searching Yelp for local pizza places, I came across Peel Pizza which looked familiar as well as delicious in the pictures. I was torn between ordering the meatball calzone I had set out for and the Big Mac pizza featured on the menu, opting for the calzone. considering how close the location is, I wasn't expecting a cold sub which I presume would have tasted much better had it not been cold enough for the cheese to be barely melty anymore but thankfully, the portions are large and reheat well. The bland sauce is what made me think this establishment is a second location to the one I originally tried years back in Hingham which was just as good especially when served hot. But the sauce was just as watery and bland as before-honestly looks as bad as it taste, red colored dirty water that only makes the calzone soggy because the sauce has no consistency to adhere to the bread when dipping and quickly absorbs if poured over the calzone making use of the "sauce" impossible unless ruining your meal. The calzone appeared to be lacking the main ingredient, meatballs, but upon getting further into eating, they use a thin sheet of meat lined under the dough that does not balance well with the amount of cheese used which also offers no flavor on its own. honestly, the best thing about this place is the brick oven crust but with the severely lacking flavor, it's disappointing seeing the overlooked potential for greatness continues. Garlic, salt, pepper and oregano go a long way; at least utilize the "holy trinity" of your cuisine. read more

See all

Quick and friendly service. We grabbed a pizza to go, the space itself was clean, organized, and inviting. We did a 1/2 and 1/2 pizza - parmageddon and tuscan. Both were delicious. The solid Neapolitan pie. We'll be back! read more

Peel Pizza - Half Parmageddon Signature Red Pie half Tuscan Signature Red Pie - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

As a Jersey native, I am very particular about my pizza. That being said, I am going to miss Peel. To me, the best Peel pizzas are their out there combinations of toppings. Take for example the Ski Lift, which features potato of all things on the pizza. It works! I loved the meat pizzas, the veggie pizzas, sometimes I was a rebel and got both! Always happy. It also was so easy to order pizza by text. The hardest part about picking up your order is finding parking. This was always our default pizza choice. read more

Peel Pizza doesn't get the recognition it deserves. Thin crust options are severely lacking in the south shore. There are tons of Greek pizzas and bar pizzas but surprisingly very little reliable thin crust choices. I think Peel Pizza hits that spot perfectly. Their small size is pretty huge and have a wide range of topping options. Get the grilled blackened chicken, you won't be disappointed. All my experiences have been through delivery and haven't had a bad pie there at all. read more

The choices were terrific we had trouble picking only two Pizzas. The food was done quickly and delicious. read more

Really disappointed. We ordered 3 pizzas tonight (Saturday) for my family. I included a Gluten Free pizza in the order for my sister who suffers from a severe gluten allergy with celiac disease. The order came and the Gluten Free pizza was made on regular dough instead of Gluten Free dough. I called at 7:45pm to let them know that the order was incorrect. It took a few phone calls to get through to them as no one was answering. When they finally picked up, the guy on the phone told me they were closed and wouldn't let me speak. When I explained to him that we were missing the Gluten Free pizza and that a family member has an allergy, he just yelled at me saying they were closed again and then hung up on me. Their hours online say open until 8:30pm; so I called 45 minutes before their closing time and they refused to help. Not only was this really disappointing as a frequent, longtime customer, but it's also concerning that they're dismissive of an allergy. Luckily, we order from here very often so my sister knew by looking at the pizza that it wasn't on the Gluten Free cauliflower dough. If this was another customer with celiac disease who ordered from Peel for the first time, they wouldn't have known the difference, would have eaten the pizza and could have gotten very sick. Peel has been our go-to for years now, but we won't be coming back. read more

I'd give them four and a half if I could, prompt service and great pizza, thin, crisp and flavor

Ordered three pies from DoorDash and it was a quick turnaround on a busy rainy Saturday night. Really loved the arribbiatta! Think "wood fired thin" vs NY style pizza. read more

