Great local Roddy with 24 hour service. The breakfast is good, the service is great and you can't beat the diner ambiance. A must have in Dexter read more

Penny's Diner - Diner - Diners Near Me - Dexter, Missouri

found a live worm in my food here ! do not ever go here. worker would not comp whole bill , unacceptable! health inspector please shut this place down ! worst restaurant i have ever been to . read more

terrible service gave me a biscuit and gravy for 40$ deluxe b&b didn't even give me no bacon or eggs . guy on the phone acted like its his first job . 0 stars read more

What a great place to eat at. My family and I stopped by here on our way home and the food and the service was both great. The prices are fair and the people that work there are nice too. read more

Biscuits were not home made. Very disappointing I would not recommend. Nothing special, waitress was nice. Floors were so greasy I almost fell. read more

This place didn't have the best reviews but we decided to try it anyway today. The lady was working alone do it was slow but she was super friendly. The burger was good, Bacon amazing, I didn't care for their fries it seem they had been left a little too long but she was by herself trying hard. My kids for breakfast foods the pancake taste a little like what you would get at a hotel so I don't recommend the pancakes. My husband got the special of meatloaf he enjoyed his meal. My oldest got the breakfast burger and loved it. Over all it's not the best burger (I prefer Lemonade house grill in Poplar Bluff or Backyard burgers) but it was good and we would go back when we are in Dexter. Be prepared to wait but over all we enjoyed it. It's a very cute place we enjoyed the theme and old feel. We left a good tip she was working hard and on Valentine's day it was well deserved. read more

Super fun place!! And the typical diner food, burger, fries, tots, onion rings, & handmade milkshakes were exceptional! Morgan was running the diner during our visit & her friendliness & attentiveness was above & beyond! Great place to eat, even better place for a Family Fun Retro experience!! read more

See all

Worth the detour off the highway for this hidden gem while traveling. Only 1 sweet older lady working but we ate late evening and were the only customers in the place, so we got our food quick and hot. I highly recommend the sunrise skillet and a waffle. We will definitely be stopping again if we are ever back in the area and hungry. read more

Penny's Diner - Diners Near Me - Dexter, Missouri

Two stars because it wasn't the WORST place I've been, but it was disappointing. If you like canned/frozen food, you'll be all about it. Person in our party asked about their tenderloin - pre-made. Cowboy burger "smothered" in chili? Barely any on it. Waffle? Cooked FIRST and left to sit while the rest was prepared. Stone cold on arrival. Asked them to put it in the microwave a minute... still cold and now "chewy" to boot. Skillet was "ok" but not nearly what was pictured on the menu. Don't bother. read more

My family and I have tried to eat at this establishment several times. Each time is just as bad as the last visit. The food is never made right, staff has a don't care attitude and by the time you get home everyone's stomach is hurting. read more

Not a lot of choices for breakfast in Dexter so if it's eggs and bacon or some heavy pancakes that your craving then give this old fashioned diner a try. Reasonable prices. Located by the Oak Tree Inn and behind the Tapatico Mexican Restaurant. read more

Penny's Diner - the interior of penny's diner - Diners Near Me - Dexter, Missouri

Nothing bad to say about the food or the staff. A little expensive for the portion that you get. But these days nothing is cheap.... I would definitely recommend. read more

Yep it's a good one out there... pretty chilly in the restaurant so you might wanna bring a jacket read more

Penny's Diner - Diners Near Me - Dexter, Missouri

Just had a wonderful breakfast at Penny's! The restaurant was spotless- they cleaned and sanitized the tables between customers and provided all condiments in single serve portions to avoid contaminated syrup bottles and such. The food was fast, hot, and delicious! The service was delightful. Can't wait to go back! read more

We stopped to have breakfast heading to Arkansas for Thanksgiving, Brought back alot of Retro memories when you found this kind of Diners in the 60's and early 70's. Very Excellent breakfast we had.We use to have a Diner like this in Michigan City,In. Will stop in our next trip South. Thanks. From LaPorte,In. read more

We were heading to another town to get something to eat on our way to the campground. Was tired and saw a sign in the highway for Penny's Diner. Sign posted that it was there. Pulled into the Mexican restaurant and parked. The Diner was tucked behind. Walked over and glad we did. Only 1 person eating which gave us concern. The place was clean. The man behind the counter was awesome! He was friendly, helpful (I have allergies) and we felt so welcomed. We got our fresh handmade patty melts to go and talked to the customer as the food was prepared. When we got to the campsite and ate-it was absolutely delicious!!! The only reasons i could think of for the lack of customers are the lack of sign direction and visibility once in the parking lot. Stop in and eat-very worthwhile. read more

What a nice little diner with good food and excellent service. This place really shines in a city where there are few choices.

