My wife and I have been to P.S. about 6 or 7 times in the past few years and we love it. We moved to the area from Boston and we ate pretty well there. So in that regard, we have high standards for fine dining. P.S. definitely doesn't disappoint.
Although its location (next to a supermarket) isn't ideal, when you walk in, you're struck by the simple elegance of the decor. They have a really nice bar and the dining room has quite a classy feel to it without coming off as pretentious.
The food, as expected, is excellent. You're started off with a complementary amouse bouche, always appreciated. The appetizers (my favorites are the wild mushroom augratin and the crab cake) are done perfectly, presented well, and arrive within 15 minutes of ordering. Also, the ravioli of the day is always great. I highly recommend the cream of mushroom soup, probably the best I've ever had. For entrees, you really can't make a bad choice. All the veal dishes are magnificent as cooked to perfect done-ness. Even the standard filet mignon comes with a delicious bernaise sauce. My wife has ordered off the Thai menu a few times and was thoroughly impressed. Also recommended - the roast duck and the quail. Desert, if you leave a little room is always great. There's always a rich, decadent chocolate desert, which I love. And creme brulee, too!
So now I leave the two standout areas for last. Firstly, the wine list is extraordinary. As a self-proclaimed wine enthusiast, their wine list really stands out. They have a huge selection of quality French reds, as well as meritages and other American reds that complement the food perfectly. It really shows that someone put a great deal of effort into planning the wine list. Every other restaurant in the area just serves the same bunch of wines, probably whatever was easiest to get from their wine distributor. P.S. features hard to find wines, many of which I have tried unsuccessfully to find elsewhere. Overall, their wine selection is huge and spectacular.
Lastly, the service really sets this place apart. In my opinion, this place has the best service in the area. The waitstaff is knowledgable about the menu. It's evident that they've all had everything the restaurant offers. They're professional and polite and will make sure you get exactly what you want. The timing of the service is great. Food comes to the table at a good pace. You get enough time to enjoy your food and your company, but you don't go hungry waiting for the next course. This is way different from the other so-called fine dining restaurants in the area (i.e. Number 5), where your salad comes 30 seconds after your appetizer and you know they just want to get your meal over with to get another table in. At P.S. you feel that you're important and not just another table.
I hope this review inspires some fans of good food, wine, and service to check this place out. Definitely recommended. read more