Tried this place out, as I was intrigued while in Humboldt. As someone who has eaten way too much…read moreNY pizza when in the city, I wanted to give it a try. Got a slice, but it was expensive. Slice was alright. Wasn't anything crazy, for the all meat. We also ordered a pie to eat, choosing a classic pep so we could try compare it to a NY style one. I was pleasantly impressed. It had thin and supple dough, robust enough for folding slices in half. Crust was thin style and had the crisp. It was really greasy, and the flavor was reminiscent more of NY than I expected. Was it a perfect NY slice? No, but it brought me further east than California. Best to eat it warm and heat it up. The cold version of the slice wasnt reminiscent of cold NY pizza I've had in the city. When hot, an interesting effort at doing NY style. It was just lacking an extra oomph that would make it 5. For those with extra pizza, I'd strongly recommend heating it up rather than eating it cold. I say that, even though I'm a big supporter of cold pizza. This pie needs to be warm.

Oh have the mighty have fallen....ordered a calzone, promised sausage, pepperoni, peppers, onion,…read moreetc. what I got was dough and cheese. Look at the pic, there is no lying here. $$20+ for this, don't go here or order here, thieves and liars, rip off to the first degree. Ok, just called to complain and was told - calzone is just cheese and bread unless specified otherwise, yet the ad states "A baked calzone with a variety of meats, cheeses and vegetables, typically including ingredients like pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions and peppers". You pay extra for other ingredients despite what the add says. Typical of Humboldt economics.

All Italian! Locally owned and operated!! Best pizza in Ferndale, eat in or out, or take and…read morebake. Salad bar, of course the best of the best...pizza, spaghetti and so much more! The locals hang out here!

The best pizza ever.... The best people ever…read more... Have been going there for over 20 years and it has always been consistent.

Aaaah! Best pizza EVER! Try today!!!…read more Drop by take her home or have delivered! . I've had MM at two locations!

They give their pizza great seasoning. Their pizza are great but you will have to put forth a…read morelittle more money.

I went to this little Caesars Fortuna today with my kids and we were amazed by the quality of the…read morefood we ordered and the price of the food was super affordable and reasonable. When the worker served us he was so nice and even acknowledged my kids which made our day. The worker was super friendly and made us feel welcomed. When we were waiting on our order the atmosphere around us was very clean and overall good looking. I for sure recommend others to go check this pizza place out and I'm for sure coming back.

you guys need to lay off the oil. its not edible like this. its been a year or so since my first…read morereview. quality is the same. never again.

September 11, 2025 - Fortuna, CA…read more Walking distance from our RV park, we decided to give this restaurant a try. We came in early on a Thursday and were greeted with attentive, cheerful service. Seated in a comfortable booth, we were quickly brought menus and warm garlic bread. The restaurant itself has a welcoming, relaxed vibe. The drink special was a blueberry martini, and it turned out to be both beautiful and delicious. For dinner, we decided to split the lasagna and added an extra dinner salad, along with a bottle of Robert Mondavi Cabernet to share. Both the salad and lasagna were enjoyable, and the wine paired nicely with the meal. By the time we were finishing up, the restaurant was starting to fill, so we were glad we opted for an early dinner.

Bella Italia, Fortuna, California - September 11, 2025…read more We came in on a Thursday evening right around 4:30 PM. They open at 4 PM and I think we might've been the first ones there. We were seated immediately by a very friendly server and given menus and some nice warm garlic bread. They had a blueberry martini special , which sounded pretty tasty, so my wife and I each got one. It's a very comfortable atmosphere with nice music playing in the background. They have a full bar as well as some limited bar seating. We decided to split the lasagna, which comes with a dinner salad. They have a five dollar split charge, which we are always happy to pay to have our meals come out on two separate plates. We also ordered a separate dinner salad. We also ordered a bottle of the Robert Mondavi black label Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon to go with the meal. Everything, including the martinis, dinner, salads, and lasagna we're very tasty. The Robert Mondavi wine was a good pairing for the lasagna.