This was a super letdown after having such a great experience at the Hingham location. I arrived a few minutes early, but overall it was timely as they handed it to me right out of the oven. I then had a short 9 minute ride home, only to experience shame and disappointment. It sucks when you talk up the food to guests, only to have everyone be super unimpressed and full of regret after the meal. Ordered wings, 1 large cheese and 1 large clam chowder pizza. The wings were well seasoned, and I like that they don't smother them in any sauces and let the plain flavor shine. However these wings were overcooked and super dry - no indication of any moisture left. An order came with 9 wings. Now onto the pizzas - both were also incredibly overcooked. The crust and dough were so dry, that our mouths and teeth were sore after dinner from pulling, shredding, and trying to chew. Literally cut up our mouths because they were sharp croutons at that point. Also had to actively search for clams on the clam chowder pizza - found maybe 8 tops. Overall such a disappointment since we had great wings and pizza from another location and were excited to try to Milton one. Will not be ordering from here again. Ordering/delivery also available through doordash and ubereats. Street parking can be a pain around dinner time and will likely have to double park to run in and grab. read more

Peel Pizza - Clam chowder - white pizza with clams (or lack thereof...), bacon, potatoes. - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

See all

Bad luck with Peel several years ago due to dirty ovens. Figured I'd give them another try. Went in and ordered a large 1/2 pepperoni. When I came back I was told I ordered plain cheese. My 10 yr old piped up 'no she said 1/2 pepperoni'. Not too big of a deal. What was more off putting was the girl ringing us up had food stuff all over her mouth- like she had bitten into the worlds biggest powdered donut- and it was STILL there 40 min later when I went to pick up the pie. Really stomach churning for a food services business. read more

Good local pizza! We order it for lunch and they are friendly and timely! What more could you ask for!

I ordered a pizza and a salad for delivery using their text to order feature. When the driver came he only had a pizza. I mentioned that I had ordered a salad and it wasn't on the invoice. He also mentioned that I didn't include an apartment number, which I did, so they are clearly still working on this system since there were apparently multiple errors inputting my order. He basically just shrugged it off. I decided to call and get the salad, because when only half our dinner came that was obviously an issue. The girl on the phone was actually nice and said it would be right out. I said i would be happy to order the larger size salad to make it more worthwhile for the driver. Minutes later I got a call back from a man who acknowledged it was their mistake but basically said "too bad" we won't be sending it out because we don't want our driver to make another trip because we are busy. I tried to discuss resolution and he hung up on me. Truly disappointing to receive such awful service from a place I previously enjoyed. read more

Peel Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

pizza is good but service was subpar at best. I had to wait three hours to get my pizza, I ordered it before hand on the website and the workers say that there was a "confusion" with my order. Then waiting three hours for a replacement pizza when they kept saying that it would take only 20. If you value time, do not go to this establishment. read more

My name is Jarrett Sweeting. Peel Pizza in Milton is Horrible. My large calzone was the equivalent of a large sub. But thats not the worst part. The pizza that I ordered for my son was a sick joke. (SEE PICTURE) i opened the box to find all the cheese and all the toppings in a pile on one side of the box. HORRIBLE. Merry Christmas to you to Peel Pizza. FIRST AND LAST TIME I ORDER FROM YOU GUYS. You deserve negative stars. UPDATE!! JANUARY 2019 Brendan the owner of peel pizza mad this situation all better on Superbowl Sunday. He delivered a large calzone a large hawaiian pizza and an order of wings that were absolutely perfect. Now I can say that I will order from Peel Pizza often in the future. 5 STARS read more

Peel Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

First time there for lunch today! Picked up a slice of pepperoni, and it was DELICIOUS! I'm very picky and like a high quality crust, and this delivered just that! It was on the thinner side (which I like) and crispy!! Can't wait to order more combinations! read more

