If I could give Hutch's 10 stars, I would! We were referred here and were fortunate to get a midweek reservation. Melissa, our waitress, was a superstar. She kept our beverages topped off, offered excellent menu recommendations, and made us feel genuinely welcome throughout the evening. Maxwell brought out a wonderful selection of homemade breads, perfect for soaking up every last bit of the incredibly garlicky, delicious escargot. The halibut topped with scallops was outstanding, finished with the most flavorful beurre blanc sauce I've ever tasted. My partner's seared ahi tuna was cooked to absolute perfection. Every dish was beautifully plated and expertly prepared. From the exceptional food and impeccable service to the warm atmosphere and great Buffalo NY location, Hutch's delivered an unforgettable dining experience. It's easily one of my favorite restaurants, and I can't wait to return. What a treat! read more

See all

First time there: Server : Lindy Bottle of Pontet Teyssier to start Appetizers were Shishito Peppers and Kale Salad Entree We both ordered the Surf and Turf special ($72) Desert: Cookie Cups Food, wine and dessert were all delicious. Shishito peppers and Kale salad are recommended. The entrees were cooked to order perfectly and the popular cookie cups were a great topper with coffee. The only improvement is we were placed in the back room and next time would like to be placed up front. We will be back. read more

Had dinner at Hutch's this week first time to dine here but won't be the last! We had great service from the moment we entered the door until we left. Nice atmosphere great bar area. We started with Oysters from PEI and Mass. the bacon appetizer and tuna tartare all were very good. I had the Portuguese fish stew and it was loaded with seafood lobster, scallops, shrimp, mussels and clams. Delish!! The place was very busy so I would suggest reservations if at all possible. read more

See all

Im not trying to be dramatic but I honestly couldn't see any room for improvement The class in the casino were a nice size and cooked perfectly, my husband LOVED the oysters The 169z bone in tenderloin (on specials menu) 2as cooked to a perfect medium, my chicken milanese (which I love, first time having it with cucumber on it) was cooked perfectly And of course their cookie cup dessert, which is fairly well known, did not disappoint Also, regarding kid friendliness, we had our 10yo with us as we were celebrating my bday They do not have a kids menu but if your child likes steak and is old enough to sit theu a 2 hour meal it is kid friendly The staff treated her as they treated us read more

See all

Another wonderful experience! The food was phenomenal. This time my date and I skipped the appetizer and got dessert at the end. I went with the Monkfish and she ordered Halibut. Both were cooked to perfection. The almond cookie with fresh fruit was to die for... I never had such an exquisite bite. The crunch from the cookie, the tartness from the fruit, the sweetness from the whipped cream. Everything was so well balanced and crave-able that I contemplated ordering a 2nd dessert! Heather, our waitress, was superb. Very attentive and gave great insight on recommendations. Very friendly and genuinely seemed to enjoy her job. The restaurant itself was beautiful. I love the leopard print carpet. The candle on the table was perfect for a a romantic evening. Plenty of parking available in back. read more

See all

The atmosphere was very nice. More of an old school bistro vibe in the best way. The food and service were fantastic.

if i could give any type of recommendation, get the portuguese fish stew! the lobster is insanely good read more

See all

Husband and I had an early reservation at 5:30 PM on a Friday. When we went to the host stand, I requested to be seated in the front area, which was 3/4 empty. He told me that we would have to wait for 10 minutes to be seated in that area. I asked why - he mumbled something about server availability. We opted not to wait and were seated way in the back of the original restaurant-which was fine with me. Our server and our waitress were excellent. The service was attentive, not overwhelming. I had the clams casino and the seafood special, which was excellent, and my husband had the veal chop and a salad which he loved. We split the chocolate cake dessert. I am withholding one star because of the weird Maitre d in the front that wouldn't seat me in an empty room! Overall, a good experience, but I would rather spend my money in New York City at the prices we paid! read more

Best steak I've ever had, Pittsford style, fries were freaking bussing and great service.

