Got the buffalo chicken wings -- taste was solid, but they came out semi-cold, which was a bit of a letdown. Homemade mozzarella sticks were a hit with the kids (they loved them). The sausage and pepperoni pizza had really good sauce. Overall it could've been better though -- the server was nowhere to be found half the time. . read more

The pizza never disappoints. Always delicious with their sweet sauce Employees are always very pleasant and appreciative of your business.

Great pizza! The paper-thin crust with pepperoni or just cheese, cooked well-done and cut pie-style, is my favorite. Excellent sauce and quality ingredients every time. read more

Amazing pizza. We drive over 45 minutes oneway to pick up this gem !!! We love Palermo's sweet sauce and spicy-ish sausage read more

Palermo's Pizza was awesome. Just like the one on 63rd in the city. Was very happy to have one right here in the area. Same sweet sauce as I remember when I was a kid. An original favorite. read more

We ordered from their catering menu for a large party. Their baked mostaccioli, chicken Iimone, and vesuvio potatoes were delicious!

Waited an hour only to get the wrong pizza. Waited another hour for the correct pizza, that was good. They took the wrong pizza that sat open on my counter when they delivered the 2nd. Thought that was strange read more

First time trying the new store now on 159 th st that used to be in Tinley park. Pizza was perfect lots of cheese , sausage and tasty sweet sauce.could be our new go 2 pizza place . Hope they do well at new spot .5* pizza Didn't even know when I ordered but was told they had special pizza prices on mon and Tuesday . read more

Palermo's is one of our favorite pizza's. Love the sweet sauce and the paper thin crust (need to order paper thin to get it thin)! Always extra saucy which I love!!! read more

Unique Sweet sauce . Great tasting sausage Pizza . Top 5 joint on South side for sure . I do Pick Up only

Not Palermos of 63rd. Thought it was the other location. My bad. Well, bring it home and it was disappointing to say the least. Not to mention no masks, no gloves by counter girl in May of Covid. read more

Great Place! Food is good, delivery takes about an hour and at the end of the day I'm happy I have a solid pizzeria near my home. read more

Palermo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orland Park, Illinois

Tried it twice & both times pizza was consistently delicious! Not sure why they have 2.5 stars but they have a return customer in me!

The pizza is just OK, but the service is TERRIBLE. Ordered for pick up, and something was left off the order. No receipt was provided when the food was picked up, so nothing could be checked against. Tried calling for the past half hour, but no one is answering. Do yourself a favor and check the "not recommended" reviews... chances are this businesses pays Yelp to "manage" this listing. The negative reviews get pushed to the bottom and the glowing reviews are at the top. Do math people... don't trust a 5 star review when a business averages 2.5 stars... read more

This pizza is always good. The sauce is sweet and delicious. The delivery is always fast. I would definitely recommend this business.

Great tasting pizza (got the thin crust ssg) ~ the crust is incredible, sauce on the sweet side; online order app kind of a mess, so easier to call; but unsure why others dissed the service, the staff was friendly and on top of everything - definitely worth going back to try other varieties read more

Picked up a couple pizzas and some appetizers from this place. Drove it home only to find out one of the pizza has the wrong ingredients. I called them up and they informed me I had to bring the messed up pizza back. So I drive another 25 minutes and bring their pizza back. I asked how they were planning on compensating me for my troubles. Their answer... I was being compensated by them making me my pizza. I asked... what about the rest of my order that was home getting cold? What about my time and gas? Their response was I should reheat it in the oven. This isn't how you treat your customers. This place deserves 0 stars. Lots of better options to pick from. AVOID AVOID AVOID! read more

Best pizza in the entire world. Every time I try another place it absolutely disappoints. I'm always annoyed that I just didn't go here. When friends are having a party and they're not having Palermo's I tactfully bring Palermo's along. I think it's 20 years I've been a fan - not even the other two Palermo's are as good as this one. The sauce, cheese, dough - comes together perfectly here. U only ever order stuffed cheese w mushroom. The small lasts me several days. read more

