Petti's Pizza & Restaurant

Awesome pizza! Satisfy your pie craving and support a great…read morelocal small business!! Cash only so come prepared.

I ordered two large pizzas. They were a bit pricey but not as much as some others. Service was…read moredecent, and my food was ready in the time frame they gave me. However, it was worth the price. I ordered a sausage and a pepperoni pizza and both were pretty good. My family devoured it lol.

Inside

Pepperoni and Hand pulled sausage

See all

Exterior

Big Cheese Pizza

4.2(22 reviews)

1.7 mi

First time ordering from this place, I called in my order for delivery even though we live right…read moreacross the street. We ordered a large pepperoni Pizza with mushrooms and extra cheese, a chicken tenders dinner and 2 chocolate chip cookies. They told us our order would be ready in 35 to 45 mintues. 1st awesome thing- our food arrived very fast- 26 mins to be exact. 2nd awesome thing- their large Pizza is huge! Most of the time a large Pizza from a local business can be a crap shoot. Best pizza in downtown Willoughby has a large that is a joke- so this was an awesome surprise. 3rd awesome thing- their sauce and crust is amazing! The sauce is just a hint sweet. I can't stand spicy sauce or sauce that has so much acid I breathe fire. And the crust is nice and soft, not hard as a rock. But it's not soggy either. It's just right. 4th awesome thing- it was hot when it came to my door. I can't stand cold pizza. My boyfriends fires were a tad on the cold side but he said he liked them and his chicken tenders were pretty good and hot. The cookies were pretty tasty too. Safe to say, this will be our new Pizza place until they give us a reason to look else where

My work gets this pizza all the time. For the price and the quality it's worth giving it a try. Try…read morethe Buffalo Chicken Pizza.

See all

Revolution Pizza

3.9(74 reviews)

1.4 mi

I'm I have been a big pizza eater for years. The last time I ordered pizza I was unhappy without…read morethe crust was the toppings weren't enough on there and also the service that I received. Just recently within the last couple of weeks I went ahead and tried Revolution Pizza in Manor and Willowick the mentor one was absolutely phenomenal just like Willowick. The thing that made me stand out the most was that the owner

ordered online (and paid in full). estimated time was 50 minutes. 1.5 hours later it's still not…read morehere. when we called to inquire about its status, we were put on hold for over 7 minutes. unreliable.

Undercooked and only half of pizza with toppings.

Buffalo Chicken with a Drizzle.. Revolution Pizza Style

See all

Joey's Wood-Fired Pizza

5.0(3 reviews)

2.2 mi

We had Joe and team out for our 45th high school reunion. It was 2 days after a tornado blew…read morethrough our area and we had to do fast switching of venues etc. We were stressed with all the changes but Joe and team kept everything perfect on their end and the event ended up being our best yet. The pizza was great as was the salad and pepperoni bread. The staff was professional and personable. The price well speaks for itself was a great value. Fresh hot pizza kept everyone full and happy!!

Wonderful experience! We had Joey's Wood Fired Pizza at a graduation party & they were extremely…read moreaccommodating with everything! Pizza was delicious, and since it was all you can eat for a specified number of guests, it was always hot & ready to grab (which was great since guests were coming & going). I highly recommend them.. Great food, VERY fair pricing, and a friendly staff!

Mario Fazios

4.5(265 reviews)

2.2 mi

We are always satisfied at Mario Fazio's. This time, they outdid themselves. We ordered the…read more"Heavenly Pasta", and it is the BEST PASTA EVER!!!!!!! APPLAUSE, APPLAUSE!!! CLAP, CLAP, CLAP!!! Thank you!

Came here for an after funeral luncheon. They did a really nice job of having the tables set with…read morewater upon our arrival. Our server Cam was great about giving people beverages and then once everyone was there after the burial they started bringing out the mini pizza and garlic bread. This was followed by a table side wedding soup and a family style garden salad with great toppings and a light bright dressing. The family style lunch consisted of a lemon chicken, cavatelli, green beans and a potato dish with regular and sweet potatoes. This was followed by a small slice of cassata cake. Highly recommend Mario Fazios if you are in need of a luncheon event.

Progressive ERPMO dinner 3.31.26

Chicken Marsala with risotto - excellent!

See all

The best Italian dinner in Cleveland! Great Catering.