My family went out to eat for lunch at Penny's.... it was honestly terrible. Slow service, food was unappetizing ( greasy, very over cooked, found hair, over all just nasty) I wouldn't recommend eating here. It was over priced as well. The dinner was cute though. read more

The day we were here they were short staffed, but they kept us posted about when our food would be ready and really made it a point to check in as they could. The food was good and it was hot when it came out. read more

Try the "big pig" scrambled eggs, bacon, sausage, and ham. If I were local, I'd eat here all the time. Open 24/7 too!

The iconic American standalone diner--looks like a cross between a subway car and spaceship, with a row of stools along the bar and some small tables along the exterior wall. Came complete with a few errant flies and the local septagenarian with John Deere hat reading the local newspaper. The bar top was moderately clean, and although the waitress was doing double-duty mopping and taking orders, it did not exactly look like cleanliness was #1 on their list. Could be wrong, though. The food unfortunately was a bit underwhelming for me--I had the breakfast burrito w/ sausage, which I usually order at Waffle House--I wanted to see how theirs would compare. It came with two large patties chopped up with the eggs, so it was more like a sausage burrito with some egg holding it all together. The big downside was that the cook waited until he was ready to wrap it up in the tortilla to add the cheddar cheese, so the cheese was still cold and dry when I started eating it--like getting a bag of shredded cheddar from your fridge and stuffing a handful into your mouth. Not my cup of tea. Maybe their breakfasts or other items were better, but the novelty factor was just not enough to make it a favorable experience in my opinion. read more

See all

Great for late-night. I've been here for several different meals at different times, and after a night at Robbie D's, it's great. Otherwise, I typically stick with healthier options. read more

Great Selection for breakfast, lunch or dinner. If your really hungry, try the biggest belly challenge, 1 1/3 lb Hamburger with all the trimmings, large order of fries, large milk shake. If you finish within 25 minutes, you get the whole meal free. I didn't take the challenge but breakfast was great and free if you stay at the Oak Tree Inn. read more

The burger I had was really wonderful and cooked just the way I asked for it. Although it doesn't seem it should be difficult to get a well done burger, it often is. Kudos to them! read more

When this place opened, it was a nice, clean place with good service and good diner food. Have been there about 10 times, but not within the past year. Went last night and there were four booths with customers. After we ordered, heard complaints from all of the booths, either about the quality of the food or the order was messed up. One table had to reorder two times and it was obvious neither the cook or waitress had a clue. After waiting about a hour (no exaggeration), the waitress came to tell me part of what I ordered wasn't available. A complete disaster. One star is too many. read more

Nice little diner and one of few places to get a non fast food breakfast at in the area on a Sunday. Not a large menu but has all you should need to fill your belly. Service was fast and friendly and price was good. read more

Love the Diner!!! Great place to eat and service is very good!!! Love the Milkshakes!!! New to the menu is a great BBQ from Darrell Hicks!! Everyone should try that!!! read more

This is our third visit to this diner, the first visit in 2012 was a great experience. The second visit was okay but this third visit was below average. The server was friendly but slow to take our order. The food arrived in 40 minutes. The food quality was not as good as in previous visits. There appears to be good foot traffic but they lacked adequate servers. read more

They have a decent breakfast but there bacon tastes old and the waiter who was the only person working at the restaurant was over worked and took a long time to get our drinks refilled. It was not his fault but the owners who made one man cashier, cook, and waiter of the whole restaurant. Also there menu is really small and most of the food tastes microwaved. read more

It was the worst. I always leave a tip when served food , this time NO! The blond waitress was more concerned about going outside for a smoke(3 times) than tending customers. The cook could only do one order at a time. When my food got there the food was burnt . How do you burn eggs and pancakes. Take from me find another place to eat when in Dexter MO read more

I eat here often with my wife and sometimes my kids. The food is great, the service is wonderful and its affordable.

don't bother. We waited over 10 minutes and were never recognized. We left and went over to Peking China, a small place at the end of the strip center and it was very good. We would give it 4 stars. read more