We have been customers of Penzey's for decades so it is about time I write a review. We love their selection of spices from the basics to the proprietary blends. We are huge fans of many such as California pepper, Foxpoint seasoning, Galena Street rub for ribs, etc. Yes their prices are a bit higher than your standard supermarket selection but quality and freshness cannot be beat. There are so many spices and choices that this is a must stop for serious cooks. They also have many specials and discounts that help make it more affordable. You can order on-line and do in store pick-up at one of their two locations in town. It is important to support a local Wisconsin business especially one that provides high quality products. read more

I LOVE PENZEY'S!!! If you haven't experienced this level of spice shop-- you are missing out!!! Every SINGLE seasoning has a jar for you to open and experience. The varieties are stellar and prices are reasonable for the quality of ingredients. They always have many specials going on that makes it impossible to pass up! I love their logos, displays and messaging about LOVE. read more

Penzeys Spices - My little helper! - Herbs & Spices Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Wonderful business making a difference by promoting kindness! Definitely get on their email list, many sales, promotions and great recipes. Smell or taste the seasoning in store it nicely spread out in the open floor plan. Warm friendly smiles welcomed us and guided us through the process of choosing the perfect seasoning! read more

The store very well set up and stocked. The three employees of the store went out of their way to help my mother in law and myself when our car broke down by their store. When they first greated us they offered to give us something to drink and use the rest room. We will never forget their sincer help 5 starts all the way. We are from Neb and they even showed us where we could go to get more spices both on line and the closest store, overland park ks. read more

The east side having a Penney's is great. This strip mall barely has parking even during COVID. I have no idea where people are because Penney's has a great COVID curbside no store entry process in effect. Just order online for in-store pickup and they'll call to confirm your preferred time. You don't have to like the CEO's politics to acknowledge the seasons are fresh, vibrant, strong and not MSG laced. They just work and Bill works to give back to he community while also putting his politics out there for the greater good and for all to see. Commendable given that's the thing everyone teaches not to do from B-school to corporations around the globe. There's always a deal to be had so sign up for the emails. read more

Penzeys Spices - External - Herbs & Spices Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Convenient location on the East Side of Madison. Get on Penzey's mailing list for regular weekend specials that lower the cost of keeping your kitchen stocked. The salt-free offerings here are excellent. read more

I love Penzeys Spices and shop here for the spices that I use the most in my cooking adventures. I particularly love the bigger bags that I can use to fill up my spice jars. The spices are fresher than what you can buy in your local store. Open the jar and smell the the fresh goodness, and compare it to your grocery store spices. You will know Penzeys offers an awesome product. The staff are always friendly and helpful. read more

Great store great selection. I like how their products never make me tired of my own cooking, Adequate pricing

fabulous spices and great value! one of my favorite businesses in Madison, always helpful staff!

A pleasant shop that needs better labeling. I've known about Penzeys for years but had never been in one of their shops. While killing time until an appointment nearby I decided to stop in and have a look around. I was considering treating myself to a fancier cinnamon than you get in the grocery store, but I couldn't find it. I made about three loops of the store and managed to miss the display entirely. It was around the holidays so they were quite busy; it's entirely possible someone was just blocking the display. However, I felt like I had to get right up to a shelf to see what spice was what, and I couldn't discern any sort of order (by alphabet, cuisine, etc.). Again, I'll admit it's totally possible in the hustle and bustle of the holidays that my brain was just not putting two and two together, but clear labeling above the shelves would go a long way. From my photo I am reminded the large signs only give general clues like "herbs" and "spices." I'll have to stop in another time when it's not so busy and give it a good walkthrough without having to dodge holiday shoppers. Prices are a bit steep, but it's also guaranteed to be higher quality and fresher than the mass-produced plastic bottles you find at the grocer. read more

Penzeys Spices - 'Tis the seasonings! - Herbs & Spices Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Great quality herbs and spices. Excellent value. Customer service is second to none. Penzeys is a special place. read more

The first of two Penzey's locations in Madison is greatly underestimated IMHO. Quiet, unseemingly spacious considering its strip mall neighbhors compared to the University Ave location, Penzey's East is just as qualitative and just as fun! It's the standard, high-quality product you would expect from the dried herb, spice, and baking ingredient royalty. The staff have never been negative in any of my experiences. Always effectively listening, helpful, and willing to go extra lengths to make my experience positive, even if the product I want is out of stock, or a free giveaway is not available during my visit. Crown goes to you, Penzey's! I've been a loyal customer for more than a decade and the beat goes on! read more

My go to local source for spices As a cooking enthusiast, I was thrilled to see that Penzey's opened a new store near East Townee Mall earlier this year. I almost exclusively rely on their products for dried spices and seasonings. Other than some eclectic Asian spices, I can pretty much find whatever I need there. The store is basically a carbon copy of the store on University Ave. While things are sorted by alphabetical order, they do have separate sections for things like baking ingredients, chilis, pepper etc., which can be a little confusing when you get to the P section and can't find pepper because it is in a separate section. But it's not a large store, so eventually you'll figure it out. The staff is generally pretty laid back. They greet you when you enter, let you do your shopping and are available when you have a question. They sell spices in various quantities, but remember that spices have a shelf life of six to twelve months, so the half pound bag of cumin may seem like a bargain on a per ounce basis, but if you are going to use an ounce per year, stick with the smaller quantity. Even though Penzey's can be a little more expensive than your local supermarket, the quality level of the product is consistently high and because it is a specialty purveyor, the product on the shelf is fresher Some of the products I really love: * Pure vanilla extract - the gold standard for vanilla * Ground chipotle pepper - infuses a wonderful smoky flavor to my Mexican dishes * Extra Fancy Vietnamese Cassia Cinnamon - The cinnamon choice of America's Test Kitchen, 'nuf said * Dutch process high fat cocoa powder - make a chocolate cake with this stuff and you'll have the unconditional love of your kids, trust me * Whole Special Extra Bold Indian Black Peppercorns - the "Bold" is in the description for a reason, these peppercorns pack some serious heat. read more

Great spices and combinations that are delicious. I like that they are a Wisconsin business with small brick and mortar local locations. The 'side' serving of Hope is also very much appreciated! read more

Been using Penzeys Spices for years but it not through mail order, so excited that I can actually walk to one other spice store awesomeness!! They have a great variety to spices! Check them out you won't be disappointed!! read more

Penzeys is a place of beauty for the eyes and the nose (and once you're home and cooking, the mouth!). Marvelous spices and seasoning from wall to wall with helpful and knowledgeable service. Really reasonable prices for the high quality of product. Plus, they're a Wisconsin company, so I'm extra proud of that. read more

I was happy when a Penzeys Spices came to the East Side of Madison. Great store, not as big as the University Store, but easier for those who live in Sun Prairie and the East Side. Staff is always friendly and knowledgeable. Great thing about all Penzey stores is that you can smell the spice/herbs before purchase. I also love all the recipes they give out at the store. read more

This is my first experience in a Penzey's store. The staff was extremely helpful. I really liked the set-up of the store and the ability to smell the different spices in sample containers. My family started to cook with Penzey's spices and got me hooked! Reasonably priced for very high-quality spices! I will definitely be back! Thank you for a great experience picking out my spices! read more