A buffalo establishment! Steakhouse with solid bar. Wish front of house staff led us to the bar as it was our first time going and didn't know where things were. Food was excellent. Had nyc steakhouse vibes read more

Best haddock I've ever had. The tuna tartare and stuffed pepper special were also incredible. We had a great dining experience and will definitely be back. If I had any complaint, it would just be that the drinks took a little bit too long each time, but it was a busy Friday night. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a great date night spot in Buffalo! read more

I have been going to Hutch's for 20 years, and the food is always excellent. I typically get the steak--personally I think it's one of the best steaks in Buffalo. Last week, I tried the salmon from their seasonal menu, by recommendation of our server, and it was phenomenal. Their homemade bread is fantastic. And for dessert, the cookie cup is one of my favorites in Buffalo. The restaurant has expanded quite a bit in size, but the level of service and quality is still consistently high. read more

See all

My husband and I received a gift certificate here as a wedding present and we were absolutely in love. The service was 10/10 from checking in with the host, throughout the dinner, until we ended with dessert. The space is nicely decorated and has medium to low lighting with great music playing. We jammed all night to classic hits. We ordered Clams Casino, Half rack of ribs, the Seafood Jambalaya Pasta, Crispy Softshell Crab, the Blueberry Crisp, and the Crème Brûlée. Every dish was cooked and seasoned to perfection with the most amazing flavors and quality ingredients. Some items were seasonal but the entire menu is intriguing. We'll definitely be back for more for the delicious food and romantic vibes. 5 stars! read more

See all

Amazing. Classy and delicious. Went to a private party dining experience and had the best steak. Cooked EXACTLY how I requested (medium rare, more towards the rare side). Highly recommend. read more

My friends and I made a reservation for 6 over a month in advance. Upon arrival, our table was not ready. The hostess was very rude. She ended up telling us we needed to move from the entrance and from blocking others while we were waiting. She did not show us or tell us where to go or direct us to the bar in the back. She was extremely rude and condescending acting as though we were the inconvenience. (Really both women at the front of house were rude). We waited 30-45 minutes for our table and another 50 minutes for the food. The only explanation given was that a walk in party arrived and needed a table so they offered them ours despite the reservation we had because it was the only table large enough to accommodate them. No one came to check on us at the bar or provided updates. The managers were not made aware until I went out of my way to find them and make them aware. The one even said it was unacceptable to wait that long and that they had no excuse for us. The waitress was fine. Not rude like the front of house. The busser was excellent and went above and beyond. The food was great - so it was a bummer the poor service ruined our experience. Ultimately the manager tried to make things right and comp us dessert which was also great. Just unfortunate that we ate 1.5 -2 hours past our reservation and that we experienced a rude front of house. It was also disappointing as previous experiences there were typically positive. I will think twice before choosing Hutch's over other local restaurants after this experience. read more

Hutch's continues to deliver--this was my third visit in three months. We started with the ceviche and soft shell crab appetizers--both fresh and full of flavor. For our mains, the Portuguese fish stew was rich and comforting, while the jambalaya pasta packed just the right amount of heat and depth. We finished with the crème brûlée and blueberry crisp, both beautifully executed and satisfying. Service began strong--attentive and friendly--but noticeably tapered off after our entrees were served. (It felt like the four-top next to us took priority for the rest of the evening.) Still, the overall experience was excellent, and I'm looking forward to my next visit. TL, DR: It's delicious! Just go!i read more

See all

Great spot. The manager, Ryan, was incredible and accommodating. The food and drinks were excellent, and the vibe was chill.

I came here for the first time for my 1 year anniversary with my husband & it was a great choice since we both love meat and seafood. Menu is very straightforward & I love how it includes the origin of where the food came from. Our server was amazing, enthusiastic & helpful as he gave us wonderful recommendations for us first timers. We decided on calamari, bison steak & the steak and frites. We both agreed that hutches was the best steak we ever had ever! Everything was cooked to perfection & left your mouth with an explosion of flavors. Trying the bison meat for the first time was a great choice as the meat was so tender and lean. We truly had an amazing time & we would most definitely come back again! read more

See all

Great food, Great place and Great service. I would recommend this place over every steak house in Buffalo.

Great food. Steak was prepared perfect. The lobster bisque soup was excellent. Our server was also terrific. Nothing but high marks.

How could you not enjoy a place with different bread offerings? Service was top tier. Ambiance was wonderful. Parking was interesting in the narrow entry way to the lot. Surprising amount of parking hidden away. My only ehh was my meal. I ordered the chicken Milanese (I know it's a steakhouse) and it was plan and needed some balsamic or something on top. So much arugula as well. Definitely a place I'd return to try something new. read more

Hutch's - Classic Caesar Salad - New American Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

