I was curious if there were any pizza places with Papa in the name other than Papa John's in the Greater Philadelphia area, and this place popped up. They had two kinds of plain pizza - regular and "Grandma" style. Both slices had excellent crust - well done and crunchy. The cheese/sauce ratio on both were pretty good - high quality ingredients on both! I could taste a lot of good flavor from both cheeses - Grandma one had pretty great tasting sauce as well. I rate the plain slice as 4.1 out of 5, and the grandma as 4.3 out of 5. On my scale, 4 is excellent (means I would drive out of my way to have the slice), so that translates to 5 stars on this site. Would love to get a whole grandma pie when I'm in this area again. read more

Papa Mario's Pizza - Plain slice, Old Fashion Grandma Pie - Pizza Near Me - Haddon Heights, New Jersey

Stopped in for a quick bite while our shopping. Ordered 2 slices of bacon, chicken, ranch. Bo it was amazing. Not a lot of seating so was going to do take out, but the guys working were so friendly and told me it was ok to stay. They were watching the Eagles game and although we didnt interact once I paid, it was like a great environment. They advertise the best wings, that'll be what I try next since they have about 15 flavors. read more

Papa Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Haddon Heights, New Jersey

You gotta love Papa Marios Pizza. I really really love the chicken wings and Buffalo wings here. The Pepperoni pizza was delicious with good melted cheese. Nice people and a awesome Pizza joint in the neighborhood. read more

We had gotten two extra toppings on a meat lover pie, onions and mushrooms, and when we looked at the pie when we got home, it looked like someone had forgotten to put the onions on and so it looked like someone just threw them on after it baked, and so they looked raw. Me and my girlfriend tried eating it, but the pizza was also very soggy, it looked like it was just not cooked enough as it was not crispy at all, the dough was very doughy, and like I said, it was honestly just one of the most depressing pizzas I have ever eaten. I also had no idea that an extra topping alone is $2.50 which is utterly ridiculous for how little of that topping they put on, on top of them forgetting, I can not recommend this place to anyone, as I feel the pizza pie is the ONE thing you should get right and if a PIZZA place can't do that, than I just wouldn't recommend... I don't want to make any assumptions, but a big reason me and my girlfriend went here was because the reviews were pretty good, but after coming here, I have a strong feeling that a lot of these reviews are fake. read more

The pizza is always FRESH & the ceaser salad is my fav!!! I absolutely recommend this place for lunch. Since the ownership has changed, the staff is friendly and makes you feel welcome. Oh and the delivery time is very fast. read more

The food here is what you would expect for a pizza shop but they are consistently above average in everything they make. It's not "artisan" like some other shops in the area but everything has been very good. The wings are nice and crispy and their hot and honey sauce is *chefs kiss*. Their pizza always hits and their fries are the best kind - the cafeteria type fries. IYKYK. read more

Stopped in yesterday on way back home. I was hungry for pizza and passed Papa Mario's on the way. Located within a strip of stores along the highway, this is a small parlor but there are plenty of seats to enjoy your food. The two employees working were extremely friendly and promptly took my order. I gave the Old Fashioned pie a try - it was delicious. Excellent mix of flavors. I've never had anything quite like it and I would definitely get it again if I were in the area. I noticed that Papa Mario's also prides itself on its chicken wings. Unfortunately I didn't have an opportunity to try those - but it the Old Fashioned was any example of the tastes offered here, I imagine they should be good. read more

Papa Mario's Pizza - a man standing in front of the counter - Pizza Near Me - Haddon Heights, New Jersey

I'm not exaggerating when I say the Chicken Rosella is my favorite hot sandwich of all time. It's just the right amount of garlicky and I don't know what you do to the roll but oooooooooh that sh!t is good. I was going to take a pic, but the camera does not eat first with this sandwich. You're going to just have to trust me and go find out for yourself. If you live close by, I suggest you get it as a lunch special, which is the perfect size with a side of fries. And THE FRIES!!!!! You know the extra crispy fries that remind you of a school cafeteria (but in the best kind of way)??? They unlocked a key memory and all other fries are now far inferior. They weren't kidding when they say "the best on earth" on their menu. Also love the bruschetta and they have the good kind of chicken tendies. I've only had pizza from here once, due to the fact that the sandwich always calls to me, but it was above average for this area. Only thing I haven't liked here is the popcorn chicken - it just wasn't anything special. Overall, this place has secured its place in our rotation of fave places and they do great work. Give Papa a call! read more

Since changing hands- no more Mario and no more bad service. Food very good and reasonably priced. Staff could not be more friendly... Ba bye Mario and your rude staff- but these new guys are great- great place for typical pizzeria food!!! read more

Papa Mario's Pizza is one of the best take out places in the area. Great prices and the food is delicious. Staff is always friendly. If you looking for good take out this is the place. read more

thanks for the crap... a round sicilian pizza really... the wings were so over done you couldn't tell the meat from the bones. pathetic. read more

If you like high quality food at a fair price, then this is your place! My family has been in this area for 60+ years so we know all the great pizza and Italian restaurants. Rolls, meat, pizza, salads, apps...this place nailed it. I know for a fact it's hard to find a place that checks all the boxes, but this place does it. It was only right to come online and drop a good review. read more

Guaranteed the best wings and pizza in the area! the owner takes pride in the food and ingredients. Give them a try you won't be disappointed. read more

As of right now working from home and this place is my go to spot! Using slice app I order a pizza and it's here under an hr! Delicious, fresh, and the best ingredients ever! My little cousin had a cheesesteak and fries last night and said it was the best he ever had and he's 16 pain in the butt and more picky then I am! I have no been disappointed yet! Next I wanna try the different kinds of pizzas and there are 2 different types of wings! Keep up the great work guys! They have great lunch specials! They are lunch portions but you get what you pay for! $$3.50 for half a cheesesteak, add fries for $1, can of coke for $1 where can you do that?? read more

