What happened to this place? It really pains me to write this review, but here goes with my summary first:
Visited last night with my friend. Sadly, it's now a nightclub posing as a restaurant and no longer has the inspired, farm to table menu, of chef Mike Mullins. The food is nothing special. I was looking for more than just "bar food" and was surprised to see a very uninspiring menu. I should have done my homework and looked at the menu on their website beforehand. I ended up going with their signature burger medium rare (with American cheese, not Cheddar as before). The burger was well done and fries seemed like they were either cooked twice, or just over cooked in the frier. The shrimp tacos my friend had, just didn't look very appealing to me at all with one or two small shrimps laid out on the tacos open faced. My friend said that they were just OK and lacked shrimp. The food sat at the pass for about 5 minutes before being served, leaving me with cold fries and a warm burger. We ordered a final dish of fried calamari to share and it was rubbery.
Despite their reservation system saying that they were totally booked up, the place was cold, and practically empty when we arrived at 6:15pm. The bartender was pleasant enough, but was simply phoning it in and not really engaging with anyone. Her check-ins were almost non existent and it appeared that we needed to practically beg for service. Their server, slash everything else, was also nice enough and was trying. She seemed to get no support from the bartender despite the fact that the bartender didn't seem to be doing much. Lastly, something I noticed on the way out was that the carpeted stairway was extremely dirty and looked like it hadn't been vacuumed in a long time, let alone cleaned with a carpet cleaner.
Not inviting at all. This place is not the Perch + Plow that I remember going to pre-COVID, and it appears to be a place that has lost its way with zero management/owner involvement or standards. Really sad... For a few more details and other observations, read-on.
As I said at the top, it's focus now seems to be more towards after hours entertainment as a nightclub, as observed by my friend and I in seeing their large DJ Unit along the wall. The first miss was when I tried to make a reservation earlier in the afternoon. Their online reservation system said that they were fully booked. I tried to call the restaurant and was directed by voicemail to either leave a message or make my reservation online. My friend and I decided to take a chance and go anyway... now I wish we had gone somewhere else.
When we arrived there were only a few people spread out - much of the restaurant was deserted. There wasn't anyone greeting people as they came in and the large screen TV over the bar was playing hockey. When I asked the bartender if we could sit at a table, she said sure, but also said that if we didn't like to be cold, we should not sit towards the front of the house. There didn't seem to be any system at all and I was very confused because I expected the place to be packed because of their reservation system saying that they were fully booked. We decided to remain at the bar - two of just four people sitting along the long bar top.
Once our food showed up at the pass, the bartender didn't take notice and was futzing with the POS system. When she finally made contact, I asked if that was our food at the pass, she shrugged and girl friday walked from the front of the house to behind the bar where she noticed our food sitting there. After dispensing a little ketchup into a little bowl, she brought over our food. We asked if the station could be changed, she apologized saying she would try, but to her knowledge, the TV was broken and could only display one channel. She did try, and as I said, she was very pleasant, and just lacked training. When my friend decided he wanted to order something else, girl friday brought back our paper menus and suggested that if we wanted to order food from the Happy Hour Menu, we had better do it soon since it was almost 7:00pm. I had to laugh, since they were also a combination of small bites and were not much different than the regular menu.
As for the menu and food. It's not really American. I would say it had more Mexican influences. A look toward the kitchen and could see two Mexican woman who were likely line cooks, preparing what they know. Which is fine, and now I'm kicking myself for not trying the empanada's. I just wasn't in the mood for Mexican and Sonoma County has a ton of Mexican restaurants that are good. Lastly, who am I to suggest anything to the owner if they're doing well, running it as a Nightclub. Pre-COVID, I came her a bunch with my wife and we really enjoyed the food, drinks and service. We now live most of the year out of the area, so we haven't been around to go back since COVID ended. What Perch + Plow is now is NOT the concept that opened years ago. read more