Cancel

Open app

Search

Otter Creek Restaurant

4.0 (6 reviews)
Closed • 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

Otter Creek Restaurant Photos

OTTER CREEK RESTAURANT ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Outdoor seating
Good for kids
Happy hour specials

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Otter Creek Restaurant

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration
Photo of Lara C.
6
116
101

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Steve C.
4
102
55

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Great service and great people! They went above and beyond our last time out there. Can't wait to go back and try some new menu items.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Tobi H.
40
41
24

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0
Photo of Mindy S.
130
19
2

3 years ago

Food is good and staff is nice and quick! Love sitting outside and enjoying the view of a beautiful course.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Otter Creek Restaurant

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for American 107 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Upland Columbus Pump House

Upland Columbus Pump House

4.0(391 reviews)
6.9 mi
•$$
Casual dining
Takes reservations

Upland Brewing Company is a great stop right off the highway! We sat at the bar and the service was…read moregreat. Sally asked us if we'd ever been there and we had not. She took the time to let us know about the history, the quality of the local-sourced food, her personal recommendations for beer and food. She was exactly what we love about trying a new brewery and sitting at the bar. She let us try a few samples and we found some pretty good brews. These are lighter than our personal preference in craft brews, but they were delicious. The food was amazing. My husband had the burger and I had the Caesar salad. Very good!!!! The overall vibe of the brewery combines elements of history with the pride of keeping things fresh and modern. It's a really nice balance. The brewery is situated right on the river and once the boardwalk and construction is done, it's going to be beautiful!!!! It's still beautiful and the construction didn't affect us at all, but it's an exciting project that Sally told us about. Highly recommend stopping here for some food and drinks. We loved it and heard the brunch is the best around.

Upland Columbus is filled with upscale historical character, offers great craft beer, tasty food…read moreand superb service. The building sits on the banks of Driftwood River (now called East Fork White River) and offers spectacular views of the famous Robert N. Stewart Bridge in Columbus, Indiana. Upland Brewing Company is a local brewery that started in Bloomington, Indiana in 1998. Now, they have a number of popular restaurants/pubs across Indiana. The building, built in 1871, served as the Pump House supplying water to the city of Columbus, Indiana. The Pump House faced financial, water and quality challenges over the years, but was instrumental in industrial growth of the city. The Pump House operated until 1950, when the city moved to well water. The Pump House served a number of businesses and organizations since 1950. Upland opened the pub in 2016. We were greeted and promptly seated in the bar when we entered. Our server/bartender, Jess, was attentive and friendly. Several other servers also engaged with us, as well. One brought me a fascinating pamphlet describing the history of the building because I was curious. We arrived in time to sample their 3:00 - 5:00 pm Happy Hour. (I love a good Happy Hour.) We ordered Dragonfly IPAs, which went down smooth on a hot summer day. We also enjoyed a couple of sliders from the Happy Hour menu. The Bad Elmer's Fav burger was good with lots of bacon but my favorite was the Hoosier Tenderloin. I should note that much of the food is locally sourced. The building has a large dining room, bar, private dining, private event room, and a fabulous patio with river views. The landscaping is gorgeous. Their signature beers are available for purchase to go along with the logo shirt and a few other logo items. I highly recommend a visit. The food and beer are first class. The setting is lovely and service is attentive.

Photos
Upland Columbus Pump House
Upland Columbus Pump House
Upland Columbus Pump House

See all

Amazing Joe's Grill - Side of Fries

Amazing Joe's Grill

4.1(143 reviews)
5.7 mi
•$$

The food was very good. The first visit my husband had the pomodoro tells with chicken. It was…read morevery light and tasty, I had the potato soup. The soup was potato soup. Creamy and very good. The second time I had the Ahi Tuna which was outstanding and my husband had the burger with sautéed mushrooms. The food was delicious. All in all I recommend this place for reasonable prices, good food and excellent service. It is kind of noisy, good for kids, and a nice place to sit and enjoy friends and good food.

