Love these products ! So much fresher than grocery store bought. Sales people so knowledgeable and…read morehelpful in this store also.

Fresh spices and corporate values I can support. Make your baking & cooking this holiday season…read moreeven more impactful.

I've always had a great experience shopping at Penzeys. The selection is impressive and everything…read moreI've tried has been top notch in terms of quality. The staff is always helpful and genuinely kind, which makes shopping there even better. The stores themselves are really inviting, and their pre made gift sets are such a thoughtful option for birthdays or holidays. It's one of my go to places for both everyday staples and special gifts.

Panzers spice stores are awesome and I love them. High quality spices and great customer service…read more Beautiful stores and they make wonderful gift baskets.

We have been customers of Penzey's for decades so it is about time I write a review. We love their…read moreselection of spices from the basics to the proprietary blends. We are huge fans of many such as California pepper, Foxpoint seasoning, Galena Street rub for ribs, etc. Yes their prices are a bit higher than your standard supermarket selection but quality and freshness cannot be beat. There are so many spices and choices that this is a must stop for serious cooks. They also have many specials and discounts that help make it more affordable. You can order on-line and do in store pick-up at one of their two locations in town. It is important to support a local Wisconsin business especially one that provides high quality products.

I LOVE PENZEY'S!!!…read more If you haven't experienced this level of spice shop-- you are missing out!!! Every SINGLE seasoning has a jar for you to open and experience. The varieties are stellar and prices are reasonable for the quality of ingredients. They always have many specials going on that makes it impossible to pass up! I love their logos, displays and messaging about LOVE.

Date of visit: November 21, 2025…read more First off, it is super weird driving into this location. Between the winding driveway and the old, abandoned guard shack it feels like a giant trap until you park and enter the store to confirm it is in fact a spice store. Outside of that, staff was pleasant enough but not particularly interested in asking if you need any help. Since I had a general idea of what I wanted, I didn't let that bother me too much and found some small gift sets for my employees to serve as part of their Christmas gifts, though I do wonder how many other people just leave and end up at the mall instead? In the past they often had little deals or bonus items while you were checking out, but that didn't seem to be the case this time--inflation must have gotten them, too!

I can't give zero stars so one star it is...recently placed an order and included with the order…read morewere a couple of samples that I did not request including a "Transgender Remember" vanilla sugar packet. This was unexpected and the anti-conservative hate speech on the back of the packet is highly upsetting/offensive. Asked customer service if I could return for a full refund and was told "the socio-political messaging on certain products and our website is a core part of our business" and that I had to eat the return shipping cost. Highly disappointed that Penzey's refused to do the right thing in this situation, and would rather lose a long time fan of your spices over the owner's personal socio-political beliefs - which have no place in a business model. As a customer I do not force my beliefs on you as a business owner, and I expect the same in return.

I really enjoy that they have so many easy to access stores in the Milwaukee metro area. Stopped in…read moreto pick up some spices for a new recipe. Great service. Checkout was quick and easy with free magnets. The store was bright, clean and nicely organized.

Great store that is very clean and well laid out. The staff are always friendly and greeting you…read morewhen you walk in. I also don't know a time when I've not had a staff person ask if I need anything. They have a great selection of spices and seasonings, including many of their blends. I've really liked the Ruth Ann seasoning and Fox Point. They offer a lot of great deals and coupons via email. It can be pricier but the quality is worth it and you can usually save with their promotions.

Stopping into Penzeys on a whim while visiting Milwaukee, I was excited to exit with a bag full of…read moregoodies for myself and to give to friends as a gift. The person working on this particular Saturday afternoon (April 4th 2026) was so helpful as they made helpful recommendations while sharing about their faves. No pressure, just like shopping with a fun friend! I love that the store has tester samples that enable shoppers to get a vibe for the mixtures of seasonings via a sniff. I loved that they had some sale items ($1/small jar) because it enables one to test it out and maybe head back to get a larger size if they wanted to make the spice a kitchen staple. Even when not on sale for $1, the small sizes available are perfect for testing it out in the kitchen. The layout of the store is neat, with everything well-organized. This is a very fun shop to browse while adding to a spice collection.