Palermo's Pizza - a slice of deep dish pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orland Park, Illinois

I was in the south suburbs in Frankfort for a romantic getaway with my better half and we were not leaving our pool suite for one minute, so obviously we needed to order some good delivery. After some wine, cocktails, swimming and unmentionable activities - we were craving some food to really hit the spot. We called and made an order for one sinfully fat-ass meal! We ordered a small half sausage and half pepperoni deep-dish pizza, an order of fried mushrooms, 1/2 slab of ribs (came w/fries, slaw & garlic cheese bread), and a dozen hot wings with hot sauce and bleu cheese. The phone call order process and credit card payment via phone was seamless - the lady that took our order was very friendly and patient to our detailed order. She even threw in most of the extra sauces we wanted for free, voiding the annoying 50 cent charges. The food arrived promptly in about 45 minutes. The deep dish pizza was decent - the cheese, toppings, and sauce weren't layered in that classic Chicago-style manner. I felt that the "deep-dish" aspect of it was just the thicker crust and bread which was quite unpleasantly hard (that's not "what she said") from being baked in a bigger pan. Either way, it had filling slices, with a moderate amount of gooey cheese, a moderately low amount of pizza sauce, and supple amount of meat. The presentation of the pizza was top notch - it looked very appealing before we took it apart to devour! You can see it in the photos section of this listing. Sadly the presentation ousted its actual quality and taste by a bit. Still, it was definitely 'good enough' as food was the not the focal point of my evening (for once). The fried mushrooms were as good as they get - hot, wet steaming mushroom on the inside - Italian herbed breaded crust on the outside. Yum! We dipped these in hot sauce, ranch, and even a special garlic mayo they included! The wings were seasoned breaded and fried, and though they weren't sauced per se, we were able to toss them in the included hot sauce and when dipped in the bleu cheese, they were yummy in the tummy - I had like 8 of em'! The 1/2 slab of ribs had a moderate amount of meat on them, I've had meatier ribs. They were not too dry but the meat was not exactly falling off the bones either. They put such a supple amount of BBQ sauce over them that we were able to toss half our chicken wings in the sauce to make BBQ chicken wings. The ribs came with some good fries that had gotten a tad soft (understandable with delivery) and some good garlic bread that we added cheese to for 50 cents. The small side of cole slaw included helped have something fresh to bite into in all that greasy yummy mess. Overall the deep-dish was good enough to eat and enjoy, but nothing to brag about. It was nowhere near the best in Chicagoland, and don't even think of comparing it to Gino's, Giordano's or Lou Malnati's! The fried mushrooms were yummy as they usually are, the chicken wings were very good (especially when complemented with hot sauce, BBQ sauce, bleu cheese, etc.), and the ribs were above average. When staying in for the night and craving some nice greasy, indulgent food - this place really can hit the spot. I highly encourage any couples staying at nearby Sybaris or are in the area and want some affordable delivery to check this place out. We ordered a ton of food (it ate like 2 separate dinners for me and my GF, and still we had 1/2 the pizza leftover) and it came out to about a $40 bill + tip, but when you take into account that we ate 2 meals out of it and still had 4 slices of pizza to take home for leftovers - it was a pretty solid value! So really we ordered enough for 3-4 people to eat big dinners with. I would order here again! read more

Palermo's Pizza - Mix plate of Palermo's wings, fries, fried mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Orland Park, Illinois

We have been regular customers for this Tinley park location since it opened. Loved the original sauce from 63rd. Unfortunately , the last 4 times have been very disappointing. the sweet sauce has been altered. We tried it several times since the first altered pizza hoping it would change. It has not. We will have to drive to Frankfort for a great sweet sauce we miss. read more