Probably the worst Lasagna I have ever had from a restaurant. Quality akin to just above inedible cafeteria lasagna. Ground hamburger meat, flavourless tomatoes, overcooked ricotta, and rubbery sponge mozzeralla, drowning in grease. You would be better served buying a discount frozen entree from your local supermarket. A marked step up in culinary effort. read more

Peel Pizza - Beef Lasagna - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

The employee I encountered was very rude. I asked him I asked him about their service he gave me a Blank Stare. Maybe there's a big language barrier problem. I was getting ready to put in a pretty sizable order and he said that we open up at 11:30. Because he was smirking at me as we were talking which put me off I told them I'm no longer interested in doing any business with him and left. I was also concerned because I never got an answer whether he delivered or not nor did he seem to be interested in bridging some type of communication in what I was trying to do and virtually no empathy. I hope others have had better results than than I. read more

BEST PIZZA IN BOSTON!!! I ordered twice, once on UberEats and once take out. The pizza is delicious. You get to choose your own CHEESE! They have a list of them. The crust is thin. The pie is not over baked. The taste is so good, you still think about the pizza afterwards! I am a vegetarian so it's great I get to choose my own toppings as well. I usually choose caramelized onions, mushrooms, olives, garlic with BURRATA cheese. It looks amazing and taste amazing! read more

Peel Pizza - a pizza with mushrooms and cheese - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

Ordered from here last night to support local business and wish the pizza was better than 3 stars. What we really loved was the chicken wings, now they would get 5 stars if I was reviewing just those. But, the pizza, not so much; we ordered takeout and when we got the pie home it was cold. We ended up heating it in the oven, the pizza was super thin almost too thin to pick up. We got 1/2 bada bang and the other 1/2 was wheelhouse. They were both tasty, but the crust was just too thin, not crispy at all. When you call the staff isn't all that friendly either. I don't know if it is a language barrier or not, but usually you say goodbye at the end of a call, not just hang up. If I order again from here it would be for the chicken wings and maybe a salad, but definitely not the pizza again. read more

Really bad service - I ordered 3 pizzas and one was cooked wrong. Not a big deal except my son has allergies. I would not order from this Peel Pizza again. While Peel indicated they would recook and deliver a pizza. The restaurant responded with a flipped "yeah we will get it to you when I can". Poor attitude. I called back a couple times with no real care or concern expressed. 2.5 house after my call, after my son already went to bed a very cold pizza was delivered to my door. Such a shame. Why not apologize and offer a refund if you are too busy and/or don't care? read more

Second time in a row that we ordered and had horrific customer service. First time delivery was over 1 hi late. This time delivery was canceled, we were told to pick up pizzas and when I arrived the pizza was not even in the oven....never coming back. The pizza itself is not bad. read more

Hate to say it, but 2 hours later than they said, and a salad that was less than appetizing. Tough night. read more

Peel Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

Phoned yesterday to confirm I could get two pizzas delivered for 5PM as a gift to a client moving into a new home. "Gentleman" asked me to call early to place my order. Just hung up a few minutes ago when the same "gentleman" told me no delivery service available today. When I reminded him of our conversation yesterday, he was adamant that he could not honor what I had arranged with him. Way to not run a business! read more

This place advertises free delivery. I called and they said well we only deliver in the town of Milton. Felt very discriminatory as i live less then a mile from them but in a different town and literally down the same street. I guess i should spend my money in my own town. read more

The food is good but the service leaves a lot to be desired. I don't pay their expensive prices for crappy service. 1. The other day i called to place an order and the guy hung up on me halfway. So i call back and ask him why he hung up on me. And he said "i couldnt hear you." Like what???? So i just said thanks and went elsewhere 2. I went in to pickup an order i had made. He gave me 1 of the items from my order and i tell him i also ordered a salad. Hes like "i know" ... so he puts all my stuff on the counter and i ask him if he has a bag. He basically throws the bag at me for me to put all my items in the bag. Also i ordered a green salad (meant to order a greek salad) but anywho the green salad is lettuce, 4 tomato slices, 4 cucumber slices and onions for 8$!!!!!! Crazy price for a measly salad that probably cost them 50 cents to make. Needless to say i wont be coming back. read more