Cleveland Pizza Co

3.6(75 reviews)

1.7 mi

New York might be known for huge slices, and Chicago might be famous for it's deep dish; however,…read morepizza in and around Cleveland was always in it's own little world. Cleveland Pizza Co is neither flashy nor pretentious, revolutionary nor groundbreaking - but their pizza is excellent and doesn't hold back on flavor. I've ordered takeout on several occasions and have yet to be disappointed. The sauce is balanced in flavor, the cheese is fragrant, and the toppings are fresh, such as the mushrooms! So, whether you're in the mood for a pie or just don't feel like standing over the stove, Cleveland Pizza will not disappoint.

Usually I like to see pictures before I order food and for some reason I couldn't find any online…read moreof their deep dish. I've been going here for years but never tried it. Today I ventured out and I was not disappointed! I called and had to wait a long time for someone to answer, but when I went in I saw they were extremely busy. I'm not sure if there is something special going on or if other people just love their pizza as much as I do. The pizza was well worth the wait. It was a tad pricy at $23 for such a small size but honestly due to the quality of their ingredients I understand.

Vape and dirty items on the food prep table

Deep dish

See all

Small Pepperoni Plunge Pizza

Pizza Booyah

3.6(45 reviews)

3.2 mi

We had an issue with Toast on our order, and Anthony went above and beyond, remaking our pizzas and…read moreeven giving us extra sides (even after the restaurant was technically closed!). The pizza was awesome and we'll definitely be coming back.

Free Unlimited Toppings, house made dough, scratch made sauces, delicious salads, loaded subs &…read morecrispy wings at Pizza Booyah in Willoughby Hills! Make sure to check out their daily specials! Dine in or carry out! Plenty of parking available! Butter Chicken Pizza Apple Walnut Salad Ultimate Meatball Sub Ultimate Spicy Italian Sub Jamaican Jerk Wings

See all

Geraci's

3.5(11 reviews)

4.2 mi

Came here for dinner with my husband and mother in law. She used to go to the original Geraci's…read morewhen she was younger with her family every Friday. She wanted to see if the pizza was the same as she remembered. She really enjoyed the pizza and said it brought back great memories. I ordered the marinara with cavatelli and had a cup of the wedding soup. Both were delicious! My husband had the cheese tortellini with spicy cream sauce. It was really really good. The spicy was perfect. There was a steady stream of people coming in to get take out pizza. Great to have a nice pizza place in downtown Willoughby. Our server TJ was helpful. The only reason for four stars instead of five is because of the check out process and overcharging. We were told to pay up front on the way out. We weren't presented a bill. I paid it and left. I did ask for a receipt (yes, I balance to my credit card statement ). We were charged for 3 beverages ( we had two iced teas and one water). Additionally, we were charged $ 2.50 versus $ 2.00 for the cavatelli. Paying, an additional $3.25 than what we should've been charged isn't the end of the world, but please check what you're charged before swiping your payment.

Geraci's pizza is awesome, unfortunately for them the employees at the Willoughby location were…read moretotal jerks.

Large Sicilian

See all

Meatball Sub w. Fries

Giuseppe's Pizza & Subs

4.1(85 reviews)

1.3 mi

The meatball and roasted red peppers pizza is to die for. Their hot Italian sub is xcellant…read more Good wings also

Ordered a chicken parmigiana meal and the sauce was so sweet , they should have called it candied…read moreparmigiana . Almost like a cook messed up in kitchen . And no garlic or Italian herb flavor to sauce . Very disappointed in the meal and I could not much. Makes me question why I even tried them when Dino's is next door and has the best sauce . Sticking to Dino's from now on .

Large Sicilian Style Pizza - pepperoni,1/2 sausage,1/2 mushroom

Buffalo wings

See all

Small Deluxe Pizza

Tony's Pizza & More

3.4(23 reviews)

1.7 mi

Good Cheap pizza! People are always very nice! Pep and chez is the fav!…read more It's not in a supper great area. But it's not the worst either. I think they would do great down town. Not a place to sit and eat eather. Just order and take home and don't forget to rent a movie at red box!

Always satisfied, and great customer service, great pepperoni pizza and meat lovers. So sad to see…read morethem go

Soooo delish!!

See all

$5.99 special.

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Stephen S.

11 years ago

Great pizza and possibly the best salads in all of Cleveland. The pizza burger and a salad are the best meal in town.

Dawn B.

1 year ago

Landmark in Wickliffe Ohio. The pizza is always good and the prices are very fair in today's overpriced world.

John M.