This is probably the best pizza place with thick crust . Very delicious and fluffy !!!! So perfect guys ... delicious sweet sauce and we ordered at 8:30 and it was ready in at 9:00 pm ! Which is nice because they close at 9 . read more

Palermo's Pizza - Perfect ! - Pizza Near Me - Orland Park, Illinois

I like palermos. Always have. Sometimes it get a little busy there. But hey, I get my order, pick it up and its tastey. I loved the one on 63rd. 95th is so so. Havent tried the one on route 30 yet. read more

Palermo's Pizza - Tastey cheese and sauseege. - Pizza Near Me - Orland Park, Illinois

Great job folks. Wonderful sweet sauce with abundant ingredients and cooked perfectly as well. I feel that reviews are often focused on some small fault rather than the positives. We're in very difficult times right now with many restaurants being under staffed and/or training new people. Let's cut some slack and give people some respect. I was welcomed by some very respectful young employees who did a great job. Keep up the good work Palermos, and kudos to your wonderful kitchen and font end staff. read more

They need to answer their phones. They say try the website but it is down. How do you order a pizza? They really need to work on fixing this. They are seriously trying to lose customers this way. read more

Last night I picked up a pizza. While waiting, the manager was belittling his employees, referring to them as dumb, and dropping the f-bomb! He was also waking around with pizza hanging out of his mouth! He was mean and cruel, and completely unprofessional. I could hear him yelling at his cooks in the back, as well. The employees up front were teenagers- and, as a parent- I'm sickened that they are treated this way! We went there weekly, but will never be back again! If I could give this place a negative review- I would!!! read more

Pizza is great. I really don't understand 2.5 stars. I have never had a bad experience. Delicious every time we order.

NO STARS!!!! Horrible service! Sick and tired of them messing up my order! Put in the order, got the email it'll be here in 55 min. Got a text saying "enjoy your food " waited... never came. Called & the no clue girl working there said the order was never put in! If I did my job like this I would be fired! Ugh! So aggravating & I'm HANGRY! read more

This is the best thin crust pizza you'll find in the Chicago area. This Palermo's has a unique sweet tasting sauce that you won't find anywhere else. I recommend the thin crust. read more

This was an absolute abortion. Ordered online, received text that delivery time. Pizza never showed, tried to call restaurant 7 times, each time was hung up on. Never received order, credit card was charged and no items were delivered. DO NOT USE THIS BUSINESS read more

Pizza is great employees are friendly,web site is horrible looks like a company called spot on is helping them run the site Created an account then tried to log on didn't work. Wasted more time on this then eating the pizza .... read more

Ordered on line ready when I got there hot and tasty. Probably pass 3 or 4 pizza places to get this pizza never had a problem always good and ready when they say it's going to be ready . People are friendly have a hard time believing some of these poor ratings .... read more

The pizza sauce is unlike any I have had. It has a distinct sweet flavor. I like their thin crust the best. Their Italian sausage is a ten! The garlic pizza is also good. They seem consistent time after time. read more

Terrible service!!! Ordered pizza online and paid for it. 15 minutes before they were supposed to deliver I get a call saying that it would be another 3 hour wait. They explained that they just got there and there cook doesn't get there for another hour on top of that. See ya never ordering again!!! BTW - after reading other reviews this is not the first that they have done this to someone. read more

My family and I ordered two pizzas from them a couple weeks ago. After the pizzas hadn't showed up for an hour and a half (reasonable is their busy) we called to check on them. They said they were coming out of the oven now. Not even two minutes later the delivery driver knocked on our door to drop them off. (That was quick) All good except pizzas were freezing cold. We called them to let them know the pizzas were freezing cold. They let us know they would remake the pizzas or put a credit on the account for an order at a later date. That's good business! However, one star for these folks as we called them today to honor the credit. After a 20 minute interview about our order and questioning whom we talked to we asked for a manager. He was too busy. They said the best they could do was 50% off. Probably so they wouldn't lose money and make a small profit. Well guess what Palermos in Tinley?? You did just lose money, because you lost a consistent customer. Not the best business decision on your part. I'll go to Jewel and cook a frozen pizza before I call you again. Adios Amigo! read more

