Cancel

Open app

Search

Outlaw Oyster

5.0 (7 reviews)
Closed • 4:00 pm - 9:00 PM

Order Outlaw Oyster Takeout or Delivery

Outlaw Oyster Photos

You might also consider

More like Outlaw Oyster

Recommended Reviews - Outlaw Oyster

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Sea legs cocktail - light and fresh like a cucumber lemonade vibe but not sweet
Sally W.

Fun rustic atmosphere. Interesting cocktail list, with about 4 spritz variations. We ended up splitting the shrimp cocktail, riptide and sweet Jesus oysters, and the lobster sliders. Everything looked great. Fries are shoestring and were realllll good! Seems like they have great happy hour deals, also some late night dinner options if you're like us and get caught up chatting after work and realize around 8 that you haven't even thought of food. We will definitely be back!

Isiah K.

One of my favorite spots!! If you're a seafood lover, this will become your favorite too. The oyster options change daily :) oysters are my absolute favorite so I try all of the options. The lobster crabs are great as well. The service is excellent. Very warm, welcoming, and attentive. It is a small place but I haven't been when it was super packed. The music is a great mix of classics which you will enjoy. I will post more pics when I have tried some other food options.

See all

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Devin E.

Devin E.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Devin E.

Devin E.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Devin E.

Devin E.

Helpful 2
Thanks 2
Love this 1
Oh no 0

8 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Devin E.

Devin E.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Devin E.

Devin E.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Outlaw Oyster

You might also consider

St Paul Fish Company - Shrimp Po Boy.

St Paul Fish Company

4.4(1.5k reviews)
2.7 mi•Historic Third Ward
•$$

This place will take care of you. Put your name on the list and you will be fed even after closing…read moretime.. when seated service was quick.Drinks first and hot food shortly afterwards...... perfect timing. The crab cake sandwich and fried shrimp dinner was delicious. This place has a big menu it's so much more to try, and they have specials for every day of the week.. you can also buy fresh seafood to cook yourself. I can't wait to come back .....try this place if you haven't it's definitely worth it!!! I watched my server take multiple tables orders with out writing anything down...that's definitely special....... And she got everything done right and quickly. Great service!!!

I had a meal here many years ago while in town and enjoyed it. Recently I had the opportunity to…read morereturn. St. Paul Fish Market is located inside the very busy and popular Milwaukee Public Market indoor shopping complex downtown. It reminds me of the Pike Place Fish Market in Seattle. The only parking option that I am aware of is metered street parking. The building has 2 levels but the 1st floor is where most of the business are. It appeared to me that St. Paul's is the most popular business there. It is a seafood restaurant and fresh fish market. They have a small sit down area for table service dining or you can order your food to go at the counter. After being seated and reviewing the menu I decided to order the same meal I had over 11 years ago. I went with a bowl of clam chowder for $8 to start and then added a fried grouper sandwich ($16) with french fries for another $2.50. The chowder was perfect. Flavorful, delicious and I wanted more (5). The sandwich also was delicious and satisfying made with quality fish, lettuce, tomato, and bread. However while it tasted very good halfway through eating it the bread bun started to disintegrate and then quickly turned to mush before I could finish. Then I needed a fork to finish it. It got messy and I don't like that in a sandwich. It's only for that reason I give an overall 4 score instead of a 5. The french fries were very good tasting too but I had ordered too much food and only had room for a few of them.The table service was very warm and friendly. I believe St. Paul's is a very good choice for a casual seafood meal but please buy more sturdy buns!

Photos
St Paul Fish Company - To go counter

To go counter

St Paul Fish Company - Lobster roll

Lobster roll

St Paul Fish Company - Bloody Mary with a beer back & a margarita

See all

Bloody Mary with a beer back & a margarita

Barnacle Bud's - Relish tray

Barnacle Bud's

3.8(318 reviews)
1.0 mi•Bay View
•$$

Comfy cozy coffee shop in Whitefish Bay. I came here at 9am on a Wednesday and it was packed with…read moreonly 2 tables open! Great place to work or study, but is quite noisy when busy. I love that they have QR codes on the tables to place an order and have it delivered to your table. Parking was paid street parking, but only $1.45 for 2 hours. I was able to easily find a spot at this time too.

Three friends and I booked a reservation two months in advance for Barnacle Bud's Pop-Up Supper…read moreClub. The only reservation we could get was 4:30PM but we were excited we were able to get in at any time. Because of the timing, the sun was setting over the water, which was really pretty to see. I got a little confused with where to enter the building and I guess I went in the wrong way because I walked down the dock and entered the back of the restaurant by the restrooms, lol. Barnacle Bud's had a cool decor vibe and moody lighting. Our waitress was incredibly friendly, welcoming, and you could tell she was very excited about the menu and the pop-up experience. She provided exceptional customer service- she went over the menu thoroughly, came back to check on us multiple times, and always refilled our water, which I always appreciate! To start, we ordered wine and the relish tray. Everything on the relish tray was a little too vinegary for me but most of the table enjoyed it. However, the four of us didn't finish it. It was pretty powerful with vinegar flavor. For an entree, I had the salmon with veggies and my friends ordered the lamb chops, carbonara, and a vegetarian friend ordered a plate of Bud's potatoes and veggies. The food was good but I thought mine was very salty. And I'm glad I ordered my sauce on the side. For dessert, the four of us shared the mousse, which had good flavor and texture. Also to note, there were up-charges for veggies, sauce was $3 extra, etc., so just pay attention to pricing if that's a concern for you. Overall, it was a unique experience and worth checking out.