This place was not amazing at all. We were sat in a section that was partially full but still…read moreignored by every server that walked past us for about 10-15 minutes. When I told my daughter we were about to leave is when a server came up and told us this wasn't her section but she would take care of us. We ordered the loaf of bread, that was amazing, the fried pickles as an appetizer, we received last because of a "miscommunication", they were alright. We got the country fried chicken, the chicken was good, gravy and mashed potatoes were flavorless. They tasted like they were potato flakes made with only water. No kind of seasoning, butter, salt...nothing. We also got the cheesy chicken mac. The only decent thing in that was the marinated chicken, all 4 tiny pieces. The Mac left a weird after taste. There were also pieces of the walls crumbling and the floor was bubbling up. And the ceiling dripping water on to the table in front of us. Our server was very polite and didn't charge us for the pickles due to the mix up.

Photos
Amazing Joe's Grill - Cajun-creole Pasta

Cajun-creole Pasta

Amazing Joe's Grill - Side of baked beans, tasty, recommend!

Side of baked beans, tasty, recommend!

Amazing Joe's Grill - Bread w special sauce

See all

Bread w special sauce

Zaharakos

Zaharakos

3.6(539 reviews)
6.7 mi
•$$
Family-owned & operated
Established in 1900

The Good: Ice Cream: Absolutely delicious. The strawberry…read moreand Oreo cookie flavors make a top-tier sundae. The Quality: Easily some of the best ice cream you can find. The Service: Good, friendly, and helpful, even if it is not quite top-level perfection. The Theme: A cool, historic building from 1900 with a fun old-time soda fountain concept. The Bad The Music: The continuous antique pipe organ sounds were monotonous. Playing peppy 1940s or 1950s tunes would make the experience much more fun and lively. The Idea: Save the nostalgic pipe organ for a rare, special background moment instead of playing it the whole time.

We were very disappointed with our experience at Zaharakos. Our girls' softball team stopped by…read moreafter a long day at the ballpark looking forward to getting dinner and ice cream. Unfortunately, we were refused service, even though another girls' softball team had just been served before we arrived. We understand that restaurants can become busy and sometimes have limitations, but it was frustrating to see one team accommodated while ours was turned away. The inconsistency left our players, parents, and coaches feeling unwelcome. It's a beautiful restaurant with a great reputation, which made the experience even more disappointing. We had been looking forward to visiting, but based on how our group was treated, we'll be choosing other places to support in the future.

Photos
Zaharakos - Blue raspberry float

Blue raspberry float

Zaharakos
Zaharakos - Front door

See all

Front door

450 North Brewing Company - RAW UNDERCOOKED PIZZA

450 North Brewing Company

4.0(313 reviews)
3.9 mi
•$$

I discovered 450 North Brewing through retail distribution about two years ago, so I had been…read morelooking forward to visiting the taproom for a long time. I was thrilled when I realized it was only about 20 minutes from where we were staying! They do an incredible job creating unique, fruit-forward beers. They even make a sour IPA that tastes almost like a margarita--bright, refreshing, and not overly hoppy at all. A flight was the perfect way to try several flavors. The food portions were huge! We ordered the brisket nachos and a mushroom burger without realizing the burger was a double. It was so much food, and everything was delicious. The beer, food, and experience absolutely lived up to two years of anticipation. We will definitely be back!

We visited 450 North for the first time this morning. We came right at opening and the restaurant…read morewas calm. We enjoyed that. Service was polite and attentive without being too much. My girlfriend ordered a Bloody Mary for her drink and we got the Loaded Pulled Pork Fries for an appetizer. The fries were tasty, only complaint is they could've used more of the BBQ sauce due to the pork being a bit bland on its own. The fries were crunchy and seasoned well. The Bloody Mary was good, not the best she had ever had but it was good. She really enjoyed the "snacky snacks" on the top. We then ordered the Margherita pizza. It came out looking visually great. Upon tasting it was a tasty pizza. Would we order it again, I don't think so, but that is because it just isn't our normal go to. It was nice to try and a pleasant experience. When we eventually return we will try a different pizza and hope to enjoy it better.

Photos
450 North Brewing Company
450 North Brewing Company - 450 Burger and Fries

450 Burger and Fries

450 North Brewing Company - Front of restaurant

See all

Front of restaurant

Otter Creek Restaurant - tradamerican - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...