I had such a wonderful afternoon yesterday at Olio that I am ready to face the week with a smile. Speaking of smiles I was greeted with warmth and kindness from the entire staff. I unfortunately was dining alone due to illness in my party but after a month of looking forward to it I wasn't going to miss it. I sat at the bar and met wonderful people, sipped a cold martini and let Mitchell take me on a culinary journey with their exciting new fall menu. The service, professionalism and cuisine was top notch. Thank you again Olio. Can't wait till we meet again. read more

Love this little gem of a restaurant. Everything you order is just as great as the last thing. Food is fresh especially the focaccia bread. Enjoyed the prosecco. Make a reservation though. read more

Everything was wonderful. We shared a bunch of plates, and I highly recommend doing that so you can sample a bunch of things! We had the Arancini (deep fried risotto balls) and the Bruschetta Mortadella for starter's. Then we went with Insalata (salad) fried eggplant (my favorite) Campanelle pasta and a pasta special. Decided to end with the chocolate cake with the olive ouo ice cream and Zeppole (deep fried ricotta) with lemons curd and oh my god. Still thinking about those desserts! Server was awesome and prices were very reasonable for such an amazing meal, will be back soon!!! read more

See all

Everything about a Friday lunch was wonderful. The food, the service and the atmosphere!

Had dinner here last night and the food was really outstanding. We knew it would be hard to get a table and the staff helped us to find a place to have a cocktail while we waited. Our first impressions were the place had a great vibe. Very warm and inviting. All I can say is the food was worth the wait. We had the Arancini, Seabass, Rigatoni and all were crazy good. For dessert we had the Zeppole which was the perfect way to cap off our meal. Can't wait to go back and try some other items! read more

See all

Just went here for the first time and was really impressed by the service and our food. Everyone enjoyed their pasta and wine. Would go back in the future for an intimate dinner! read more

If I could give more stars I would. The ambiance is comfortable and inviting, our server Sam was patient, knowledgeable and on top of it. Food was top notch. I ordered the pappardelle and cherished every bite. A taste combination I would never expect with tuna, dill and olives. This is a must go if you are anywhere near the place! I am sure this place will be here to stay. read more

Really tasty pasta and apps were great too!! Not even that expensive either! The vibes of the resturant were cute and ambient. We expected portions to be small but they were hearty! I'd definitely return to olio went with 6 people and got a variety of apps to share - the focaccia was very delicious and toasty. Also the buratta with sweet potato and apple dish was amazing. read more

Olio - Mushroom casarecce - Italian Near Me - Bayport, Minnesota

See all

Fantastic, delicious Italian food! Highly recommend this place, even though I wish it could be kept secret so it is easier to get reservations. Worth the wait if you need to book in advance! read more

OMG! Olio is amazing! The food is incredible, the service is excellent, wine top notch and ambiance is perfect. Scratch pasta is chef's kiss. So excited to have this nearby and I am booking reservations for a few upcoming occasions. read more

Excellent food and wine. We called to see if we needed a reservation around 1:50 pm on a Saturday. We were told we could be accommodated and I informed them we would be there in 10 minutes. We arrived at 2pm and were seated at one of the tables. We tried few wine samples and our order was placed for food by 2:07 PM. Bruschetta was good, wine was lovely. Caesar salad was authentic . Our meals were very delicious! We did not linger once our food came we ate and enjoyed our meal. The bummer came when at 2:55 PM our server(same person we spoke with on phone) came and told us that there was a reservation for our table at 3PM! instantly felt rushed and like we were in the way. Not a good feeling. We were so excited we were planning to get dessert but instead we got espresso and quickly drank them and left. We were out of our seats by 3:10. I would kindly recommend that this not be repeated. I know it's a cozy restaurant with few tables but I would have preferred to be told that there is a reservation for a table immediately upon arrival and given a choice of want to sit there? This was a special day until that comment. The young person who told us had been lovely and helpful but once that was stated we instantly felt bad. We spent almost $200 and left feeling like we were a bother. I wanted to give 5 stars because it was such a lovely meal but we left feeling uncomfortable. It should be said we pulled away from parked right in front at 3:15 and did not see anyone go in the restaurant for 3:00 reservation? read more

Absolutely gorgeous restaurant with amazing Italian food. The pasta is made in house and so is the delicious sourdough focaccia. Their new pasta menu is to die for and so is their dark chocolate tiramisu. The bartender is incredibly knowledgeable as well. I highly recommend this place, just make sure you have a reservation because everyone loves it as much as I do. read more