We sat right next to the ramp to outside. I'm right handed and the glass was to my right, so I kept hitting it with my elbow. We tried to move the table a bit away but then it was wobbly. I don't remember the servers name, but she was good, I think I would have liked her to be slightly more attentive though. Tomato & Fresh Mozzarella Salad 10/10 Super fresh and delicious. All ingredients paired well with each other. Traditional Steak Tartare 10/10 Very flavorful and good seasoning. Steak was tender. I thought the bread was too hard and crunchy. Bison strip (daily special) 9/10 Medium. Cooked perfectly. Seasoned with salt and pepper. It was very good, I just wish it had more flavor like finished in butter and rosemary or something. Steak frites 8/10 Medium rare. Was slightly over cooked. A little closer to medium. Seasoned with salt and pepper, flavor on the steak was good. Truffle butter was delicious and the truffle flavor was great. Fries were overcooked, garlic aioli tasted good though. Double chocolate brownie sundae 10/10 Brownie was delicious, melty and gooey inside. Ice cream was vanilla bean. Tasted homemade. Delicious flavor. read more

See all

Insanely good. I'm always on the hunt for the next best cooked steak, and found it here. It lived up to the hype. We went on a date night here (reservations recommended because it was packed). I got the ribeye, and it was seasoned and cooked to perfection. We had the tuna tar tar and the pork belly appetizer and both were also phenomenal. It's upscale and pricey but worth every penny. read more

Hutch's is a solid spot and has become a staple visit whenever I'm in town. I focused mostly on the specials during my visit, and while some dishes were excellent, others were just okay. The escargot was great, served in a delicious buttery garlic sauce with bread for dipping. Their ribs (not pictured) are also good--great sauce and a nice char. The special monkfish, served osso buco style with shrimp and rice, was solid but didn't quite wow me. The real star was the seasonal sautéed soft shell crab. It came with rice, veggies, and an incredible white wine/buttery sauce. I returned specifically to have it again, but unfortunately, it didn't live up to the first experience--the crabs were a bit anemic, the sauce lacked the bright citrus notes, and they served a smaller portion of it this time around. Service was attentive, especially by the bussers, but the wait staff service can be inconsistent. Some waiters were on point, while others seemed either too busy or less engaged to deliver the same level of service. In terms of ambiance, the move is to come here early to enjoy a nice romantic evening out. It can get quite busy and frankly loud, especially in the bar area, when you come during peak hours. Hutch's has the potential to be an exceptional dining destination, but the inconsistent food and service, along with the loud ambiance during my visits knocks it down to 4 stars IMO. I'd still recommend it, especially for those signature dishes, but there's room for improvement to make it a truly standout experience. read more

See all

Hutches for dinner Good wait staff and attentive Parking behind the restaurant Allen brothers meat! read more

See all

We had dinner reservations, upon arrival we were greeted and seated right away. The restaurant is a lot bigger since last time mi was here was years ago! Really nice tho. Overall ambiance was okay. A little loud as the restaurant got crowded. Our server came over, provided us the specials of the day. Gave her recommendations. Spaced out apps to entrees. Everything was delicious including our Oregon Pinot Noir. We started with oysters, had the sliced bacon which has a caramlized flavor, really good. The tomato and mozzarella salad with prosciutto was delicious. For dinner we had the strip steak and jambalaya pasta. Both were excellent. Was a little nervous coming to visit with the most recent unfavorable reviews but we had a great visit. S read more

See all

Hutch's for the win as always! Went there on a Tuesday evening to celebrate a birthday. The service is exceptional, lot of attention to detail. We sat in the bar room, which was a nice cozy experience, but maybe a bit loud. The food was excellent, from the bread basket or our entrees and appetizers. I've never had a bad time at hutch's so I am glad to have gone back and will most definitely be returning. read more

See all

I moved back after 5 years away I missed Hutch's food and the pizza here I'm making reservations now..

Went here for my birthday dinner on a coworker's recommendation. The space is very nice, the space between the tables are a little tight though. The place filled up quick on a Thursday night so definitely make a reservation ahead of time! Our server was very nice, attentive and informative about the specials for the night. We actually ended up going with his recommendations for the appetizers. The drinks and the food were all delicious and I would definitely order everything again! The portions were all really big. My one critique would be that the shishito peppers needed more salt or it needed to be salted a bit more evenly. My husband was getting full but I convinced him to split a dessert and he was glad he did. The sticky toffee pudding with the vanilla gelato was a great way to end our dinner. read more

See all

Excellent lobster bisque This restaurant has excellent sermons and food and great atmosphere in the back bar read more

I drove by this restaurant many, many times, but never visited. It was time to change that. We were seated in the original part of the restaurant (before they expanded into the former flower shop). That part looks small, but I noticed there were more rooms and a bar area somewhat hidden in the back. The tables are a bit close together. I was in a steak mood and they have several options. I went for the. beef tenderloin "au poivre", an 8oz. peppercorn crusted steak, , pan-seared with a brandy cream sauce. It was served with some pieces of squash on a bed of spinach and a generous serving of mashed potatoes. I requested medium rare and the chef delivered. The sauce was great. It's not inexpensive ($64.95) but it was excellent. read more

Used to love this place However the prices have doubled ( to be expected ) However the quantity and quality has been halved A steak tar tar is 1" high now ??? What's the point A 14 Oz cheapO sirloin $79.00 These people are insane I can fly from Buffalo to Fort Laudy $88 round trip Grab a car for $8.00 and hit the freshest steak and seafood place you ever tasted and smelled in your life When these ppl do r figure in what customers would do for a great meal - then forget about them I used to drive on Thruway and back Gas Tolls Time No of that matters and I will never come back read more

Food was fantastic! Steaks were cooked perfectly! The atmosphere awesome. The Waiter was the best waiter you could have ever asked for. Hutch's was the highlight of a UB reunion weekend. Thank you for the excellence! We will be back.9 read more

Hutch's had been a go to date night favorite for us for years. The fact that that this never wavered is the secret sauce of the total experience. The staff is a total vibe. I feel like Norm from Cheers when we come here (even after a 6 month absence). The braised short ribs were phenomenal as usual. Even the appetizers were exceptional. The Thai fried calamari is a must have appetizer. Last but not least was the bar service. The whiskey list is well curated & the Som is a total expert and very personable. Our beverage experience has always been top notch thanks to the Som & bar staff. Hutch's is the ultimate casual but fine dining experience. read more

Hutch's is the model class steak house of Buffalo!!! I surprised my wife with a reservation on a Friday at 5 and we were thoroughly impressed with the food, service and ambiance! We were sat in the elegant and beautiful front dining room. We ordered wine and the caramelized bacon appetizer which was five stars! My wife ordered the bison steak which was cooked to medium rare perfection! I ordered the steak Au Poivre and was blown away at how tasty this was! I would recommend 5 out 5 and will definitely be coming back for those special occasions to celebrate! read more

Hutch's - Bison steak (top) and Steak Au Poivre (bottom)!!! - New American Near Me - Buffalo, New York

The food, setting, and staff are all fantastic. We've been going to Hutch's for over 30 years and it has always been a wonderful experience. Last night, we took my in-laws there for their 60th wedding anniversary and it was every bit as good as they deserved. read more

Came here for a group dinner and had a wonderful experience. This is a place to go to celebrate a special occasion, or to impress a date. Our group split a few appetizers with the table including calamari, stuffed poblano and stuffed jalapeños - all great. The bread basket had a variety of bread and came with a spicy oil. Awesome wine menu, including a few New York State wines. For my first course I had the lobster bisque which was delicious, followed by the Nova Scotia Halibut which came with 2 scallops and veggies. For dessert, I had their cookie/toffee bowl dessert which was out of this world amazing. I'd love to come back here again sometime. read more

See all

Phenomenal! I had heard amazing things about Hutch's for years and finally made it in for a surprise birthday dinner from my friends. Each and every one of us absolutely loved and raved over our meals and drinks. Some of the freshest oysters and a delicious meatball to start our night, with espresso martini's and wine. I had the pork chop special with pear chutney and WOW, the biggest and moist cut of pork I've had with an amazing flavor profile. I had the fruit cookie for dessert and it was absolutely divine. Our server, Amanda, was so friendly and helpful, suggesting apps, working with my friend to find the perfect red wine for her, and even humoring my other friend to pick a meal and surprise her- and she picked well! Good service makes all the difference and we can't say enough about her and the atmosphere here. I have friends who routinely come to Hutch's and all I can say is I've been influenced and hope to return much more frequently! Thanks for an amazing dinner experience to celebrate my 30th! read more

See all

Very cool spot in Buffalo that I have visited several times now. Great back bar with old school brick ambience. Delicious menu that mixes classics with some Buffalo culture and wonderful staff. I took a group there but going back and sitting at the back bar enjoying a cocktail and having the meatballs. read more

Hutch's - My team enjoying dinner at Hutch's. - New American Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Had a great dinner. I was originally going to get a steak but they had swordfish au poivre as a special so I got that. It was delicious. Fish was perfectly cooked and the cream sauce was amazing with a nice amount of various peppercorns. Service was great, someone was checking on us or topping off the water frequently to make sure we were never waiting if we needed something. read more

Hutch's - Swordfish special - New American Near Me - Buffalo, New York