Stevie's Pizza is awesome on all levels, starting with taste and service. I'm especially impressed that the blizzard on Sunday didn't deter them from delivering a pizza to me all the way from Milton. Ironically, pizza places nearby didn't have a driver available, but Stevie's Pizza in Milton came through in the clutch and enabled me to enjoy watching the football game! read more

I'm giving this place 2 stars because while the employees were working extremely hard and doing their best, the conditions inside the shop were honestly unacceptable. The air conditioning was not working, and the staff were visibly sweating while trying to serve customers and keep up with orders. I understand things break, but when employees are working in that kind of heat, it becomes more than just an inconvenience. It is a basic workplace comfort and safety issue. The workers deserve better. They were still polite and working hard, but ownership needs to step up and take care of the people keeping the business running. Until that is addressed, I cannot give a higher rating. read more

Solid spot for pizza at a great price! Cheese pizza was classic - hit the spot with what we were looking for. Fries were good but I prefer thinner fries read more

Stevie's Milton - Large fries - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

See all

I love everything about this restaurant. The customer service and the food is phenomenal !!! It's an order to go place - no seating. You can order through under ways or order from them directly and their website is efficient The pic I posted is a veggie pizza with Alfredo sauce and feta cheese I have had their fried chicken (equally delicious) and their sweet and spicy/sweet chili sauce is good as well. read more

Stevie's Milton - Veggie Pizza with alfredo sauce and feta cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

I was looking forward to ordering from here because I had heard good things, but I ended up being very disappointed. We ordered two steak and cheese subs. One of them was supposed to have extra cheese. When we went to eat them, it was as if there was no cheese on them. Worst steak & cheese I've ever had. We also ordered mozzarella sticks and they were a different type than I'm used to. They weren't the normal breaded type typically received from a pizza place. I don't recommend them. read more

We want to support our local restaurants so we placed an online order at Stevie's. What a mistake. The wrong order was delivered to us and we immediately called to get it corrected. We were put on hold twice for 10 minutes each time. Since the order was our dinner and was getting cold we had to eat what was delivered. We ordered a pizza and a greek salad. We received the greek salad and a buffalo chicken calzone.The calzone was awful. It had dry chicken without any sauce inside and then had melted cheese on the outside. We've never seen a calzone made that way. Ever. The "greek" salad had a tiny amount of feta cheese and literally only one olive. We noticed the $6.99 delivery fee had also been charged a sales tax. We believe that is illegal and will look further into that. That adds up if they've been doing it for years. There are three other pizza shops within 3 miles. One has free delivery and the other two charge $3.50 or $4.00 respectfully and do not tax the delivery charge. Stevie's sent us an email asking for a survey. We filled it out listing our complaints.We didn't receive an apology just a $2 coupon towards our next order. Which will never be used. We will continue to use Pats Pizza in Lower Mills. Much higher quality food, lower prices and a reasonable delivery charge (not taxed). Unlike Stevie's. read more

It has been a few long years since I found a really good steak and cheese. I took a chance and ordered it for delivery after reading a few reviews. Fresh, neat presentation, good taste and neatly packaged. Will definitely be returning and will definitely be going in for order in and trying other things. The cheesecake is also delicious read more

Stevie's Milton - Steak & Cheese and Cheesecake slice - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

We order from here at least once per week. Food is always fresh and delicious. I especially love their steak and cheese subs, chicken parm calzones and their Greek foods like the individual Spanikopita. Delivery is great too! Foods arrives fast, accurate and still hot. read more

We gave Stevie's a try a few weeks ago for our weekly pizza night and overall, feedback was mixed. Delivery was lightning quick and I was overjoyed to see that there was a pesto pizza offering as one of their specialties. Sadly, it underdelivered; that pizza tasted hard like cardboard and it didn't have enough toppings. My hubby, on the other hand, really liked their meat lover's pizza and would order again. All in all, I'd try again and maybe stick to something that is made more regularly like their cheese pizza. I do love to support local small biz after all! read more

Ordered from there tonight because I wanted to try a place I never had before. Got chicken strips, curly fries and Mac n cheese. Arrived cold and delivered upside down so the Mac n cheese was all over the place. Whatever, I'm hungry from waiting so I dig into the Mac n cheese. It's black peppered Kraft Deluxe so that's an automatic 0. The curly fries were probably decent when they were hot. The chicken strips are just ok, not much flavor but edible. Not worth a return visit for me. read more

Excellent sandwiches at this place. I ordered a sandwich for delivery through Grubhub and was very happy with the flavor and the portion size. Everything on the sandwich was fresh and the ingredients were of excellent quality. I will surely be ordering from this place again. read more

All these reviews have got to be fake, the pizza was garbage slop, dominoes is better. Fries tasted a week old

Amazing pizza! Very nice and fast service. Well priced for such a large slice of pizza. I like his yellow hat.

