The prices for a while were great but for a few months became absolutely rediculous. The food and drinks are great but the change in prices pulled us away. Happy to say they have lowered their prices back to a reasonable amount, and we are back enjoying Pasquale's again. Thanks for realizing things were getting a little out of hand read more

I have been eating the Stromboli sandwich from Pasquale's for 50 years. The meat was what was so good about it. It was like Salisbury steak. Regrettably ii is now just a small hamburger patty. I'm going to miss eating them. So sad to see quality going down everywhere. read more

In the early 1970s, my hometown had a Pasquale's. In our teenage years, it was our hangout place. I went to this Pasquale's in Cullman, Alabama. First, the food was exactly as I remembered! My favorite was always the Stromboli beef sandwich! This, of course is what I ordered. Our server was great! She was so kind to listen to a 70 year old man, feeling like a teenager again! A billion thumbs up to this nostalgic newly remodelled restaurant! read more

I have this a 2 because the people were nice and the place is clean. By far the worst dining experience I've found in Cullman. I can't believe they charged me $17 for 12 of these wings. They were small and barely had any meat on them. The calzone is a giant dough ball and the flavors are not good. I highly recommend going anywhere but here. read more

I've seen these restaurants before, but never really thought twice about going in to eat. I do love pizza, but I decided to try the cheese ravioli, which was very delicious and it came with garlic bread or a salad, and I picked garlic bread I got a margarita on the rocks and it was better than what I've had in a Mexican restaurant. Khloe was our waitress and she was very attentive. The bathroom was very clean. I'll definitely stop at the next one I see read more

See all

Great pizza! Carry out order for a visiting swim team. Pizza was hot and fresh, ready to go. Orders several different pizzas, kids devoured and we still had leftovers! Service was good and the folks were nice. Will definitely visit again! read more

This restaurant NEEDS Gordon Ramsey!!! Food is overpriced for cheap, low quality food. Absent manager. The interior is not a good vibe. I go to support locally but it really seems like the owner could care less. read more

Old school pizza buffet with pasta and the best stromboli sandwich you'll ever eat! Great to see someone keeping the Pasquale's brand going. I loved it as a kid and it was just as good today. read more

Pasquale’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cullman, Alabama

We stopped by tonight, June 20th 2026. We seated ourselves as the sign said. A person at the counter acknowledged seeing us but never came to our table. There were a couple of servers but nobody ever came to wait on us. We finally got up to leave and the young lady at the counter condescendingly said "have a good night." Wow! Just wow. read more

Wonderful restaurant in Cullman. While my first review was "five stars when cooked right, one star when it is so over cooked" ... and we received two separate orders that were. We have ordered again after a super kind reply from the restaurant. I was told they had been working on consistency and the heat of their oven. My husband ordered a pizza to go when our son came to watch the game. That pizza was great. I am ordering again today and hope it is just as good! Thank you to the staff at the restaurant for caring! read more

Pasquale’s Pizza - Very over cooked deep dish. Cheese dry as beef jerky. - Pizza Near Me - Cullman, Alabama

See all

We are traveling cross country and stopped in Cullman Alabama for the night. We found a lovely spot that was pet friendly and were treated to some of the best pizza we have ever had. We ordered a veggie pizza with sausage and it was outstanding. The service was quick and spot on. We sat out on their porch so our pups could be with us and the waitress even brought them ice water. We would highly recommend Pasquale's. Next time we plan to try the pasta on our return trip. If you live in Cullman or are just traveling through you must stop and have some outstanding pizza and a glass of wine or a beer. Well worth the stop. read more

Pasquale’s Pizza - A couple of well loaded slices for the road. - Pizza Near Me - Cullman, Alabama

Good food!! Service was great!! Had a Stromboli steak sandwich Brought back a lot of memories Nicest Pasquale's I've ever been in read more

We went for lunch after church. We had the buffet and my teenage son ordered a pizza! Our waitress was very attentive and all the food was really good! They have a great salad bar selection too! I will definitely be back for this family favorite! read more

Ordered the roast beef sandwich for both of us. Very stingy on the meat, surprised since that's never been the case before. The cole slaw was terrible. I usually eat it but not my favorite. Husband eats it and d likes it but not today. Very bad. Prices seemed much higher than last time. All in all a disappointing trip. And we drove an hour for this. read more

Food, Service, and Ambiance were amazing! Highly recommended to anyone who loves pizza!