I had a few slices and they were good. Crisp bacon. Also had their old style pizza which I recommend. They have $3.99 cheesesteak specials. Excellent. They chop it up fine and the cheese and onion flavor infuses the whole steak. About a 6 inch roll. Fries added for 99 cents. Highly recommend that. They have other options for the $3.99 deals. read more

Extremely poor service,food overcook. they have no clue how to cook Italian food couldn't figure out Alfredo sauce .Italian bread, garlic bread burned, soup is in nothing but broth. Unfortunately they do not make the return list. Cannot recommend them for anything. Not even a slice of pizza ! read more

We just ordered fried ravioli which were great and the sauce was amazing! The fried cheesesteak was awesome , rolls were great and we had a tossed salad which was good as well. read more

Look I'm not going to lie last night at like 12:30am I was starving so I have this place a try... I ordered online and wanted a root beer with my meal. unfortunately they didn't have it but they called me right away to let me know. customer service was amazing. I asked for them to drop the food at my door and they did just that but also called to let me know. once I ate my food cheesesteak fries and popcorn chicken. 10/10 i was beyond satisfied. will be a regular customer now. Thanks again! read more

Customers beware!!!! The owner is crazy! My fiancee left a bad Google review after we ordered a disgusting buffalo chicken pizza. The owner called me repeatedly at 11pm that night and left a few very nasty voicemails!!!! He was so rude and condescending. Very unprofessional and if you write a bad review he will harass you. After reading the Google reviews I'm not the 1st customer that this owner harrassed over a negative review. He is a bully and this is not ok. Please think twice before ordering from this place! read more

Not Sure what the crappy reviews are all about our experience was great!!!. We don't live far from Papa Mario's. We were looking for a good pizza and we tried Papa's for the first time. The women's that took our order was very friendly. The old fashioned pizza was excellent. Crust was crispy and it was really good. The wings were very large and we enjoyed them. In addition they have a special where you get a mini cheesesteak for $4 and it was very good. Liked it so much we ordered a second time a few days later and when I went in I met the owner Mario. He was friendly. read more

Awful customer service. Contacted grub hub/yelp after my order didn't come for 2 hours. They were told they were busy and it would be here in 30 min. I said I didn't want it anymore. RIDICULOUS read more

First time here not from the area. Live about 2 1/2 hours away in North Jersey. Ordered regular cheesesteak with delicious homemade roasted red peppers. It was delicious. Service was great and they were very kind and friendly read more

The only thing wrong with this place is we don't have one near our house! We stopped in quite by accident traveling back from CT home to the DC area. We ordered a chicken cheesesteak with these amazing roasted red peppers and a slice of cheesesteak pizza with a fantastic homemade red sauce on the side. Absolutely fabulous! We will be back! PS I wouldn't trust food this good to the delivery hands of GrubHub. Come in and get it while it's fresh and hot! read more

I love the food here!!! However, after placing an order for over $40, why must a delivery change be charged?

The food is wonderful but when u r told 1 hr for pizza and wings and fries. Thats a problem.

My new go to. Best Sicilian pizza in the area Wings were big meaty sauce. Was thick. My wife loved the Mediterranean salad The counter staff were friendly and helpful. If you haven't tried them you don't know what you're missing read more

Terrible customer service!!! Very unsanitary!! I ordered pizza they dropped the plate to cover the pizza and then they picked it up and put it on top of my pizza also I noticed they didn't wear gloves when they were seasoning/ dipping my buffalo wings.. I'm very disappointed with their services and I would not recommend them to anyone!!! read more

i ordered food at 5:30 today. it is 7:12 and i'm still waiting. i called to ask about our order and the man who answered the phone hung up on me. (all i said was "hi, we placed an order at 5:30?") and he hung up. never again. read more

We have ordered from this establishment on multiple occasions, continued to make mistake after mistake and always gave them another chance. After countless messed up deliveries and always at-least an hour late on delivery we will not be ordering from them anymore. Sad to say their food is good, if it's correct. They need to work on their customer service or how to run a kitchen properly so people aren't sitting around, wasting their night on wrong food that was delivered late. read more

I am giving a 4 star review because their food is consistently delicious. With that said, we will not be ordering in the foreseeable future. Two weeks ago we ordered and were quoted a 35 minute wait time, which we know from experience is closer to 45/50, and ended up waiting an hour and a half for our food. Even with that, we called again this evening to order and the woman who answered the phone was both arrogant and abrupt. It's unfortunate, as we love supporting small businesses; especially during this pandemic. So disappointing. read more

I had my husband's surprise birthday party catered by Papa Mario's Pizza. Our guests raved about the food....chicken parmesan, meatballs, sausage and peppers, baked ziti, wings, sliced hoagies, and tossed salad. I would definitely use Papa Mario's Pizza again for a catered affair. I was so very pleased to hear that our guests really enjoyed the food! read more

Horrible customer service!!! They don't care about their customers!! I do not recommend this place!!!

They do an excellent burger, fries were great and the cheese steak was well priced for what my coworker got (forgot the fried onions though). I'd suggest them for anyone looking for good lunch specials. read more

Moved to the area a couple months ago and was so happy to live near this spot. I fell in love with the pizza at first bite LOL. The old fashioned pizza is definitely worth trying ! Their cheese steak is hands down the best one I've ever had! Lastly, their jumbo wings are just perfect. Yes they may have some kinks to figure out as far as delivery and customer service but you can tell that their food is made from fresh ingredients so if you can overlook some of their kinks you definitely won't be disappointed! read more