Called this place in the middle of the afternoon (around 3) thinking that they might have a 45 minute to an hour wait for pick up. Reading some of the other reviews people commented about the amount of time they had to wait to pick up their order after calling it in. We didn't have an issue, walked right in got our order within thirty minutes. The place was busy, lots of customers at 3:30 on a Saturday. The island chicken pizza was amazing! It was the perfect balance of flavors and ingredients ... amount of cheese and chicken were good (that's hard to mess up) the perfect amount of bbq sauce that was not overpowering, the thinly sliced red onion added a slight sharpness, the pineapple bits added sweetness without being super juicy and making it a sloppy mess. As my family and I enjoyed, we realized we should have ordered two island chicken pizzas! It's a shame we discovered this spot the day before we are leaving for home because we definitely would have ordered island chicken pizza more than once. We also ordered a pepperoni pizza, basket of fries and beer battered onion rings. All delicious and what you would expect from a pizza place. Glad we checked out this spot! read more

Pizza was fantastic. Great service and accomodations to change items on pizza. Fresh and hot so yummie when your stuck due to the road being out!! LOL read more

Lisa's Pizzeria - Could not wait and ate most of it before I could take a picture. - Pizza Near Me - Rodanthe, North Carolina

Our table split a couple large pizzas and some fries, all of which was phenomenal. Service was quick and friendly, made their rounds frequently with checking in and topping up drinks. Such a cute little place, was clean and seating options were spaced out well for the space size. read more

See all

Some of the other reviews are iffy so I was hesitant but we ordered carryout the other day while on vacation and thought everything was fresh, hot and delicious. We had a large pepperoni pizza, individual mushroom pizza, and the mozzarella sticks - they were so good and the sauce for dipping was also great! Don't let the bad reviews hold you back and try them out! read more

Lisa's Pizzeria - Large pepperoni pizza for carryout! - Pizza Near Me - Rodanthe, North Carolina

We got The Hippie and some chicken tenders---both were so good! The pizza was absolutely amazing--by far the best original pizza we've had! The folks working there were very busy but so kind! read more

Food was ok because it was the only place still open. As far as pizza goes, it's nothing special about it. Frozen grocery store pizza is just as good. Sorry if that sound harsh but it's the truth. Service was great and the ambiance is nice for island vibes that's about all. Skip this place unless your in a pinch to get something right away and don't feel like driving read more

Lisa's pizza was decent. Nice little spot in OBX, I wish they had options to order online as their phone is always busy.

Our pizza was great and the employees were so kind and friendly! They also offer gluten free crust!!

I am a resident here and dine here all the time.. all food and consistently delicious!!!! I give extremely high marks to the employees, even under extreme pressure (with the restaurant filled to capacity and orders to come take out) they are friendly and willing to explain any item on the m read more

Very stingy on the sauce. The pizza is extremely dry and there are bubbles on some of it without sauce and little cheese. This was the Buffalo pizza and there were sections of just bubbles and no sauce or cheese very little chicken if any. read more

The food was so amazing we ate there two nights in a row! The service was quick and friendly. Their house made dressings were good enough to drink! read more

I placed an order to here and the lady told me I would receive a text in 30-35 minutes letting me know it was ready. After 50 minutes I called and expressed I had not received a text yet. The lady on the phone says "oh yeah it's ready". I picked the pizza up, as I'm leaving the parking lot I get a text saying my pizza is ready. It was only a 5 minute drive, I get the pizza back home and it's room temperature. I wouldn't trust whatever system they have that is supposed to notify their customers. If they say 30-35 minutes, better show up in 30 so you don't have a room temperature pizza from the only open pizza joint. The pizza was decent, probably would've been better if it was some kind of warm. read more

Loved the atmosphere here! This is the first place we at after arriving in NC! It was a great first meal to have and might have been our best pick of the day! The pizza came out hot and fresh, not taking too long. The flavor of the pulled pork on the barbecue was interesting but definitely good! The service was nice and fast, more of a laidback spot to hang out! read more

See all

Best pizza we have found since, we relocated to Hatteras Island, that comes close to NJ/NY style pizza.

