LOOK NO FURTHER!! This place gets 5 stars, because they deserve it. Just regular people who do not make you cringe because you know how "car shops" are. I would have to say that this is the best Auto Shop to which I have been! Honestly, it is kind of weird how honest and nice they are. LOL. I was referred to by a friend because I am from Chicago. So here are the HIGH POINTS... Honest... yep, I said it! MIRACLE in car fix it places. Respect. Just normal guys that did not treat me like a moron because I am a girl. Its like an older brother fixing your car... Here is the takeaway... Ollie's has plenty of business without my review, but they EARNED my business. I knew I needed new tires, as well... and other work. They did not try to bury me with all of it. The Owner (I think it was the owner), just gave me a breakdown and gave me a long timeline and priority list to fix absolute necessities on my car. I already knew about them, (well because I am awesome and love cars), so he wasn't feeding me a lot of BS. I am working with the timeline and the budget... Air is fixed, new tires for the winter so the family is safe, oil change... and so on! Strong work Ollie's and THANK YOU for not sucking like every other car place on Earth! LOLOLOL read more

Ollie's Garage is the only mechanic I have taken my card to for 15+ years. Dave and his team are honest and do great work.

I think I finally found a local garage that has some very knowledgeable mechanics. I have a car that is a little rare and had some suspension work done. Result was great and promptly done. I recommend! read more

Honest and great work. Highly recommend. Have had several cars worked in over the years. They notified me of a recall which saved me $900.

Ollie's is the neighborhood spot, and they have been around for a reason. I went to Ollie's for an oil change, and after that visit I was having some issues. Ollie's came in big and corrected the issue at no cost to me. Absolutely no complaints--would take my vehicle there again. Very accountable and reasonable folks read more

Maybe. I really liked this place for many many years. It's an ethically run shop as far as I can tell. I've been given help on minor and midline issues without grudge and gratis for years. Remember I'd paid for many other routine and special items for years and years. This garage is a for profit business. It all changed when I asked if a routine 6 month check didn't show a replacement air filter. Truth be told I asked this twice between 2 6 + month checks. My question was an insult! Questioning if the air filter needed changed, not listed on my bill, was tantamount to insulting a generation of flag waving patriots. The owner quietly cussed me out in front of staff and customer. I thought modern consumers were supposed to ask these rather harmless questions. Now I'm afraid to call about regular maintenance. Should I be subordinate to Master Mechanic? If I asked about tire pressure or antifreeze brand will he, with bulging eyes, throw me out of the shop? To be band forever. (Side thought... ever experienced a volatile uncontrolled father who'll hit you?) read more

Dave, Tyler and their team do great work at very reasonable prices. Their work ethic, honesty, and professionalism are impeccable. We've used them for many years for all of our cars and will continue to use them. They have always gone above and beyond to be helpful, timely, and to get the job done. We are fortunate that a friend of ours recommended Ollie's garage to us. read more

My car was acting up and not locking properly. It would just unlock itself. I brought it in and they did a reset and replaced the battery in my key fob. They couldn't find anything truly wrong so they didn't charge me. I can't recommend them enough. read more

Ollie's did a front end alignment on my Mercedes GLK350. It drives like a new SUV. Great job guys. Thanks.

I am so grateful to have a mechanic that I can trust. He just fixed my dons AC for under $200. He's fair and honest and that's not easy to find! Highly recommend him. read more

WOW! These guys are the best! I can't say enough about this team. This was my second visit (different issue) to Ollie's. They provide the best price/performance service. In the future, I won't take my car anyplace else. Torque mount was replaced and they did an excellent job in a timely manner. Great team! read more

Had rear brake issues and this garage fixed only what was necessary and at a fair price. Will definitely bring future business here.

Ollie's Garage has always been our go to for quick repairs and has always been reliable. This week our teen son commented that his brakes seemed to be making noise. My husband checked it out and the brakes were very much in need of brakes. Concerned about my son driving the car in this condition, we called Ollie's. Unfortunately, they were booking out two weeks. After asking my husband a few questions, the guy recommended we bring in the car that day and they would try to work it in. Not only did they work it in, they finished the brakes by 3:30. So once again Ollie's came through for us and I was thrilled! read more

We have been exclusive customers of Ollie's Garage in Batavia for almost 15 years. I cannot imagine having to use another garage. The owner, Dave, and his son, Tyler, are amazing. They are fair, honest, experienced, and responsible. I would recommend them to anyone and will continue to be a loyal customer forever. read more

My husband and I have been taking our cars to Ollie's for many years, and every time I have my car serviced there, I leave feeling so thankful that there is an honest, fair, reliable and extremely accommodating garage nearby! I can't recommend enough Dave, Tyler and crew! read more

Countless repairs covering cars 50+ years old to current. Always repaired correct the first time. Fair pricing and only repairs what's needed unless requested by me. As a classic car owner, my car friends with valuable cars, are now going here for their classic cars. This shop understands cars and diagnostics to identify the root of a problem. They have kept us on the road saving thousands from having to replace a vehicle. read more

Brought my wife's 2016 Nissan Murano in for a new battery and oil change. The last time I was at the dealership the service department said the car needed brakes and a new battery cable. Ollies confirmed as I had suspected that nothing was wrong with either. The car only has 19,000 miles on it. First time at Ollies, my neighbor referred me. As most of the reviews say they are honest, transparent and very friendly. I'll be taking my car there from now on and avoid the dealerships and spend my money with honest local business owners like Ollies. I should have done this years ago. read more

Thanks Dave for taking care of my flat tire! So busy, but made me a priority to get it fixed and get me to work on time. You are the best!

These guys are amazing. Fixed my 1928 Dodge in a minute.....brilliant history and vast knowledge.

Reliable. Honest and transparent. Can't recommend this garage enough!! Will be where I bring my car for any future repairs. Thank you, Ollie's!! read more

I can rely on Ollie's Garage to take a minute to look at my car to let me know if the problem I notice needs immediate attention or can wait. So far, they have never charged me for this advice and are honest and fair when they do repair my car. read more

Being 1. a person who knows less than nothing about vehicles and 2. a young woman, I always felt like I needed to bring someone with me in order to be sure that i'm not being yanked around at an auto garage. I have not had that feeling whatsoever at Ollie's. I have used Ollie's for roughly 5 years and trust them fully. Ethical, local, honest and transparent family business. When something is wrong with my car, they explain it and break it down visually and in language that I can understand. Scheduling maintenance has always been a joy and very easy. I've recommended Ollie's to a number of my friends and they all share this sentiment. read more

I work down the street from Ollies, so I have had to drop my truck off there a couple of times. They do good work, on time & it is fairly priced. I wouldn't hesitate to use them again. read more

have really enjoy work with the whole crew there to get our vehicle up and running with no "funny" noises. They did not try and over sell us, they gave us options, were real with us and I appreciate that. Great job everyone at Ollie's, you deserve the spotlight in my book! read more

Definitely one of the best repair locations I have encountered. I was impressed with the high level of integrity and honesty they exhibited. My son and I had done some repairs to correct a cylinder misfire error and spent 2 weekends under the hood trying to correct and clear the misfire diagnosis completely. After multiple attempts and hundreds in self repairs, Tyler diagnosed the issue and fixed it - A bent wire on a newly installed ignition coil. They could have easily charged me for unneeded parts and labor - I was frustrated and need help. They were extremely kind and acknowledged the efforts my son and I had made in actually finding the initial problem (bad cylinder coil). They did all the work for no charge with only a handshake and a request to come back when we needed service. This was our first visit and we will go nowhere else but Ollie's from this point forward. read more

Great place! I've been there three times over the past year for brakes, timing belt and alternator. They have been upfront, great with pricing and professional each time. No surprises! read more

What a great find in Batavia! These guys are fantastic! A totally professional and honest car repair shop!

My 1st time using Ollie's and I will never go to another shop. They got me in last minute and spent hours on the phone with GM to try and figure out what one of the issues was. He advised that the part is under warranty and that I should take it to a dealership so that I could have it fixed for free. He also offered to follow up with me to ensure that I am able to obtain the warranty fix and provided a local dealership to go to. They fixed a couple of the other issues and for a cost that was beyond reasonable. If you want outstanding service at reasonable prices I highly suggest calling Ollie's! read more

I'm still working on trusting Ollies, and not because of anything they have or haven't done, but just because mechanics are tough to trust, especially being a woman without a lot of auto mechanic knowledge. My last experience there was top-notch and my trust is growing! Everything, from the initial phone call, through the final pick up, was EASY and as promised. No surprises, no difficulties. In this day and age, that is a blessing. Both the woman who took my initial call and the mechanic that I worked with (sorry, forgot his name) were friendly, personable and again, easy to work with. My car was fixed on time, and as promised. The job was reasonably priced and no pressure for anything additional. I have taken my other car here before for some minor work and although I had a small issue with squeaky brakes after they were installed, Dave took every step he could to try and rectify the problem. He was patient and understanding. I still have squeaky brakes in the winter time, but there appears to be no harm done and its not an issue in my mind. I will be returning here for further work - great job by everyone at Ollies. You are trustworthy, and the way you run your business is much appreciated! read more

Can't echo the other peoples experences, took my van in for maintence a week later the part they worked on broke and I was stuck on the side of the road waitng for a tow that cost $300. Did not back the repair or the part which was over trorqued which caused the damage. Should have gone to the dealer would have been charged more but it would have been done right the first time. read more

Very fair and good work, I service my Classic Camaro and tour family cars here. Dave makes you feel comfortable and doesn't pile up the charges. Work is done on time and within budget. Car is respected and all promises are kept. Highly recommended read more

The mechanics here are trustworthy and honest! They do such a great job and they get the job done fast and right. I tell everyone I know about Ollie's Garage I would never take my car anywhere else! read more

Really good, honest, trustworthy mechanics! When I first moved here quite a few years ago I went to Ollies Garage because my neighbor referred them to me. I am a woman and don't really know much about cars. My car had a leak. The mechanic at Ollies said it was the radiator and noticed that the radiator was fairly new. He could have fixed it for me but instead he told me to take it back to where it was fixed originally and that they should fix it for free. Ollies Garage filled up my radiator for free and sent me on my way. Since then I have always used Ollies Garage It's hard to find someone you trust, and I trust Dave. He always takes time to explain things to me and has very reasonable prices. My car is 16 years old and thanks to Ollies Garage it's still running smooth! read more

I can't say enough good stuff about Ollie's Garage. Awesome customer service, decent prices and knowledgeable staff. I've taken 2 different cars there & been totally satisfied with the work and experience both times. They let me know what my options were, kept in touch with me as promised and finished the work on time - or sooner. read more

I have read rave reviews of Ollies and really wanted them to be my new mechanic. But the 2 times I have used them there were issues. The first time I had a brake job on my pickup. They had the truck the entire day which was fine. When O picked it up the truck wasn't there. I was told is was out being test driven. Took the truck straight home. In the morning I left for work, I could hear a grinding noise. Had yo get to work. Called them up and returned it the next morning. Turns out the brake sheila was bent and rubbing on the rotor. They fixed it right away but I questioned what the "test drive was for." Today took my wife's car in for a brake job and oil change. When I dropped it off he asked if I wanted synthetic oil. I said no. He asked when I needed it I told him end of day. Got a call about 12 telling me the car was done. when to pick it up at 4:15. he told me he forgot the oil change and it was being done. These are not major issues, but I really start to wonder. If they can't hear a grinding noise and forget to complete the job. Just not sure about a 3rd chance. btw he took the additional charge for the oil off. I would have paid for it. It's just I was asked in the morning which oil. I understand the manufacture recommends it but why ask. read more