Stopped at Bob's for some lunch while in town for a basketball tournament. We found seating easily,…read moreeverything was nice and clean and the service was friendly! I had the veggie burger, which was pretty good. I loved how you can see the veggies in the patty! The fries were a hit with the family and a small tip: we ordered a large and easily shared between 4 people, it's a very large portion! For a quick bite Bob's served its purpose, we left stuffed and satisfied!

Im sorry about the low review. I grew up with bobs being the staple of fortuna high school many…read morememories. Thank you for getting back to me. The reason why I mentioned the pocket pizzas was the website said they were out of stock and the young lady helping us said they were out of stock that day. Thank you, again

I love coming to this place!! The pizza is always warm and delicious! The manager lady is very…read morewelcoming! There is always a clean atmosphere. I recommend coming here!

Pizza is always ready quickly & correctly! Staff is polite & friendly. Because of these…read moreconsistencies it has become our go to place.

Our family visited the Eureka area this week, and on our drive back home, we decided to follow the…read moreAvenue of the Giants. If you have the time and you are in the area, I would not skip it. It's amazing! While we were going through, we decided to stop for lunch and stopped in at the Avenue Cafe. What a great experience! The food was great and the staff made us feel welcomed. When we arrived, we walked in the front door and found it packed. So packed, in fact, that we had to eat at their outside tables. We chose the fully outside table (versus under the cover) and found that it was a mistake...when it started raining on us. Trisha didn't even mind that we resat ourselves in the covered area. We will definitely stop there again even when we don't drive the Ave itself...the food and service was that good!

Rather standard fare but for the remote location OK. Staff are nice. Love the patio which makes you…read moreenjoy the trees across the street.

Really pleasantly surprised by this pizza spot!…read more We were coming down from the Redwoods and saw this place on Yelp. Thankfully, we decided to call an hour ahead. The wait was around 1 hr 15 min when we called around 6 PM, which gave us enough time to check in to our Airbnb and grab some groceries next door. We ordered the Garden Grove vegan pizza. It was my first time trying a vegan pizza, and I thought it was delicious. The pizza was hot when we arrived, the crust was thin, pizza was loaded with toppings, and was flavorful and filling. The staff is friendly and welcoming. Would recommend ordering out as there is little space inside for dining in. Would definitely recommend and come again.

My wife and I picked up a pepperoni pizza with black olives and garlic knots. Being from the east…read morecoast, the crust was a bit thinner than we are used to and the cheese was a bit less, but we both agreed it was a good pizza. The garlic knots were quite good. Both were improved with a bit of salt being added.

Amy was our waitress, and she made the entire experience amazing from start to finish. She was…read moreincredibly helpful when it came to choosing our drinks and appetizers. The onion rings were absolutely brilliant, and the Organic IPA was also fantastic. What really stood out was how well Amy understood the drinks menu -- she listened to the kinds of flavors we were looking for, answered all of our questions, and recommended drinks that matched exactly what we wanted. She also had a great sense of humor that made us feel completely at home. On top of that, the atmosphere was incredible -- even the people around us were interactive and engaged in conversation despite us not knowing each other. The whole night was filled with great energy, shared laughs, and an overall memorable experience.

Overall this spot was very good and a surprise for us. We came here to live out our "Virgin River"…read morefantasy and left satisfied. There was no Preacher or Jack, but our waiter was very friendly and made sure we got everything we asked for. He came from SoCal like us and moved to Fortuna to escape the crowd. I understand why and I would move too if I could. The food was great. I got the smoked wings and my wife got the tri tip dip. It was the first time we had smoked wings and they were great. Not only were they juicy, they were smoky, and tasted very healthy. Healthy and tasty don't usually go along. The tri tip was tender though my wife wanted a more crispy bun. The double IPA I got was good too. Bitter is how I like it. My wife got a cider and sweet is how she likes it. Overall 5/5 I'm not sure why people didn't like this spot, but our experience was great. The ambiance was cool, we got our small town vibe and felt the friendly atmosphere of Fortuna.