Steer clear. You are better off at the Dollar General getting DiGiorno frozen pizzas. The pizza tasted like Domino's and the prices were absurd for the quality which was lacking. The Chicken Caesar salad was good, but that was that. You can't tell the difference between an extra cheese pizza and a normal pizza. The cheese fries with bacon were cold, not very cheesy and not very good. Mozzarella sticks were subpar and the sauce smelled like it had clam chowder in it!! Oh and to top it off it cost way too much!! Ripping off tourists is NOT good business read more

It was our first time vacationing on Hatteras and we tried many local spots and Lisa's Pizzeria was such a great ending to our week long stay! I mean, one of the best takeout pizza's I've ever had. This is the pizza I look for when I'm at home, and I haven't found it. The margarita pizza was perfect. Great amount of each ingredient. Not overly salty and the crust was crispy, but dense and soft. We got 3 pizzas and each had a generous amount of toppings. Even the fries and chicken fingers had a great flavor to it. Hoping to stay in Hatteras again next year and will absolutely stop by again. Thank you! read more

Food was off the charts. We got the person bbq pizza and veggie wrap. So good and the staff are super helpful and friendly. read more

See all

stopping in on vacation and the pizza was perfect!!! we all got different pizzas and the garlic bread and we're still talking about how great it is! services was also excellent, super sweet staff :) cute little place! definitely stop in!!!! read more

Website and social media not up to date. Told 1/2 hour for small pizza and salad. Arrived and told another 20 minutes. Finally after one hour and ten minutes it was done. Also not given option to pay cash and avoid credit card charges but others were. Avoid at all cost! read more

Food was delicious. Pizza was also amazing will be back in quick service. Wish they had in door eating though

Our first night in town we stopped at Lisa's Pizzeria for dinner. We got there around 5 pm and the place was basically empty. It's a super cute place, kind of a beach shack meets pizzeria vibe. We were seated immediately and ordered a house salad, the island Chicken Pizza, and my husband ordered the buffalo chicken pizza. The salad came out right away and the veggies were super fresh and crisp and I absolutely loved their house made ranch. The pizzas came out soon after and I was impressed. I have no idea what kind of crust they use, but it was a perfect balance between crispy and chewy and I liked the flavor. The toppings were delicious and the bbq sauce tied it all together nicely. I tried a bite of the buffalo chicken pizza, and really liked that one as well, but for me I think it needed a bit more of the buffalo sauce. If you're in the area and hungry, definitely give Lisa's a try! read more

Lisa's Pizzeria - Island Chicken Pizza: Barbeque sauce base with grilled chicken, pineapple, onion and bacon - Pizza Near Me - Rodanthe, North Carolina

This is the best pizza I have eaten in a long time!! One of the personal pizzas was not correct and they sent me a new one asap. We ordered the bbq and the buffalo pizzas as part of our order, best bbq and buffalo pizza I have ever eaten hands down. I will never eat any other pizza when we visit. read more

Stopped by early afternoon in May. Not crowded. Food and service was very good. Going back next May, as this is a must stop for us. Bringing the whole family this time read more

Busy local spot with the body pizza! Definitely worth the wait. Super friendly staff and looks like a good place to meet your neighbors.

Came all the way from Sarasota Fl! This is some of the best pizza iv had in a long time! Came in random looking for lunch, was not disappointed at all! The cheese fries were amazing as well! Definitely recommend to anyone here or visiting for vacation! We want to bring Lisa Pizza back with us! read more

Lisa's Pizzeria - Greek Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Rodanthe, North Carolina

Nothing special. Tasted like little Caesar's hot and ready. Overpriced. Service was slow. Store is tiny and you can't eat inside on Saturdays. I would go somewhere else but after a 12 hour drive we were hungry read more

Carry out a few pizzas. Was easy enough to call ahead and order. Pretty thin style pizza, hard almost too crisp bottom. Got the loaded supreme style. Not a topping heavy gooey slices that strings apart. Wasn't bad, wasn't great. Easy enough meal for everyone. I'd grab another pie from here for a quick meal. read more

Vibe: 7/10 (casual, beachy) Service: 10/10 (always great!) Pizza: 8/10 Total: 8.3/10 (4.12/5 read more