I want to like Peel but I finally gave up. We ordered delivery from them at least five times and I've been disappointed more often than not. They seem obsessed with making the thinnest crust possible to the point that the pizza tastes like you are tasting a burnt cracker . The crust is awful. read more

First and foremost... I think we all agreed that the pizza we got from Peel was the best pizza we've ever had. We loved it and gobbled it down. But, a a pizza is more than just eating it. There is paying for it and dealing with the restaurant staff. Peel is expensive. Very expensive, compared to pizza joints. For that kind of money, I want a great pizza AND great customer service. On the night we tried Peel, they failed the whole customer service thing completely. This is the first (and likely the last) time I've ever visited Peel. Starting with ordering over the phone, it was clear the guy had no interest in taking orders or dealing with the public. You know the type... they just exude a vibe that they couldn't care less about you or what you want to order. That's never a good thing. No "hello". No "thank you". No "would you like anything else". Just "yep" and a twice repeated order to get it correct. If the phone personality wasn't bad enough, the in-store personality was even worse. Zero interest in greeting a customer. Only a question "Name?" -- in the wonderful East German "give me your papers" tone of utter disinterest. Handed me the pizza, let me pay for it and that was it. ONE WORD from the guy behind the counter "Name" -- and that was it. There was one other person there and the place seemed like a ghost town -- so it wasn't like he was busy. Peel has a great product and some incredibly inventive pizza ingredients. But I am sick of spending money at places where the workers just don't care at all about their jobs, the customers, or their products. Funny how, after eating the best pizza ever, I'm left with a memory of the crappiest customer service. read more

Ordered pizza to be delivered at .7:15 PM. When pizza hadn't arrived by 8:15 PM I called them. Asked who I was, my name, address, and why I was calling. Then he hung up on me. Pizza never arrived by their 9PM closing. I was treated rudely! Made to feel like dirt!!! I will NEVER do any business with Peel Pizza. read more

Well for something that cost three dollars at the most to make you could at least put some cheese on the pizza. I would not give you a half a star go back to the recipe and learn how to put cheese on the pizza. WAY OVER PRICED. Soon there will be no need for comments because you guys are cutting corners you will not have any customers. Pay attention and put the right amount of cheese on each pizza.I would like a refund it was that bad. Michael MAY 857-243-1611 read more

Honestly, the pizza is pretty good. Good enough that I have repeatedly put up with atrocious service. I would say 50% of the time they get the order incorrect. I call to point out the error and I am treated like it is my fault my pizza is wrong. They never offer to replace the pizza or credit me. Their delivery system is a joke. If they say 60 minutes it's gonna be 120 minutes. I try to circumvent working with them directly and going through Uber eats. Two times in a row now, Uber eats has said About an hour and it's taken two hours. Uber eats has indicated the delay is due to peeled asking for more time. Again, when they get it right, the pizza is super yummy. Just not sure I can put up with all of the mistakes, poor service and delays in delivery. read more

Best pizza in Massachusetts hands down! They would get a 5 star if they delivered to Braintree

Excellent thin crust pizza! They quickly prepared our pizza for take out and have tons of cool options to choose from. I also appreciated the generous cheese! read more

