I must say, this has been an amazing experience. Very clean and intimate atmosphere. Then we met Devon/Devin and has to be one of the best waiters I have ever had. Knew the food, flavors, and the descriptions were spot on! Food was absolutely delightful and magical. Small plates were amazing and the steaks we had were magical. The only downfall was the noise inside. Sitting next to my girlfriend we had to keep leaning in to hear each other. Besides that, absolutely coming back. read more

I hadn't been to Oliver's in probably eight years, and it's still met and exceeded our expectations. I have to remember to come here more often, whether it is for a classy time at an ample bar space, or a special dinner. Service was exceptional at the bar and the table. They still had an item I remembered from my visit many years ago, decadence of egg, and they still have it and it's still outstanding. Pricey, but worth it for a real treat. They were excellent in accommodating food allergies, and had many options for me as a gluten-free person - including desserts! read more

See all

Me and my girlfriend went to Oliver's and from the food to the great hospitality I felt taken care of the moment we walked in the door. The ambiance is warm and welcoming making everyone feel like royalty. I am definitely coming back read more

See all

Came to Oliver's solo for a 5 course menu tasting for $150 and an extra 150 if you wanted wine pairing and this is on the lower spectrum. Everything was delicious and I like the fact that they set each course down and explained what ingredients were in the dish you were about to consume. Would definitely come back to try the regular menu great atmosphere great vibe. read more

See all

I will start with the food, the salad was the best part of my meal. The lobster was terrible, small portioned, lousy sauce that was way over salted. I've had much better lobster at a chain restaurant for less than half the price. My wife enjoyed her meal, so I never complained. She treated me for my birthday, so I didn't want her to feel bad that my meal sucked. The server was excellent but didn't like the mandatory valet parking. We parked illegally in another lot and walked in the rain. They seated us near the bar so toward the end of our meal there were people four deep at the bar, standing right next to our table. And it was very loud. To sum up, it's not a place that I would recommend to my friends, and we won't be returning anytime soon. Way overpriced for small portions for sure! read more

Very nice people. Service was excellent. Food is of very high quality. Ambiance is very good.

Four of us friends went for dinner on a Tuesday evening to celebrate a birthday. The bar and dining area looked beautiful, the staff were friendly, warm and welcoming. And Devon was extremely knowledgeable about the menu and how it would be executed. Everything was temperature appropriate, and delicious. And the Mocktails were exceptional. A really memorable evening. Can't wait to go back! read more

Came here with a group of 7 of us for a combined birthday / christmas / new year dinner back in February. Very good experience. We ordered some Parker House Loaves, oysters, and a few rounds of cocktails to start. We all ordered a different cut of steak. I got the NY Strip, cooked to perfection, with Truffle butter. Our waiter was attentive, and made the experience great. Reservations highly recommended! And take advantage of valet, otherwise it can be tough to find a spot on the street to park. read more

Really wanted to love it, but a little underwhelming for the price. This restaurant is in Buffalo, not Paris,NYC or Milan. As you can see from the menu it's a bit overpriced. I did have a pretty amazing drink, a Cynar Swizzle with a ton of flavor. We had a loaf of spinach bread which was crispy and delicious. I had the butter poached lobster which was little bit chewy and overcooked with a side of scallops (3) which were very small. My wife did enjoy her filet though. Our waiter Joe W was very pleasant and helpful. I give it an overall 4 stars because of the drink, spinach bread and Filet. The overall atmosphere was pleasant. read more

See all

As Oliver's catered our wedding two years ago, we decided to celebrate 2 years by going to Oliver's. Let me get it out of the way that I HATE the valet parking experience. I dread coming here because of the valet situation, especially when you have to wait ages for your car when you can literally just walk to the car, along with having the tip for something we could do more conveniently. Now that I have gotten that out of the way, lets just say they we had an amazing time. The staff was wonderful, our steak and drinks were perfect, and there is nothing I could complain about (besides the parking). I would highly recommend coming here for a nice night out. There are a lot of restaurants in Buffalo with overrated and overpriced restaurants, and even though Oliver's isn't cheap, everything you pay is highly worth it. Keep up the good work, Oliver's! read more