15 years ago

Best pizza in Cleveland. My favorite for at least 30 years!

S E.

110

14 years ago

A perfect amount of food and resonable priced!

Petti's Pizza & Restaurant - pizza - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Petti's Pizza & Restaurant also viewed

Trios Italian Grille

4.5

(43 reviews)

The best family business. Owners are friendly. Food is fresh and delicious. This is my go-to place.read more

The location is very small. The majority of the their business is the take out and catering…read more They have two small tables which have reserved signs on them. When I asked about the signs, the owner told me that she kept the signs there so the delivery services won't sit down. A friend and I met for dinner. The service was exceptional. The food was even better. The portions were generous. The white balsamic vinaigrette was thick and tasty which went beautifully with the freshness of the salad. The chicken picatta was so good. My friend loved her chicken marsala. The owner let us sit there until we were ready to leave. I would highly recommend Trios.

Mangia Mangia

3.9

(152 reviews)

Service was super friendly. The trio was very tasty; one of the best Alfredo sauces in Geauga. The…read moreroom itself was traditional and eclectic. The garlic bread was good but simple. Highly recommended.

Italian sub very good!! Shrimp Santa Fe was also very good!!! Pasta here is fresh tasting, not like…read moreout of the box!!! Waitress was very attentive & on top of everything!!! Pizza is also very good!!! Nice atmosphere with nice decor!!! If you're like good Italian food, I would recommend this place to try!!!

Scotti's Italian Eatery

4.1

(116 reviews)

This is the most underrated unassuming little pizzaria . Its timeless decor....wonderful staff,…read morefood is always consistent and very reasonable for the portions and well thought out flavors! It actually has one if the best patios in Cleveland with gorgeous flower and herbs all around.....a little romantic or family night. Always a treat and never disappoints!

I came here about 2:00 pm. Door was locked. I called and man said it was a slow day so they decided…read moreto close and come I should come back at 4:00. (This is a family owned business.). I said I was already in the parking lot and in the meantime, the Orlando bread truck came there to deliver their bread and then driver drove away when no one answered the door. Man then opened the upstairs window and yelled at me to try to find the truck to come back. Seriously. You can't make this stuff up.

Zappitelli's Pizza

4.2

(150 reviews)

Great pizza. One order of chicken piccata is enough for two. Good family restaurant.read more

Went for lunch with with wife wife it took seconds into we sat die. Smile with a service the…read morewaitress was very helpful gave us time to look at what we want. So you can't go wrong with any you order we got large cheese pizza spaghetti and meatballs their rolls are great I could imagine the garlic knots. Everything came out on time. Everything is freshly made you can tell they take pride in their products...

Augies Pizza & Ribs

3.6

(53 reviews)

Ordered the Lasagna dinner and it was delicious. Came with a really great salad and fabulous garlic…read morebread . You need to visit you won't be sorry !!

Heather was our server and was awesome. Also had a very nice conversation with Joe. The ambience…read morereminded me of an old-school pizza parlor which was absolutely amazing. The food was super delicious. We had a pizza, salad, chicken, Parm, and ribs. All of it was absolutely delicious. This was our first time in and we will definitely be back. Thank you for the hospitality.

Geraci's Restaurant of Pepper

3.1

(106 reviews)

Great service and great food! Giovanni the bartender was fantastic! The Chicken Parmesan and…read moreSpaghettini was amazing!