There seems to be an ongoing theme to the reviews about bad service, extra wait times and cancelled orders. I think they need to be held accountable for their actions..and quickly I would have given this no stars. Our meal this weekend was probably one of the worst take outs we had in a very long time. Parmesan chicken and eggplant with no cheese, baked mostaccoli soupy in the container with no cheese, wet soggy and cold food. And a bug on the top of our lid was the best part!! Bruchetta was stale bread with unripened tomatoes and Italian dressing. The manager or whatever it was, was rude and sloppy looking loud music from the back and dirty conditions. Do not eat here!!! A call to the health department and finding out who owns this location are our next moves. I hope the word gets out and we can hold these people accountable for horrible service and inedible food! read more

This place REALLY hits the spot if you're craving a dinner or late night chow down feast of epic cheesy and fried proportions! My bf and I had a great delivery experience with Palermo's, we ordered the food with very specific instructions on extra sauces, and little personal preferences on how we like our food, and they are probably the first delivery place ever to not mess up our order! They remembered everything we asked for and then some. The deep dish pizza was off the cheesey-fo-sheezey, and they way the packaged it kept it piping hot when we unveiled it at our table even after traveling thru 15 degree weather outside. The ribs were saucy and tender, the fried mushrooms were every bit as scrumptious as I knew they would be, their wings were fried to perfection with a little hot sauce on the side, their cheesey garlic bread and the garlic dipping sauce were phenomenal too. This isn't Gino's East or anything, but it's a damn good place to eat! read more

Oh boy, let me tell you about this one... First, and I acknowledge its just me, I don't like their pizza. The sauce is too sweet and gives me shits. Everyone else likes them, shits or not, so more power to them. But they ran out of sausage. Really? I don't know if you know this, but sausage pizza is mostly a Chicago specialty - you can't even get it in other parts of the country. HOW THE HELL do you run out of your most popular topping? And then, AND THEN... We call them, and they said yes, they have sausage this time, but they won't deliver anymore today. Should have been our sign. Two hours later, an hour after they told us it would be ready, 40 minutes after they said 20 more minutes, they won't even respond to our inquiries anymore. And I know why. They still haven't put it in the oven. Edit: So it turns out a cook walked off mid-shift. The amateur help filling the gap are presumably doing the best they can, given the circumstances. Cut the pizza through, boys, and and cut along the separate toppings. It doesn't change how I feel, there are other stories where the moral is: their operations are inconsistent. read more

The best pizza in Tinley Park. They have the best sauce and all the toppings are cooked right.

Ordered online and it said it would be 1hr 15 min, after 1hr 45min I called, they said they never got the order, I find that hard to believe since it gave me all the info, price etc. Just don't think they know what their doing, another of one of the many screw ups I've had from there. Never ordering again, Durbins has a great pizza and never screws up! read more

So, you may know by now that I am a pie fanatic. Yep, I will stalk a pie in an alley if its the bomb! Having quite the za tour this round during the holidays, I have to say that Palermo's stands out of the 6 different pies I had from different restaurants. The crust is cooked to perfection. This is your average hand-tossed style. Not overly thick to overfill you and not so thin that the ingredients fall off the slice. Just right. The knockout punch to your taste buds come from the cheese on this pie. This pie had complete coverage. The ingredients were fresh and plentiful. Also, the sauce has a nice sweet taste to it that brings you back for more. The trick with many sweet sauces is that Americans' love their sugar. Sprinkle a little in the sauce and you'll be defending your stock with dough rollers! There are a ton of pizza places in this area. It can be quite flooding in the cranium to pick the right one. If it is worth anything; I suggest you stop reading pizza reviews and order your pie from Palermo's. read more