Lisa's Pizzeria - 1/2 pepperoni and mushrooms, 1/2 cheese (large) - Pizza Near Me - Rodanthe, North Carolina

Fantastic pizza and salad! Great atmosphere for adults and kids. The prices are reasonable, especially for the food. The service was quick and super friendly! We ordered drinks and pizzas as soon as we sat down. I wasn't even half way through a small house salad and pizzas were on the table. We will definitely be back! read more

Lisa's Pizzeria - Large Supreme and Large cheese pizzas! - Pizza Near Me - Rodanthe, North Carolina

See all

This was the closest pizza place to us in Avon, OBX. We got the four cheese and buffalo chicken pizzas plus chicken tenders and fried mushrooms. The buffalo chicken pie was good, the rest not so much. The cheese on the four cheese was still whole and not cheesy enough. Tenders were dry and fried mushrooms were bland. It is convenient though! read more

Lisa's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Rodanthe, North Carolina

We picked up a pizza from here over Memorial Day weekend 2020 and again this past week when we were staying in Rodanthe. Both times the food was quite good, fresh, appropriate amounts of toppings and ready when they said it would be. I'm a New Yorker, so I'm a little bit of a pizza snob, but this is pretty good for a southern pie in a beach town. We ordered a traditional cheese and another with veggies. We picked up from here due to covid times, so didn't dine in. I really liked that they had a pickup window outside (like you'd find at an ice cream stand), it was nice to not have to go indoors. I'd definitely come back again, an overall pleasant experience. read more

Lisa's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Rodanthe, North Carolina

The food was so good here the pizza was a perfect size for me also I need to add about how good the ice was and everyone was so nice here read more

Lisa's Pizzeria - Ice - Pizza Near Me - Rodanthe, North Carolina

Best pizza on the island. Cozy atmosphere with welcoming staff!! Reasonably priced! Went there the last night of our stay...should have gone earlier so we could go more. read more

Visited Lisa's because Yelp said to, she was literally less than 500 feet of where I was camping, and the smell of the cook, in the night air. Lunch personal pan pizzas were delicious! They were topped as asked. We received a text, when it was ready for pickup. It was hot and fresh! Dough was good. I like extra sauce. Needed a little more sauce for moisture during the cook. I'll be back when in the area! read more

Lisa's Pizzeria - Outside 11/07/2020 - Pizza Near Me - Rodanthe, North Carolina

Great service and delicious pizzas! My family usually hit this stop on the way in for the week on Hatteras island. Love their pizza choices!

I don't want to be critical, but I always give honest reviews. The pizza was terrible. i don't believe the shell was hand tossed. Being in the pizza business for years, I know a premade frozen shell when I taste one. very little uninspired sauce, and very little toppings! Won't be going back next time im at the beach! read more

Small town pizza place in Waves, NC. Our pizza was undercooked and very chewy. Definitely pricey for the size.

Great pizza! The pork bbq pizza was excellent! If you are camping In the area is a great place to go and pick up a quick dinner..

Thank you Lisa's pizza! Checking into a beach house unpacking and getting settled in is tough and the last thing you want to do is to have to cook. So thankful for Lisa's and the entire staff for taking such good care of so many beach families who all had the same idea today. They were swamped and packed and busting at the seams but you could tell that people cared and the food was good and we enjoyed our meal in our house. We had the fried mushrooms the barbecue pizza and the margarita pizza and it was plenty for everyone to enjoy. We had heard good things prior to coming to Rodanthe and I can see why everyone loves Lisa's. Note to those you're out of town have patience we are all doing more with less and they will do everything they can to serve you. Insider tip if the phone line is busy just drive over and order. read more

This place was a disgrace and the lack of customer service was appalling. We ordered 3 pizzas and it took over 2.5 + hours of waiting. We sat in the restaurant face to face with the staff while they gave us inaccurate updates. This place has some serious issues. When asked about the status of the order, we were told the ovens were "broken" and there was a delay. It would have been nice to have an initial heads up. Honesty is the best policy. We would have made alternate plans. Apparently the oven was broken the day before yet they happily accepted orders that they could not handle. When asked to speak with the manager, the rudeness was the most disappointing. Don't waste your time people, get your pizzas from the grocery store or make them yourself, it'll be faster! read more