other popular campus venues. Inventive pizzas, fresh salads, build-your-own pasta entrees. Fried mushrooms are the best in town! Servers quick and have great recommendations. Kite collection adorns the walls. read more

Very nice looking place and plenty of room to get a table. Service was great! Mac and cheese bites were great. Mozzarella sticks had a good flavor. Pizza had plenty of cheese but the crust and sauce were just okay. read more

Always great pizza. Not a huge fan of the margarita pizza but all the others. Fried mushrooms are still our favorite app. I just wish the shrooms were bigger like they use to be. read more

The Hide-A-Way staff's service was excellent. We sure enjoyed our lunch there. The menu was easy to understand and the food was delicious!

Hideaway is considered the best pizza spot in town and for good reason - it's some amazing pizza. It can get pretty busy in there so be prepared to wait. It's great for all audiences and relaxed atmosphere. But it is NOT quiet. No little love whispers had there. read more

I've hit this spot a few times this past year. Food's good, portions hit right, but the staff? Kinda meh, not really what you'd expect service-wise. read more

Before we graduated, we obviously had to stop by this iconic Stillwater spot. We started off with the beginners salad with Parmesan dressing and the cheesy bread! For our main meals, we got the pepperoni pizza, the sausage pizza, and the build your own. The build your own was the classic marinara with spinach, tomatoes, and chicken. Even though everything was delicious, something just hits so different than a classic Hideaway Pepperoni Pizza! Definitely going to miss this spot next year! Overall, the service can be spotty. We had an amazing waiter this day that we came but in the past it's just been average. There's something very nostalgic about coming to Hideaway in Stillwater. I didn't grow up coming here but every-time I'm in Hideway it just makes sense. The cute plants, the kites, the open kitchen. What's not to love about this spot! read more

See all

Look out Oklahoma! OG Hideaway is here to kick butt and chew bubble gum and they are all out of bubble gum. This place is part of the eateries backbone of Stillwater. As far as a pizzeria goes this place will tickle your funny bone with its laid back setting. We have eaten here countless times during regular days and game days and always have a splendid time with quick service while enjoying delicious food. Speaking of delicious, the food is so enticing I have seen hardcore vegetarians renounce their food-philosophy here...all for the sake of a pepperoni pizza (here's lookin' at you Kirk!) What other proof do you need??!!! If you only eat leaves, but are meat-curious or are a staunch meat-o-saurus I would definitely grab a plate at the Hideaway! read more

While taking the Man Child up to OSU for his Sophomore year we were looking for places to go eat on Yelp OF COURSE. We tried to hit another spot but they were closed for kitchen renovations and so i looked again and he said he had heard of The Hideaway and was supposed to be good. We hustled over to get us some food. It is right on the south side of campus so it is an easy walk to visit for the student. When we walk in it was a dark and dated decor that looked to be original when they opened the place and it was FANTASTIC!! Finally a spot with character and KITES!!! While people watching it is clear this is a favorite spot with the locals and that is always a good sign!! The best was an elderly couple and he was wearing a sharp OSU orange button down shirt and overalls!! We ended up going with the Big Country pizza because either go big or go home. I also started with the house salad. I will say the medium was way more filling that the two of us could take down and so like everyone else leaving ...we left with a box!! The pizza was tasty!! Our order did come out super slow but they took care of us without even having to ask which was super nice of them. Clearly the big country got lost in the big kitchen!! If you end up in Stillwater you have to go get a Pie here!! read more

The Original Hideaway - Big country Pizza Medium - Pizza Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

Hideaway is still the place to go in Stillwater! They still have great food and great service. Such a good place to meet up with your friends. read more

Good food. Love the fried mushrooms. Wish the waiting area was larger tho bc it is always so packed

Original Hideaway crust is the best and you can always count on consistency there with ingredients and flavor. Fried mushrooms are also great! read more

Bad pizza cold and long weight and there was no waite really but my service was oki will never go back

We were in Stillwater for a family celebration of life and enjoyed a variety of pizzas. They were all very delicious. The crust was just right and the toppings very tasty. We had a great time and enjoyed the pizza and family. read more

I come here for the food. They have the original fried mozzarella sticks. Other locations have changed theirs and not for the better. The Original Hideaway also has their own crust. It is closer to the thin crust and a great complement to the unique ingredients that Hideaway uses to create their pizzas. I have been to this location twice and have also been impressed by the consistent great service. read more

Fam favorite! Paradise pie & Big Country are the favorites in our house. Service has never been a problem and it has a fun look. Close to campus. read more

YIKES!!!!!! My friend and I drove three hours to Stillwater for our very first time. We went to Hideaway after many recommendations and were looking forward to indulging in a delicious drink after our long drive. Too bad for my poor friend, she turns 23 soon and they took her REAL ID and refused to serve her. We asked if there were options in order to prove her age, but they were unwilling to work with us. We told them to call the cops, they didn't. The manager told us she was trying to protect their liquor license, but what is the point of having a liquor license if you aren't going to serve 21+ guests alcohol !!! The manager was QUIVERING because she knows she illegally took the ID and gave it back after many arguments. If you are a 21+, normal human, wanting to drink, then don't come here!!! Because they won't serve you read more

It would be a lot better if they had different pizza dough like Tulsa, the flavor was good but the dough was bad. They should definitely consider bringing garlic knots to the menu for sure. read more

We were in town for a softball game and looking for something tasty to fill our belly's. With not much to really choose from in Stillwater we opted for what we thought would be a great option. The place was packed with lots of the local crowd on their Friday lunch break it was a bit noisy and the decor was definitely interesting. But hey it's a college town. Have some fun. We ordered ther famous Fried Mushrooms and the spinach dip for an appetizer and I got the "in-betweener" salad. We both ordered a small pizza.. the mushrooms and dip were pretty good and my salad was much bigger than anticipated. The salad was hard to eat because the bowl was so full. But we'll worth the price and the grated ham was good in it. We were extremely disappointed in the pizza. Everything about it was mediocre. The dough was dense and the topping were low quality. The red sauce was just crushed tomatoes and tasted like a tin can. No seasoning what so ever. Other people were ordering sandwiches and they looked good. Personally for pizza I would find somewhere else. read more

See all

My family and I came for an early dinner so it wasn't packed. I like the place, it's a cute college town feel. We ordered meatballs for our appetizers, which were delicious! And ordered margarita pizza, kahuna pizza, and chicken parm sandwich. I read all the reviews before coming and saw a couple of reviews saying how bland the food was, but there were more positive reviews so we gave it a shot. But honestly, the food was bland. The pizzas lacked flavor. The kids got cheese pizza and oh my cheese! Do they load it! My daughter felt like it was way too much. Overall, the best thing we ordered were the meatballs! Definitely get the meatballs! And the service was good! read more

See all

Amazing pizza. Consistently great. Super cool staff. It has been one of the best restaurants in town for decades.

Customer service second to none Big Country Pizza Loved It Pizza was delicious Sweet tea great Tall dude working the front was hustling read more

The Original Hideaway - Pizza Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma