Gina, the owner of this store, is wonderful. I go to her estate sales frequently and always know that I will get fair pricing for quality merchandise. Although I have never been to her consignment store, I can say that all of my dealings with her have been pleasant and she has always been kind and helpful. I would highly recommend her sales! read more

Such a cute little store was throughly enjoying looking For items to buy for my new home!! Unfortunately staff was extremely rude so I decided to leave without purchasing anything. read more

Such a fun find in this store for my chandelier & they have wall paper coverings to choose from! It's so hard to find a place you can view all types of books of sample wall coverings... my new fav spot! read more

Once & Again Consignment - Chandelier base plate - Used, Vintage & Consignment Near Me - Madison, New Jersey

High quality items at fair prices! Kim, the owner has an impeccable eye! Nice staff too.

Terrible. Bad business practice for both buyer and seller, but the real issue is the people who work there. They have found a way to make shopping a truly joyless experience and that is a challenge. Perhaps at one time this was a good consignment shop, and I LOVE consignment shops, but currently it's a bad vibe, filled with overpriced and unexciting merchandise. Whomever owns this place needs a business course asap. So many better options in town. read more

Very disappointed in my experience here, I understand that consignment shops take high percentages, and I knew this going on. But I had to call 8 times and remind the owner to issue me a check for the sale of my item. They only issue checks quarterly, so to have to wait for the end of the quarter to roll around and then be told that your disbursement was forgotten about is extremely disappointing. It's clear that the management here is not on top of the ball. I'd recommend going elsewhere for your consignment needs. read more

Ok, so first impressions are everything. The staff was not friendly, not helpful (completely ignored me), and seems extremely annoyed that I asked any questions. Too bad too, they seemed to have some interesting merchandise. Don't bother going unless you are a glutton for punishment. read more

Do not bring your consignment merchandise here. There is a new owner who is disorganized and she "forgets" which items are yours and then sells them keeping all the profits for herself. I brought in 39 beautiful unused items and was paid $14.80. Also, she will not send you a check. She makes you schlep in for it. I now take my consignment to a retailer who is honest and ethical. read more

What an amazing consignment store where you can get everything that you need for your house and a wonderful selection of women's apparel. There is such a great and helpful staff and the new owner made the store look gorgeous and is so sweet to everyone who walks in her door. This is a place that you need to stop and look, and consign thing you no longer use. You won't be disappointed! read more

Friendly staff, best consignment store in Madison Fair & Honest I am a regular

I've consigned & purchased items at Once & Again & have had no issues with Gina & her team. The prices are fair & I'm happy to have received my checks in the mail or gone to the store to get my sale proceeds (& I've even purchased against my account too!). Yes, there is a min. amount to reach before checks are mailed quarterly - it's stated in the consigment agreement. And yes, maybe they don't have the most up-to-date website with an online customer account system like other consignment stores in the area - but O&A is happy to print out your account details if you ask when you're there. Under the new management the store is more organized which makes it easier to browse. And I love the fact that O&A has a HUGE selection of fashion, jewelry, shoes, furniture, paintings, tableware, lamps and loads of other gift & home decor items (there's more furniture downstairs). Definitely a great place for retail therapy! #Shopmadisonnj read more