Got chicken parm with penne pasta. It's a large portion, but the entire top was melted cheese, which is never a good sign. Chopped up bits of what send to be a chicken patty (rather than fresh chicken) melted to the cheese on top. Since chunky tomato sauce which must be layered on before they melt the cheese, because very little of it ever makes contact with the overcooked penne that seems like it's probably been sitting cooked in water for hours before being added to make the dish. So instead of sauce, the pasta gets only the giant pool of water that it sits in at the bottom of the dish with just a hint of tomato from the bits that dropped off of the melted cheese. All this for 17 bucks. If it cost less than the competition, the poor quality could maybe be more understandable, but for almost 20 bucks this garbage is inexcusable. I won't be making this mistake twice read more

A++ food & excellent service, delicious deserts & super friendly staff........... ........ ........

Was in the mood for a cheesesteak and was very disappointed. I asked for mushrooms, onions &banana peppers. It was an unappetizing mushy mess the steak had no texture, there were no visible mushrooms but a few specks, the onions were plentiful and all of five banana peppers. I could not eat it. A salad would have been a better choice. read more

We had greek salads with chicken and some calzones. Everything was fresh and cooked to perfection. In one word, Delish!

Everything I have ever ordered was more than satisfactory. I am usually pleasantly surprised.

I hate not supporting small businesses, however we've given them 3 tries and sadly the rating is warranted at this point. Over the 3 different times we've ordered, they have either messed up our order, charged us for a wrong item, and/or the food wasn't good. This last time several people in our party ordered steak subs and the meat was clearly not good. Either they didn't wash the grill well enough (it was a bitter chemical taste), or the meat was rancid. Everyone who ordered it mentioned it right away and so it wasn't just a one off sub. Also charging an almost $7 delivery fee (this is not the tip) for anyone within a 1 mile radius is absurd. read more

As a long term resident of the neighborhood, I was excited to see what Stevies was going to offer. First, the food is delicious and most importantly fresh. Their fried options are amazing, as the batter is crisp and not greasy. Second, the process of ordering on line is super easy. Lately, as a regular customer I receive coupons offering significant savings. (Tonight....10% off order of 30 or more.) For a family of three, this definitely brings us back. read more

This place sucks no blue cheese with large buffalo chicken calzone, Do not order from here people are rude when you call. Negative stars if I could. read more

My to-go for pizza in Milton. Their online ordering is great ! Never a wait you can time it and track the order and it's ready on time. Pizza is great ! clam chowder and fish is also good. read more

Awful pizza and service. They mess up your order and all. We loved Tino's pizza in the same place so we were excited to try a new restaurant for our Friday pizza. The first Friday it was really good. It was also really busy. The next Friday they were not answering their phones and had adjusted their website to have closed really early like before 6 pm in the evening. Later on I was able to get through by calling them. After that Friday we have yet to get a good pizza again. Plus last Friday they put the wrong topping on for the second time! I would recommend going down the street to the Mattapan House of Pizza for a pizza Very good! read more

Every neighborhood needs a reliable, crowd-pleasing spot like Stevie's! Great pizza, calzones, and American.

Really friendly service and fast pick up. Greek pizza with the best crispy and buttery crust. Big fan of this new pizza restaurant.

Great add to the neighborhood. Friendly and good food plus always appreciate the gluten-free options!!

Food is anything but sub par. Whoever decided to sign off on the pizza being cooked and styled the way they make it should be fired. Pizza shouldn't feel like your chewing gum. I asked for crispy and it was a floppy greasy pie. Ordered as they opened and took an hour an 20 minutes. Mind you I live relatively close so I didn't understand that. You guys opened in MILTON. Central square. Step your game up. You don't even hold a candle to Pats Pizza. I'll give you a star for the Chicken tenders, but really that's it. Mozzarella sticks leaked some kind of liquid. Wild. Hire new cooks or someone with a bigger imagination on what food should be like for a pizza shop in a high traffic area. Godspeed read more

Veggie pizza: Crust is very buttery, vegetables are plentiful and fresh. Pizza is dry because of the lack of sauce.

Just ordered a steak and cheese sub. It was spectacular. Online order process was super easy and efficient. Really great app that lets you customize to your desire. Delivered within 30 minutes. Food was hot and exactly as ordered...and was spectacular! Will be a regular here! read more

Stevie's Milton - Too good to wait for a photo!! - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

Reliable source of comfort food prepared well, and at a fair price. Stevie's has an extensive menu. Chicken tenders are GREAT! Pan pizza tasty. read more

steak and cheese calzone. slaps. the best in milton slays teriyaki chicken wrap was too good to be true uwu

I never leave reviews. But this place has the best wings in all of the Boston area. I'll never go anywhere else from now on. Best wings hands down. read more

Not good at all.. cheap ingredients / all bought pre made or something so bad . Get take away from across the street or around in lower mills read more

My friends and I love a mean buff chic calzone and this place DELIVERS. My buddy Parker is so hungry and Stevies is just what he needed. My friend O man is vegetarian and Stevies were able to suite his needs and that's all we could ask for. As for me, I love throwing back wings and pepperoni pizza like it's 1997 and Stevies does just that. It's not a pizza place Milton wanted but rather a pizza place we NEEDED. Goodbye Tinos hello STEVIE'S! read more