Don't go anywhere else for your pizza in the area. Seriously, you want pizza, you're in Nags Head,…read moreyou have to order from only here. It is delicious. We ordered well ahead of time online, that way it would be ready for pick up as we passed by. After ordering, you will get an estimated time of when it will be ready. We were given a time and then made a stop before coming here. However, they are quicker than the estimated time. Which is a great thing, less waiting when you pull up, but not good if you get stuck elsewhere beforehand. Pulled in, right up to the window, let them know I had an order. Within seconds, my order was in my hands. The hardest part about this was the enticing smell in your vehicle back to your house. Totally takes over and your stomach starts grumbling. When we got back, we immediately opened up those boxes so the aroma filtered through the house. Each pizza was amazing. The garlic bread was amazing. The right amount of garlic that doesn't overpower. Then the pizza itself blows you away. Perfect crust, perfect amount of sauce, perfect amount of toppings. Made you go back for a slice over and over again. Then it doesn't hurt that there are personal touches to each box with a message. Each box has a message when you open. A nice touch from such an amazing place to grab a slice.

So many options here. Both of the pizzas we had were so good. It's take out only but totally worth…read moreit! everything is fresh and fast!

Super nice staff, beautiful sound views, only complaint was my garlic mushroom pizza had either…read morepepper spill on it, or my English taste tastebuds (that can handle curry AND Cajun) couldn't bear it. But it had several.tablespooons of pepper making it inedible for me. I ended up passing it over to my partner to eat. The crust was delicious though!

Kept hearing this place was the best pizza in the area. Well the staff were very nice. They are…read morefamous for the big 28 inch pizza and you can get by the slice. Got the cheese and the crust was good like a NY slice. The sauce seemed like very low quality and the cheese was mediocre in taste. They have a great place to sit facing the sound and stay out of the nasty weather. If the weather is nice you can sit outside.

We almost let the reviews talk us out of trying Firetender, and I'm really glad we didn't…read more My daughter ordered the mac and cheese, and somehow it ended up being one of the best things on the table. We were unofficially judging grilled cheese and mac and cheese all week, and this one absolutely held its own. I ordered the Smash Burger Pizza, and I was skeptical until the first bite. It somehow captures all the flavors of a really good smash burger, complete with the tangy "special sauce" flavor, pickles, beef, cheese, and onions, but on a wood-fired pizza crust. It sounds a little ridiculous on paper. It works. I also accidentally ordered one of their cannabis-infused cocktails because I apparently skipped over an important word on the menu. It did exactly what it promised without sending me into another dimension, which was appreciated. The only downside was that I spent the rest of the evening happily eating leftover Smash Burger Pizza and wondering why anyone would order anything else. The atmosphere was laid back, the service was friendly, and we'll always say anything positive about anyone who helps take care of our sweet little one. We'd happily come back the next time we're in Manteo. Don't let the current rating scare you away. We almost did, and we'd have missed out on one of our favorite meals of the trip.

We got takeout. Brussels sprouts (without the bacon) were delicious. Also got a mushroom pizza…read morewhich was very flavorful and good though I expected it would have more mushrooms. Would order again and probably try the margherita pizza next time.

Pretty solid spot. Tried a sausage and pepperoni pizza. I'd get it again for sure. Check it out!read more

Great place to order pizza to bring back to your hotel. The order was ready right on time and the…read morequality was quite good. Was it NY style? No, based on this Brooklyn native's experience. But the crust was well done while still having sufficient flop. The sauce was savory and there were plenty of toppings.

Large order delivered on time and food quality was excellent. Would definitely recommend and order…read morefrom them again in the future.

Figured I would start with the lowest on the OBX totem pole. The pizza was average at best…read more Thankfully I have other pizza places in the area to recommend, bc this ain't it. The pizza felt low quality. High bread density, cheap sauce, and overall bland. If you live there and never venture out to any pizza beyond this block I understand the reviews. Otherwise, come on people?! Mediocre! Do not recommend. Venture out to Nags Head for far better options.

This place was excellent! Super busy when we went and they had our group of 6s order out in almost…read more20 minutes. Buffalo chicken pizza was awesome. We also got the boneless mild wings, they were fantastic. Even being busy the service was awesome!

web site and order says asap. confirmation gives not time…read more show up for take out and was told "we have no order for you". it was done on-line with 2 emails exchange. they return and say "its a 1 1/2 hour wait. thats the way it is on saturday night". so it sounds like they did get me order. got my money back. the "third party" web site is pathetic. from "asap" to no time given. then you find out its a 11/2 hr wait. food great and has been for 30 years. staff and "third party" need to get their act together. "be kind?" try being effecient.

I found this place when looking for a new spot to try. I had the Lobster & shrimp ravioli and a…read moreglass of red wine, which was a lovely dinner, I decided to try the cannoli for dessert which was so tasty! The ambience is clean and simple and the service was great. I will definitely come back the next time I am down in the OBX.

"Fast, convenient, good takeout Italian sandwiches, entrees, and more"…read more Punchline-- pass on the sandwiches (tasty but not big) and go for the entrees (giant and similarly priced) We ordered some takeout from this place based on positive Yelp reviews. Fortunately, Yelp came through for us! Note, although some things mention that you can eat in, at the time of this review, there were no visible tables inside-- it seemed to be a takeout only operation. Also, some of the online menus are now wrong-- they list all the meals and sandwiches as coming with a drink included, but they do not do so any longer. We opted for sandwiches and dishes, but they do have some desserts too-- we didn't partake this time. Service: very friendly, both when ordering and during pickup. They also warned us as we ordered about the menu/ drink change mentioned above, which helped prevent any unpleasant surprises. Food: Two of us got sandwiches and two got meals. Mozzarella caprese & Italian cheesesteak sandwiches -- both very good. Each came with a side of chips. But my family members who got these finished their food for dinner and found themselves still hungry. Note, these sandwiches cost $14. Lasagna & eggplant parmigiana -- These came with garden salads (though you could opt for bread for the eggplant parm). GIANT. It was a vat of food. I will say that a lot of the weight was the delicious tomato sauce, so there's a reason to consider getting bread. But even still-- I didn't finish my meal, nor did the other person who ordered one. These cost $16-17. Quite a contrast to the folks who ordered the sandwiches. Synopsis: Go for the entrees. WAY better value. And worth hitting up this place more generally for takeout if you want a break from seafood.

we ordered takeout. pizza was good and loved the crust. there were many families eating inside the…read morerestaurant, which was cute and cozy. service was straightforward and efficient.

I mean, it was good, just not great. There really wasn't anything wrong with it, it just wasn't my…read morefavorite pizza I've had. The fries reminded me of the frozen ones you make at home, so those were pretty disappointing. I also wasn't a big fan of the pizza dough. Overall it was a decent meal, but nothing really stood out enough to make me want to come back over some of the other pizza places around.