0 stars. Avoid this place. We walked in a little after lunch on a Saturday afternoon. We sat outside and noticed half the tables were still uncleaned after meals. We found a clean table and waited 20 minutes before our drink order was taken. We ordered an appetizer (jalapeño poppers) which fooled us into thinking the food would be good. It was the only food item we ordered that was actually hot. I ordered the roast beef sandwich with fries. My guest 1 ordered the Hawaiian pizza and my guest 2 ordered the specialty salad. The waitress said oh the salad would be less expensive if you do the salad bar but my guest wanted a freshly made salad. So noted the waitress. When my sandwich arrived it was cold and so was the gravy they poured over it. See photos. The Hawaiian pizza was cold as well. Then we sat waiting for that special salad that never came. The waitress said if you can fix it yourself or I can? So my guest went to the salad bar and made her own salad. Coming back to the table she said the place inside was disgusting and the salad bar items did not look fresh. So none of us feel okay to eat this junk. Waitress brings the ticket and on it I am charged for the specialty salad!! Talk about NO. So I reminded her of her conversation regarding the salad and so she removed the cost from the ticket. I told her I would be leaving a yelp not in their favor and she offered a free pizza . Umm NO thank you. Will absolutely positively not ever bother these folks again with my presence ! read more

See all

I am 62 years old and I have been a fan of Pasquale's since I was 6-7 years old. We have always stopped into Pasquale's in Cullman after trips to Birmingham. When I was there recently, I was excited to see all of your new renovations. I was disappointed when I purchased roast beef sandwiches. The roast beef was sandwich meat cut in cubes(it appeared) with the same gravy . My friends I purchased it for thought it was sketchy. It was not the real beef. Have you changed pizza sauce? The service was good. Just missed old food before renovations. It does look like you are still successful. The place was very crowded. read more

The ham and cheese calzone is the absolute best calzone with their marinara sauce. It has been one of my favorite since the mid-90s. I do like their meatball sub occasionally. They have really good deep dish pizza as well! read more

i have enjoyed the deep dish pizza since the reopening. Generally i buy pizza from other vendors as there is a price war currently and pasqually is more expensive. i thought though that i would splurge this time. i got this pizza to go. when i got home to eat it i noticed it wasn't as good as before. deep dish is about 1 inch thick. the crust was 7/8 thick crust with a smear of tomato paste. i dont know if they have a different chef or have decided to cheap out on ingredients. either way, it was terrible. read more

I remember eating at a Pasquales's when I was growing up. I happened to be in the area and decided to give this new location a try. The food was even better than I remember. The service was outstanding! I had the garlic cheese bread, a pizza, burger with cheese added, and an order of fries. I can't wait to go back and get the pizza! I also loved the ambience. They had one original booth in there and the rest of the place was decorated very modern and upscale. They had a very nice bar area, tvs, and a great patio outside. Definitely someplace you'd love to go and hang out with friends. read more

See all

My wife and I are from out of state and every few years we may pass through Cullman. We checked Yelp for a few ideas and settled on Pasquale's. We are glad we did! Pizza was very good. Made from what we could tell were the freshest ingredients. Atmosphere was nice. If you want to watch the game, no fears... quite a few TV's. Although we didn't drink, there is quite a large selection of beers. Overall, a positive dining experience. Next time we come through Cullman, we will be visiting Pasquale's. read more

Party of six for lunch. Seat yourself so we found a table to accommodate us. Our waitress greeted us soon after to take our beverage order. That was encouraging that the service would be awesome. WRONG! Once our drinks were delivered and it was determined we were all having the lunch buffet our server was never to return. Signs at the buffet indicated to take a clean plate at each visit. But what happens to your soiled plates? They sit on your table. We even started piling them up for easy removal. Didn't happen! Forget about eye contact, our server avoided us until, you guessed it. Time to pay. The food at the buffet was good, nothing fancy but a good verity of pizza, Stromboli, pasta with 3 different sauces. Salad bar also was well stocked. Music was louder than it should be, difficult to carry on a conversation between six people at a long table. read more

We sat at the bar, don't think that was our mistake but we ordered two half sandwiches and a side. it took an hour to get. If we had not been on vacation and no plan for the evening it might had presented a problem. The food was not worth the wait. The was a good sandwich but as a regular yelper, it always is disappointing to post a mediocre review. The bartender tried to keep up with the bar and food orders but you can tell she was in a constant run. read more

The service was quick and good, pasta sauce was a little bland. The pizza and wings were good.

Service great but pizza sucked. Very doughy, loaded with cheese, sent back to cook longer and that didn't help. I want to be able up pick up my slice up eat and not cut with fork. read more

Great food and service. We enjoyed eating on the patio and recommend it highly! Pizza and drinks were served quickly and by a friendly waiter! read more