Papa Johns Pizza

Love this place! Beautiful old building, nice & comfortable inside. Staff super friendly, Jen was…read moreour server. Kept our drinks full & served us with a smile. I enjoyed the chipotle shrimp burrito, delicious & exactly as i had hoped. Not loaded with shrimp but had avocado & black beans, yum! My mom had a Lucky Duck burger with onion rings, she said the best ever! Hubby had the fish tacos, blackened & very much enjoyed. Slow paced but we weren't in a hurry.

We have visited this place twice this past month. Both times disappointed in the food. Strictly…read morebar food at this place, wings and burgers. I had a subpar burger the 1st time. Got lured in with the "Hand Made, No Filler Crab Cake". I know there's not many good ones north of Maryland, but this was pathetic! Go here for a drink and the bar atmosphere, salmon salad is pretty good. Stay away from the entrees.

Menu Logo

See all

T J Rockwell's

3.1(360 reviews)

1.7 mi

5 Stars! One of the Best Burgers I've Ever Had!…read more What a beautiful day to enjoy lunch outside at T.J. Rockwell's! After a long bike ride, the sun was shining, the weather was perfect, and the outdoor deck was such a nice, relaxing place to sit and enjoy a great meal. I'm not just saying this, but the burgers were honestly some of the best I've ever had! I ordered the Montreal Burger, and it was absolutely incredible. So tender, juicy, perfectly cooked, and full of flavor! The other burger looked amazing as well. The fries were delicious, and being able to enjoy a Troegs IPA with everything made it even better! Between the beautiful outdoor atmosphere, great food, and excellent service, this is hands-down one of the best restaurants around. Such a wonderful place to relax, enjoy the sunshine, and have an incredible meal. Highly recommend! I'll definitely be back!

Used to a favorite of mine when we were visiting the area. The menu has been changed & my favorite…read moresandwich the Ruben & the Rachel are no longer available. I tried something different, the grilled chicken & tortellini salad. I imaged something completely different that what arrived at the table.... Let's just say i am not the intended audience for hot temperature ranch dressing or this item. I must be odd because i noticed this has been on their menu for a while. My mom had teriyaki chicken stir fry & husband had fish tacos; they enjoyed their meals just fine. Decor in the bar is cute, empty gold frames & mirrors on black wall.

Schnitzel BLT

See all

Meatloaf Stack

Hennigan's Restaurant And Bar

3.1(50 reviews)

2.7 mi

Good food and terrific service. Our server, Lauren, was a gem and took great care of us. My one…read moregripe is that they charge $3.50 for soda, with no free refills. My husband had two beers and it only cost $2 more than my two sodas.

This is located in the bowling alley. Doubt they are part of the alley. Really friendly place. Most…read moreyou will see are bowlers who stop through afterward or between sets. The food selection is plentiful. From light eating to stuffing yourself on pastas. I have enjoyed several things from this place. And never have I had any complaints. Above par food with good portions The staff is really attentive, talkative, and friendly. Anytime I am at this tournament. This is my go-to place. I've been to several places in the area, and they did not stand up to this place for taste, portions, or friendly service.

Inside bar

See all

Country Meadows Restaurant

3.9(56 reviews)

1.4 mi

Great family atmosphere with fresh, homemade meals, and huge portions for very reasonable pricing…read more The servers were all welcoming and friendly, and you can tell there are a lot of regulars that return often. The place is always packed and we always need to go boxes because the portions are so large. The owner is always seen checking on her customers and you can tell she truly cares. This is our favorite place to eat with our kids!

Cute hometown restaurant with a very large menu it was hard to decide on what to get…read more The chicken wings on the appetizer menu are so delicious. Lots of daily specials and our waiter was so nice. If you want to go to a place with a nice hometown feel this is your place.

#countrymeadowrestaurantpa #countryrestaurant #preservefootprints

Captain Nachos

See all

#countrymeadowrestaurantpa #countryrestaurant #preservefootprints

P & J Pizza

3.4(50 reviews)

0.3 mi

We love their cheesesteaks. They give you so much meat at a reasonable price. I live in Florida and…read moreI'm always disappointed in the size of their cheesesteaks here. They give you half the meat that you get at P&J's. We also like their pizza. It so hits the spot. The only downside is the parking.

I love their Italian subs! Definitely recommend. Friendly service and fast. I love the easy in…read moreeasy out.

Medium broccoli and chicken boli

See all

The slice I devoured

Babbo's Pizza

3.7(16 reviews)

0.8 mi

Food was good. We both had Pizza. Reg and sicilian. Tables needed to be kept cleanerread more

The staff was very nice and helpful. Ordered cheese pizza…read morevery bland, no flavor greasy. I can make better pizza in my home oven.