I have driven by "Geraci's Restaurant" in Pepper Pike many times. It is in a very nice area along…read moreChagrin Blvd; and many times I have thought we should stop in to see what it was like. The restaurant is in the bottom floor of an attractive office building and has a very nice red brick enclosed patio out front. In the evening, when it is all lit up, it looks very cozy. We made our reservations, which required a call rather than online. They were very accommodating. The establishment is a bit of a fooler when you first arrive. It is actually much larger inside than it appears from the outside. There is a lot of square footages that is split up into several separate rooms and distinct areas giving it a more comfortable and warmer feeling than that much space would typically afford. We were seated quickly in a space that was open and bright and very comfortable. A very pleasant young lady by the name of Celine introduced herself as our server for the evening and quickly took our drink order. The wine list was not extensive but it had a satisfactory selection of good wines (Italian) by the glass. Which I always appreciate as our party typically only drinks one or two glasses and a bottle would go to waste. I enjoyed an excellent "Montepulciano D'Abruzzo". When Celine returned with our beverages she answered all the questions we had and we proceeded to place our order. I noted right away "Geraci's" does something with their salad offerings that very few establishments do. They offer all their salads in two sizes. I often want a salad to start my meal but the typical salad in most restaurants is MUCH too big. I just don't want that much lettuce. "Geraci's" offers all their salad options in a small size to solve that problem. I really appreciated that thoughtfulness. So, we all started out with a small salad that was crisp and fresh. Nothing that had been sitting around getting wilted... Good start. We also ordered the "Breaded Artichoke Hearts" from the appetizer menu for the table (one order was plenty for the 4 of us). The artichokes were very good. Lightly breaded and NO TOUGH LEAVES. There are few things more disgusting than bighting into an artichoke heart and hitting an unchewable leaf... aaaugh! These were very nicely done. All tender and flavorful... nothing fancy, just a pleasant start. My wife followed this with "Chicken Piccata" and I chose the "Chicken Marsala". Our guests ordered the "Veal Cutlet" and a personal sized "Sicilian Pizza". Our chicken dishes were good. The meat was tender and nicely cooked. The sauces were pleasant. There was nothing exceptional about either one. They were typical "American/Italian" cuisine. However, the "Veal Cutlet" was a bit disappointing. The meat was tender enough. But the breading was dry and flavorless. The "Sicilian Pizza" was ok... just ok. The crust was palatable. The sauce was somewhat flavorless. The Romano cheese had no flavor at all (typical American Romano)... they should have gone with the good stuff. We followed the evening with an excellent cup of coffee and three different desserts. I had the "Cannoli Trio" which were nice and crispy with good flavor. My wife had the "Spumoni Bomba" which she was very happy with. Our guests shared the "Limoncello Tartufo" that was excellent. So, is the 4 star rating too much? Probably, but I feel like a 3 is too little. If a 3-1/2 was an option that would be more accurate. All in all, it was a good evening. The atmosphere was nice. The service was excellent. The food was mostly good, but not entirely. So would I go there again... yes, maybe, in a pinch. Would I call it fine dining... absolutely not. I think maybe you should give it a try and see for yourself. It's worth a try and another opinion.

Abo's Grill

4.0

(202 reviews)

Another great experience at Abos. Family owned and it shows. Comfortable seating, service was…read morefriendly, and food was great as always. Couple TVs over the bar are also helpful when you want to track scores of the big game. Tried the chicken sandwich which was flavorful and cooked perfect with fresh toppings. This place is a staple for consistent good service and food.

Very good meal for lunch at Abo's Grill. The sauce on my eggplant was very delicious and can tell…read moreit was homemade. Eggplant was cooked well too. Service was excellant. I would definitely recommend for some authentic Italian cuisine

Dino's Restaurant

3.9

(109 reviews)

It's been a while since I dined at Dino's so we stopped in for lunch. Place is very basic nothing…read morefancy but the food is always good. The chicken parmigiana was tender with just the right amount of sauce and cheese. The Chicken Piccata was one of the best. It's a perfect blend of lemon and white wine. Every bite was so good. The server was friendly and took her time to explain their menu to us and recommended her favorites.

If you're craving some great authentic Italian food, then this is the place! Their artichoke dip is…read moreawesome, and they served it hot and cheesy with fresh bread. Tiramisu is top-notch. You really can't go wrong with anything on the menu. The bar area is very cozy in a Cheers kind of way. I've been utilizing the carryout quite often, and I always enjoy the brief ambiance when I pop in to pick up my order. Very friendly staff. And did I mention that the portions are grandiose? A good bang for the buck in this economy. I highly recommend checking out this restaurant!

TJ's On The Avenue

3.9

(142 reviews)

TJ's on the Avenue is a true staple. It's one of those local places you know you can count…read moreon--reliable, consistent, quick, and always filling. The portions are generous, the food is savory and satisfying, and there's something about it that feels genuinely old-school. It tastes like the kind of recipe that could have been passed down from someone's grandmother and never needed much changing because it was already right. What I appreciate most is the trust factor. You know what you're getting, you know it's going to be good, and you know you're going to leave full. In a town with plenty of options, there's real value in having a place that's simply dependable. A longtime staple for a reason.

Stopped in today for lunch with my daughter. It was awesome. Our server, Allison, was charming and…read moreknowledgeable. We enjoyed Veal Parmesan and a perfect salad. Best meal I have had in a long time.

Zeppe's Tavern & Pizzeria

3.4

(59 reviews)