See all

High-end Italian, rare for a small town in the Upper Midwest. New York tight seating, room quite loud. Mean age of patrons: mid 30s. Wait staff is young, attentive, well-trained and well-groomed. Tables are hard to get, extremely popular. Try to go with three or more unless you enjoy being a part of your neighbors' conversations at the tables for two. The only bad thing I had was burned sourdough bread, which should never have been served. Perhaps a minor problem with quality control, everything else was fabulous. read more

Amazing Italian food. Their meatballs were delicious and went well with their sauce. The vibe of the restaurant was relaxed with friendly staff. Very cute place near twin cities. read more

This new restaurant in Bayport Mn and is a Hugh success.We had the burnt carrots it was amazing and I had the chicken parmigiana it was also amazing with a new red sauce taste.Wow is all u can at about this place great service, food, freshest ingredients and to your table quickly to eat. Oh yea don't forget to get there bread the best I ever had with the frosting as are waitress called it. read more

So the most amazing dish is now not on the menu. Not sure I would go three times a week anymore without the dish. ONE HAS TO MAKE RESERVATIONS IN ADVANCE MORE THAN A DAY IN ADVANCE. They got rid of my favorite wine as well! However, amazing lounge feeling with a surprise in music. They know how to bring in a great crowd. read more

I live two blocks from Olio and have tried multiple dishes. All have been delicious and flavorful.

Olio has the best Italian food and wine in the twin cities with knowledgeable and friendly staff. The space is elegant and comfortable. I can't recommend this place enough! read more

The sourdough focaccia bread was EXCELLENT! I didn't care for the tomato sauce dipping sauce. It was WAY too sweet. I wish people would stop putting sugar into tomato sauce!!! Ugh! It's nothing real Italians even do! Why does America need to have sugar in everything we eat? We ended up splitting the short rib with risotto. The short rib was cooked in a tomato sauce that wasn't great. The risotto was excellent. I probably wouldn't eat here again. I wish they had a marinara sauce instead to put on things. I'm not a huge fan of tomato sauce, but marinara sauce, made with San Marzano tomatoes: now you have my full attention. It's a super small, but quaint place and it fills up quickly. There's no TV's which I super appreciated. They had a cute bar and lots of drinks. read more

We went for a celebratory dinner at Olio in Bayport for a second visit. The first time we went we loved the food, service, atmosphere and couldn't rave about the restaurant enough to others. We were excited to go back and bring another couple with us to experience it. However, the second time going we had a different evening. Because the restaurant has limited space and seating, the one room without the bar has tables that are quite close together. The problem with this configuration, is that if one party is loud, really no one else in the dining space can hear. Last night the food was still wonderful and the service was adequate. I am leaving this review, because the restaurant owners/service individuals need to know and intervene if they have a group in that space that is being extra loud. Really, no one else in the room can talk or have a conversation. It went on the entire hour we were there and was awkward for everyone else in the room. The couple next to us also voiced frustration. Please help an awkward situation be better, and with grace, let a big party know that everyone is wanting a good dining experience. Not Olio's fault, but needs to be addressed when it happens. We probably won't be back unless we could guarantee the one of the two tables that is in the bar/kitchen space. It sort of wrecked $200+ dinner. I never leave reviews and don't want to be negative about such a wonderful little gem of a restaurant. But it really did affect our experience dining out. read more

Wonderful ambiance and amazing food. Our server was warm, knowledgeable, and responsive. We had a big group and ordered almost everything on the menu. Everyone raved about their meal and we shared samples. Olio is sought after...get a reservation early. Now we know why! Excellent new place in a great location! read more

Three of us visited the restaurant on two occasions. We enjoyed the food and thought the preparation was inventive. One of our party is a vegetarian and there was only one pasta she could have on both occasions. Either need to change up the menu more often or increase the offerings. We would go back if the menu offerings changed so we could have more variety. Also we had never seen a restaurant charge for cream and sugar with coffee. What's with that? The coffee is already expensive and its over the top to add more for the regular offerings of cream and sugar. read more

Fantastic and Quaint. Great food, drinks,ambiance! Tough to get reservation for a very good reason

This place is impossible to get a reservation. The girl handling the reservations was quite rude and didn't care for our business. Needless to say, I don't think I'll be going here anytime soon. read more

Just plain awesome! Great food, good prices and an excellent small restaurant informal atmosphere.

Congratulations to this wonderful new restaurant. Visited on day 11 of their opening and everything was perfect. This is authentic Italian made from fresh ingredients. Perfectly sized portions that do not miss a beat on taste or presentation. Definitely will be back. read more

Unbelievably good food in a wonderful atmosphere. Taste was incredible, staff is outstanding, and the entire experience made you want to put in your reservation for the next visit while you were still at the restaurant! Thank you. read more