Absolute pool of grease from the Hot Honey Pepperoni pizza. Was a 10min drive and thought setting them on my seat was ok

See all

Sausage Parmesan Sub w/ Peppers and Onions

Black Gryphon

3.7(114 reviews)

1.3 mi

Best fish and chips this side of the Atlantic! Fish was lightly breaded, not greasy, and just…read moreoverall delicious. Salt and vinegar deviled eggs were also winners, and my husband said his mushroom Swiss burger was also terrific. Extensive beer list and great service topped off the evening. *I should say that when we arrived, we were informed by the bartender that they were short-staffed and it would be a bit of a wait, but believe me, it was well worth it!

Service was excellent The food was not…read more It took over an hour to get our dinner served to us. I will not be going back

Bar

Pork belly tacos

See all

Open faced duck confit sliders

E Yuan

3.7(44 reviews)

0.2 mi

E Yuan is a typical, Chinese food takeout restaurant in Elizabethtown. Prices are fair and I have…read moreyet to have a bad meal or experience. They feature the classic staples such as lo mein, sweet and sour chicken, dumplings, and so on. I have only gotten small serving sizes of dishes and its more than enough for a meal. Its a pretty huge portion. I cannot imagine what the large looks like! The only real downside to E Yuan is its lack of delivery service. Hire a delivery boy so I can get an egg roll brought to my doorstep!

2026 review. It's not good I got the general toes, orange chicken and sweet-and-sour soup. The…read morechicken is extremely bland mushy and weirdly hard in some spots. They barely give you any rice. The soup wasn't that good either in terms of flavor should have listened to the other bad reviews very bland food it smelled weird in there too like an old house that hasn't been visit

Great restaurant, especially if you like to eat Chinese food, go for it. You won't regret.

Awaiting deliciousness.

See all

Sals' Pizza

2.7(91 reviews)

2.1 mi

Pizza is great for our central PA area. Frank's Romano pizza is a fave. Not sure why the bad…read morereviews other than some of their young servers just needing some more experience with customers. Great job, Sal's- we're glad you're local!

VERY SLOW service! Ordered a pizza and was told 25-30 min…read more Waited an hour for a single pizza!

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Zoey H.

6 years ago

Me and some friends were hungry so we decided to order papa john's. We called in and ordered our pizza, my friend ordered and they asked for a first and last name so we used my moms because she had told us too. My friend had not known how to spell our last name so i tried to help her and she laughed by accident. The lady then hung up on us. We were very confused so we called again and it was a different worker who had picked up, we proceeded with our order and and the worker asked for our address and we gave it and told us that we called his co-worker inappropriate names and then hung up. So apparently my families last name is an "inappropriate name" read more

Robert James R.

9 years ago

Will never eat here again. The employees can't get a simple order correct, and when they fuck up, manager Dennis threatens you over the phone. FUCK DENNIS. They forget to charge me for one soda and threaten me if I don't DRIVE BACK to return it, which is actually illegal. You are a bad face for Papa Johns and don't deserve a customer service job. Sorry to your employees that aren't properly trained and have to deal with you as a boss. read more

Papa Johns Pizza - pizza - Updated November 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Elizabethtown, Pennsylvania Restaurants near Papa Johns Pizza

BEST of Elizabethtown, Pennsylvania Parking near Papa Johns Pizza

BEST of Elizabethtown, Pennsylvania Desserts near Papa Johns Pizza

BEST of Elizabethtown, Pennsylvania Things to Do near Papa Johns Pizza

BEST of Elizabethtown, Pennsylvania Coffee near Papa Johns Pizza

BEST of Elizabethtown, Pennsylvania Dinner near Papa Johns Pizza

BEST of Elizabethtown, Pennsylvania Breakfast near Papa Johns Pizza

BEST of Elizabethtown, Pennsylvania Burgers near Papa Johns Pizza

BEST of Elizabethtown, Pennsylvania Shopping near Papa Johns Pizza

BEST of Elizabethtown, Pennsylvania Movie Theatre near Papa Johns Pizza

People found Papa Johns Pizza by searching for…

Best of Elizabethtown

Things to do in Elizabethtown

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Papa Johns Pizza also viewed

Robertos Pizza

4.0

(52 reviews)

Best pizza place in Harrisburg Pa!! The food is always consistently amazing. I always get the large…read morecheese pizza, bbq wings, and 2liter soda everyday special. I'm obsessed with this food. The pizza is very cheesy and the wings are always big. The service is always top notch because they care about their customers. I actually used their restaurant for catering my son's birthday party in the end of January and ordered 10pizzas once I'll never forget how they were on time and the quality was impeccable.