Photos
Barnacle Bud's - 2023 seafood boil

2023 seafood boil

Barnacle Bud's - Mushroom tostadas from their Autumn/seasonal specials during their popup supper club

Mushroom tostadas from their Autumn/seasonal specials during their popup supper club

Barnacle Bud's - Chocolate mousse

See all

Chocolate mousse

Cavas

Cavas

4.8(103 reviews)
2.3 mi•Historic Third Ward
•$$

Fantastic quaint, little Spanish restaurant in the Third Ward. It's only open a few days a week,…read moreand with only 5/6 tables, reservations are required. It was one of the most special dining experiences we've ever had in Milwaukee. From the moment we walked in, we felt like we entered the home of an Argentinian chef. In fact, you pretty much having Chef Ana as your own personal chef, with her husband Peter also providing some exceptional hospitality. She came up to our table multiple times during the evening to chat with us and ask us how our meal was. It's pretty amazing that she is the sole chef in the restaurant and is able to prepare all the meals while also checking in with patrons regularly. The food was really good. They have two prefix options, and we went with the paella, with an appetizer, dessert and bottle of rosé. Each course felt thoughtfully curated, beautifully presented, and bursting with authentic flavor. The warm staff and intimacy is something unique and different than anything else we've experienced. It's rare to find a place where you can experience both world-class cuisine and the personal touch of the people behind it. FYI, there is a price to be paid for such wonderful food and service. But for a special occasion, it's well worth the money spent and would be right up near the top of my list. Cavas is truly a hidden gem -- If you're looking for a unique dining experience, I recommend you check it out!

If you are looking for an intimate dining experience, look no further than Cavas. This quaint…read morerestaurant in the Third Ward leaves no detail overlooked. First, the food was amazing. Chef Ana is incredibly talented and created a unique and delicious menu. We were speechless after the Amuse Bouche, and continued to love every course thereafter. Secondly, the service was second to none. Both Peter and Ana continuously checked in on us and made us feel like family, not just customers. They provided curated wine pairings based on our preference and were incredibly accommodating to dietary restrictions. Our experience at Cavas transported us to Spain and we loved every second (and morsel). Already looking forward to our next opportunity to return!

Photos
Cavas
Cavas
Cavas - Ready for dinner!!

See all

Ready for dinner!!

Odd Duck - Chili Crisp Devilled Eggs

Odd Duck

4.5(1k reviews)
1.9 mi•Walker's Point
•$$

On the tail end of my summer trip where I completed visiting all fifty US States, passed thru…read moreWisconsin on the way to Chicago to fly home back to California. The Odd Duck was where my friend and I grabbed dinner one night. Street parking. I didn't buy a lottery ticket but lucked out and found a spot across the street. Didn't have to do laps or pay. Always a good start when going out anywhere. Place was busy. No reservation. However, the luck continued as a table opened up in the bar area - window seating to boot. And though busy, service was attentive, friendly and great. Food was great! See pics. There wasn't a dish I didn't like and I can say that I'd definitely order the same line up again. Though I'd definitely like to try other menu items. It wasn't just about presentation - ingredients, flavors all just hit the spot. These are tapas size dishes so I could have eaten everything myself. Know that so you order accordingly. If you're looking for a cool, fun spot with good food and drinks, make a reservation and head over. If I lived in the area, this would definitely be a spot I'd regularly hang out at.

Odd Duck has been one of the top places I've been wanting to go to for a while…read more The vibes were 10/10. This is such a cool place to take your time eating at. The servers here know the menu very well which was super helpful when deciding what we wanted to order. The food was good but out of the 4 dishes we ordered the Tempura Nori Roll GIMMARI was the only memorable item to me and our server said it would be rotated off of the menu. I can tell that there has been a lot of care and detail put into the experience here and I can really appreciate that.

Photos
Odd Duck - Bar service!

Bar service!

Odd Duck - Charred Broccolini $17

Charred Broccolini $17

Odd Duck - Chili crisp deviled eggs $6

See all

Chili crisp deviled eggs $6

Crabby's Bar & Grill - Menu

Crabby's Bar & Grill

3.3(15 reviews)
0.9 mi•Bay View, Fernwood
•$$

This place was probably built in the 50's and never changed since. The problem is, while it's fully…read moreretro by default, it doesn't have the appeal of a place like At Random or Bryants at all. The creepy factor is high here: No windows, TVs with dials to change the channel, a parking lot full of RV's. Came here with some friends on a Friday night just to satisfy our curiosity of what is inside this windowless bar/restaurant. Had a drink each at the large bar, then they kicked us out because they were closing... At 9 pm... On a Friday!

This place is in need of some curb appeal, the interior is dated and the atmosphere is lonely but I…read morecan tell you that this establishment is one of the best kept secrets of Bay View. The owners run the whole operation, from the hosting, serving, cooking, and cleaning. You don't see that anymore. The waitress (owner) was incredibly friendly and talked to us during our stay about the history of the restaurant and the ingredients of the menu items. She attended us like a mother would, tenderly and with genuine care. All items we ordered were outstanding. The scallops were like butter, the homemade paste melted in your mouth. Even the homemade French salad dressing was so spectacular that I jokingly asked for a bottle to take home and the waitress brought me a container full of it at no charge. There was no room for dessert but overall what started as an odd experience turned into an excellent adventure through time with amazing food. Don't judge a book by its cover. Do yourself a favor and check out this place.

Photos
Crabby's Bar & Grill - Exterior

Exterior

Crabby's Bar & Grill - Menu

Menu

Crabby's Bar & Grill - Menu

See all

Menu

Outlaw Oyster - seafood - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...