See all

I came here to celebrate my birthday and boy it did not disappoint! Upon arrival for our reservations we were offered to enjoy a drink at the bar. The bar was so beautiful that I couldn't resist. I ordered an espresso martini, it was perfect. The toasted nuts on the bar were delicious and addicting, I had to stop eating them to save room for our meal. The overall design of the restaurant feels so elevated that you don't realize it's located next to two gas stations. Our server Fred was fantastic. Throughout our entire experience he was extremely helpful and knowledgeable regarding the menu. We were served with the complementary amuse bouche, it was refreshing and delicious. Next we ordered the beef tartare, roasted cauliflower, confit Spanish octopus and the Parker house loaf. Fred was kind enough to serve us the egg of decadence (on him) as well. Everything was absolutely delightful. The beef tartare was out of this world. The egg of decadence was unlike anything we've ever had before and was truly delectable. The Spanish octopus was a tad rubbery but even with that being said I would still order it again. For dinner I ordered the prime filet mignon with an add on order of seared scallops. My cousin ordered the prime filet with mashed potatoes and broccolini. My husband ordered the C.A.B Prime Rib with mashed potatoes and broccolini. Everything was divine. We could not have been any happier with our entrees. Fred's recommendations were excellent! For desserts I ordered the creme brûlée (which I've been thinking about daily ever since). My cousin ordered the carrot cake and my husband got the chocolate pave. Each dessert was fantastic! If you have not been to Oliver's yet I would highly, highly recommend them. The staff is professional and knowledgeable, the ambiance is classy while still being modern. We absolutely loved our entire experience and will be returning!! read more

See all

Service was excellent, food was very good as were the cocktails. Valet parking was really helpful. Loved our experience here.

My husband I came for dinner this evening. I had the filet and he had the ribeye. We cannot say enough about our experience. Service was top notch. The food was absolutely delicious from the bread, sides and main dish. I believe our waiters name was Carl. He is the best at what he does. Kudos to the chef and everyone else on the staff. Can't wait to return. Thank you! read more

See all

Parking. Parking is an absolute mess. If coming here in the winter, be prepared to walk on ice and un shoveled sidewalks. Experience. This place offers professional service in a charming and lively atmosphere. It was a little funny, and the service was quick. Everyone enjoyed the food, and everything was presented beautifully. Food. Great dishes. I had the duck and it was cooked to perfection and was absolutely delicious. Highly recommend. read more

First, the service was incredible! Kai (or Kyle? Sorry!) was exceptionally attentive. The ambiance is what you would expect of an older, established, more expensive restaurant. The acoustics were actually decent and I had no issue talking with my friend at the table. The food was overall good. The cocktails were maybe slightly disappointing but still decent cocktails. The oysters and the spinach bread were the star of the show. I highly recommend both. My friend said the lobster risotto was very good. The bolognese was too salty. I love salinity but this was too much for me. Next time I'm here I will have to try one of the steaks. read more

See all

Everything about Oliver's is top notch. From the valet, to the hostess. Food and bar service. They definitely make you feel welcomed. The food was the best read more

We have been dying to try Oliver's and finally had the chance for my birthday weekend to use a $200 gift card purchased at Christmas. We tried everything we could. Spinach bread is delightful. I was dubious at first from the description but it's a must and was well worth it. We also had oysters that were delicious, and shrimp cocktail that was also very nice. For entrees I had the scallops which were perfect in every way and had an amazing brown sear. The rare steak arrived rare so you can trust Oliver's and not order one or two shades down from what you desire. We tried three desserts all amazing. A pecan tart with a banana bourbon gelato, a chocolate ganache cake, and a salted caramel gelato with snickerdoodle biscotti. We also tired as many cocktails as we could... an ube and paw paw drink was my first and very good, the blood orange cocktail and the islandy coconut one were also divine. Everything was clearly made with care and quality in mind. Our server was also lovely and offered many helpful suggestions and took wonderful care of us. I would say that Oliver's and Prescotts Provisions are tied for best restaurant in Buffalo. And I would choose either OR BOTH for any special event you may want to plan in the future. Just superb food, presentation, and experience. read more

See all

This was a once in a few years treat that we were able to take part in because of a generous gift certificate we received from my sister. The service is so spectacular that it made everything worth it. But, overall, I'm glad we weren't spending our own money. We started with the wagyu carpaccio...it was delicious but so small, with just three tiny pieces of the wagyu placed on top of rice crisps. I wouldn't order it again. We also ordered the spinach loaf to start, which was good enough but didn't seem to belong on the menu. It was something you'd get from your local red sauce joint. I opted for the lobster risotto for my main and was pretty disappointed. The amount of lobster was generous enough but the risotto was all wrong. It appears as if they use a medium grain rice instead of the traditional arborio rice. This meant that there was no creaminess to the dish at all. The acid from the white wine was abrasive and there was nothing to balance it. On top of that, the rice was undercooked and toothsome....just not pleasant. I didn't complain, but I probably should have. We shared the Brooklyn Blackout cake for dessert and it did not disappoint, a highlight of the meal. And I can't say enough about how good the service was. Our server Devin and his assistant were on top of everything, all the time. We couldn't have asked to be better taken care of...I just wish the food had been as excellent. read more

See all

Our annual holiday dinner spot. Parker house rolls and decadence of egg are must haves ! Great cocktails and wine list, great service. read more

Oliver's Restaurant - Holiday dessert. Winter wonderland - New American Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

My boyfriend and I came here recently and we had a wonderful experience. Parking was valet. Our waiter was attentive. We ordered the oyster rockefeller which had a creamy spinach and maybe egg base to it. I thought they were tasty but overpriced. The oysters were also tiny. We ordered the lobster risotto and the strip steak. I thought my lobster risotto was delicious. It was flavored perfectly and had poached lobster in it. My boyfriend said it was the best steak he's ever had so I guess that's a plus! We were too full for dessert but perhaps next week. I also knocked over my glass of wine by accident and they were happy to replace it with a full glass. The inside of the restaurant has such a sleek vibe to it. It was also really quiet so it provided quite an intimate ambiance. I would return. read more

Oliver's Restaurant - New American Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

(4.25) ~ Very good Overall food & Service. Note: They have Valet parking ONLY, & I'm not sure you are allowed to street park near there...Reservations are recommended too. DRINKS: ** Britesmith Brewing "Walk the Dog" Dry Irish Stout = (4.25) Very good, would be better if they could make it "Nitro" like Guinness;) ** French Press Coffee (half) = (4) very good option *** Water (tap) = We ended up getting bottled, so I'm not sure... FOOD: ** "Apple of My Eye" Dessert = (4.5) Very Good! Highly Recommend:) See photo ** Spinach Roll (whole) = (4) kinda like garlic bread (w. spinach;) ** Roasted Beet Salad = (4) very good ** Prawn Pappardelle = (4) very tasty read more

Oliver's Restaurant - "Apple of My Eye" Dessert! Highly Recommend:) - New American Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Finally made it here and I am so happy that we did. We were greeted right away. I love that they have coat check and valet parking. We were brought over to our table right away. Our waiter was Fred, and he was fabulous, very attentive and informative in helping us make decisions on what to get for dinner and appetizers. The food did not disappoint. We had oysters, chilled shrimp and spinach loaf to start. Dinner was the filet mignon which was tender and flavorful. Salmon dinner was delicious. For dessert we had the apple of eye and the presentation was so pretty. Highly recommend coming here. Excellent service, food and a great wine menu. read more

See all

Fine dining, upscale, special occasion choice. Had my birthday dinner here tonight. It was enjoyable in all respects. Meals were cooked perfectly. Service was pleasant and attentive but not over-done. Started with the small serving of spinach loaf for our appetizer. I had the scallops with risotto. Delicious! Chicken Milanese with lemon zest was also tasty and came with a decent serving of arugula. My partner and I shared the crème brûlée. With 9 oz servings of wine for two, the total without tip was $158. We will return for another memorable meal and dining experience. read more

See all

Food was outstanding and our service were great as usual. Olivers always makes your dining experience special.

We had a great experience at Oliver's. And yes, I specifically say "experience" because it is about so much more than the food, although the food was top notch. The ambiance and the service enhance the meal exponentially. There are only a few places in Buffalo where you can get the full package and this is one of them. read more

Lovely experience. Great attention to service and detail. Food was exquisite. Atmosphere was warm and comfortable.

From the moment we arrived and we received complimentary valet parking, to coat check, and immediate seating, the experience was sublime. We enjoyed a variety of appetizers, entrees, and desserts. Carl & Stephanie were attentive to all our needs, for drinks, rolls, clearing away dishes, and answering all our questions. I highly recommend reservations. You'll enjoy delicious food in a relaxing atmosphere, with attentive and friendly staff. read more

See all

Excellent food. Excellent service. If you're looking for a sure thing for any occasion, this is the place.

My overall experience with Oliver's was great. This isn't someplace I can normally eat however my wife's sister got us some gift certs for our birthdays. We chose 8pm on a Friday night and the place was quite busy. We didn't have to wait long for our table. They do have a valet and coat check if needed. The whole decor was nice and well taken care of if a little dated. Our server was Devin and what a professional he was. His service was impeccable and was a delight all evening. My wife and I started with the beef carpaccio. It was my first time having it and I loved it. It came as 3 pcs arranged with each being essentially an amuse bouche. We also got a half loaf of their spinach bread and found that it was delightful. I ordered C. A. B. ribeye steak. It was served boneless (as it should be) and without the deckle (my second favorite part of the ribeye after the spinalis). They cooked it to perfect med rare and the meaty flavor was out of this world. I definitely recommend this cut. For dessert we got the Brooklyn Blackout. Talk about rich and decadent. It probably took almost a half an hour to finish because I wanted to savor every bite and make last as long as possible. There was one minor incident with my partner's drink not being made right but Devin took care of it promptly and without hesitation. Aside from this I cannot speak to their beers and wines because I was driving and thus did not partake. I would also say their plating style and side choices seemed a bit dated but by no means should prohibit you from going here unless you want new American cuisine. I would definitely like to go back again. read more

See all

For many years, Oliver's was my favorite restaurant in Buffalo for a special occasion or fine dining meal. The service and food are great. Unfortunately, our last visit wasn't as impressive as in the past. They no longer offer complimentary bread service and the overall portion sizes seem to have gotten smaller. The service is always top notch from the valet, to the coat check, to the hostess, to the servers. We recommend the beef carpaccio, octopus (the most tender you will ever have), duck entree, and lobster risotto. Also, the bartenders make one of the best cosmos in Buffalo (IMHO). The desserts change seasonally and all we have tried have been delightful. read more

If possible I would give this restaurant a four and a half stars as I definitely think it's worth more than four but is certainly not perfect. They had valet parking and a coat check which seemed kind of unnecessary. The parking lot was very small and right next to the restaurant and their was definitely room at the table for coats. The decor of the restaurant was very welcoming and cozy. I really enjoyed the rose on the table and the paintings on the wall where beautiful as well. Restrooms where very clean and I enjoyed the large mirror inside. Our server Cai was extremely kind, attentive and knowledgeable about the dishes on the menu. The assistant servers where also extremely attentive but I didn't catch any of there names. We started with some rolls and whipped butter and wow was that a great way to start. Perfectly fluffy and fresh! Next came our starters the spinach loaf and a charcuterie board. The spinach load wasn't all that amazing. The spinach flavor was overwhelming and ever the bread alone wasn't nearly as good as the rolls. The charcuterie board was great though! It featured an especially delicious white cheddar truffle cheese as well as some amazing prosciutto. I also enjoyed the gherkins. The jam was bitter but that didn't bother me much as the rest was perfect. For my main I got the Wagyu BMS 8 served with mashed potato's and Brussel sprouts. That steak was the most amazing piece of meat I'd ever tasted. The marbling made it so it just melted in your mouth. It was almost like eating steak flavored butter. The Demi gaze it was served with was a great paring and tasted SO GOOD! Those potato's where perfect! The taste reminded me of my grandmas home made mash. The Brussels sprouts I got where burnt to a crisp sadly I didn't really enjoy them. For dessert I got the Brooklyn Blackout Cake served with oat ice cream. It honestly tasted like the petridge farm chocolate cake you can buy from the freezer section at most stores. The ice cream was super tasty though it reminded me of brown sugar oatmeal. They gave us some cute chocolates at the end of the meal shaped like sea shells that where very minty and delicious. Overall this place is 100% amazing and worth your time if your order the right things! read more

See all

The service from start to finish was excellent. Cocktails were impeccable! Had a great time enjoying dinner at the bar. Great job! Looking forward to returning for steak! read more

See all

I'm unsure what Oliver's is trying to be. We visited Oliver's on a Saturday night so it was busy. The service was impeccable, although a bit slow we were there for almost three hours. The valet and our server, Cal, were very friendly and informative. Now to the food. We were offered an amuse bouche of sashimi and avocado spread in a miniature cone that was absolutely delicious. As for the appetizers, I ordered the half spinach loaf which was delicious. My husband ordered the chilled prawns appetizer. The presentation was beautiful but very small. There were three shrimp sliced in thirds, almost like sushi but for $24 seemed very high for three regular sized shrimp. For my main dish I decided on the lobster risotto which I would go back there just for that. There was lobster in every bite and enough for two people. My husband chose pan seared scallops with fennel and lentils. The presentation was beautiful but there were only four scallops. They were only a bit larger than every other scallop you've seen at any other high end restaurant in the area. Black lentils and fennel are pretty inexpensive but my husband's dish cost $49. The dish was pretty small for the price. We each decided to get our own dessert. My husband decided on the creme brulee which was delicious and enough for two. I decided on the apple of my eye. My dessert was one of the best I've ever had in the area. We may try Oliver's again but we may just stick to the burger and steak sandwich. read more

See all

We recently had the best meal ever at Oliver's. First, we had no idea Valet parking was included, that was such a nice treat. We were seating right away even tho we were about 15 minutes early for our reservation. They had 3 different mocktails using 3 different alcohol-free spirits, I really appreciated this as I do not drink but like to get an interesting drink when we go out for a fancy meal. Both of the mocktails I had were very good. Unfortunately I don't remember the actual names of them, one was a jalapeño based margarita type drink and the other was a very sweet drink with a good amount of honey in it. For appetizers we each had a decadence of egg and ordered a 1/2 order of the spinach bread. Man, the decadence of egg may have been the most special thing I have ever eaten. It was such an interesting bite and so fun to savor each little spoonful. The spinach bread was really yummy, but it's something I feel like I could definitely replicate At home pretty easily.L so I wouldn't order it again. For dinner I had the lobster risotto and my husband had an aged steak. We both loved our meals! They beautifully presented and tasted just as good as they looked. We had dessert as well. A really delicious crem brule and a really nice cake. Overall we would recommend Oliver's to everyone. We hope to go back more regularly! read more

See all

Our 1st experience at Oliver's started with a warm friendly greeting from the Hostess and we were seated at a lovely table . The ambiance is welcoming and elegant. Our server Devin B. , Greated us with a warm smile and presentation of the menu selections. Our drink orders were taken and we reviewed the dinner selections and extensive wine list. Our dinner selections were delivered, prepared expertly the presentation was perfection. Seafood and steaks were enjoyed fully as was our Cabernet selection. Desserts were a sweet ending to a perfect meal. Our thanks to Nicolas and Chi for their attentive service along with Devin B. Overall a great special dinner experience. read more

We just enjoyed a superb dining experience for our 10th anniversary This past Thursday The service was fantastic, Kyle our waiter was so good ,very welcoming and knowledgeable. The lobster bisque was very good maybe the finest I might have enjoyed, our dinners were even better. The lobster risotto was wonderful with enough lobster for anyone to like, I had the duck and Wow, amazing Perfectly cooked large portion with a sauce to die for Absolutely the best duck ! Thank you for a wonderful evening . read more

Fantastic experience. Wonderful service, ambiance and the food was amazing. They go the extra mile to make sure your dining experience is perfect. read more

*TAKEOUT COVID REVIEW* I must start with.... WOW! Just WOW! During this surreal time, our own individual calendars find reasons to celebrate happiness in some of the gloom; today was one of those days. It's our anniversary! Earlier in the week we started thinking about places to get take-out from for our special day, and after a fun playoff-style elimination process, OLIVER's was the winner! We pre-ordered today at 12:30 pm for a 6:00 pm pickup, and it was spot on. They asked the type of car, our order, and requested time. They asked if it was for any special reason, and upon hearing it was our anniversary, asked if we wanted champagne! Well, yes, we do! We arrived smartly at 6 pm, parked, called and let them know we were there. Less than one minute later, they were at our trunk with our order, secured the champagne so it wouldn't roll and surprised us with a bouquet of flowers! I was so shocked and delighted - what a wonderful surprise on a dreary warm spring day! We came home and unpacked our meal. Whether perfectly plated or in a black plastic container, it was easy to see that our filet mignon dinners with a Caesar said were going to be amazing. As we hoped, first bite of the steak and pairing it with their whipped potatoes, vegetables and Demi sauce, we were BEYOND happy! Thank you so much to the entire staff of OLIVER's for making and giving us a truly unique meal that surpassed our expectations. Absolutely memorable! So perfectly cooked, presented, and delivered. Again, thank you, and we will share our positive experience with many! #thankyouthursday read more

Oliver's Restaurant - Filet mignon in takeout container - New American Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Very good but could use some work on their acoustics. Was really hard to have one-on-one conversation during dinner without really raising our voices, even when we were seated under their large sound paneling in the ceiling. Would go again by invite, but probably wouldn't suggest it myself. read more

We had a most enjoyable evening at Olivers. I had the best prepared octopus ever and my filet was cooked to perfection. Joe our waiter was very attentive. Our guests were very pleased as well. It has been a while since I visited Oliver's and I believe they're now at a whole different level than before. I will definitely be returning again soon. Thank you. read more