This stuff is crap, what a rip-off. You can get the same quality at any grocery store at half the…read moreprice and without liberal tears mixed in....

I love Penzys. 98% of the spices in my pantry are from Penzys, and have been for well over 20…read moreyears. I sometimes buy their gift boxes for family because I want them to love Penzys spices too! Prices are reasonable and the quality is impeccable. The potency lasts much longer than any store brand or the famous red-capped spice company. Additionally, Penzys has many whole spices which last even longer as I can grind up only what I need. They also sell jars for storing spices, cookbooks, etc. I've been to other locations, but the 74th St location is my closest shop. I can't even remember when they moved in but it's always been well maintained and well stocked. Herbs and spices up front, baking goodies in the back. I love the little kitchen nook that baking items are displayed on, reminds me of my grandmas kitchen. They are staffed by friendly and helpful employees who love cooking and baking as much as everyone else. Don't hesitate to ask questions or for suggestions. Penzys also has sales a couple of times per year. Sometimes it's free items with a specific purchase amount, sometimes a discount.

I had the best experience picking up spices here! Once home, I put them to the test, making shrimp…read moretacos and chicken tacos--both turned out *fantastic*. I also grabbed other seasonings that we'll be using for future meals, and I can't wait to experiment more! As someone with **celiac disease**, I was thrilled to find out that these seasonings are **completely gluten-free**. The entire factory is celiac-safe, even though there's no GF logo on the packaging. I'm *very, very, very* sensitive, and I can confidently say I had no symptoms whatsoever. If you're looking for high-quality spices, this is the place to go. Highly recommend!

Possibly my new favorite Penzey's!!…read more They have two different entrances - one with a ramp, the other with stairs. The place is so wide open and they have a cute area for kids to play, draw, etc. Really loved the elevator and how they set up the space. Staff were very friendly and they have had consistently great spices/ seasonings. You can usually save if you sign up for their emails.

Poor service and poor quality products. Very disappointed…read morein the quality of the products that we received. And the service, they could care less if we were there or not.

Ready to spice things up? This purveyor of herbs and spice blends at the end of the Milwaukee…read morePublic Market is worth taking a look at! We bought a couple of things including a delicious maple popcorn sprinkle that makes me want to eat nothing but popcorn. Staff is milling around ready to help. This was a busy spot (popular products + the turnaround for the market); they could stand to have about twice the space!

I love fun spices. The Spice House has fun spices and regular spices. Located inside the Milwaukee…read morePublic Market, it's easily accessible. There is a huge selection of spices, and when I went, there was a sale. Cool! There are some nice spice mixes to use for fish, veggies, meat, poultry, basically anything you can imagine. I bought one a Tuscan herb blend, then I know I'm going to have to go buy more because it is perfect for grilled veggies. I also got a spicy hot mix for Christmas presents. I'm not about to try that one. There is basically something for everyone. I do want to go to their bigger store. They also sell online.

I had not been to Penzeys in several years and was looking forward to seeing what new spice…read moreadventures I would find. The education about the spices and spice blends was the reason I would go there when I lived in Wisconsin. It's unfortunate that now, their education on spice jars and in spice boxes, includes their stand on the political divide in our country. As with individuals, I respect this businesses decision to express their own ideology. As for me however, when I go to a store whose product I enjoy using ; I go for the product not to learn about their ideology. Thank you for all the previous years of spice and spice blend education. Unfortunately the business decision to teach [your] ideology is something I am not interested in, and will take my business elsewhere.

First time shopping at Penzey's Spices. Easily located across from Woodman's, near the Starbucks…read moreand near I94. The entry is very welcoming and staff provided good details about their products, including empty jar offering that includes stickers to label the jars. Positive messaging throughout the store provided a nice vibe for shopping. It did not disappoint! Thank you!