1. Paws Resale Shoppe

1. Paws Resale Shoppe

0

Highland, IN

Cancel

Open app

Search

Paws Resale Shoppe

4.5 (10 reviews)
Open 9:00 am - 6:00 pm
Updated 3 months ago

Paws Resale Shoppe Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Paws Resale Shoppe

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

3 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 3
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Amazing resale shop. Unique inventory. Wonderful staff. Not to mention a great cause to support. Plan on going back soon.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 3
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

7 years ago

A wonderful little store. Has lots of random items. I can always find something good here. Prices are great too. There mission is great too!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Love this place! Organized and helps animals! I always find something I can't live without.

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 1

Ask the Community - Paws Resale Shoppe

Review Highlights - Paws Resale Shoppe

Otherwise, clean, neat, orderly, no smells, great merchandise and for an awesome cause!

Mentioned in 3 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Antiques 874 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Michaels Resale &Consignment - Michael's Resale and Consignment offers gently used home goods and furnishings. It is a great place to shop for gifts for the entire family.

Michaels Resale &Consignment

2.7(15 reviews)
0.7 mi
$$$

The store is not super packed full of items, but there is a decent amount of things to look at…read more They have a nice set up where they are selling furniture and they have it decorated like it would be if you go into a furniture store. The place was clean and the people were very friendly. They had some interesting furniture items so I would definitely go back there once I get a place if I'm looking for something unique.

AS A CUSTOMER: This is not a bad thrift store. They have…read moresome high end furniture, things are well laid out, and clean. AS A CONSIGNOR: If you are planning to sell your items here, READ THIS FIRST. I think I've figured out this places business model. When you sell your items at Michael's, 1) you have to take pictures of the items, 2) they decide if they want to sell the items, 3) then you have to sign a contract, 4) then they will accept the item to sell. THE CONTRACT: The items are for sale at their store for a period of time (I think its like 3 months), then you have 5 days to pick up the items. IF YOU DONT PICK UP YOUR ITEMS, THEY TAKE POSSESSION OF YOUR ITEMS. I do not envy anyone running a thrift store, or consignment shop. This is not an easy business to run, peoples stuff is dirty, peoples stuff doesnt sell, you have to keep track of who gets paid, etc. I get it. I know lawn mower repair shops, automotive service shops, and storage places have similar policies; If you dont pick your stuff up, they take possession and throw it away, or get rid of it, or sell it. This policy is to encourage people to come pick up their sh**. All that being said; what I think Michael's is doing is betting on you not coming to pick your stuff up within that window of time, so they can take possession of your items and sell it without having to pay you your commission. WHAT HAPPENED TO ME: I took two items in to be sold; one sold, one didnt. I called them and told them I would be in next week to pick up the item. She said "thats fine" and didnt say anything about the 5th day window (which I knew about and had remembered from the contract, which is why I called). I came on the 7th day, and she said "oh, sorry, the 5 day window is up. The shop takes possession of the item," which I thought, meant they had thrown my item out. As Im walking out, I see my item in the window. THE ITEM WAS STILL THERE BUT THEY WOULDNT ALLOW ME TO TAKE IT. MY THEORY: So this is what I think they are doing. You give them an item and a price you want to sell it for, and they double the price when they put it on the sales floor; so they are earning 50% of the final sale price if the item sells. The problem is, when 50% is added onto what I want to sell the item for, it bumps the price beyond what most people are willing to purchase the item for (a $150 becomes a $300 dollar bed). After the time passes and the item doesnt sell, they dont inform the consignor that the time is up, 5 days pass and they take possession of the item (per the contract). At this point, they can drop the price down where ever they want the price to be. If you brought in a bed, that was marked at $300 and didnt sell, the second the 5 days pass, and they take possession, they can mark the price of the bed down to $150 (a more reasonable price) and make just as much through the sale as if they sold the item for $300 and had to pay a commission. So I think, they have created a situation where they are "banking" on consignors not being able to make it back to the store within that 5 day time frame, and then repossessing the items, then pricing the item more reasonably and, finally, making their money by cutting out the consignor. It just seems like a simple solution would be for them to send out a reminder email that the deadline is coming up, and the consignor should pick up their item. This store has a good inventory item, I dont think this is too much to ask... or be a little flexible on the 5 day window, instead of strong-arming people out of their items. I would love to see a break-down of how many items they are actually selling when the consignor is involved compared to how many items are sold after the items have been repossessed. My guess is, the majority of the items in the store have been repossessed from a consignor, and the majority of the revenue earned by this shop is from items they have repossessed. And if that is the case, all the complaints about the employees treating the customers like thieves would make sense; the employees are probably watching to see that the consignors do not come to take back their items. CONCLUSION: There is no way I would sell with this store again, especially items of a higher value. It is much easier to sell through Facebook Marketplace on my own, than deal with this place. If you are planning to sell large amount of items, or expensive items, I would recommend steering clear of this place. If you do not come back within the 5 day window, they will take possession of your items and resell them. Sell on FB Marketplace, or The Shopper. If you dont care about your items, and you are selling large quantities of things that you dont plan to pick up after the sale, ok, I could see that.