Been going to this pizza shop since the 1990s and it's been through a few owners, BUT the guys that…read moreown it now KNOW WHAT THEY ARE DOING. The pizza is continuously great, Crust is good, sauce is good, and always plenty of cheese.

Dannys Lets Get It

3.8

(23 reviews)

The pizza crust is dry and hard to eat. It had very little sauce that was very salty. In addition,…read morethe pizza definitely needed more cheese. I will not purchase pizza here again! Service was good, but I won't return.

This place has been here for a while but today was the first chance that I actually had to go in…read morethere and grab something to eat. That happened to be in the area to me with a client and this shop was in route to my next appointment so I stopped in for a quick bite to eat. Upon entry, the dining room was full nearly every seat was taken with dining customers. I quickly approached the counter see what they had in the case which included varieties of stuffed pizza slices, paninis, garlic knots and rolls, and pepperoni sticks. The clerk quickly ran down the prices of these items and I ultimately chose turkey panini. She warmed up the Panini in the oven then packed it in a box for me to go. I had to eat in my car since, as I mentioned before, the dining room was full and no seats were really available. The sandwich was delicious and the flavors of each ingredient were discernible and complemented each other well. I think the real star of the sandwich was the House made bread. It was crunchy yet light and was just really really good! The first good impression has been made and I will definitely plan on returning to try some other items on their menu. The first suggestion I was given was to try their cheesesteaks so possibly that's what I will choose next time I visit.

Little Caesars Pizza

3.2

(12 reviews)

best deep dish pizza i ever had and even my wife who is picky said it was very good. way more…read moreflavor than PH pan pizza. perfect balance of cheese and sauce, all ingredients were flavorful and blended well together with a nice crispy crust! wings are on small side and little expensive at 6.50 for 8, more than a regular pizza so not a good deal there but were tasty. got regular and hot sauce. service was decent.

WTF how hard is it to get the order ready! These people even left a new person on the register and…read morethey went out to do trash! But before they left they screwed up my order and I had to wait even longer till they remade it! Some times I just don't get it! Such a hurry to close and get out that mistakes are flying! Been here for 40 minutes for an order that was Supposed to take 6-8 minutes! It's a good thing this pizza is cheap & I am hungry!

Pizza Al Bacio

3.8

(65 reviews)

Pizza was great NY Style thin crust not crispy but firm enough with little flop. The homemade…read morebread was delicious, but the size of the subs were small 8-9 inches only.

We have ordered from Pizza Al Bacio on multiple occasions, each time it being very good. This…read moreevening we ordered a large pepperoni pizza and a personal pizza with mushrooms. Love that they use fresh mushrooms and not canned - it makes such a difference in taste. We have never dined in, but we've gotten take out plenty of times. Our pizza arrived hot, and even when cooled - it is delicious tasting pizza! Give them a try, yum!

Pizza City

4.0

(72 reviews)

We had the all meat Stromboli and it's one of the best I've ever had. Their tomato sauce that they…read moregive you with the Stromboli is very good. Highly recommend this place.

The food is consistently delicious, service is spot on. Ambiance... like stepping into a true…read moreItalian pizza shop! It's where all the locals gos

Blaze Pizza

4.3

(23 reviews)

Top notch pizza and excellent service. Pizzas were made fresh to order and nothing was skimped on…read more 3 pizzas and 5 sodas for $40? What a deal. Not too much seating so it might be tight during a rush, but enough for when we were there. Will certainly stop in again next time we're in the area.

Blaze Pizza is fantastic! The restaurant is very clean, and the staff is incredibly friendly and…read moreamazing. I especially love their margarita pizza--it is absolutely delicious. Highly recommend!

Dimaria's NY pizza and Italian restaurant

3.5

(71 reviews)

Slice perfection !!! I'm not from Mount Joy. I was passing through the area and asked a local where…read moreto go for good Pizza, he sent me here. I got some of the best New York style slices I've had in a very long time. I ordered three slices from a fresh pie just out of the oven. Crust is perfect, slightly crispy on the bottom, not soggy. The cheese was just right. Next time I'm in Mount Joy I'm coming here again.

Our family group of 9 visited twice in one weekend because we enjoyed it so much. They were…read morefriendly and quick. We tried plain cheese pizza, calzones, appetizers and a cheesesteak. We all enjoyed our food and even enjoyed our leftovers we took home. We will be back next time we are in the are!

Hot Z Pizza

3.3

(83 reviews)