It is great to have a new pizza place in Milton. Cudos to the owners of Peel for the considerable investment in opening up! I am a very picky pizza eater and I prefer Neopolitan pizza. As in my disappointing review of Santarpios I will list pizza that I love for reference. Frank Pepes, New Haven/Chestnut Hill Stoked, Brookline Totonos: Coney Island DiFara: Midwood Brooklyn Juliana: Dumbo Brooklyn and Eataly, at the Pru (if you can stomach the crowd) I think that the thing that these examples have in common is a well fermented, yeasty, salty crust. Thin but not cracker thin. There is firmness to the crust but a chewy, light bread like quality to the interior. The other three components of high quality pizza are pretty straight forward. Fresh high quality mozzarella, olive oil and crushed tomato's. I have not tried the other Peel locations but I assume that they make and rise their dough at a central location. For me the crust is too much on the cracker side, not enough chew or yeasty flavor complexity that only comes with long, cold rising. The sauces are fine but I don't believe that they are using fresh mozzarella. All of this is probably in an effort to control cost. If this is truly the case, I would prefer to pay a bit more for the quality and components that I describe. Again, it is great to have an upscale alternative in Milton. Compared to the uninspired and flavorless Pat's I would give Peel 4 stars (and will almost certainly continue to be patrons given the options). However, compared to my list, 2.5 stars is all that I can muster...sorry. It would be interesting to know how others (and the owners) feel how their pizza compares to those listed above? read more

the worst service I have ever experienced. I ordered 5 pizzas for a party, more than 90 min before desired delivery. The pizzas arrived cold and an hour late. I called 4 times to check not heir arrival and the last call the person hung up on me. They have a great selection of pizzas on their menu but who cares when it is the worst experience. And it was on a wednesday night no less. DON'T BOTHER!!!! read more

One of the best pizza places I've ever been to! For multiple reasons: 1.) the staff is incredible. The manager (maybe owner?) was extremely personable, offered advice on what to order (which we're glad we listened to, our food was great!), and was generally just such a nice guy. Everyone we interacted with in there was awesome! 2.) THE. FOOD. WAS. INCREDIBLE. We got the bada bing pizza, two calzones, wings, and the garlic cheese bread. I was blown away by everything we ordered, it was all DELICIOUS! Highly recommend this place for anything from gourmet pizza to your classic cheese pizza. So good! read more

What an awful waste of my time. Walked in and took a menu. Ordered a pizza and salad. Place was very cold even with my jacket on. Guess I'm taking it out. Too cold to eat here. Now I could see they were cleaning so asked if we were too late. But guy said no problem we ordered just in time. Then I asked about the salad. They showed me not what the menu said. "Oh we changed it". Ok. Well it looked ok. Clearly it was a different salad on the menu but probably what they had left over. They just would add olives and dressing. Still ok. Now the guy started ringing it up. What did you get? I told him. Large? Yes. More ringing. He then put salad in bag. More ringing up. He said he's only charging me for the salad. It's too late for the pizza?!? I'm like you just told me you'd make it?! I wanted a pizza. The salad was a side. What a waste of my time. I hope another local place is still open after this nonesense. Never go here again. Luckily I'm writing this waiting for a good pizza from somewhere else. read more

We've had it twice and it's delicious! The pizza is thin so naturally it will turn cool quicker. Also, the wings are delicious!! read more

First off, the gluten free crust is the best that I have had in a while and there are lots of white pizza options. In addition, my family likes the regular crust as well. HOWEVER, my experience with the ordering process and interaction with staff makes me continue my search for a better option. It always takes a long time for them to answer the phone and they seem to be surprised whenever I ask for gluten free- put me on hold and then return and ask me to repeat several times, and still have gotten it wrong many times. It often takes much longer to be ready than the time I am told and they are never even remotely apologetic for this. The last time I picked up, there were several workers who didn't seem to be busy, but none offered to open the heavy door for me while I was holding several boxes. So, I really want to love this place but... read more

We've been going to Peel for a few years now, but their pizza has gone downhill. Tonight sealed the deal...I think we need a new place. The pizza was dry and flavorless. I ordered grilled chicken and broccoli...but the sauce and cheese really have no flavor so not enjoyable at all. Disappointing given the prices. read more

Great pizza, friendly employees. Would definitely recommend. I would come back for the baked chicken wings, they are great even without any sauce! read more