Photos
Michaels Resale &Consignment - All donation proceeds support education about the early warning signs of severe mental illness.

All donation proceeds support education about the early warning signs of severe mental illness.

Michaels Resale &Consignment - A sample of the items that we sell.

A sample of the items that we sell.

Michaels Resale &Consignment - BUY NOW or CRY LATER!

See all

BUY NOW or CRY LATER!

America’s Antique Mall

America’s Antique Mall

4.0(18 reviews)
0.6 mi

I could have sworn I wrote a review for this antique mall in the past. My first time here was…read morearound new years 1 year ago, and I've been back a couple times since- most recently NY day. Yep- that's right, they are open NY day! First of all, this place is huge! You might think you've seen it all, but then go to the far right, past the Eatery, and you will find a whole other wing to check out. I've spent hours upon hours looking at each vendors "booth" and the cabinet cases to the far left front of the store. I've purchase things from jewelry, to gilded mirrors, gold antique letter stands, wall shelving unit, and an animal skull. But I've also purchased fudge, fried pickle mix, and bourbon carmel sauce. This place has everything you need. One thing I must point out, is some of the booths have modern items, things you can buy from Amazon. So, not everything is antique or even used/second hand. But I think overall, there is a good mix. I go for the antiques primarily, but I have found myself looking at some of the modern stuff that has antique style. I love when I walk in around holidays and see booths with sale signs. I try to go straight for those, because that's when I find I get the best deal. And almost always when things are on sale, you get the best value for your money. That's not to say that I don't buy things when they aren't on sale, I will. I just get excited when I'm bleach to spend less. But be wary, one time there was a sale sign with the correct dates but when I brought the item to the front, they admitted they must have printed the wrong sign because there was no sale listed for that booth in their computer. I always double check now before buying things. Another thing to note, if you find an item and it doesn't have a sale price on it, take note of what the booth number is and where in the booth you found it, then bring it to the front. They can contact the booth vendor for you to ask what the price is. Logistics: - there is always parking- the lot is big - there are not always carts to shop (they have run out more times than not) - the people working are very nice and helpful - if you get hungry while shopping, they have eatery32 inside on the right. Great place! Make sure you have a lot of time if you want to explore everything. Or make several trips :) The people

Fake Jellycats that cost more than the real ones. So dishonest! I'm so glad that we were paying…read moreattention and my 10 year old didn't waste her chore money ($50) that she worked hard for on a fake stuffed animal. Then to top it off...they sell the dust bags (that are free if you order the real ones from the actual Jellycat website) just to try to make them look more authentic. If you sell a fake product you should clearly state that, but no matter what IT SHOULD NEVER BE MORE THAN THE REAL PRODUCT. How terrible can you be to be making a buck ripping children off? These ppl should be ashamed of themselves.

Photos
America’s Antique Mall
America’s Antique Mall
America’s Antique Mall

See all

Paws Resale Shoppe - antiques - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...